Compare Vacation Rentals & Airbnb in Sister Bay, WI

118 available vacation rental offers

7 nights
2
1
  • airbnb
  • booking
  • vrbo
  • expedia
  • priceline
  • tripadvisor
  • tripcom
  • sonder
  • homestay
  • hostelworld
  • hotelscom
  • agoda
Sister Bay, WI vacation rentals
Choose the perfect vacation accommodation
Price per night
Accommodation type
Rating

118 Rentals and Airbnb in Sister Bay, WI

Best family friendly Sister Bay, WI vacation rentals

Among the 118 accommodations in Sister Bay, WI, here are the 4 best family friendly rentals

Lost Lane | Luxury Retreat W/ Hot Tub & Trails - Sister Bay, WI
10 8 reviews
Sister Bay, WI
11/07 – 13/07
$2036/nighttotal: $4072 (2 )

Lost Lane | Luxury Retreat W/ Hot Tub & Trails

3 2
apartment , Ellison Bay
This Ellison Bay holiday home is situated within 5km of Newport State Park, The Clearing Folk School, and Ellison Bay Pottery Studios, and 10km from Lake Michigan and Ellison Bluff State Natural Area.
This 232 square metre property boasts four bedrooms, three bathrooms, sleeps six guests, and includes a fully equipped kitchen, Jacuzzi, terrace, garden, free Wi-Fi, and barbecue facilities.
Historic Farmhouse Near Entrance To Peninsula State Park - Sister Bay, WI
8.4 8 reviews
Sister Bay, WI
11/07 – 13/07
$816/nighttotal: $1632 (2 )

Historic Farmhouse Near Entrance To Peninsula State Park

1 2
apartment , Ephraim
This Ephraim holiday home is peacefully situated in a rural setting, less than 1 km from Peninsula State Park and Lake Michigan, and within a 2.4 km radius of Eagle Trailhead and Fish Creek Public Beach.
This 74 square metre property sleeps six guests in three bedrooms and one bathroom, offering a terrace, garden, tennis court, parking, Wi-Fi, and on-site barbecue facilities.
Top-rated 6-bedroom Vacation Home In Sister Bay  Walkable & Family-friendly - Sister Bay, WI
9.6 40 reviews
Sister Bay, WI
04/07 – 06/07
$1695/nighttotal: $3390 (2 )

Top-rated 6-bedroom Vacation Home In Sister Bay Walkable & Family-friendly

6 15
apartment , Sister Bay
This family-friendly holiday home is located in Sister Bay, just a 15-minute walk from Pirate's Cove Adventure Golf and Lake Michigan, offering easy access to the area's attractions. The property has consistently received excellent user ratings, making it a popular choice for families and groups.
The house sleeps up to 14 guests in its six bedrooms, providing ample space for everyone to relax and enjoy their stay. Guests can enjoy a range of amenities including a fully equipped kitchen, a spacious garden with barbecue facilities, and a designated arcade/game room for entertainment.
Secluded Dog-friendly Retreat In Baileys Harbor - Sister Bay, WI
Sister Bay, WI
30/07 – 02/08
$1799/nighttotal: $5397 (3 )

Secluded Dog-friendly Retreat In Baileys Harbor

1 2
apartment , Ephraim
This dog-friendly holiday home in Baileys Harbour offers a secluded wooded setting, a short drive from Lake Michigan, beaches, restaurants, and wineries.
This three-bedroom, two-bathroom holiday home accommodates up to eight guests, featuring a fully equipped kitchen, air conditioning, Wi-Fi, and outdoor amenities such as a grill and fire pit.

