Compare Vacation Rentals & Airbnb in New Buffalo, MI
258 available vacation rental offers
Choose the perfect vacation accommodation
Price per night
Accommodation type
Rating
258 Rentals and Airbnb in New Buffalo, MI
9.9 25 reviews
New Buffalo, MI
20/06 – 27/06
$731/nighttotal: $5117 (7 )
James Dēne 11: Sunset Lake Views And Indoor Pool!
1 2
apartment , New Buffalo
This three-bedroom apartment in New Buffalo is situated just a short walk from the lively downtown area and the beautiful shores of Lake Michigan. It has received excellent ratings for location, cleanliness, and overall experience. The apartment spans three floors, comfortably accommodating up to eight guests. It offers a range of amenities, including a swimming pool, jacuzzi, fitness centre, and a fireplace, as well as private decks and a rooftop terrace with stunning lake views.
10 19 reviews
New Buffalo, MI
06/07 – 09/07
$703/nighttotal: $2109 (3 )
Brand New King Suite In Downtown New Buffalo
1 3
apartment , New Buffalo
This New Buffalo apartment offers a tranquil lakeside retreat, conveniently located near New Buffalo's beaches and other attractions, although precise distances aren't specified. The one-bedroom, one-bathroom flat sleeps three guests, boasting a king-size bed, Moccamaster coffee machine, well-equipped communal kitchen, and C.O. Bigelow bath products; reliable Wi-Fi and a TV are also provided.
9.9 19 reviews
New Buffalo, MI
21/06 – 23/06
$1635/nighttotal: $3270 (2 )
Lodge Retreat W Hot Tub,firepit,foosball,bbq&pool
4 6
apartment , New Buffalo
Lodged in the Trees is a four-bedroom, three-and-a-half-bathroom lodge near New Buffalo, Michigan, a short distance from Lake Michigan beaches and Warren Dunes State Park. This spacious property sleeps nine guests and boasts a chef's kitchen, hot tub, firepit, two porches, two decks, and access to Camp Buffalo's pool, pickleball courts, playground, outdoor theatre, and clubhouse.
New Buffalo, MI
20/06 – 21/06
$566/nightfor 1 night
Cozy 2 Bedroom Home Near Lake Michigan & Downtown
2 4
apartment , Michigan City
This two-bedroom flat is located in a developing Michigan City district, 300 metres from the Carroll Avenue Station on the South Shore Line commuter rail, offering convenient access to Chicago and proximity to Indiana Dunes National Park, Beechwood Golf Course, and Washington Park Zoo. This family-friendly accommodation for up to six guests includes a full kitchen with a fridge, freezer, microwave, and dishwasher, and boasts a screened-in porch for enjoying sunsets, with local dining and wine tasting available nearby at Shady Creek Winery.
8.4 15 reviews
New Buffalo, MI
20/08 – 24/08
$472/nighttotal: $1888 (4 )
Updated Studio, Walk To Downtown New Buffalo
1 2
apartment , New Buffalo
This New Buffalo apartment is situated in the downtown area, a short walk (less than 0.8 km) from New Buffalo Public Beach, Stray Dog Restaurant, and Beer Church Brewing Company. The newly remodelled, one-bedroom flat offers a king-size bed, a sofa bed (sleeping four), a full kitchen with a French door refrigerator, a private Weber gas grill on a small deck, and two smart TVs.
New Buffalo, MI
01/07 – 06/07
$1005/nighttotal: $5025 (5 )
Witch Hazel - Upscale 2 Bedroom Villa At Petite Acres
1 4
house , New Buffalo
The Upscale 2 Bedroom Villa at Petite Acres is situated in Petite Acres, 2.6 kilometres from New Buffalo Beach and 46.7 kilometres from South Bend Regional Airport. This 49 square metre villa accommodates up to 7 guests and features a fully equipped kitchen with a microwave and toaster, on-site sauna and fitness centre, private entrance, garden access, free WiFi and parking.
