Cottages in Sanibel Island, FL at the best prices

100 available cottage rental offers

7 nights
2
1
  • airbnb
  • booking
  • vrbo
  • expedia
  • priceline
  • tripadvisor
  • tripcom
  • sonder
  • homestay
  • hostelworld
  • hotelscom
  • agoda
Sanibel Island, FL cottages
Choose the perfect vacation accommodation
Price per night
Accommodation type
Rating

100 Best cottages in Sanibel Island, FL

Best family friendly Sanibel Island, FL cottage rentals

Among the 100 accommodations in Sanibel Island, FL, here are the 4 best family friendly cottage rentals

Cottage ∙ 1 Bedroom ∙ 2 Guests - Sanibel Island, FL
10 1 review

Cottage ∙ 1 Bedroom ∙ 2 Guests

cottage, Captiva
This holiday cottage is located within Jensen's Twin Palm Marina and Cottages on Captiva Island, offering direct access to marine facilities.
This family-friendly lodging accommodates two guests and features a kitchen with a fridge and microwave, air conditioning, internet, and parking, with on-site boat rentals and docking available.
Cottage ∙ 2 Bedrooms ∙ 4 Guests - Sanibel Island, FL
No reviews

Cottage ∙ 2 Bedrooms ∙ 4 Guests

cottage, Captiva
Jensen's Cottage #4, a holiday let situated within Jensen's Twin Palm Marina and Cottages on Captiva Island, provides direct access to the island's fishing village amenities and boating activities, located approximately 4.8 kilometres from the main shops and restaurants.
This family-friendly abode offers two bedrooms and one bathroom, accommodating up to four guests with a kitchen featuring a fridge and microwave, air conditioning, and on-site parking, with optional boat docks and rentals available for exploring the surrounding waters.
Waterfront Matlacha Cottage With Dock, Gorgeous Sunsets & Fishing! - Sanibel Island, FL
10 23 reviews

Waterfront Matlacha Cottage With Dock, Gorgeous Sunsets & Fishing!

cottage, Matlacha
This Matlacha waterfront holiday home is located less than 0.8 km from local shops and restaurants, and a community boat ramp.
The two-bedroom property, sleeping up to six guests, offers a kitchen with fridge and microwave, air conditioning, a garden, spa, free WiFi, and kayak access; Tropical Breeze Fun Park and Bowland Coral Lanes are a short drive away.
Cottage ∙ 1 Bedroom ∙ 2 Guests - Sanibel Island, FL
10 2 reviews

Cottage ∙ 1 Bedroom ∙ 2 Guests

cottage, Captiva
Jensen's Cottage #15 is located within Jensen's Twin Palm Marina and Cottages on Captiva Island, a dedicated fishing village offering direct access to boating and angling activities.
This one-bedroom, one-bathroom holiday home accommodates two guests, featuring a kitchen with a fridge and microwave, air conditioning, and on-site parking, with options for boat rentals and docking.

Best Sanibel Island, FL cottages with a garden

Gorgeous Renovated Cottage Steps To Beach! - Sanibel Island, FL
No reviews

Gorgeous Renovated Cottage Steps To Beach!

cottage, Captiva
The Jensens On The Gulf Cottage is centrally located in Captiva, Florida, a short walk from the Gulf of Mexico beach and close to Captiva Chapel By the Sea.
This 204-square-metre (approximately 2200 square feet) holiday home, comprising two historic cottages, sleeps up to seven guests and offers two bedrooms, two bathrooms, a fully equipped kitchen, air conditioning, a garden, a spa, parking, and Wi-Fi.
Entire Cottage In Fort Myers-iona, Minutes To Fort Myers Beach & Sanibel Island. - Sanibel Island, FL
No reviews

Entire Cottage In Fort Myers-iona, Minutes To Fort Myers Beach & Sanibel Island.

cottage, Iona
This two-storey beach house in Iona, Fort Myers, offers convenient access to Fort Myers Beach, Sanibel Island, and Bunche Beach, all within a few kilometres.
Accommodating up to eight guests, this pet-friendly property features three bedrooms, four bathrooms, air conditioning, Wi-Fi, and fully equipped kitchens on each level, with private porches and an on-site barbecue grill for outdoor dining.
Island Cottage In Quaint Matlacha Florida. Amazing Island Life Is A Click Away - Sanibel Island, FL
10 13 reviews

