Restored Farmhouse With Hot-tub In Penn Yan, New York
4 8
cottage , Penn Yan
This restored 1850s farmhouse, a detached cottage, is located in Penn Yan, just 5 minutes from town and centrally positioned for the Seneca and Keuka Lake Wine and Beer Trails. This property offers accommodation for 8 guests with 4 bedrooms and 2 bathrooms, featuring a private hot tub, extensive outdoor amenities including a terrace and fire pit, on-site kayak rentals, and available packages for private wine tours and horseback riding.
8.0 10 reviews
Finger Lakes, NY
20/06 – 27/06
$878/nighttotal: $6146 (7 )
Deep Run Fun - Luxury Lake Life
3 5
cottage , Crystal Beach
This Canandaigua lakefront holiday home, located minutes from local breweries, wineries, and restaurants, is a short drive from Canandaigua's historic district, Kershaw Park, and the New York Wine and Culinary Centre. The 116 square metre (1248 sq ft) property boasts three bedrooms, two bathrooms, a living room with a stone fireplace, a fully equipped kitchen, and can accommodate up to twelve guests, with added features including a private dock (subject to water levels), a lakeside patio with a gas grill and firepit (seasonal), and pet-friendly access.
9.8 31 reviews
Finger Lakes, NY
28/07 – 31/07
$971/nighttotal: $2913 (3 )
Seneca Knoll:"gorgeous Custom-built Home With Seneca Lake Views"
3 1
cottage , Romulus
This Romulus waterfront holiday home boasts easy access to Sampson State Park, lying within 9.6km of Zugibe Vineyards and Three Brothers Wineries, and under 19km from Rose Hill Mansion. The 149 square metre property offers three bedrooms, three bathrooms, sleeping up to six guests, and features a fully equipped kitchen, patio, garden, on-site laundry, BBQ, and parking.
9.4 3 reviews
Finger Lakes, NY
21/09 – 28/09
$376/nighttotal: $2632 (7 )
Lucky Catch: Best Cottage On The Best Lake!
1 2
cottage , Keuka Park
This lakeside holiday home in Penn Yan, located on East Lake Road, is approximately 8 kilometres from downtown Keuka Park and within walking distance of Keuka Lake and Keuka Lake State Park. This 56 square metre cottage accommodates up to six guests with one bedroom, a sleeper sofa, and a futon, offering direct Keuka Lake access, private docks, a boat lift, a canoe, and a swim raft, alongside a glass-enclosed sunroom perfect for sunset views.
9.8 15 reviews
Finger Lakes, NY
04/09 – 06/09
$592/nighttotal: $1184 (2 )
Sublime Sunsets--charming Cottage With No Bad Views
2 4
cottage , Interlaken
This Interlaken holiday home is situated near Cayuga Lake, a 5–10 minute drive from Aurora and Wells College, and 30 minutes from Ithaca, Cornell University, and Ithaca College. This 71-square-metre property boasts two bedrooms, one bathroom, sleeping up to six guests, and features a kitchen with a fridge and microwave, a garden, a spa, parking, Wi-Fi, and a Roku TV; kayaking and fishing on Cayuga Lake are also available.
9.6 18 reviews
Finger Lakes, NY
24/07 – 26/07
$3512/nighttotal: $7024 (2 )
Wine To Water - Family Adventure On Keuka Lake Awaits!
4 2
cottage , Hammondsport
This holiday home is situated on Keuka Lake in Hammondsport, just eight kilometres north of the town centre and a ten-minute drive from five popular Keuka Lake wineries, offering direct waterfront access with a private dock, lake deck, and kayak. This spacious, 223 square metre cottage sleeps ten guests across four bedrooms and three bathrooms, featuring a newly renovated kitchen, a finished lower level recreation room with a second kitchen and gas fireplace, and an outdoor living space with a covered patio, gas grill, gas fire pit, and a six-person hot tub.
10 15 reviews
Finger Lakes, NY
14/09 – 18/09
$394/nighttotal: $1576 (4 )
Quiet/charming 2-bedroom Sunset-lake View Cottage Lovely Seneca Lake, Wine Trail
2 2
cottage , Geneva
This Geneva lakeside holiday home boasts a private waterfront location with 11km of private lake access and a removable dock, situated a short walk from local breweries and Ventosa Winery, and 11km from Geneva city centre. The 102 square metre property offers two bedrooms, one bathroom, sleeping up to five guests, and features a full kitchen, spacious open-plan living area, outdoor fire pit, Weber barbecue, and access to kayaking, canoeing, and paddleboarding (equipment not provided).