Best Sister Bay, WI vacation rentals with parking

Classic Door County Cottage On Lake Michigan + Great For Families - Sister Bay, WI
8.8 13 reviews
Sister Bay, WI
11/07 – 13/07
$2461/nighttotal: $4922 (2 )

Classic Door County Cottage On Lake Michigan + Great For Families

3 2
apartment , Sister Bay
This Sister Bay holiday home enjoys a waterfront location, just 0.16 km from Lake Michigan and within 9.6 km of Pirate's Cove Adventure Golf and Sister Bay Beach.
The 93 square metre property offers three bedrooms, two bathrooms, sleeps six guests, and includes amenities such as a spa, tennis court, and free Wi-Fi.
Captains Quarters By Simple Life Rentals - Sister Bay, WI
Sister Bay, WI
30/07 – 02/08
$1052/nighttotal: $3156 (3 )

Captains Quarters By Simple Life Rentals

2 2
house , Ephraim
Captains Quarters, a two-bedroom house in Ephraim, Wisconsin, is situated 19 kilometres from Cana Island Lighthouse and 34 kilometres from Cave Point County Park.
This self-catering property sleeps up to 15 guests, offering free Wi-Fi, private parking, and a fully equipped kitchen; nearby attractions include the Door County Maritime Museum (47km).
Indoor Pool + Hot Tub Condo Complex Near Egg Harbor - Sister Bay, WI
8.8 35 reviews
Sister Bay, WI
30/07 – 02/08
$1456/nighttotal: $4368 (3 )

Indoor Pool + Hot Tub Condo Complex Near Egg Harbor

3 2
apartment , Egg Harbor
This holiday home is situated in Egg Harbor, just 1.6km from Egg Harbor Beach and Lake Michigan, providing easy access to the stunning shoreline and recreational activities.
This 217 square metre property boasts 3 bedrooms and 3 bathrooms, comfortably accommodating up to 10 guests, and features a private indoor pool, fitness centre, spa tub, and arcade/game room for entertainment and relaxation.
Modern, New Egg Harbor Retreat | Dog-friendly, Fire Pit - Sister Bay, WI
10 19 reviews
Sister Bay, WI
11/07 – 13/07
$1193/nighttotal: $2386 (2 )

Modern, New Egg Harbor Retreat | Dog-friendly, Fire Pit

2 2
cabin , Egg Harbor
This three-bedroom Egg Harbor lodge, situated 2.9 kilometres from The Orchards and 3.9 kilometres from Lake Michigan, offers a quiet rural retreat near Egg Harbor's attractions.
The 107-square-metre property sleeps six guests and includes a fully equipped kitchen with dishwasher, a fireplace, free Wi-Fi, a Smart TV, barbecue grills, and a washing machine; nearby amenities include Harbor View Park and the Peg Egan Performing Arts Centre.

Frequently Asked Questions about vacation rentals in Sister Bay, WI

  • What are some interesting places to visit in or near Sister Bay, WI?

    Sister Bay is a charming town with lots to see and do. The Peninsula State Park is a must-visit, with its stunning scenery and hiking trails. You can also check out the historic Al Johnson's Swedish Restaurant, famous for the goats that graze on the roof. For a bit of history, visit the Sister Bay Historical Society Museum.
  • What are the best Airbnb and vacation rentals in Sister Bay, WI?

    Harbor House - July Dates Just Became Available, Sister Bay Vintage Log Cabin and The Nordic Lodge are the most popular Airbnb and vacation rentals in Sister Bay, WI among travelers.

  • Which walking or cycling routes are the best in Sister Bay, WI?

    The most popular walking and cycling route is the scenic Door County Coastal Bike Trail, which runs along the shore. For a shorter walk, try the Sister Bay Village Loop, which takes you past shops and restaurants. If you're feeling adventurous, you can hike the Eagle Trail in Peninsula State Park for some stunning views.
  • What are the most popular Airbnbs in Sister Bay, WI?

  • What sports or outdoor activites can visitors enjoy in and around Sister Bay, WI?

    Sister Bay is a great place for outdoor activities. You can go kayaking or paddleboarding on the bay, rent a boat for fishing, or play a round of golf at the Peninsula State Park Golf Course. In the winter, you can go cross-country skiing or snowshoeing on the trails.
  • What are the best vacation rentals with a pool in Sister Bay, WI?

  • What other towns or cities can be easily accessed from Sister Bay, WI?

