Search Sag Harbor, NY accommodations

192 available accommodation offers

7 nights
2
1
  • airbnb
  • booking
  • stayz
  • expedia
  • hotelscom
  • tripadvisor
  • tripcom
  • agoda
  • homestay
  • tuivillas
  • hostelworld
  • hotelopia
Sag Harbor, NY accommodation
Choose the perfect holiday accommodation
Price per night
Accommodation type
Rating

192 Best accommodations in Sag Harbor, NY

Sag Harbor, NY: Best accommodations with a pool

Among the 192 accommodations in the area, here is the list of the 4 best ones with a pool

Newly Renovated, Centrally Located East Hampton Home, Total Privacy,... - Sag Harbor, NY
10 9 reviews
Sag Harbor, NY
31/07 – 03/08
A$9172/nighttotal: A$27516 (3 )

Newly Renovated, Centrally Located East Hampton Home, Total Privacy,...

4 4
apartment , Wainscott
This Wainscott holiday home is situated in East Hampton North, less than 5 kilometres from attractions including the Jewish Center of the Hamptons, Guild Hall, and the Home Sweet Home Museum.
This four-bedroom, four-bathroom property sleeps ten guests and boasts a private pool, fitness centre, tennis court, and gas grills, alongside a fully equipped kitchen and convenient amenities such as a washing machine.
Amazing Getaway! Stunning East Hampton House. Captivating! - Sag Harbor, NY
9.9 71 reviews
Sag Harbor, NY
01/07 – 07/09
A$2519/nighttotal: A$171292 (68 )

Amazing Getaway! Stunning East Hampton House. Captivating!

3 2
apartment , Wainscott
This charming apartment is situated just 5 kilometres from Wainscott's Main Beach and Beach Lane, offering easy access to the area's beautiful coastline and the vibrant village of Sag Harbor, just 6.5 kilometres away. The apartment has consistently received excellent ratings for its location, cleanliness, and overall experience.
The apartment spans 242 square metres and comfortably accommodates up to 5 guests in its three bedrooms. Enjoy the spacious yard, relax by the lagoon-style pool, or take advantage of the many amenities including a tennis court, spa, and Jacuzzi.
Tranquility Base; Architect-renovated, Modern Ranch With Heated Pool - Sag Harbor, NY
10 30 reviews
Sag Harbor, NY
04/10 – 12/10
A$1420/nighttotal: A$11360 (8 )

Tranquility Base; Architect-renovated, Modern Ranch With Heated Pool

4 2
apartment , Shelter Island Heights
This Shelter Island Heights holiday home, near the beach and a short drive from Sylvester Manor and Havens House, offers a luxurious stay close to Shelter Island's attractions.
This four-bedroom property boasts 265 square metres of living space, including a fully equipped kitchen with high-end appliances, a heated gunite pool, ample parking for five cars, and sleeping arrangements for eight guests, alongside a lower-level kitchenette and ping pong table.
Sag Harbor Hamptons Hideaway - Sag Harbor, NY
10 12 reviews
Sag Harbor, NY
19/07 – 24/07
A$3812/nighttotal: A$19060 (5 )

Sag Harbor Hamptons Hideaway

1 4
apartment , Noyack
This Noyack house, situated on over 0.4 hectares of private land, offers seclusion yet proximity to Noyack's attractions, the precise distance to which remains unspecified.
The 4-bedroom, 4-bathroom property boasts a heated 20x40 ft waterfall pool, ample parking, and sleeps up to 8 guests; features include a fully equipped kitchen, air conditioning, and a primary bedroom on the ground floor.