9.0 13 reviews
New Buffalo, MI
14/08 – 16/08
$1149/nighttotal: $2298 (2 )
Charming Home W/large Yard, Free Wifi, Furnished Deck, Gas Grill, Firepit
3 5
apartment , New Buffalo
This Union Pier property is situated on a one-acre lot, just a short distance from Lake Michigan and local attractions including the Round Barn Union Pier Tasting Room. This spacious 146 square meter apartment offers three bedrooms, two bathrooms with heated floors, and can accommodate up to nine guests, featuring a fully equipped kitchen, a smart TV, and an outdoor area with a firepit and gas grill.
10 15 reviews
New Buffalo, MI
19/06 – 21/06
$1053/nighttotal: $2106 (2 )
The Victorian
1 10
apartment , Michigan City
This five-bedroom Victorian house, situated in Michigan City's Haskell-Barker District, is within walking distance of Franklin Street's shops and restaurants and Lake Michigan's beaches. Sleeping up to twelve guests, this Michigan City property boasts two living areas, two and a half bathrooms, a fully equipped kitchen including a dishwasher, and air conditioning; nearby attractions include the South Shore Line for easy Chicago access.
9.9 54 reviews
New Buffalo, MI
26/06 – 30/06
$1012/nighttotal: $4048 (4 )
Brand New House! Hot Tub-bbq-gameroom-workspace!
1 8
apartment , Michigan City
This newly built Michigan City house is situated in a residential neighbourhood, approximately 5km from Michigan City Beach, the Blue Chip Casino, and 6km from Lighthouse Place Premium Outlets. Sleeping up to 10 guests, this three-bedroom, two-bathroom property boasts a fully equipped kitchen, Jacuzzi, hot tub, five smart TVs with Hulu access, a spacious backyard, and ample parking for four vehicles; enjoy nearby beach activities, casino entertainment, and outlet shopping.
10 10 reviews
New Buffalo, MI
14/08 – 16/08
$934/nighttotal: $1868 (2 )
Catherine's Cottage
1 5
apartment , New Buffalo
This New Buffalo holiday home, conveniently located near the beaches, offers three bedrooms and two and a half bathrooms, sleeping up to seven guests. The self-catering property boasts a fully equipped kitchen with a Weber Genesis gas BBQ, a large yard with a fire pit, and modern amenities including high-speed Wi-Fi and YouTube TV.
9.8 309 reviews
New Buffalo, MI
20/08 – 24/08
$666/nighttotal: $2664 (4 )
Romantic Modern Casita Nestled In The Woods. Pet Friendly!! Close To Beach ️
1 2
apartment , New Buffalo
This loft house is situated in a secluded spot near New Buffalo, surrounded by woods and trails, just a short drive (approximately [insert approximate distance] km) from the beach and [insert approximate distance] km from the town centre. The accommodation has received excellent ratings for its location, cleanliness, and overall experience. The loft house offers a spacious and comfortable living area with a king-size bed, a fully equipped kitchen, and a bathroom with a unique claw tub. Guests can enjoy the privacy of the wooded setting, relax on the large deck, or take advantage of the outdoor amenities including a fire pit and an architectural swing set.
9.1 9 reviews
New Buffalo, MI
20/06 – 21/06
$570/nightfor 1 night
Newly Renovated / Dog Friendly / Sleeps 6
1 4
apartment , Michigan City
This 2-bedroom flat on the 10th floor offers an elevated view in Michigan City, providing convenient access to local attractions. This accommodation sleeps up to six guests and includes a fully equipped kitchen, air conditioning, and parking, with amenities such as fresh towels and linens provided for a comfortable stay.
Best family friendly New Buffalo, MI vacation rentals
Among the 258 accommodations in New Buffalo, MI, here are the 4 best family friendly rentals
10 4 reviews
New Buffalo, MI
07/08 – 10/08
$1283/nighttotal: $3849 (3 )
Irish Spring In Three Oaks
3 4
apartment , Three Oaks
This recently renovated 1870s residence, offering 3 bedrooms and space for 7 guests, is located just 100 metres from Three Oaks' Main Street and next to the Journeyman Distillery, making it ideal for exploring local attractions such as the Vickers Theatre and Hesston Steam Museum. The property boasts a professionally designed interior with an open-plan living, dining, and kitchen area, a separate den with a TV, and a unique double-height rear extension, complemented by an exterior lodge building with outdoor dining and a firepit for seasonal entertainment.