    Sister Bay is conveniently located near other charming towns in Door County. You can easily drive to Fish Creek, Ephraim, and Baileys Harbor, all of which offer unique attractions and dining options. If you're looking for a bigger city, Green Bay is about a 1-hour drive away.
  • What are the best rentals for families and kids in Sister Bay, WI?

  • What amenities are commonly available in vacation rentals in Sister Bay, WI?

    Vacation rentals in Sister Bay typically offer a range of amenities, including fully equipped kitchens, laundry facilities, and Wi-Fi. Many also have outdoor spaces like decks or patios, and some even have access to private beaches or docks.
  • What are the best rentals or Airbnbs with a jacuzzi in Sister Bay, WI?

    The best vacation rentals or Airbnb with a jacuzzi in Sister Bay, WI are The Nordic Lodge, Walk To Marina Hot Tub - Arcade & Pet-friendly and Spacious Family-friendly Cottage In Peaceful Woods.

  • What time of year is best to rent a vacation rental Sister Bay, WI?

    The best time to visit Sister Bay depends on your preferences. Summer is the busiest season, with warm weather and plenty of outdoor activities. Autumn is beautiful, with colourful foliage and a quieter atmosphere. Spring and fall are also great times to visit, with milder temperatures and fewer crowds.
  • What are the local dishes in Sister Bay, WI region?

    Door County is known for its fresh seafood, so you'll find plenty of fish and shellfish dishes on the menus. Try the whitefish, perch, or walleye, often served pan-fried or baked. You'll also find delicious cherry-themed desserts and pastries, as Door County is famous for its cherry orchards.

Destinations nearby

Best Sister Bay, WI vacation rentals with a balcony

#1downtown Spot | Walk To Beach, Hot Tub & Pets Ok - Sister Bay, WI
9.8 8 reviews
Sister Bay, WI
11/07 – 13/07
$1686/nighttotal: $3372 (2 )

#1downtown Spot | Walk To Beach, Hot Tub & Pets Ok

4 2
apartment , Sister Bay
This Sister Bay apartment, located on North Bay Shore Drive, offers prime downtown accommodation, steps from the beach and adjacent to Al Johnson's Swedish Restaurant, a five-minute walk from the marina and a four-minute drive (approximately 3.2km) from Seaquist Orchards.
The 116 square metre dwelling boasts four bedrooms sleeping ten guests, two bathrooms, a fully equipped kitchen, a private deck with a hot tub, free high-speed internet, and a streaming bundle including Hulu + Live TV, Disney+, and ESPN+, alongside spa and parking facilities.
New! Walk To Water, Shops Hot Tub, Sauna & Games - Sister Bay, WI
Sister Bay, WI
03/07 – 04/07
$3904/nightfor 1 night

New! Walk To Water, Shops Hot Tub, Sauna & Games

4 2
house , Ellison Bay
This detached house in Ellison Bay is located 26 kilometres from Cana Island Lighthouse and 40 kilometres from Cave Point County Park.
This spacious property offers accommodation for up to 15 guests with four bedrooms and four bathrooms, featuring a fully equipped kitchen, air conditioning, a swimming pool, jacuzzi, sauna, terrace, garden, and complimentary bicycles, with parking and WiFi included.
#1downtown Spot Walk To Beach, Hot Tub & Pets Ok - Sister Bay, WI
Sister Bay, WI
11/07 – 13/07
$1579/nighttotal: $3158 (2 )

#1downtown Spot Walk To Beach, Hot Tub & Pets Ok

4 2
house , Sister Bay
This property offers a prime downtown Sister Bay location, just a 3-minute walk from Sister Bay Beach, 17.7 kilometres from Cana Island Lighthouse, and 32.2 kilometres from Cave Point County Park.
This dog-friendly cottage boasts 116 square metres of space, accommodating up to 19 guests with a fully equipped kitchen, air conditioning, a private hot tub, garden, and on-site parking, with complimentary WiFi provided.
Collings Summer House By Simple Life Rentals - Sister Bay, WI
10 1 review
Sister Bay, WI
30/07 – 02/08
$898/nighttotal: $2694 (3 )

Collings Summer House By Simple Life Rentals

1 2
house , Ephraim
Collings Summer House is a self-catering property in Ephraim, Wisconsin, situated approximately 32 and 45 kilometres from Cave Point County Park and the Door County Maritime Museum respectively.
This one-bedroom house, offering 65 square metres of floor space and sleeping up to seven guests, features a fully equipped kitchen, air conditioning, free Wi-Fi, private parking, and accessibility features for disabled guests.

