Search special places in Long Island, NY from 100+ sites!

A cabin, a lighthouse, a glamping, your extraordinary stay awaits you

7 nights
2
1
  • airbnb
  • booking
  • vrbo
  • expedia
  • sonder
  • priceline
  • tripadvisor
  • tripcom
  • homestay
  • hotelscom
  • orbitz
  • vacasa
Long Island, NY unique stays
Choose the perfect vacation accommodation
Price per night
Accommodation type
Rating

468 Unique places to stay in Long Island, NY

Best family friendly Long Island, NY unique stays

Among the 468 accommodations in Long Island, NY, here are the 4 best family friendly unique accommodations

Family Cottage With 4 King Beds - Long Island, NY
No reviews

Family Cottage With 4 King Beds

chalet, Norwalk
This chalet is located in Norwalk's Historic District, approximately 1.2 miles from Norwalk City Hall and East Norwalk Historical Cemetery, and about 1.9 miles from Old Mill Beach and Lockwood Mathews Mansion Museum.
This pet-friendly lodge offers free Wi-Fi in common areas, on-site parking, laundry facilities, a garden with a gas barbecue, and a picnic area.
A  Breathtaking And Relaxing Place To Call Home - Long Island, NY
10 44 reviews

A Breathtaking And Relaxing Place To Call Home

bungalow, Milford
This Milford, Connecticut bungalow is located one block from Cedar Beach and offers easy access to downtown Milford's restaurants, shops, the Westfield Connecticut Post Mall, the Metro-North train station, I-95, and the Boston Post Road.
This newly renovated two-bedroom, one-bathroom house sleeps four guests and features a covered patio, in-unit laundry, fiber optic WiFi, a Smart TV with streaming services, and a manicured yard.
Doubletree By Hilton Newark Airport - Long Island, NY
No reviews

Doubletree By Hilton Newark Airport

hotel, Newark
The DoubleTree by Hilton Newark Airport offers convenient lodging for travelers visiting Newark, located approximately 0.5 miles from Newark Liberty International Airport with shuttle service available.
This 4-star hotel provides guests with complimentary Wi-Fi, an on-site restaurant and bar, a fitness center, a swimming pool, and parking, along with room service for added convenience.
Modern Farmhouse W/ Heated Pool, Beach, Horses And Winery In Heart Of North Fork - Long Island, NY
10 19 reviews

Modern Farmhouse W/ Heated Pool, Beach, Horses And Winery In Heart Of North Fork

farm, Mattituck
This Mattituck farmhouse rental is minutes from Love Lane, Breakwater Beach, and the Mattituck train station, adjacent to Seabrook Farm and Bridge Lane Vineyards, offering easy access to beaches, wineries, and farm-to-table restaurants.
The 2,000-square-foot property features three bedrooms, two bathrooms, and accommodates up to eight guests, boasting a heated saltwater pool (May 10-October 1), a large fenced yard, and high-end amenities including a gourmet kitchen and flat-screen TVs in every room.

Best Long Island, NY unique accommodations with a garden

Cozy Orient Farmhouse On 1.6 Acres With Pool And Walk To Beach - Long Island, NY
10 8 reviews

Cozy Orient Farmhouse On 1.6 Acres With Pool And Walk To Beach

manor house, Orient
This charming historic farmhouse is nestled in Orient Point, a tranquil enclave on the North Fork of Long Island, just steps from Orient Beach State Park and a short bike ride from Orient town center. The 1700 square feet farm features 4 bedrooms, 4 bathrooms, and can accommodate up to 10 guests.
The farm offers a secluded setting on 1.6 acres with a fenced-in yard and private woodland, a heated saltwater gunite pool with a hot tub and outdoor kitchen, a spacious eat-in kitchen with a dining table and separate outdoor pergola for entertaining, a cozy living room with a wood-burning fireplace and a separate den for kids, a mudroom with a full washer and dryer, and bikes available for use in the barn.
Delightfully Renovated Colonial Barn By The Beach! - Long Island, NY
10 87 reviews

Delightfully Renovated Colonial Barn By The Beach!