New Buffalo, MI
19/07 – 26/07
$513/nighttotal: $3591 (7 )
Newly Rehabbed 3-bedroom Harbor Country Cottage!
3 2
apartment , Shorewood-Tower Hills-Harbert
This detached house in Harbert offers a secluded half-acre setting with a stream, located on the lake side of Red Arrow Highway, approximately 900 meters from Harbert Beach and a short drive to Cherry Beach and the Dunes, with New Buffalo 32 kilometers north. This family-friendly property provides 93 square meters of living space, accommodating up to 8 guests across 3 bedrooms and 1 bathroom, and includes a well-equipped kitchen, air conditioning, garden, parking, and outdoor amenities such as a canoe, beach chairs, bikes, a wood fire pit, and a gas grill.
10 7 reviews
New Buffalo, MI
18/06 – 22/06
$1680/nighttotal: $6720 (4 )
Heated Pool + Hot Tub | Fire Pit & Game Area
1 2
apartment , Grand Beach
This Grand Beach residence is located a short 500-metre walk from the beach and is surrounded by woodland. This family-friendly apartment offers accommodation for up to 12 guests across five bedrooms and three bathrooms, featuring a mid-century modern design, a swimming pool, hot tub, fire pit, screened porch, game-filled lower level, garage hangout space, and a deck overlooking the pool and woods.
9.5 113 reviews
New Buffalo, MI
06/07 – 09/07
$471/nighttotal: $1413 (3 )
Bright Beach-community/winter Wonderland Cottage
1 3
apartment , Michiana Shores
This charming cottage is situated in a peaceful wooded area in Michiana Shores, just a short walk from the beach and an hour from Chicago. It has consistently received excellent ratings for its location, cleanliness, and overall experience. The cottage offers four bedrooms and two bathrooms, comfortably accommodating up to five guests. Amenities include a fully equipped kitchen, a spacious screened porch, two patios with dining tables and chaise lounges, a charcoal grill, a fire pit, and Wi-Fi.
Best New Buffalo, MI vacation rentals with a pool
Among the 258 accommodations in New Buffalo, MI, here are the 4 best rentals with a pool
New Buffalo, MI
20/08 – 24/08
$2352/nighttotal: $9408 (4 )
Lodged In The Trees
1 2
house , New Buffalo
Lodged in the Trees, a New Buffalo holiday home, is situated 2.7km from New Buffalo Beach and 56km from South Bend Regional Airport. This four-bedroom, four-bathroom property boasts 212 square metres of floor space, accommodating up to 17 guests and featuring a fully equipped kitchen, Jacuzzi, garden, free Wi-Fi, and private parking.
8.4 10 reviews
New Buffalo, MI
17/07 – 19/07
$5337/nighttotal: $10674 (2 )
Schoolhouse Now 5k Sq Ft Lux Bnb: Gym, Sauna, Hottub, Gameroom, Billiards, Pets
7 4
apartment , New Buffalo
This luxurious 5,000 sq ft (465 sq m) former schoolhouse in Union Pier, a short 8 km drive from New Buffalo's beach and town centre, offers a unique stay in a spacious guesthouse. Sleeping up to 20 guests across seven bedrooms and boasting a swimming pool, hot tub, sauna, games rooms, and family-friendly features including a ball pit, this New Buffalo property is perfect for large groups and families.
10 22 reviews
New Buffalo, MI
01/07 – 06/07
$1395/nighttotal: $6975 (5 )
The Beachside Harborfront Hideaway
1 5
apartment , New Buffalo
This downtown New Buffalo apartment is located within easy walking distance of the bustling Main Street, the beautiful beach, and the New Buffalo Amtrak station. The surrounding area offers a vibrant mix of shops, restaurants, and attractions. The apartment has two bedrooms and two bathrooms, comfortably accommodating up to six guests. It includes a range of amenities such as a fully equipped kitchen, a gas fireplace, a balcony with marina views, and access to a fitness centre, indoor and outdoor pools.
