Cottages in Sanibel Island, FL at the best prices

123 available cottage rental offers

7 nights
2
1
  • airbnb
  • booking
  • vrbo
  • expedia
  • priceline
  • tripadvisor
  • tripcom
  • sonder
  • homestay
  • hostelworld
  • hotelscom
  • agoda
Sanibel Island, FL cottages
Choose the perfect vacation accommodation
Price per night
Accommodation type
Rating

123 Best cottages in Sanibel Island, FL

Best family friendly Sanibel Island, FL cottage rentals

Among the 123 accommodations in Sanibel Island, FL, here are the 4 best family friendly cottage rentals

Sanibel Shore C1- 2-bedroom Cottage Sanibel Near The Beach - Sanibel Island, FL
9.8 23 reviews
Sanibel Island, FL
06/12 – 10/12
$498/nighttotal: $1992 (4 )

Sanibel Shore C1- 2-bedroom Cottage Sanibel Near The Beach

2 2
cottage , Sanibel
This charming cottage is located on Sanibel Island, just a short walk from the famous beaches and a short drive from the J.N. Ding Darling National Wildlife Refuge. The cottage has received excellent reviews from previous guests, highlighting its comfortable and convenient features.
This two-bedroom property can accommodate up to four guests and is equipped with a fully equipped kitchen, a screened porch, a private bathroom, and a shared swimming pool. The cottage also offers a range of amenities, including air conditioning, a washer and dryer, free Wi-Fi, and parking.
Cottage ∙ 1 Bedroom ∙ 2 Guests - Sanibel Island, FL
10 2 reviews
Sanibel Island, FL
06/12 – 10/12
$399/nighttotal: $1596 (4 )

Cottage ∙ 1 Bedroom ∙ 2 Guests

1 2
cottage , Captiva
Jensen's Cottage #15 is located within Jensen's Twin Palm Marina and Cottages on Captiva Island, a dedicated fishing village offering direct access to boating and angling activities.
This one-bedroom, one-bathroom holiday home accommodates two guests, featuring a kitchen with a fridge and microwave, air conditioning, and on-site parking, with options for boat rentals and docking.
Cottage ∙ 2 Bedrooms ∙ 4 Guests - Sanibel Island, FL
Sanibel Island, FL
29/10 – 01/11
$511/nighttotal: $1533 (3 )

Cottage ∙ 2 Bedrooms ∙ 4 Guests

2 2
cottage , Captiva
Jensen's Cottage #3, part of Jensen's Marina & Cottages, is located on Captiva Island within a fishing village, offering direct access to on-site fishing and boating facilities. This two-bedroom holiday home accommodates up to four guests and features a kitchen with a fridge and microwave, air conditioning, internet, and parking, with on-site boat docks and rentals available for an additional fee.
Cottage ∙ 1 Bedroom ∙ 2 Guests - Sanibel Island, FL
Sanibel Island, FL
23/10 – 28/10
$383/nighttotal: $1915 (5 )

Cottage ∙ 1 Bedroom ∙ 2 Guests

1 1
cottage , Captiva
Jensen's Cottage #2 is a 1-bedroom holiday let located within Jensen's Twin Palm Marina and Cottages, a dedicated fishing village on Captiva Island.
This family-friendly accommodation sleeps two guests and offers air conditioning, Wi-Fi, and a kitchen with a fridge and microwave, alongside on-site boat rentals and docking facilities for those keen on angling and boating excursions.

Best Sanibel Island, FL cottages with a garden

The Shore Bird-private Captiva Escape Bay To Gulf Cottage! - Sanibel Island, FL
8.0 2 reviews
Sanibel Island, FL
26/12 – 02/01
$1181/nighttotal: $8267 (7 )

The Shore Bird-private Captiva Escape Bay To Gulf Cottage!