farm, Fairfield
This converted barn is located in Fairfield County, a short distance from Fairfield's charming town center and close to the beaches of Bridgeport. This property has received excellent ratings for location, cleanliness, and overall experience.
The barn offers a spacious living area for up to 6 guests, featuring a modern kitchen, cozy fireplace, and private patio with outdoor seating and a gas grill. Guests can enjoy the unique blend of historic charm and modern amenities, including a claw foot soaking tub and outdoor shower.
Sunny French Cottage - Long Island, NY
9.9 121 reviews

Sunny French Cottage

cabin, Norwalk
This Norwalk cottage, situated between the Merritt Parkway and I-95, offers a peaceful retreat near major highways.
The completely renovated studio features a queen-size bed in a loft-style bedroom, a small kitchenette with a fridge and microwave, a stylish bathroom, accommodates two guests, and includes a free Tesla charger.
Beach & Woods: Cozy Cabin, Hot Tub, Peloton, Oh My - Long Island, NY
9.7 121 reviews

Beach & Woods: Cozy Cabin, Hot Tub, Peloton, Oh My

cabin, Aquebogue
This secluded Aquebogue cabin is just a short walk or bike ride from the ocean, farms, vineyards, and other attractions, offering a peaceful escape surrounded by nature. The cabin consistently receives excellent ratings for location, cleanliness, and overall experience.
The home has 4 bedrooms and 2 bathrooms, comfortably accommodating up to 9 guests. Amenities include a Peloton bike, a hot tub, a private beach across the street, and a spacious lawn, making it perfect for families and groups looking for a relaxing and enjoyable getaway.

Frequently Asked Questions about unique stays in Long Island, NY

  • What are some hidden gems to explore on Long Island, NY?

    Long Island has tons of hidden gems! For a peaceful escape, check out the Planting Fields Arboretum State Historic Park in Oyster Bay. It's gorgeous, with expansive gardens and a historic mansion. Another great spot is the Theodore Roosevelt County Park in Oyster Bay, offering beautiful hiking trails and stunning views. If you're into history, the Sag Harbor Whaling Museum is a fascinating look into the area's past. And for a unique experience, explore the charming village of Cold Spring Harbor, with its quaint shops and waterfront views.
  • Are there any notable festivals that take place on Long Island, NY?

    Long Island hosts many festivals throughout the year. The Long Island Summer Festival is a popular event, featuring a variety of musical acts. The Oyster Bay Fall Festival is a great family-friendly event with crafts, food, and entertainment. Many towns also host smaller, local festivals celebrating everything from wine to art. Check local event listings closer to your travel dates for the most up-to-date information.
  • What types of natural environments are typical on Long Island, NY?

    Long Island boasts diverse natural environments. The north shore features beautiful beaches, charming seaside towns, and stunning waterfront views. The south shore has a more laid-back vibe, with long stretches of sandy beaches perfect for swimming and sunbathing. Inland, you'll find charming villages, state parks with hiking trails, and plenty of opportunities for birdwatching. Fire Island National Seashore is a must-see for its pristine beaches and wildlife.
  • Are there popular sporting events or activities on Long Island, NY?

    Yes! Long Island is home to the Long Island Ducks, a minor league baseball team, whose games are always a fun outing. Many local parks offer opportunities for biking, hiking, and fishing. Jones Beach State Park is a popular spot for swimming, surfing, and other water sports. Golfing is also very popular, with many excellent courses available across the island.
  • What special gear or clothing is recommended for the climate on Long Island, NY?

    Long Island's weather can be unpredictable, so packing layers is key. Summers are warm and humid, so pack light clothing, swimwear, and sunscreen. Winters can be cold and windy, especially near the coast, so bring warm coats, hats, gloves, and scarves. Rain is possible year-round, so packing a raincoat or umbrella is always a good idea. Comfortable walking shoes are also a must, as you'll likely be doing a lot of exploring on foot.
  • What activities allow you to experience local traditions and interact with residents on Long Island, NY?

    To experience local traditions, visit some of the many farmers' markets found across Long Island. These markets offer a chance to sample local produce, meet the farmers, and learn about the area's agricultural heritage. Exploring the charming towns and villages will also give you a feel for the local culture. Many towns host regular events and festivals where you can interact with residents and experience Long Island's unique character.
  • Is Long Island, NY known for any unique natural displays or phenomena during certain seasons?

    During the fall, the changing leaves in the many parks and preserves provide spectacular foliage displays. In the spring, the beaches and parks come alive with migrating birds. The coastline offers stunning sunrises and sunsets year-round.
  • What are the best local foods on Long Island, NY?