New Buffalo, MI
20/06 – 27/06
$1365/nighttotal: $9555 (7 )
Grand Beach & Indoor Pool Retreat
1 2
apartment , Grand Beach
This Grand Beach flat offers direct private shoreline access across from Walnut Beach, with Whitewood Beach a short walk away, and is minutes from New Buffalo's amenities. This spacious residence accommodates 14 guests with a 20x40 indoor pool, wraparound decks featuring lake views and an outdoor hot tub, extensive entertainment options including foosball and a poker table, and ample parking across two driveways.
Frequently Asked Questions about vacation rentals in New Buffalo, MI
What are some interesting places to visit in or near New Buffalo, MI?
There's plenty to see in New Buffalo! The New Buffalo Railroad Museum is a must-see for history buffs, and you can't miss the stunning views from the top of the New Buffalo Lighthouse. If you're looking for a bit of nature, head to the Warren Dunes State Park, where you can hike, bike, or even go sandboarding.
What are the best Airbnb and vacation rentals in New Buffalo, MI?
Which walking or cycling routes are the best in New Buffalo, MI?
The paved bike path along the lakefront is perfect for a leisurely cycle, and the Warren Dunes State Park has some great hiking trails. You can even walk or cycle along the beach, it's a real treat.
What are the most popular Airbnbs in New Buffalo, MI?
What sports or outdoor activites can visitors enjoy in and around New Buffalo, MI?
You can go swimming, sunbathing, fishing, and kayaking on the lake, and the Warren Dunes State Park is great for hiking, sandboarding, and even horseback riding.
What are the best vacation rentals with a pool in New Buffalo, MI?
What other towns or cities can be easily accessed from New Buffalo, MI?
You can easily get to Chicago, which is about a 1.5 hour drive, or head to the charming town of South Haven, about 45 minutes away. There's also the beautiful city of St. Joseph, a short drive to the north.
What are the best rentals for families and kids in New Buffalo, MI?
What amenities are commonly available in vacation rentals in New Buffalo, MI?
Most vacation rentals in New Buffalo have things like Wi-Fi, a TV, a washing machine and dryer, and a fully equipped kitchen. Many also have a barbecue, a patio, and access to a swimming pool.
What are the best rentals or Airbnbs with a jacuzzi in New Buffalo, MI?
What time of year is best to rent a vacation rental New Buffalo, MI?
Summer is the most popular time to visit, but it gets quite busy. Spring and autumn are lovely for a quieter trip, with pleasant temperatures and beautiful scenery.
What are the local dishes in New Buffalo, MI region?
You've got to try the whitefish, it's a local speciality. There are lots of great seafood restaurants in New Buffalo. And of course, you can't go wrong with a classic Chicago-style deep dish pizza!
Destinations nearby
Best New Buffalo, MI vacation rentals with a balcony
9.3 17 reviews
New Buffalo, MI
26/06 – 30/06
$1509/nighttotal: $6036 (4 )
Journeyman Distillery Farmhouse In Three Oaks! Three Night Summer Minimum!
3 8
farm , Three Oaks
The Journeyman Distillery Farmhouse is located just 5 kilometres from the centre of Three Oaks, set in a peaceful wooded area. The property consistently receives excellent ratings for its location, cleanliness and overall experience. The farmhouse is a spacious property with 3 bedrooms and 3 bathrooms, suitable for up to 10 guests. It features a modern kitchen with a fridge, microwave, dishwasher, a terrace, a garden, parking, air conditioning, and internet access.
9.8 37 reviews
New Buffalo, MI
18/06 – 22/06
$694/nighttotal: $2776 (4 )
Union Pier Hidden Gem | 3 Blocks To Beach | Screened Porch & Fire Pit
3 2
cottage , New Buffalo
This Union Pier holiday home is located three blocks (approximately 0.24 km) from Lake Michigan, offering easy access to Whistle Stop Deli and Grocery Store, and is within easy reach of Warren Dunes State Park. The 149 square metre single-storey property boasts three bedrooms, two bathrooms, sleeping up to six guests, and features a fully equipped kitchen, screened porch, outdoor shower, and Starlink high-speed internet.