10 78 reviews
Finger Lakes, NY
08/09 – 12/09
$755/nighttotal: $3020 (4 )
Wow! Newly Renovated Cottage On Keuka Lake. Perfect For A Vacation On The Water
1 4
cottage , Keuka Park
This waterfront holiday home in Penn Yan, New York, boasts direct Keuka Lake access, under 1.6km from Keuka College and less than 4.8km from the Yates County Arts Center and Oliver House Museum. The 102 square metre property sleeps eight guests in four bedrooms plus a sofa bed, offering a fully equipped kitchen, air conditioning, Wi-Fi, a terrace, garden, parking, and barbecue facilities.
9.8 8 reviews
Finger Lakes, NY
19/06 – 21/06
$1433/nighttotal: $2866 (2 )
The Kove - Lakeside Living With Spectacular Views!
4 6
cottage , Keuka Park
This waterfront dwelling in Branchport offers direct access to 100 feet of Keuka Lake shoreline and a seasonal dock, located a short drive from the Narcissa Prentiss House and Oliver House Museum, and in proximity to Hunt Country Vineyards and Heron Hill Winery. This 186 square meter cottage accommodates up to 12 guests with 4 bedrooms and 3 bathrooms, featuring wall-to-wall windows with lake views, a sunroom, a fully equipped country kitchen, a spacious garden, and air conditioning, ideal for exploring Keuka Lake State Park and nearby wineries.
Finger Lakes, NY
28/07 – 31/07
$784/nighttotal: $2352 (3 )
2 Bedroom 1.5 Bath - Cottage In Welcoming Aurora On Cayuga Lake!
2 1
cottage , Aurora
This lakeside lodge, located in the Town of Ledyard, Aurora, offers direct access to Cayuga Lake and is situated approximately 1 kilometre from Long Point Winery and Long Point State Park. This 2-bedroom, 1-bathroom holiday home accommodates up to 6 guests and features a microwave, air conditioning, a terrace, garden, spa, parking, and includes a kayak and paddleboard for use on the water, with a separate annex bedroom and bathroom accessible externally.
Finger Lakes, NY
26/07 – 30/07
$700/nighttotal: $2800 (4 )
Lakefront Honeoye Cottage
2 4
cottage , Honeoye
This cottage in Honeoye provides convenient access to Canandaigua Lake and Honeoye Lake Boat Launch State Park, with the Honeoye Falls-Mendon Historical Society Museum and Bristol Valley Theater also nearby. Sleeping up to eight guests across two bedrooms and two living rooms with futons, this property offers air conditioning, Wi-Fi, parking, and a kitchen equipped with a fridge and microwave.
Finger Lakes, NY
07/08 – 11/08
$422/nighttotal: $1688 (4 )
Ultimate Relaxation! Lake-view Cottage In Bradford
2 2
cottage , Hammondsport
This holiday home is located on Lamoka Lake in Bradford, offering direct lake access and a shared seasonal boat dock, situated 14 kilometres from Hammondsport and its attractions, including the Glenn H Curtiss Museum, and within 20 kilometres of the Seneca Lake Wine Trail and 32 kilometres of the Keuka Lake Wine Trail. This 95 square meter, 2-bedroom, 1-bathroom property comfortably accommodates up to 6 guests, featuring air conditioning, a fully equipped kitchen with a dishwasher, in-home laundry, 2 Smart TVs, an electric fireplace, a laptop-friendly workspace, and a Juliet balcony with lake views, with easy access to outdoor pursuits at Watkins Glen State Park (24 kilometres) and Sugar Hill State Forest (14 kilometres).
Best family friendly Finger Lakes, NY cottage rentals
Among the 562 accommodations in Finger Lakes, NY, here are the 4 best family friendly cottage rentals
9.3 194 reviews
Finger Lakes, NY
07/09 – 10/09
$241/nighttotal: $723 (3 )
Rustic, Cozy Cottage With Backyard Waterfall And Cayuga Lake Views!
1 4
cottage , Ithaca
This charming cottage is conveniently located in the city centre of Ithaca, just under 5 kilometres from the Museum of the Earth and Cayuga Lake, and within 3 kilometres of the Cayuga Medical Centre. The cottage has consistently received excellent ratings for its cleanliness, location, and overall experience. The cottage is a comfortable and spacious one-bedroom property with a 70 square metre floor area, suitable for up to four guests. It offers a range of amenities including a fully equipped kitchen, a private garden, a terrace, a fireplace, and access to a spa, making it an ideal choice for a relaxing getaway in Ithaca.