Island Cottage In Quaint Matlacha Florida. Amazing Island Life Is A Click Away

cottage, Matlacha
This charming cottage sits on a peninsula in Matlacha, Florida, offering direct access to the waterways and is just a short boat ride from Sanibel, Captiva, and Useppa Island. The cottage has consistently earned excellent reviews from guests, highlighting its comfortable and well-equipped nature.
The cottage has three bedrooms, two bathrooms, and can accommodate up to eight guests. It offers a range of amenities and activities, including a private pool, a boat lift, two kayaks, and a fully equipped kitchen.
Sanibel Shore B2 - Newly Refurbished Cottage Walking Distance To Beach - Sanibel Island, FL
10 2 reviews

Sanibel Shore B2 - Newly Refurbished Cottage Walking Distance To Beach

cottage, Sanibel
This newly refurbished holiday home is situated in the Mid Island district of Sanibel, a mere 500 meters from the beach and within easy reach of the Sanibel Historical Village and Museum.
This two-bedroom, one-bathroom cottage accommodates up to four guests and is equipped with air conditioning and heating, offering a comfortable base for exploring attractions such as the Bailey-Matthews Shell Museum and the Sanibel Island Golf Club.

Frequently Asked Questions about cottages in Sanibel Island, FL

  • What are the top must-see attractions on Sanibel Island, Florida?

    Sanibel Island boasts many attractions. Shell-seekers flock to its world-famous beaches, especially Bowman's Beach and Turner Beach, known for their shelling opportunities. The J.N. "Ding" Darling National Wildlife Refuge offers incredible wildlife viewing, with opportunities to spot various bird species, alligators, and other animals. The Bailey-Matthews National Shell Museum is a must for shell enthusiasts, showcasing a vast collection and educating visitors about these natural wonders. For a bit of history and art, the Sanibel Historical Museum and Village provides a glimpse into the island's past.
  • What are the best cottage rentals in Sanibel Island, FL?

  • How to spend a 5-day holiday on Sanibel Island, Florida?

    A five-day trip to Sanibel Island allows for a relaxed pace. Day one could be dedicated to exploring Bowman's Beach and shelling. Day two, immerse yourself in nature at the J.N. "Ding" Darling National Wildlife Refuge, perhaps taking a tram tour. Day three, visit the Bailey-Matthews National Shell Museum and the Sanibel Historical Museum and Village. Day four, rent bikes and explore the island's many bike paths, stopping for lunch at a casual eatery. Day five, relax on the beach, do some souvenir shopping, and enjoy a final sunset.
  • What are the best cottage rentals with a pool in Sanibel Island, FL?

  • Is Sanibel Island, Florida a good destination to rent a cottage?

    Absolutely! Sanibel Island offers many charming cottages perfect for a relaxing getaway. Many rentals are located near the beaches and offer a tranquil atmosphere. Look for rentals in areas like the Gulfside City or near the Sanibel Lighthouse for beautiful views and easy access to attractions. Booking in advance, especially during peak season, is highly recommended.
  • What are the best cottage rentals with a jacuzzi in Sanibel Island, FL?

  • What weather, wildlife, or natural hazards might affect travelers on Sanibel Island, Florida?

    Sanibel Island's weather is generally subtropical, with warm temperatures year-round. However, hurricane season (June 1st to November 30th) poses a risk, so checking forecasts before and during your trip is crucial. Be aware of wildlife such as alligators (mainly in the refuge) and various insects. Strong currents and riptides can occur on the beaches, so swimming only in designated areas and paying attention to lifeguard warnings is essential.
  • What are the best cottage rentals for families and kids in Sanibel Island, FL?

  • Is Sanibel Island, Florida pedestrian and cyclist-friendly?

    Yes, Sanibel Island is very pedestrian and cyclist-friendly. There are numerous bike paths and sidewalks throughout the island, making it easy to explore on foot or by bicycle. Many people rent bikes to get around, and it's a wonderful way to experience the island's natural beauty.
  • What are the best pet friendly cottage rentals in Sanibel Island, FL?

  • Are there any unusual or hidden places to explore on Sanibel Island, Florida?

    While not exactly hidden, the smaller, quieter beaches like Lighthouse Beach offer a more secluded experience compared to the more popular spots. Exploring the back bay areas by kayak or paddleboard can reveal hidden mangrove tunnels and tranquil waterways. The Sanibel-Captiva Conservation Foundation's nature trails provide opportunities to discover less-traveled parts of the island.
  • What are the best cottage rentals with parking in Sanibel Island, FL?

  • What are some of the best cultural experiences that allow you to meet locals on Sanibel Island, Florida?