9.4 11 reviews
New Buffalo, MI
07/08 – 10/08
$3142/nighttotal: $9426 (3 )
12-20 Guests | Gamerm | Hot Tub-all Year | Dog Ok
5 4
apartment , Michigan City
This Michigan City lakefront property is situated a short 1.6km walk from Washington Park and Blue Chip Casino, and within 4.8km of Lake Michigan and Indiana Dunes National Park. The five-bedroom house, perfect for large families or groups, boasts a fully equipped kitchen, jacuzzi, private game room, terrace, and barbecue facilities, offering stunning lake views and direct water access.
9.6 8 reviews
New Buffalo, MI
20/08 – 24/08
$2060/nighttotal: $8240 (4 )
Lodge Retreat W Hot Tub,firepit,foosball,bbq&pool
4 2
apartment , New Buffalo
This luxurious four-bedroom lodge in New Buffalo, Michigan, is located a short distance from Lake Michigan beaches, the region's largest recreational harbour, and Warren Dunes State Park. The 212-square-metre property boasts four bathrooms, sleeps nine guests, and includes a chef's kitchen, multiple living areas, a hot tub, firepit, and access to a community pool with pickleball and playground facilities; two dogs are welcome.
Best New Buffalo, MI vacation rentals with parking
New Buffalo, MI
20/06 – 27/06
$1118/nighttotal: $7826 (7 )
Dartwood Dunes, Dunes, Lakes, Union Pier, Hot Tub
3 2
apartment , New Buffalo
This New Buffalo apartment is situated in Union Pier, a short walk or cycle to Lake Michigan's shoreline, its beaches, and local amenities, and a brief drive to other towns within Harbor Country. This spacious 180 square metre flat offers accommodation for up to six guests, featuring three bedrooms, three bathrooms, a fully equipped kitchen, air conditioning, a hot tub, and a screened porch, with parking provided.
10 8 reviews
New Buffalo, MI
14/08 – 16/08
$687/nighttotal: $1374 (2 )
*New* < 3 Miles To Beach + Casino + Zoo + Shopping!
2 5
apartment , Michigan City
This apartment is ideally located in Michigan City, just 5 kilometres from the beach, casino, zoo, and a range of restaurants and breweries. It has received excellent user ratings, highlighting its appeal to travellers. This two-bedroom apartment spans 85 square metres and comfortably accommodates up to six guests. It offers a fully equipped kitchen, a spacious basement with entertainment facilities, and a private garden with a barbecue and seating for five.
8.4 18 reviews
New Buffalo, MI
20/08 – 24/08
$458/nighttotal: $1832 (4 )
Remodeled Apartment, Downtown New Buffalo
1 2
apartment , New Buffalo
This New Buffalo lakefront property offers direct water access, situated steps from the New Buffalo Railroad Museum and 2.1km from Lake Michigan. The two-bedroom, one-bathroom house sleeps four guests and includes a fully equipped kitchen with fridge, microwave, and oven; amenities such as a TV and coffee maker; plus on-site gas grills and a spa.
9.6 24 reviews
New Buffalo, MI
20/06 – 27/06
$821/nighttotal: $5747 (7 )
Union Pier Home With Private Hot Tub And Close To Beach! 2023 Open!
3 2
cottage , New Buffalo
This charming cottage is located in Union Pier, just 1.6km from Townline Beach and Lake Michigan, offering easy access to the beautiful shores and the refreshing waters. The property enjoys excellent ratings for location, cleanliness, and overall guest experience. The cottage offers 3 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms, and a spacious 119 square metres of living space, accommodating up to 6 guests. Enjoy relaxing amenities like a spa tub, a fireplace, a balcony, and a fully equipped kitchen, perfect for unwinding after a day of exploring the local area.