1 4
cottage , Captiva
This Captiva Island beachfront cottage offers direct beach access, a short 1.6km walk from the J.N. Ding Darling National Wildlife Refuge and Captiva Beach, and within 3.2km of Turner Beach and Castaways Marina.
Sleeping four guests, this one-bedroom holiday home boasts three bathrooms, a private pool, fully equipped kitchen, in-unit laundry, Wi-Fi, patio, and Smart TV; enjoy self-catering and explore the nearby wildlife refuge.
1 Mi To Beach: Modern Cape Coral Home W/ Pool - Sanibel Island, FL
Sanibel Island, FL
07/08 – 10/08
$450/nighttotal: $1350 (3 )

1 Mi To Beach: Modern Cape Coral Home W/ Pool

1 2
cottage , Cape Coral
This holiday home in Caloosahatchee is situated less than 3.2 kilometres from Yacht Club Community Park, Veterans Foundation Headquarters, Cape Coral Yacht Club Beach, Cape Coral Farmers Market, and Hospital del Prado.
This property offers air conditioning, a swimming pool, a garden, parking, and a fully equipped kitchen with microwave and dishwasher, with free Wi-Fi available in public areas.
Waterfront Cape Coral Home: Views & Birdwatching - Sanibel Island, FL
Sanibel Island, FL
07/08 – 10/08
$356/nighttotal: $1068 (3 )

Waterfront Cape Coral Home: Views & Birdwatching

1 2
cottage , Cape Coral
This Trafalgar holiday home is located within 4.8 kilometres of Palmetto-Pine Country Club, Sun Splash Water Park, and Cape Coral Sports Complex, with Hunters Run Executive Golf Course also nearby.
This cottage offers a patio, two bathrooms, and a well-equipped kitchen with an oven, stovetop, microwave, and dishwasher, and permits pets with complimentary WiFi in public areas and free on-site parking.
Romantic Getaway, #302, 2 Min Walk To The Beach. - Sanibel Island, FL
9.5 217 reviews
Sanibel Island, FL
06/12 – 10/12
$691/nighttotal: $2764 (4 )

Romantic Getaway, #302, 2 Min Walk To The Beach.

1 2
cottage , Sanibel
This Sanibel Island studio is conveniently located just a 320-metre walk from the pristine white sands of the Gulf beaches, accessible via a private road.
The studio offers a comfortable 56 square metre space with a fully equipped kitchen, a private garden, and parking, ideal for couples or solo travellers looking for a peaceful retreat on the island.

Frequently Asked Questions about cottages in Sanibel Island, FL

  • What are the top must-see attractions on Sanibel Island, Florida?

    Sanibel Island boasts many attractions. Shell-seekers flock to its world-famous beaches, especially Bowman's Beach and Turner Beach, known for their shelling opportunities. The J.N. "Ding" Darling National Wildlife Refuge offers incredible wildlife viewing, with opportunities to spot various bird species, alligators, and other animals. The Bailey-Matthews National Shell Museum is a must for shell enthusiasts, showcasing a vast collection and educating visitors about these natural wonders. For a bit of history and art, the Sanibel Historical Museum and Village provides a glimpse into the island's past.
  • What are the best cottage rentals in Sanibel Island, FL?

  • How to spend a 5-day holiday on Sanibel Island, Florida?

    A five-day trip to Sanibel Island allows for a relaxed pace. Day one could be dedicated to exploring Bowman's Beach and shelling. Day two, immerse yourself in nature at the J.N. "Ding" Darling National Wildlife Refuge, perhaps taking a tram tour. Day three, visit the Bailey-Matthews National Shell Museum and the Sanibel Historical Museum and Village. Day four, rent bikes and explore the island's many bike paths, stopping for lunch at a casual eatery. Day five, relax on the beach, do some souvenir shopping, and enjoy a final sunset.
  • What are the best cottage rentals with a pool in Sanibel Island, FL?

  • Is Sanibel Island, Florida a good destination to rent a cottage?

    Absolutely! Sanibel Island offers many charming cottages perfect for a relaxing getaway. Many rentals are located near the beaches and offer a tranquil atmosphere. Look for rentals in areas like the Gulfside City or near the Sanibel Lighthouse for beautiful views and easy access to attractions. Booking in advance, especially during peak season, is highly recommended.
  • What are the best cottage rentals with a jacuzzi in Sanibel Island, FL?

  • What weather, wildlife, or natural hazards might affect travelers on Sanibel Island, Florida?

    Sanibel Island's weather is generally subtropical, with warm temperatures year-round. However, hurricane season (June 1st to November 30th) poses a risk, so checking forecasts before and during your trip is crucial. Be aware of wildlife such as alligators (mainly in the refuge) and various insects. Strong currents and riptides can occur on the beaches, so swimming only in designated areas and paying attention to lifeguard warnings is essential.
  • What are the best cottage rentals for families and kids in Sanibel Island, FL?