Best pet friendly Sister Bay, WI vacation rentals

Among the 118 accommodations in Sister Bay, WI, here are the 4 best pet friendly rentals

** New Home W/  Wood Fireplace, Tucked In Peaceful Woods Centrally Located !! - Sister Bay, WI
9.7 73 reviews
Sister Bay, WI
30/07 – 02/08
$1145/nighttotal: $3435 (3 )

** New Home W/ Wood Fireplace, Tucked In Peaceful Woods Centrally Located !!

3 2
apartment , Ephraim
This charming cabin is situated just outside Ephraim, a short 8km drive from Sister Bay and 16km from Baileys Harbor/Fish Creek, offering a tranquil escape in a peaceful wooded setting. It consistently receives excellent guest ratings for location, cleanliness, and overall experience.
The cabin provides comfortable accommodation for up to six guests across two bedrooms and one bathroom, spanning 149 square metres. Guests can enjoy a fully equipped kitchen, high-speed internet, a dedicated workspace with woodland views, a fire pit, and ample parking, making it ideal for families and pet owners seeking a relaxing getaway.
Historic Home Near State Park In Fish Creek - Sister Bay, WI
9.2 18 reviews
Sister Bay, WI
11/07 – 13/07
$861/nighttotal: $1722 (2 )

Historic Home Near State Park In Fish Creek

1 2
apartment , Ephraim
Fish Creek Farmhouse, a pet-friendly self-catering property near the entrance to Peninsula State Park in Fish Creek, Wisconsin, offers easy walking access to Fish Creek's downtown area with its shops and restaurants such as Julie's Cafe and Fish Creek Market.
This one-bedroom, one-bathroom guesthouse, sleeping up to six guests, features a fully equipped kitchen (fridge, microwave, dishwasher), Wi-Fi, a Smart TV, outdoor space with a fire pit and propane grill, and is situated on a quiet residential street.
Charming Sister Bay Vacation Home With Hot Tub, Steps From Beach & Downtown, Wisconsin - Sister Bay, WI
Sister Bay, WI
11/07 – 13/07
$1734/nighttotal: $3468 (2 )

Charming Sister Bay Vacation Home With Hot Tub, Steps From Beach & Downtown, Wisconsin

4 2
house , Sister Bay
This detached house in Sister Bay, Wisconsin, is located a 3-minute walk from Sister Bay Beach and close to downtown amenities, with Cana Island Lighthouse 17.7 kilometres away.
This spacious holiday home accommodates up to 19 guests across 4 bedrooms and 2 bathrooms, featuring a private hot tub, a fully equipped kitchen with a dishwasher and microwave, and a garden.
Spacious Home In Central Ephraim- Dog Friendly Home - Sister Bay, WI
9.3 65 reviews
Sister Bay, WI
30/07 – 02/08
$1535/nighttotal: $4605 (3 )

Spacious Home In Central Ephraim- Dog Friendly Home

2 2
cabin , Ephraim
This charming cottage is situated just a mile from Eagle Harbor and Lake Michigan, offering a peaceful retreat in a rural setting near the village of Ephraim. It has received excellent ratings for its location, cleanliness, and overall experience.
The two-bedroom property comfortably sleeps up to eight guests and features a fully equipped kitchen, a terrace, and free Wi-Fi. Enjoy outdoor dining with a barbecue grill, explore local art galleries, and relax by the water with easy access to swimming and kayaking.
©2026 cozycozy.com