9.2 27 reviews
Finger Lakes, NY
26/09 – 30/09
$737/nighttotal: $2948 (4 )
Live Your Best Vacation Life! Lovely 4 Br Property On Cayuga Lake. Dog Friendly
4 3
cottage , Aurora
This charming cottage is situated just 0.2 kilometres from the shores of Cayuga Lake and 2.7 kilometres from Bright Leaf Vineyard in Aurora, offering a peaceful retreat in the heart of wine country. It consistently receives excellent guest reviews, highlighting its comfortable and convenient features. The cottage spans 139 square metres and comfortably accommodates up to eight guests across its four bedrooms and three bathrooms. Guests can enjoy a range of amenities, including a fully equipped kitchen, a spacious terrace, and a private garden, making it ideal for both relaxing and exploring the surrounding area.
9.9 96 reviews
Finger Lakes, NY
14/07 – 17/07
$531/nighttotal: $1593 (3 )
Hot Tub, Lake View Cottage, Dog Friendly, Lake Access
2 1
cottage , Hammondsport
This charming cottage is conveniently located just five minutes from The Arrowhead golf course, nestled between Keuka and Seneca Lakes, and right next to Waneta Lake. It has consistently received excellent ratings for its location, cleanliness, and overall experience. The cottage spans 102 square metres and comfortably accommodates up to six guests. Guests can enjoy an enclosed hot tub, a spacious garden, lake access for kayaking, a private screened-in porch, and a well-equipped kitchen, making it ideal for families and pet owners.
10 111 reviews
Finger Lakes, NY
21/09 – 28/09
$922/nighttotal: $6454 (7 )
Great Summer Rental On Finger Lakes Wine Trail: Owasco East Side Lakefront
3 2
cottage , Melrose Park
This waterfront cottage is situated just 10 kilometres from Auburn, a charming town with a range of amenities, and 15 kilometres from the picturesque village of Skaneateles, known for its scenic lake and historic restaurants. This property has received excellent user ratings. The cottage offers 139 square metres of living space, with 3 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms, and a capacity of 8 guests. It boasts a fully equipped kitchen, a private terrace, a garden, a spa, and direct access to the lake, perfect for swimming, fishing, and relaxing.
Best Finger Lakes, NY cottages with a garden
10 63 reviews
Finger Lakes, NY
07/08 – 11/08
$1674/nighttotal: $6696 (4 )
Wineries & Breweries Nearby-newly Renovated Lakefront Cottage-boat Slip-hot Tub
3 2
cottage , Dundee
This charming cottage is located on the east side of Keuka Lake in Dundee, just a short distance from restaurants, wineries, breweries, and the #1 winery in New York State. The property has received excellent ratings for user experience, location, and cleanliness. The two-bedroom cottage spans 84 square metres and offers a fully equipped kitchen, central air conditioning and heating, a private covered gazebo with a smart TV, and a hot tub (available except for July and August). Guests can enjoy stunning lake views, relax on the terrace, explore the garden, and make use of the on-site parking.
9.7 74 reviews
Finger Lakes, NY
25/09 – 27/09
$638/nighttotal: $1276 (2 )
Cottage On Seneca Lake Shoreline
1 2
cottage , Dresden
This Seneca Lake cottage, near Penn Yan, Geneva, and Watkins Glen in the Finger Lakes region of New York State (approximately 800km from Dresden), offers direct waterfront access and tranquil lake views. This one-bedroom, one-bathroom dwelling sleeps six, boasting a fully equipped kitchen (fridge, freezer, microwave), air conditioning, garden, parking, and excellent guest reviews; fishing and exploring nearby wineries and breweries are readily available.
9.9 255 reviews
Finger Lakes, NY
25/09 – 27/09
$2510/nighttotal: $5020 (2 )
Amazing Lakefront And Well Designed Lakehouse: That Is Sure To Please
4 2
cottage , Geneva
This charming lakeside cottage is located on the eastern shore of Seneca Lake, just a short distance from the vibrant city of Geneva. It enjoys an excellent rating for location, cleanliness and user experience. The 4-bedroom property comfortably accommodates up to 10 guests and features a fully equipped kitchen, a relaxing spa, a private garden and parking. Guests can enjoy breathtaking sunset views, direct lake access, and a range of on-site amenities, making it the perfect choice for a relaxing getaway.