  • Is Sanibel Island, Florida pedestrian and cyclist-friendly?

    Yes, Sanibel Island is very pedestrian and cyclist-friendly. There are numerous bike paths and sidewalks throughout the island, making it easy to explore on foot or by bicycle. Many people rent bikes to get around, and it's a wonderful way to experience the island's natural beauty.
  • What are the best pet friendly cottage rentals in Sanibel Island, FL?

  • Are there any unusual or hidden places to explore on Sanibel Island, Florida?

    While not exactly hidden, the smaller, quieter beaches like Lighthouse Beach offer a more secluded experience compared to the more popular spots. Exploring the back bay areas by kayak or paddleboard can reveal hidden mangrove tunnels and tranquil waterways. The Sanibel-Captiva Conservation Foundation's nature trails provide opportunities to discover less-traveled parts of the island.
  • What are the best cottage rentals with parking in Sanibel Island, FL?

  • What are some of the best cultural experiences that allow you to meet locals on Sanibel Island, Florida?

    Sanibel Island has a close-knit community. Attending local events at the Sanibel Community House can offer opportunities to interact with residents. Visiting the smaller, locally-owned shops and restaurants provides a chance to chat with the owners and staff. Participating in guided nature walks or shelling tours led by local experts can also be a great way to connect with the island's people and learn more about its unique ecosystem.
  • What are the best authentic dishes to taste on Sanibel Island, Florida?

    Sanibel's culinary scene offers a blend of fresh seafood and casual dining. Expect to find many restaurants serving fresh, local seafood dishes like grilled grouper, stone crab claws (in season), and shrimp scampi. Many restaurants also offer lighter fare like salads and sandwiches, reflecting the island's relaxed atmosphere. Island Cow and The Mad Hatter are popular spots.
  • Are there any recommended items to pack for a stay on Sanibel Island, Florida?

    Pack light clothing, swimwear, sunscreen, sunglasses, a hat, and insect repellent. Shelling is a popular activity, so bring a bucket or bag for your finds. Comfortable walking shoes or sandals are essential, and if you plan to bike, bring or rent a bicycle. Don't forget a reusable water bottle to stay hydrated in the warm climate.

Nearby regions

Best Sanibel Island, FL cottage rentals with jacuzzi

Among the 123 accommodations in Sanibel Island, FL, here are the 4 best cottage rentals with a jacuzzi

Quaint Beautiful Backyard Sanctuary - Sanibel Island, FL
9.0 2 reviews
Sanibel Island, FL
07/08 – 09/08
$992/nighttotal: $1984 (2 )

Quaint Beautiful Backyard Sanctuary

2 2
cottage , Fort Myers Beach
This Fort Myers Beach holiday home is situated less than 0.6km from Estero Boulevard Beach, 3.2km from the Key West Express ferry, and within 1.6km of the Bay Oaks Recreation Centre and Matanzas Pass Preserve.
The two-bedroom, one-bathroom self-catering property sleeps six, offering a fully equipped kitchen, Jacuzzi, air conditioning, Smart TV, and on-site barbecue facilities; guests can also enjoy the nearby hot tub.
Private Home - Steps Away From Beach - Newly Renovated - Sanibel Island, FL
10 3 reviews
Sanibel Island, FL
30/08 – 01/09
$829/nighttotal: $1658 (2 )

Private Home - Steps Away From Beach - Newly Renovated

2 2
cottage , Fort Myers Beach
This 2-bedroom, 1-bathroom holiday home in Fort Myers Beach offers a prime location, just a 4-minute walk from Estero Boulevard Beach and an 8-minute walk from Bay Oaks Recreation Centre.
This property provides essential amenities, including internet and air conditioning, and accommodates up to 6 guests, with convenient access to Matanzaz Pass Preserve and local shopping at Coconut Point Mall.
Island Cottage In Quaint Matlacha Florida. Amazing Island Life Is A Click Away - Sanibel Island, FL
10 13 reviews
Sanibel Island, FL
29/10 – 01/11
$772/nighttotal: $2316 (3 )

