The widest selection of unusual accommodations in Buffalo, NY

A cabin, a lighthouse, a glamping, your extraordinary stay awaits you

7 nights
2
1
  • airbnb
  • booking
  • vrbo
  • expedia
  • premierinn
  • sykescottages
  • plumguide
  • hotelscom
  • tripadvisor
  • homestay
  • tuivillas
  • hostelworld
Buffalo, NY unique stays
Choose the perfect holiday accommodation
Price per night
Accommodation type
Rating

14 Unique places to stay in Buffalo, NY

Find Unique Stays in the City Centre of Buffalo, NY

Stay seconds away from popular independent eateries and transport networks at central unique stays in Buffalo, NY.

Hidden Steampunk Carriage H, Quiet, Park 1 Car - Buffalo, NY
9.9 14 reviews

Hidden Steampunk Carriage H, Quiet, Park 1 Car

cabin, Buffalo
This steampunk-themed carriage house apartment is situated in a quiet Buffalo neighbourhood, conveniently close to local restaurants and shops.
The two-bedroom, one-bathroom property sleeps four guests and boasts a well-equipped kitchen with modern appliances, a private porch, Roku TV, gas fireplace, and three individual air conditioning/heating units.
4-bedroom Harbourtown Beach House, Mins From Beach - Buffalo, NY
9.9 27 reviews

4-bedroom Harbourtown Beach House, Mins From Beach

tower, Fort Erie
This four-bedroom townhome is located in Fort Erie's Crescent Park, a short 1.6km drive from Erie Beach and 16km from Crystal Beach.
The 280m² property offers an open-plan living/dining area, a chef's kitchen, four bathrooms, and a self-contained basement suite; sleeping up to twelve guests, it includes parking for two cars and is close to major highways.
2bd Log Cabin In The Heart Of The City - Buffalo, NY
9.8 97 reviews

2bd Log Cabin In The Heart Of The City

house, Buffalo
This Allentown, Buffalo property is centrally located, within easy walking distance of Allentown's restaurants, theatres, and sporting venues.
The two-bedroom house offers a spacious layout, sleeping up to four guests, and boasts a sauna, garden, parking, and a relaxing steam room; it's also featured in Buffalo Spree magazine.
Former Monastery - Aspirant Cell (Budget) - Buffalo, NY
9.2 46 reviews

Former Monastery - Aspirant Cell (Budget)

church, Buffalo
Moreland Guesthouse, a unique guest house in a restored 1922 nun's convent in Buffalo, offers convenient access to various Buffalo landmarks, though precise distances aren't specified.
This single-bedroom lodging, sleeping one guest, features a shared kitchen with fridge and microwave, two bathrooms, and communal areas including a dining room, living room, and billiard room; daily cleaning of common areas is provided.

Choose the Right Family-Friendly Unique Stays in Buffalo, NY

Perfectly suited for family holidays, these unique stays in Buffalo, NY sit moments from top city attractions.

Riverview Retreat - Buffalo, NY
9.0 4 reviews

Riverview Retreat

bungalow, Fort Erie
This Fort Erie riverfront house boasts direct Niagara River frontage with a private dock, situated a short drive from Niagara Falls and the Niagara Parkway.
The three-bedroom property sleeps eight, offering a movie room with Bose sound system, table tennis, two gas fireplaces, an outdoor firepit, and over 0.4 hectares of land for outdoor activities.

Frequently asked questions about unique stays in Buffalo, NY

  • What clothing or gear is recommended for the climate in Buffalo, NY?

    Buffalo has a humid continental climate, with cold, snowy winters and warm, humid summers. You'll definitely need a warm coat, hat, gloves, and scarf for the winter months. In the summer, pack lightweight clothing and comfortable shoes for walking. Don't forget sunscreen and sunglasses, too.
  • What are the best ways to travel to Buffalo, NY eco-consciously?

    The best way to travel to Buffalo eco-consciously is by train. Amtrak offers direct service from many major cities, and it's a much more sustainable option than flying. You can also rent a bicycle and explore the city at your own pace, or take advantage of the extensive public transport network.

Popular destinations

Browse Unusual Places to Stay with a Jacuzzi in Buffalo, NY

Relax in your own private hot tub at a unique stay after a busy day exploring Buffalo, NY.

Former Monastery - Aspirant Cell (Budget) - Buffalo, NY
9.2 46 reviews

Former Monastery - Aspirant Cell (Budget)

church, Buffalo
Moreland Guesthouse, a unique guest house in a restored 1922 nun's convent in Buffalo, offers convenient access to various Buffalo landmarks, though precise distances aren't specified.
This single-bedroom lodging, sleeping one guest, features a shared kitchen with fridge and microwave, two bathrooms, and communal areas including a dining room, living room, and billiard room; daily cleaning of common areas is provided.

Best pet friendly Buffalo, NY unique stays

Among the 14 accommodations in Buffalo, NY, here are the 2 best pet friendly unique accommodations

Hidden Steampunk Carriage H, Quiet, Park 1 Car - Buffalo, NY
9.9 14 reviews

Hidden Steampunk Carriage H, Quiet, Park 1 Car

cabin, Buffalo
This steampunk-themed carriage house apartment is situated in a quiet Buffalo neighbourhood, conveniently close to local restaurants and shops.
The two-bedroom, one-bathroom property sleeps four guests and boasts a well-equipped kitchen with modern appliances, a private porch, Roku TV, gas fireplace, and three individual air conditioning/heating units.
4-bedroom Harbourtown Beach House, Mins From Beach - Buffalo, NY
9.9 27 reviews

4-bedroom Harbourtown Beach House, Mins From Beach

tower, Fort Erie
This four-bedroom townhome is located in Fort Erie's Crescent Park, a short 1.6km drive from Erie Beach and 16km from Crystal Beach.
The 280m² property offers an open-plan living/dining area, a chef's kitchen, four bathrooms, and a self-contained basement suite; sleeping up to twelve guests, it includes parking for two cars and is close to major highways.

Discover Unusual Places to Stay with a Swimming Pool in Buffalo, NY

Enjoy a unique stay in Buffalo, NY with a pool for a refreshing swim right in the city centre.

2bd Log Cabin In The Heart Of The City - Buffalo, NY
9.8 97 reviews

2bd Log Cabin In The Heart Of The City

house, Buffalo

Top-Rated 5-Star Unusual Places to Stay in Buffalo, NY

The luxury unique stays below in Buffalo, NY offer a sophisticated urban base with a singular twist.

4-bedroom Harbourtown Beach House, Mins From Beach - Buffalo, NY
9.9 27 reviews

4-bedroom Harbourtown Beach House, Mins From Beach

tower, Fort Erie
©2026 cozycozy.com