8.6 20 reviews
Finger Lakes, NY
19/06 – 21/06
$2442/nighttotal: $4884 (2 )
The Willows:"delightful Cottage With Peaceful Sunsets"
2 6
cottage , Lodi
This lakeside holiday home near Lodi is situated within 3km of King's Garden, Lamoreaux Landing, and Wagner Vineyards wineries, with Silver Thread Vineyard a further 4.7km away. The 152 square metre property boasts two bedrooms, two bathrooms, sleeps six, and includes a fully equipped kitchen, patio, barbecue, fireplace, and DVD player, perfect for exploring Lodi's wineries and enjoying water activities.
Frequently Asked Questions about cottages in Finger Lakes, NY
What would be a good 2-days itinerary for visiting Finger Lakes, NY?
For a two-day trip, you could spend the first day exploring Seneca Lake. Visit Watkins Glen State Park, a beautiful gorge with waterfalls and hiking trails. In the evening, enjoy a wine tasting at one of the many wineries along the lake. The second day, head to Cayuga Lake and visit the charming town of Ithaca. Explore Cornell University campus and enjoy a scenic boat ride on the lake.
What are the best cottage rentals in Finger Lakes, NY?
What part of Finger Lakes, NY is ideal for renting a cottage?
The area around Seneca Lake is particularly popular for cottage rentals. You'll find many charming cottages nestled along the lake's shores, offering stunning views and a peaceful retreat. Skaneateles Lake is also a good option, known for its picturesque scenery and quieter atmosphere.
What are the best cottage rentals with a pool in Finger Lakes, NY?
When is the best time to rent a cottage in Finger Lakes, NY?
The best time to rent a cottage in the Finger Lakes depends on your preferences. If you enjoy warm weather and outdoor activities, summer (June to August) is ideal. For a more peaceful and scenic experience, consider visiting during the shoulder seasons, spring (April to May) or autumn (September to October), when the colours are stunning.
What are the best cottage rentals with a jacuzzi in Finger Lakes, NY?
What are the can't-miss sights in Finger Lakes, NY?
You absolutely must visit Watkins Glen State Park, with its dramatic gorges, waterfalls, and hiking trails. The Corning Museum of Glass is also a must-see, showcasing the history and art of glassmaking. For a unique experience, visit the Taughannock Falls State Park, home to the tallest waterfall east of the Mississippi River.
What are the best cottage rentals for families and kids in Finger Lakes, NY?
Why consider renting a cottage in Finger Lakes, NY for your stay?
Renting a cottage provides a more intimate and secluded experience compared to staying in a hotel. You'll have your own space, a kitchen to cook in, and often a private outdoor area to relax and enjoy the beautiful surroundings. Many cottages offer stunning lake views and are close to hiking trails and wineries.
What are the best pet friendly cottage rentals in Finger Lakes, NY?
Can you easily explore Finger Lakes, NY on foot or by bike?
While some areas are walkable, exploring the Finger Lakes by car is the most convenient option. The region is quite spread out, and many attractions are located in different towns and villages. However, you can find bike trails along the lakes and in some towns.
What are the best cottage rentals with parking in Finger Lakes, NY?
What family-friendly activities are available in Finger Lakes, NY?
The Finger Lakes offer many family-friendly activities, including visiting the Seneca Lake State Park, which has a playground, a beach, and a boat launch. The Corning Museum of Glass offers interactive exhibits and workshops for children. You can also take a scenic boat ride on one of the lakes or visit a local farm to pick your own fruit.
Destinations nearby
Best Finger Lakes, NY cottage rentals with jacuzzi
Among the 562 accommodations in Finger Lakes, NY, here are the 4 best cottage rentals with a jacuzzi
9.6 90 reviews
Finger Lakes, NY
02/10 – 06/10
$1056/nighttotal: $4224 (4 )
A Shore Thing: Breathtaking Panoramic Views And Spectacular Design Await You!
4 3
cottage , Aurora
This five-bedroom Aurora lakeside property, situated less than 1.6km from Cayuga Lake and within 3km of several wineries including Varick Winery and Vineyard, offers stunning lake views and easy access to local vineyards. The 178 square metre holiday home boasts a fully equipped kitchen, jacuzzi, tennis court, and can comfortably accommodate up to ten guests, with amenities including free Wi-Fi and a DVD player.