Sag Harbor, NY: Best family friendly accommodations

Among the 192 accommodations in the area, here is the list of the 4 best family friendly ones

The Chequit - Sag Harbor, NY
Sag Harbor, NY
04/10 – 12/10
A$572/nighttotal: A$4576 (8 )

The Chequit

1 2
island , Shelter Island Heights
The Chequit is located in Shelter Island Heights, a short drive from the Shelter Island Country Club and Sylvester Manor, and within easy reach of Sunset Beach and Crescent Beach. The peaceful environment of Shelter Island Heights makes this hotel a great choice for travellers seeking a break from the hustle and bustle of city life.
The hotel offers 35 guest rooms, each equipped with blackout drapes/curtains, complimentary wireless internet access, and bathrooms with showers. The Chequit also has a restaurant, a coffee shop/cafe, and free self parking.
Cozy Summer Cottage In The Hamptons - Sag Harbor, NY
9.6 37 reviews
Sag Harbor, NY
04/10 – 12/10
A$522/nighttotal: A$4176 (8 )

Cozy Summer Cottage In The Hamptons

1 2
apartment , Noyack
This Noyack holiday home is minutes from Sag Harbor's town centre, within walking distance of a bay beach, a freshwater pond, and Cromer's market, and a 32-kilometre drive from Cooper's Beach in Southampton.
The three-bedroom, one-bathroom property sleeps six, offering a fully equipped kitchen, laundry facilities, a fenced garden with BBQ and fire pit, plus Wi-Fi, and is ideal for families or couples seeking a relaxing Noyack getaway.
Our Peaceful, Beach Escape From The City - Sag Harbor, NY
9.8 49 reviews
Sag Harbor, NY
10/08 – 14/08
A$2058/nighttotal: A$8232 (4 )

Our Peaceful, Beach Escape From The City

1 5
apartment , Sag Harbor
This Sag Harbor house, a short distance from a private beach with direct access and within walking distance (less than 0.8 km) of Sag Harbor village's shops and restaurants, offers excellent location ratings.
Sleeping up to 12 guests in six bedrooms and four bathrooms, this spacious property features two living areas, a garden with a tennis court, two decks, a patio, a horseshoe pit, a ping pong table, and a fully equipped kitchen including a dishwasher; short and long-term rentals are available.
Oasis In The Heart Of The Hamptons - Sag Harbor, NY
10 20 reviews
Sag Harbor, NY
10/08 – 14/08
A$3470/nighttotal: A$13880 (4 )

Oasis In The Heart Of The Hamptons

1 5
apartment , Bridgehampton
This Sagaponack house, situated in the heart of the Hamptons, is a short drive (approximately 8km) from Bridgehampton, East Hampton, and Sag Harbour, offering easy access to both ocean and bay beaches.
This 260 sq m property boasts three bedrooms, two bathrooms, and sleeps up to eight guests, featuring a heated saltwater pool (additional fee), a well-equipped kitchen, and amenities including bikes, kayaks, and tennis racquets; it's close to Wölffer Estate Vineyard and Poxabogue Golf Club.

Frequently asked questions about accommodations in Sag Harbor, NY

  • What are the must-see sites in or near Sag Harbor, NY?

    Sag Harbor has a lot to offer! You definitely want to check out the Sag Harbor Whaling Museum, which tells the story of the town's whaling history. The Long Wharf is a charming spot to stroll along the waterfront, and the Sag Harbor Cinema is a classic movie theatre with a great atmosphere. If you're interested in art, visit the LongHouse Reserve, a sculpture garden and museum with incredible outdoor installations.
  • What are the best accommodations in Sag Harbor, NY?

    Among the accommodations in Sag Harbor, NY, Sag Harbor Inn, Baron's Cove and Sag Harbor Beach House are the most popular ones.

  • How can travelers reach Sag Harbor, NY?

    The easiest way to get to Sag Harbor is by car. It's about a 2-hour drive from New York City. You can also take the Long Island Rail Road to the Hampton Bays station and then take a taxi or a bus to Sag Harbor. For those flying in, the closest airport is Long Island MacArthur Airport, about an hour away.
  • What are the best accommodations with a pool in Sag Harbor, NY?

    Sag Harbor Inn, Baron's Cove and Sag Harbor Getaway-enjoy Fall In The Hamptons Hot Tub Open are the best accommodations with a pool in Sag Harbor, NY.

  • What outdoor activities can visitors enjoy in and around Sag Harbor, NY?

