Accommodations at the best price near The Old Mill, Ithaca

109 available accommodation offers

7 nights
2
1
  • airbnb
  • booking
  • vrbo
  • expedia
  • sonder
  • priceline
  • tripadvisor
  • tripcom
  • homestay
  • hotelscom
  • orbitz
  • vacasa
The Old Mill, Ithaca accommodations
Choose the perfect vacation accommodation
Price per night
Accommodation type
Rating

The Old Mill, Ithaca: Compare Airbnb, Hotels and vacation rentals

Best family friendly The Old Mill, Ithaca lodging

Among the 109 accommodations in The Old Mill, Ithaca, here are the 4 best for families

Secluded, Elegant Country Home Only 10 Minutes From Downtown Ithaca! - The Old Mill, Ithaca
10 4 reviews

Secluded, Elegant Country Home Only 10 Minutes From Downtown Ithaca!

apartment, Ithaca
This country ranch house in Ithaca offers a secluded setting, located a short drive from Buttermilk Falls State Park and Cayuga Lake, and close to Butterfield Stadium and Newman Arena.
This 2500 square foot estate features two bedrooms, three bathrooms, and accommodates up to 4 guests with two living areas, a cook's kitchen, a covered deck with a Blackstone griddle, and a lower-level wet bar/kitchenette.
Luxury Estate W/ Pool & Barn  Sleeps 14 | Groups - The Old Mill, Ithaca
9.9 58 reviews

Luxury Estate W/ Pool & Barn Sleeps 14 | Groups

apartment, Ithaca
This Victorian farmhouse, located near Ithaca, New York, offers a peaceful countryside setting just 15 minutes from Ithaca's attractions.
This 7-bedroom, 3-bathroom property sleeps 10 guests and boasts a pool, hot tub, and fully equipped kitchen, including a dishwasher, plus free internet access.
Cayuga Heights Home - Cornell Commencement - The Old Mill, Ithaca
10 2 reviews

Cayuga Heights Home - Cornell Commencement

apartment, Cayuga Heights
This charming two-story home is located on a quiet street in Cayuga Heights, just a short distance from Cornell University, downtown Ithaca, and Ithaca College. The property has received excellent ratings for location, cleanliness, and overall experience.
This cozy rental offers three bedrooms and two bathrooms, comfortably accommodating up to six guests. Enjoy a fully equipped kitchen, a private yard with a screen porch, a spacious backyard with lounge chairs, and a fitness center.
Classy, Comfy & Clean Downtown & Parking - The Old Mill, Ithaca
9.8 38 reviews

Classy, Comfy & Clean Downtown & Parking

house, Ithaca
This charming 6-bedroom home is located in a residential area of Ithaca, just a short walk from restaurants, shops, and parks. Guests rave about the excellent location, cleanliness, and overall experience.
The home comfortably sleeps 12 guests and features a spacious kitchen and backyard. Guests can enjoy the hot tub, play catch in the fenced-in yard, or take advantage of the nearby playgrounds, basketball courts, and public pool.

Best The Old Mill, Ithaca lodging with a pool

Among the 109 accommodations in The Old Mill, Ithaca, here are the 2 best ones with a pool

Cottages At Pinecreek - The Old Mill, Ithaca
10 2 reviews

Cottages At Pinecreek

cabin, Ithaca
This Ithaca cabin, located 0.5 miles from Robert Treman State Park and the Finger Lakes Trail, offers easy access to three more state parks and 30 wineries within a 35-minute drive.
The cottage features one bedroom, one bathroom, sleeps five, includes a full kitchen, air conditioning, a private deck, and a swimming pool, with parking provided.
Rustic Log Cabin At Pinecreek - The Old Mill, Ithaca
10 1 review

Rustic Log Cabin At Pinecreek

cabin, Ithaca
This Ithaca-area cabin rental boasts a peaceful pond-side location in a rural setting outside of the city center, requiring a short drive to reach Ithaca's attractions.
The one-bedroom, one-bathroom lodge sleeps six guests comfortably, featuring a fully equipped kitchen, air conditioning, a seasonal pool, laundry facilities, an outdoor fire ring, and a porch overlooking the pond; linens are not provided.

Top-rated The Old Mill, Ithaca accommodation

Historic Train Station Cottages - The Old Mill, Ithaca
9.5 1065 reviews

Historic Train Station Cottages

apartment, Cayuga Heights
This charming historic train station is located in Cayuga Heights, just across the street from Stewart Park and the Cayuga Waterfront Trailhead, making it a perfect base for exploring the area's natural beauty. The accommodation has received excellent ratings for its cleanliness, location, and overall experience.
The house features a rustic bohemian vibe, combining historic charm with modern comforts. Guests can enjoy a full kitchen, a BBQ grill, and a friendly resident cat named Blue, adding a touch of warmth to the stay.

The Old Mill, Ithaca: Other neighborhoods and points of interest

Best The Old Mill, Ithaca accommodation with a balcony

Luxurious House Near Cornell Campus With Lake Views And Incredible Sunsets. - The Old Mill, Ithaca
10 1 review

Luxurious House Near Cornell Campus With Lake Views And Incredible Sunsets.

apartment, Lansing
This Ithaca vacation home, a 15-minute drive from Cornell University and offering breathtaking Cayuga Lake views, is ideally located near Ithaca Commons and Buttermilk Falls State Park.
The six-bedroom, seven-bathroom residence comfortably sleeps twelve guests and boasts a private in-ground pool, a fully equipped kitchen with dishwasher, and ample parking; nearby attractions include Newman Arena and Dutch Harvest Farm.
©2026 cozycozy.com