The widest selection of unusual accommodations in Ithaca, NY

A cabin, a lighthouse, a glamping, your extraordinary stay awaits you

7 nights
2
1
  • airbnb
  • booking
  • vrbo
  • expedia
  • sonder
  • priceline
  • tripadvisor
  • tripcom
  • homestay
  • hotelscom
  • orbitz
  • vacasa
Ithaca, NY unique stays
Choose the perfect vacation accommodation
Price per night
Accommodation type
Rating

7 Unique places to stay in Ithaca, NY

Find the Best Family Unique Stays in Ithaca, NY

Traveling to Ithaca, NY with kids? A family-friendly unique stay offers something beyond the ordinary for all ages.

The Cozy Caboose! - Ithaca, NY
9.9 93 reviews
Ithaca, NY
07/26 – 07/30
$344/nighttotal: $1376 (4 )

The Cozy Caboose!

1 4
train , Ithaca
This renovated 1953 D&H railway caboose, located seven miles outside Ithaca near Robert Treman State Park, offers a unique stay in a rural setting.
The 4-guest railway car features a kitchenette, tiled shower, bunk beds, a futon, and a sofa bed, plus a continental breakfast; it's one mile from the park's swimming holes.

Best Ithaca, NY unique accommodations with a garden

Upscale Rustic Cabin In Ithaca - Ithaca, NY
9.9 39 reviews
Ithaca, NY
08/15 – 11/20
$517/nighttotal: $50149 (97 )

Upscale Rustic Cabin In Ithaca

1 1
cabin , East Ithaca
The Hilltop House, a three-bedroom East Ithaca rental, is located in a rural area near Cornell University (5 minutes), downtown Ithaca and Ithaca College (10 minutes), and offers easy access to Taughannock Falls (25 minutes) and the Seneca Lake Wine Trail (40 minutes).
This pet-friendly cottage boasts a spacious interior with two bathrooms, a large kitchen with two ovens, a wood-burning fireplace, and a deck showcasing stunning 20-mile valley views; it comfortably sleeps eight guests and includes amenities such as internet, air conditioning, and parking.
The Cozy Caboose! - Ithaca, NY
9.9 93 reviews
Ithaca, NY
07/26 – 07/30
$344/nighttotal: $1376 (4 )

The Cozy Caboose!

1 4
train , Ithaca
This renovated 1953 D&H railway caboose, located seven miles outside Ithaca near Robert Treman State Park, offers a unique stay in a rural setting.
The 4-guest railway car features a kitchenette, tiled shower, bunk beds, a futon, and a sofa bed, plus a continental breakfast; it's one mile from the park's swimming holes.
Ithaca Bungalow/tiny Home, Quiet Escape In City - Ithaca, NY
9.9 316 reviews
Ithaca, NY
08/07 – 08/12
$268/nighttotal: $1340 (5 )

Ithaca Bungalow/tiny Home, Quiet Escape In City

1 2
bungalow , Ithaca
This charming studio apartment is located in a peaceful neighborhood, just a short walk from Ithaca College and Cornell University. It boasts excellent ratings for location, cleanliness, and user experience.
The apartment features a private deck and patio, a sunroom, and a full kitchen with laundry facilities. Guests can enjoy access to a nearby recreational trail, explore the owner's ceramics studio and gallery, and relax in the peaceful ambiance of the bungalow.

Frequently Asked Questions about unique stays in Ithaca, NY

  • What attractions is Ithaca, NY famous for?

    Ithaca is known for its beautiful natural scenery. Cornell University is a big draw for visitors, and you can enjoy a scenic walk through the Cornell Botanic Gardens. The Buttermilk Falls State Park is another popular spot, with stunning waterfalls and hiking trails. And of course, no trip to Ithaca is complete without a visit to the Ithaca Falls.
  • What clothing or gear is recommended for the climate in Ithaca, NY?

    Ithaca has four distinct seasons, so pack accordingly. In the summer, you'll need light clothing, but be prepared for some rain. In the winter, it can get very cold, so bring a warm coat, hat, and gloves. And don't forget comfortable shoes for all the hiking and exploring you'll be doing.
  • Which neigbourhood offers the best unique stays in Ithaca, NY?

    The Collegetown neighborhood is a great place to find unique stays. It's close to Cornell University and has a lot of cool shops and restaurants. You can find some really interesting Airbnbs in this area, like a converted barn or a historic house.
  • What should you know about unique stays in Ithaca, NY before booking?

    Before you book a unique stay in Ithaca, make sure you read the reviews carefully. Some unique stays might not be as luxurious as traditional hotels, so it's important to know what to expect. You should also check the location to make sure it's convenient for you and your travel plans.

Destinations nearby

Popular Unique Stays with a Hot Tub in Ithaca, NY

These unique stays in Ithaca, NY feature hot tubs in one-of-a-kind settings, perfect for a private soak at the end of a city day.

Knot Work - Ithaca, NY
Ithaca, NY
08/15 – 10/31
$299/nighttotal: $23023 (77 )

Knot Work

1 1
boat , Ithaca
This unique houseboat, "Knot work," offers waterfront accommodation along the Cayuga Lake trail, a few blocks from the Island Health and Fitness Center.
This boat sleeps up to 5 guests and features a full kitchen, air conditioning, and one bathroom, providing a distinct houseboat living experience near Ithaca.

Best pet friendly Ithaca, NY unique stays

Among the 3 accommodations in Ithaca, NY, here are the 3 best pet friendly unique accommodations

Upscale Rustic Cabin In Ithaca - Ithaca, NY
9.9 39 reviews
Ithaca, NY
08/15 – 11/20
$517/nighttotal: $50149 (97 )

Upscale Rustic Cabin In Ithaca

1 1
cabin , East Ithaca
The Hilltop House, a three-bedroom East Ithaca rental, is located in a rural area near Cornell University (5 minutes), downtown Ithaca and Ithaca College (10 minutes), and offers easy access to Taughannock Falls (25 minutes) and the Seneca Lake Wine Trail (40 minutes).
This pet-friendly cottage boasts a spacious interior with two bathrooms, a large kitchen with two ovens, a wood-burning fireplace, and a deck showcasing stunning 20-mile valley views; it comfortably sleeps eight guests and includes amenities such as internet, air conditioning, and parking.
The Cozy Caboose! - Ithaca, NY
9.9 93 reviews
Ithaca, NY
07/26 – 07/30
$344/nighttotal: $1376 (4 )

The Cozy Caboose!

1 4
train , Ithaca
This renovated 1953 D&H railway caboose, located seven miles outside Ithaca near Robert Treman State Park, offers a unique stay in a rural setting.
The 4-guest railway car features a kitchenette, tiled shower, bunk beds, a futon, and a sofa bed, plus a continental breakfast; it's one mile from the park's swimming holes.
Spotted Sandpiper - Cabin #3 - Ithaca, NY
9.0 2 reviews
Ithaca, NY
08/15 – 10/31
$279/nighttotal: $21483 (77 )

Spotted Sandpiper - Cabin #3

2 1
cabin , Trumansburg
This Trumansburg cabin rental is a five-minute walk from Cayuga Lake and a five-minute drive from Taughannock Falls State Park.
The two-bedroom, one-bathroom cottage sleeps four and includes Wi-Fi, air conditioning, and parking, offering easy access to nearby parks, Ithaca Commons, and other attractions.
©2026 cozycozy.com