    Sag Harbor is a fantastic place for outdoor activities! You can go swimming, kayaking, or paddleboarding at the beach. There are also plenty of hiking and biking trails in the area, like the Long Island Rail Trail. For a more relaxing experience, take a scenic walk along the waterfront or visit the Sag Harbor Bay. The beach at the end of Main Street, known as 'The Ditch', is a local favourite.
  • What are the best accommodations with a jacuzzi in Sag Harbor, NY?

  • When is the ideal time to plan a trip to Sag Harbor, NY?

    The best time to visit Sag Harbor is during the summer months, from June to August, when the weather is warm and sunny. You can enjoy the beaches, outdoor activities, and the vibrant summer atmosphere. If you prefer milder weather and fewer crowds, spring or autumn are also good options.
  • What are the best accommodations for families and kids in Sag Harbor, NY?

    The best accommodations for families and kids in Sag Harbor, NY are Sag Harbor Inn, Baron's Cove and Walk To The Beach.

  • What are the best walking or cycling routes in Sag Harbor, NY?

    For a leisurely stroll, the Sag Harbor Village Walk is a great option. It's a 2km loop that takes you past historic buildings, shops, and restaurants. If you prefer cycling, the Long Island Rail Trail is a 100km paved path that runs through Sag Harbor and connects to other towns on Long Island.
  • What are the best pet friendly accommodations in Sag Harbor, NY?

    The best pet friendly accommodations in Sag Harbor, NY are Baron's Cove, Whaling Captain Pierson's Apartment Too and Whaling Captain Pierson's Apartment.

  • What nearby towns or cities can be explored from Sag Harbor, NY?

    Sag Harbor is a great base for exploring the Hamptons. You can easily visit nearby towns like Southampton, East Hampton, and Montauk. Each town has its own unique charm and attractions. If you're looking for a bigger city, you can take a day trip to New York City, which is about a 2-hour drive away.
  • What are the best accommodations with parking in Sag Harbor, NY?

    Sag Harbor Inn, Baron's Cove and Sag Harbor Beach House are the best accommodations with parking in Sag Harbor, NY.

  • What amenities can travelers expect from accommodations in Sag Harbor, NY?

    Sag Harbor offers a variety of accommodation options, from charming bed and breakfasts to luxurious hotels. Most accommodations offer amenities like Wi-Fi, air conditioning, and parking. You can also find places with swimming pools, hot tubs, and other recreational facilities. Many accommodations are within walking distance of shops, restaurants, and the beach.

Destinations nearby

Best Sag Harbor, NY accommodations with a balcony

Villa Willow & Waves - Sag Harbor, NY
Sag Harbor, NY
28/07 – 01/08
A$30652/nighttotal: A$122608 (4 )

Villa Willow & Waves

4 4
apartment , Wainscott
Villa Willow & Waves, a spacious four-bedroom apartment in East Hampton, is located 17.7 kilometres from Montauk Point Lighthouse and 25.7 kilometres from the Second House Museum.
This apartment offers 279 square metres of living space, accommodates up to 15 guests, and features a swimming pool, garden, terrace, and private parking.
Cove View Manor Of Sag Harbor - Sag Harbor, NY
10 72 reviews
Sag Harbor, NY
04/10 – 12/10
A$2372/nighttotal: A$18976 (8 )

Cove View Manor Of Sag Harbor

3 2
apartment , Noyack
This stylish apartment is ideally situated in Sag Harbor, just 1.6 kilometres from both Long Beach and the town centre, offering easy access to the area's attractions. The property has consistently received excellent guest reviews, highlighting its comfortable and well-equipped nature. The apartment offers three bedrooms and three bathrooms, spanning 186 square metres of living space. Guests can enjoy a range of amenities, including a private swimming pool, a terrace with water views, and a fully equipped kitchen.
Charming Sag Harbor Apartment. Two Blocks From Main And Bay Streets. - Sag Harbor, NY
Sag Harbor, NY
04/10 – 12/10
A$1618/nighttotal: A$12944 (8 )

Charming Sag Harbor Apartment. Two Blocks From Main And Bay Streets.