9.9 126 reviews
Finger Lakes, NY
09/09 – 12/09
$843/nighttotal: $2529 (3 )
Sunset Oasis Cottage
2 3
cottage , Aurora
This Aurora lakefront property, situated on Cayuga Lake's eastern shore less than 1.6km from Long Point State Park, offers stunning views and private dock access. Sleeping up to six guests in two bedrooms and a sofa bed, this fully equipped apartment boasts a jacuzzi, spa, and access to kayaks and inflatable tubes for exploring Cayuga Lake, alongside amenities including a dishwasher, smart TV, and high-speed internet.
10 1 review
Finger Lakes, NY
26/09 – 30/09
$952/nighttotal: $3808 (4 )
Charming 2 Bedroom Lakeside Cottage With Loft
3 3
cottage , Dresden
This Dresden cottage, ideally located near the wine trail, offers convenient access to nearby attractions. Sleeping six guests, this three-bedroom holiday home boasts a fully equipped kitchen (fridge, microwave), air conditioning, a hot tub, and access to four beach cruiser bikes, two kayaks, a double kayak, and a paddleboard.
9.6 37 reviews
Finger Lakes, NY
21/09 – 28/09
$1636/nighttotal: $11452 (7 )
Lakeside Solace: Luxury Family Retreat!
7 2
cottage , Honeoye
This Honeoye Lake waterfront property, minutes from Naples, New York, offers easy access to Bristol Mountain (approx. 24km) and the Cumming Nature Center, with potential boat docking depending on water levels. This six-bedroom, three-bathroom holiday home boasts 341 square metres of space, featuring an open-plan kitchen, dining, and living area, a hot tub, pool table, and sleeps up to 18 guests.
Best Finger Lakes, NY cottages with a fireplace
Finger Lakes, NY
31/07 – 03/08
$694/nighttotal: $2082 (3 )
Stunning Cottage With Fire Pit And Access To Great Hiking Trails In Keuka Park, New York
3 2
cottage , Keuka Park
This rural retreat is situated in the mountains of Penn Yan, offering seclusion on 13 wooded acres, a 9-minute drive from Keuka Lake and the town of Penn Yan. This three-bedroom lodge accommodates up to eight guests, featuring a private hot tub, a large wrap-around deck with a partial lake view, and is equipped with a full kitchen, Wi-Fi, and air conditioning.
10 50 reviews
Finger Lakes, NY
21/09 – 28/09
$596/nighttotal: $4172 (7 )
Sunrise, Sunset, Relax, Repeat Lamoka Cove
3 2
cottage , Hammondsport
This Hammondsport lakeside property offers direct waterfront access to Lamoka Lake, situated 5km from Waneta Lake and 14.5km from Keuka Lake and Ravines Wine Cellars. Sleeping eight guests, this three-bedroom, two-bathroom holiday home features a fully equipped kitchen, gas grills, free Wi-Fi, a terrace, and a private garden; enjoy nearby wineries and lakeside activities.
9.8 18 reviews
Finger Lakes, NY
26/06 – 28/06
$3459/nighttotal: $6918 (2 )
Sunrise Lake House Unveils New 2026 Deck & Hot Tub Your Lakeside Escape Just Got Better
4 2
cottage , Crystal Beach
This waterfront holiday home in Crystal Beach is located on the west side of Canandaigua Lake, approximately 24 kilometres south of downtown Canandaigua, offering 250 feet of lake frontage with excellent swimming and panoramic sunrise views, and is conveniently situated near Bristol Mountain Ski Resort and Hazlitt Winery. This spacious 207 square metre cottage, accommodating up to six guests, features four bedrooms, three bathrooms, a high-end kitchen, a great room with continuous lake views, a private lakeside patio, and an upstairs game room with an air hockey table and arcade system, with water access facilitated by a tram.
10 103 reviews
Finger Lakes, NY
28/07 – 31/07
$728/nighttotal: $2184 (3 )
3br Cottage Deck & Fire Table Ev Charger Wi-fi
3 1
cottage , Penn Yan
This holiday home is located in Penn Yan, a short drive from Keuka Lake and the Finger Lakes Wine Trails, and offers convenient access to the Oliver House Museum and Narcissa Prentiss House. This family-friendly cottage accommodates up to 8 guests, featuring 3 bedrooms and 2 bathrooms, with amenities including air conditioning, Wi-Fi, a full kitchen, and an on-site EV charger, ideal for exploring local vineyards and golf courses.