    Long Island is known for its fresh seafood, particularly its clams, oysters, and lobsters. Many restaurants offer delicious seafood dishes using locally sourced ingredients. Local farms also produce a variety of fruits, vegetables, and other agricultural products. You'll find many farm stands and markets selling these fresh, seasonal items. Don't forget to try the famous Long Island iced tea!
  • What are the best adventurous activities on Long Island, NY?

    For adventure, kayaking or paddleboarding in the Great South Bay offers stunning views and a chance to explore the coastline. Hiking the trails in one of Long Island's many state parks provides a rewarding experience, with opportunities for birdwatching and wildlife viewing. For something different, try deep-sea fishing for a chance to catch some of the local seafood.

Nearby regions

Best Long Island, NY unique stays with a jacuzzi

Among the 468 accommodations in Long Island, NY, here are the 1 best unique accommodations with a jacuzzi

Jana House Getaway /Hot Tub/game Room/king Bed - Long Island, NY
No reviews

Jana House Getaway /Hot Tub/game Room/king Bed

chalet, Baldwin
Jana House Getaway is a chalet located in Baldwin, 4.3 miles from Nassau Veterans Memorial Coliseum and within 10-17 miles of Jones Beach, Belmont Park Race Track, Aqueduct Racetrack, and Citi Field.
This 1650 square foot lodge accommodates up to 8 guests in 4 bedrooms and features a hot tub, game room, fully equipped kitchen with a dishwasher and oven, fireplace, and free WiFi.

Best pet friendly Long Island, NY unique stays

Among the 468 accommodations in Long Island, NY, here are the 4 best pet friendly unique accommodations

Luxury 9 Acre Sagaponack/sag Harbor Compound Retreat & Year-round Spa - Long Island, NY
10 106 reviews

Luxury 9 Acre Sagaponack/sag Harbor Compound Retreat & Year-round Spa

manor house, Bridgehampton
This Bridgehampton farm is located in the heart of the Hamptons, just a short distance from the beach and close to Sag Harbor, known for its historic whaling museum and Bay Street Theatre. The farm has earned an excellent user rating and is perfect for families and groups.
This 9,000 square foot farmhouse comfortably accommodates up to 16 guests. The property features a private tennis court, a koi pond, a playground, a heated pool, a cedar soaking tub, a fire pit lounge, a sauna, and a pergola with a 200-inch projection screen. Guests can enjoy a variety of activities, including boating, paddle boarding, kayaking, and even private chef services.
Cabin ∙ 3 Bedrooms ∙ 5 Guests - Long Island, NY
No reviews

Cabin ∙ 3 Bedrooms ∙ 5 Guests

cabin, Rocky Point
This three-bedroom log cabin is located in a private beachfront community in Rocky Point, offering direct beach access via a private path, and is a short drive from North Fork wineries, farm stands, and the village of Greenport. This family-friendly retreat accommodates up to five guests with air conditioning, internet, a full kitchen, and an outdoor shower, and is ideal for enjoying sunsets, kayaking, and fishing.
Beautiful Shinnecock Bay View. Spacious - Long Island, NY
10 48 reviews

Beautiful Shinnecock Bay View. Spacious

chalet, Hampton Bays
This Hampton Bays chalet is just 54 feet from the beach, offering breathtaking water views of Shinnecock Bay, and is a short drive to downtown Hampton Bays. The chalet has received excellent ratings for location, cleanliness, and user experience.
The 2-bedroom, 2-bathroom chalet comfortably accommodates 4 guests. This vacation rental features a fully equipped kitchen, a fitness center, a Tesla charging station, and a private garden.
Beach Lodge With Private Beach-2.5 Acres Of Quiet Nature,4 Beds, Chefs Kitchen - Long Island, NY
No reviews

Beach Lodge With Private Beach-2.5 Acres Of Quiet Nature,4 Beds, Chefs Kitchen

chalet, Southold
This Southold lodge is located in Greenport, NY, 5 minutes by car from Greenport's dining and shopping, and near the Railroad Museum of Long Island.
This four-bedroom chalet accommodates up to 11 guests and features a chef's kitchen with Viking appliances, private beach access, and a 2.5-acre park-like property with two outdoor decks.
©2026 cozycozy.com