Island Cottage In Quaint Matlacha Florida. Amazing Island Life Is A Click Away

3 2
cottage , Matlacha
This charming cottage sits on a peninsula in Matlacha, Florida, offering direct access to the waterways and is just a short boat ride from Sanibel, Captiva, and Useppa Island. The cottage has consistently earned excellent reviews from guests, highlighting its comfortable and well-equipped nature.
The cottage has three bedrooms, two bathrooms, and can accommodate up to eight guests. It offers a range of amenities and activities, including a private pool, a boat lift, two kayaks, and a fully equipped kitchen.
Cozy And Private Our Island Home On North Captiva Is The Perfect Escape - Sanibel Island, FL
9.4 18 reviews
Sanibel Island, FL
06/12 – 10/12
$588/nighttotal: $2352 (4 )

Cozy And Private Our Island Home On North Captiva Is The Perfect Escape

2 2
cottage , Captiva
Calliope Cottage is a secluded bungalow located on North Captiva Island, a short walk from the beach and a short distance from the North Captiva Island Club. It has received excellent user ratings and is a great option for those seeking a tranquil escape.
The cottage offers 92 square metres of space, with two bedrooms and two bathrooms, accommodating up to four guests. It boasts a range of amenities including a swimming pool, jacuzzi, terrace, parking, high-speed internet, a fully equipped kitchen, and access to a variety of activities such as kayaking, cycling, and golf cart rental.

Best pet friendly Sanibel Island, FL cottage rentals

Among the 123 accommodations in Sanibel Island, FL, here are the 4 best pet friendly cottage rentals

Are You Looking For A Quaint Fishing Village In The Heart Of Captiva Island? - Jensen's Cottage #15 - Sanibel Island, FL
9.2 5 reviews
Sanibel Island, FL
29/10 – 01/11
$470/nighttotal: $1410 (3 )

Are You Looking For A Quaint Fishing Village In The Heart Of Captiva Island? - Jensen's Cottage #15

1 2
cottage , Captiva
Jensen's Cottage #15, a waterfront holiday home on Captiva Island, offers convenient access to Sanibel Island Southern Beach and North Captiva Island Beach, the precise distances of which are unspecified.
This one-bedroom, one-bathroom self-catering property sleeps two, features a fridge and microwave, air conditioning, parking, internet access, and is situated in a fishing village setting with on-site boat rentals, a bait shop, and opportunities for birdwatching and nature walks.
Heated Saltwater Pool < 2 Mi To Yacht Club Beach! - Sanibel Island, FL
Sanibel Island, FL
07/08 – 10/08
$386/nighttotal: $1158 (3 )

Heated Saltwater Pool < 2 Mi To Yacht Club Beach!

1 2
cottage , Cape Coral
This holiday home is located in Caloosahatchee, within 3.2 kilometres of Yacht Club Community Park, Veterans Foundation Headquarters, and Cape Coral Yacht Club Beach.
This holiday home offers a private patio, an outdoor swimming pool, barbecue grills, and complimentary WiFi in public areas, with pets welcome and free self-parking provided.
Saltwater Pool & Dog Friendly: The Cape Escape - Sanibel Island, FL
10 2 reviews
Sanibel Island, FL
07/08 – 10/08
$462/nighttotal: $1386 (3 )

Saltwater Pool & Dog Friendly: The Cape Escape

1 2
cottage , Cape Coral
This charming cottage is situated in Caloosahatchee, just 3 kilometres from the Veterans Foundation Headquarters, Dolphin Marina, and Hospital del Prado, offering easy access to local amenities and attractions. It has been rated excellent by previous guests.
The cottage features two bathrooms, a ceiling fan, and a shower, ensuring a comfortable stay. Guests can enjoy a range of amenities including a swimming pool, barbecue grills, free parking, and free WiFi.
Sanibel Shore B2 - Newly Refurbished Cottage Walking Distance To Beach - Sanibel Island, FL
10 2 reviews
Sanibel Island, FL
23/10 – 28/10
$462/nighttotal: $2310 (5 )

Sanibel Shore B2 - Newly Refurbished Cottage Walking Distance To Beach

2 1
cottage , Sanibel
This newly refurbished holiday home is situated in the Mid Island district of Sanibel, a mere 500 meters from the beach and within easy reach of the Sanibel Historical Village and Museum.
This two-bedroom, one-bathroom cottage accommodates up to four guests and is equipped with air conditioning and heating, offering a comfortable base for exploring attractions such as the Bailey-Matthews Shell Museum and the Sanibel Island Golf Club.
©2026 cozycozy.com