1 2
apartment , Sag Harbor
This two-storey flat offers prime Sag Harbour village accommodation, situated just 320 metres from Main Street, Marine Park, and The Jitney, with Haven's Beach a short cycle away.
This dwelling for two guests boasts a first-floor open-plan living space with a kitchen and dining area, leading to a two-level brick terrace and gardens, whilst the second floor features a spacious bedroom, lounge, balcony, and a marble-enclosed shower, complete with air conditioning, Wi-Fi, and on-site parking.
Cozy Shelter Island Cottage, Walk To Beaches And Mashomack Preserve - Sag Harbor, NY
9.8 29 reviews
Sag Harbor, NY
04/10 – 12/10
A$577/nighttotal: A$4616 (8 )

Cozy Shelter Island Cottage, Walk To Beaches And Mashomack Preserve

3 2
apartment , Shelter Island
This Shelter Island holiday home is situated near the Shelter Island ferry, offering easy access to Sag Harbor and the Hamptons, and is close to the Mashomack Preserve.
The 139 square metre property boasts three bedrooms, two bathrooms, sleeping up to six guests, and features a private pool, dock with beach access, gourmet kitchen, and paddleboards and bikes for exploring the island.

Best Sag Harbor, NY accommodations with a kitchen

Paddle Board? Beach Sunsets? Fine Dining? Vineyards? This Is The Ideal Getaway. - Sag Harbor, NY
9.6 5 reviews
Sag Harbor, NY
04/10 – 12/10
A$1858/nighttotal: A$14864 (8 )

Paddle Board? Beach Sunsets? Fine Dining? Vineyards? This Is The Ideal Getaway.

4 2
apartment , Sag Harbor
This Sag Harbor holiday home is situated near Foster Memorial Town Beach (0.8 km) and within 4.8 km of Bay Street Theatre and The Style Bar.
The four-bedroom property, sleeping eight guests, boasts a private pool, fully equipped kitchen, laundry facilities, and a terrace; enjoy al fresco dining with barbecue grills in the garden, all within a smoke-free environment.
Sag Harbor Chic Mid-century Retreat - Sag Harbor, NY
10 70 reviews
Sag Harbor, NY
28/07 – 01/08
A$1461/nighttotal: A$5844 (4 )

Sag Harbor Chic Mid-century Retreat

1 4
apartment , Noyack
This Noyack house, a short walk from Long Beach and one minute from the Serene Green market, offers easy access to local amenities and the coast.
Sleeping six guests across three bedrooms and two bathrooms, this property boasts a fully equipped kitchen with fridge, freezer, and dishwasher, air conditioning, a garden, parking, and excellent sunset views from its front deck.
Summer 2026 Now Available! Grab An Amazing Property In The Heart Of The Hamptons - Sag Harbor, NY
10 90 reviews
Sag Harbor, NY
06/07 – 13/07
A$5836/nighttotal: A$40852 (7 )

Summer 2026 Now Available! Grab An Amazing Property In The Heart Of The Hamptons

7 2
apartment , Bridgehampton
This luxurious seven-bedroom house is located in Sagaponack, just two miles from Bridgehampton village, harbour and beaches, offering a peaceful retreat in the heart of the Hamptons. It has consistently received excellent user ratings, making it a popular choice for families and groups.
The 418 square metre property comfortably accommodates up to 14 guests, providing ample space for everyone to relax and enjoy their stay. Amenities include a heated saltwater pool, a 12-person hot tub, a professional outdoor BBQ grill, a state-of-the-art home theatre system, a finished basement with games and an indoor gym, as well as a spacious deck with a pergola, outdoor furniture, a fire pit and a 50' LED LCD TV.
Sag Harbor Cottage, Walk To The Beach! - Sag Harbor, NY
9.9 313 reviews
Sag Harbor, NY
06/07 – 13/07
A$1326/nighttotal: A$9282 (7 )

Sag Harbor Cottage, Walk To The Beach!

1 2
apartment , Noyack
This Noyack apartment is located just under 300 metres from Long Beach, a mile-long stretch of sand on Peconic Bay.
The three-bedroom property features a spacious outdoor area with a mahogany deck, an outdoor shower, a gas BBQ grill, and a roomy lawn with a fire pit, perfect for relaxing and entertaining.
©2026 cozycozy.com