    Sanibel Island has a close-knit community. Attending local events at the Sanibel Community House can offer opportunities to interact with residents. Visiting the smaller, locally-owned shops and restaurants provides a chance to chat with the owners and staff. Participating in guided nature walks or shelling tours led by local experts can also be a great way to connect with the island's people and learn more about its unique ecosystem.
  • What are the best authentic dishes to taste on Sanibel Island, Florida?

    Sanibel's culinary scene offers a blend of fresh seafood and casual dining. Expect to find many restaurants serving fresh, local seafood dishes like grilled grouper, stone crab claws (in season), and shrimp scampi. Many restaurants also offer lighter fare like salads and sandwiches, reflecting the island's relaxed atmosphere. Island Cow and The Mad Hatter are popular spots.
  • Are there any recommended items to pack for a stay on Sanibel Island, Florida?

    Pack light clothing, swimwear, sunscreen, sunglasses, a hat, and insect repellent. Shelling is a popular activity, so bring a bucket or bag for your finds. Comfortable walking shoes or sandals are essential, and if you plan to bike, bring or rent a bicycle. Don't forget a reusable water bottle to stay hydrated in the warm climate.

Nearby regions

Best Sanibel Island, FL cottage rentals with jacuzzi

Among the 100 accommodations in Sanibel Island, FL, here are the 1 best cottage rentals with a jacuzzi

Private Home - Steps Away From Beach - Pool And Hot Tub - Sanibel Island, FL
10 5 reviews

Private Home - Steps Away From Beach - Pool And Hot Tub

cottage, Fort Myers Beach
This 2-bedroom, 1-bathroom holiday home in Fort Myers Beach offers a prime location, just a 4-minute walk from Estero Boulevard Beach and an 8-minute walk from Bay Oaks Recreation Centre.
This property provides essential amenities, including internet and air conditioning, and accommodates up to 6 guests, with convenient access to Matanzaz Pass Preserve and local shopping at Coconut Point Mall.

Best pet friendly Sanibel Island, FL cottage rentals

Among the 100 accommodations in Sanibel Island, FL, here are the 4 best pet friendly cottage rentals

Cottage ∙ 1 Bedroom ∙ 2 Guests - Sanibel Island, FL
10 1 review

Cottage ∙ 1 Bedroom ∙ 2 Guests

cottage, Captiva
Jensen's Cottage #7, a holiday home located within Jensen's Twin Palm Marina and Cottages on Captiva Island, is situated in a fishing village offering convenient access to Jensen's Marina & Cottages.
This one-bedroom, one-bathroom bungalow accommodates two guests and features a kitchen with a fridge and microwave, air conditioning, and on-site parking, with optional boat docking available for an additional fee and boat rentals on the premises.
Are You Looking For A Quaint Fishing Village In The Heart Of Captiva Island? - Jensen's Cottage #15 - Sanibel Island, FL
9.2 5 reviews

Are You Looking For A Quaint Fishing Village In The Heart Of Captiva Island? - Jensen's Cottage #15

cottage, Captiva
Jensen's Cottage #15, a waterfront holiday home on Captiva Island, offers convenient access to Sanibel Island Southern Beach and North Captiva Island Beach, the precise distances of which are unspecified.
This one-bedroom, one-bathroom self-catering property sleeps two, features a fridge and microwave, air conditioning, parking, internet access, and is situated in a fishing village setting with on-site boat rentals, a bait shop, and opportunities for birdwatching and nature walks.
Sage Sands Cottage | Steps To Beach/pool/ Fort Myers Beach Times Square - Sanibel Island, FL
10 3 reviews

Sage Sands Cottage | Steps To Beach/pool/ Fort Myers Beach Times Square

cottage, Fort Myers Beach
Sage Sands Cottage, a newly renovated beach bungalow in Fort Myers Beach's TP Hill's neighbourhood, offers a 300-500 metre walk to the beach, Times Square, and Margaritaville Beach Resort.
This accommodation for up to three guests features a king bed, a queen sofa bed, a kitchenette with microwave and cooktop, air conditioning, complimentary WiFi, and access to a shared heated swimming pool, with parking provided.
Sanibel Shores A1: Cozy 2-bedroom Cottage In Sanibel - Sanibel Island, FL
No reviews

Sanibel Shores A1: Cozy 2-bedroom Cottage In Sanibel

cottage, Sanibel
This Sanibel holiday home, situated in Mid Island, offers a short walk or cycle to the island's renowned shell-strewn beaches and is conveniently close to local eateries and attractions.
This 79 square metre bungalow accommodates up to six guests with two bedrooms, two bathrooms, and a sofa bed, featuring air conditioning, a swimming pool, a terrace, a garden, and is pet-friendly for dogs under 10kg for a fee.
©2026 cozycozy.com