Bed and Breakfast in Fire Island, NY

69 available b&b offers

7 nights
2
1
  • airbnb
  • booking
  • vrbo
  • expedia
  • premierinn
  • sykescottages
  • plumguide
  • hotelscom
  • tripadvisor
  • homestay
  • tuivillas
  • hostelworld
Fire Island, NY bed and breakfast
Choose the perfect holiday accommodation
Price per night
Accommodation type
Rating

69 Bed and Breakfasts and Inn in Fire Island, NY

Best Fire Island, NY bed and breakfasts with air conditioning

Double Queen Room - Fire Island, NY
9.8 82 reviews

Double Queen Room

B&B, Fire Island
This charming bed and breakfast is located within the Grove Hotel, the largest hotel in Fire Island, placing it right in the heart of the island's activity. It has consistently received excellent ratings for its cleanliness, location, and overall experience.
Each room in this guesthouse offers two queen-size beds, comfortably accommodating up to four guests. The B&B provides a range of amenities, including internet access and air conditioning, and its central location allows for easy access to the island's beaches, shops, and restaurants.
Bask In This Bay-shore Beauty!! (Listing #3) - Fire Island, NY
No reviews

Bask In This Bay-shore Beauty!! (Listing #3)

B&B, Bay Shore
This guest house offers exclusive use of the entire second floor of a home in Bay Shore, providing a private retreat with access to a garden, located within 1 kilometre of local amenities.
The accommodation sleeps up to eight guests across three bedrooms, featuring an open-plan living and dining area, a fully equipped kitchen, and is well-suited for those seeking a self-contained stay with the convenience of a fridge, microwave, and dishwasher.

Best Fire Island, NY bed and breakfasts with breakfast included

Come As You Are Inn - Fire Island, NY
9.8 154 reviews

Come As You Are Inn

B&B, Sayville
This B&B is ideally situated in Sayville, a short walk from the train station and within easy reach of several beautiful beaches. It has consistently received excellent ratings for its location, cleanliness, and overall experience.
The guest house offers a comfortable and spacious bedroom with a private bathroom. Guests can enjoy a range of amenities, including a swimming pool, jacuzzi, terrace, and garden, as well as a restaurant and bar on site.
The Ocean Bay House - Fire Island, NY
9.9 127 reviews

The Ocean Bay House

B&B, Bay Shore
The Ocean Bay House is a charming bed and breakfast in Bay Shore, New York, just a short drive from Benjamin's Memorial Beach and within easy reach of Nassau Veterans Memorial Coliseum and Jones Beach. It has consistently received excellent ratings for location, cleanliness, and overall experience.
The property offers a range of modern amenities, including a swimming pool, garden, and spa facilities, ideal for relaxation and rejuvenation. Guests can enjoy a continental breakfast, room service, and a private terrace with stunning views, making it a perfect choice for a comfortable and enjoyable stay.
Come As You Are Inn Llc - Fire Island, NY
9.5 36 reviews

Come As You Are Inn Llc

B&B, Sayville
Come As You Are Inn LLC is a recently renovated, adults-only guesthouse located in Sayville, 6.9 kilometres from Long Island MacArthur Airport, with Splish Splash 43.5 kilometres away and Nassau Veterans Memorial Coliseum 49.9 kilometres distant.
This establishment offers guest rooms with air conditioning, private bathrooms, and mini-bars, alongside a saltwater pool, hot tub, and garden, accommodating up to two guests with a floor area of 14 square metres.

Frequently asked questions about bed and breakfast in Fire Island, NY

Popular destinations

Best Fire Island, NY bed and breakfasts with a garden

Come As You Are Inn Llc - Fire Island, NY
9.5 36 reviews

Come As You Are Inn Llc

B&B, Sayville
Come As You Are Inn LLC is a recently renovated, adults-only guesthouse located in Sayville, 6.9 kilometres from Long Island MacArthur Airport, with Splish Splash 43.5 kilometres away and Nassau Veterans Memorial Coliseum 49.9 kilometres distant.
This establishment offers guest rooms with air conditioning, private bathrooms, and mini-bars, alongside a saltwater pool, hot tub, and garden, accommodating up to two guests with a floor area of 14 square metres.
Come As You Are Inn - Fire Island, NY
9.8 154 reviews

Come As You Are Inn

B&B, Sayville
This B&B is ideally situated in Sayville, a short walk from the train station and within easy reach of several beautiful beaches. It has consistently received excellent ratings for its location, cleanliness, and overall experience.
The guest house offers a comfortable and spacious bedroom with a private bathroom. Guests can enjoy a range of amenities, including a swimming pool, jacuzzi, terrace, and garden, as well as a restaurant and bar on site.
Moonrise Motel Kismet Unit 104 - Fire Island, NY
10 4 reviews

Moonrise Motel Kismet Unit 104

B&B, Fire Island
The Moonrise Motel, a pet-friendly guesthouse in Kismet, Fire Island, is situated near the marina and a short walk from the beach.
This newly renovated property offers 3-bedroom units sleeping up to 8 guests, each with a kitchenette, patio seating, and access to a courtyard with BBQ facilities, an outdoor bar, and a market; bike rentals are available on-site.
The Ocean Bay House - Fire Island, NY
9.9 127 reviews

The Ocean Bay House

B&B, Bay Shore
The Ocean Bay House is a charming bed and breakfast in Bay Shore, New York, just a short drive from Benjamin's Memorial Beach and within easy reach of Nassau Veterans Memorial Coliseum and Jones Beach. It has consistently received excellent ratings for location, cleanliness, and overall experience.
The property offers a range of modern amenities, including a swimming pool, garden, and spa facilities, ideal for relaxation and rejuvenation. Guests can enjoy a continental breakfast, room service, and a private terrace with stunning views, making it a perfect choice for a comfortable and enjoyable stay.

Our Favourite Bed and Breakfasts with a Pool in Fire Island, NY

Enjoying a refreshing dip in your B&B pool is a superb way to complement a day in Fire Island, NY.

Double Queen Room W/ Small Balcony - Fire Island, NY
9.7 18 reviews

Double Queen Room W/ Small Balcony

B&B, Fire Island
This charming bed and breakfast is situated right next to the Ice Palace Night Club in the heart of Fire Island, offering easy access to the island's vibrant nightlife and attractions. The establishment enjoys excellent user, location, and cleanliness ratings, making it a popular choice for travellers.
The guest house offers one bedroom with two queen-size beds, accommodating up to four guests. Amenities include air conditioning, internet access, and pet-friendly policies, ensuring a comfortable and convenient stay.
Double Queen Room - Fire Island, NY
9.8 82 reviews

Double Queen Room

B&B, Fire Island
This charming bed and breakfast is located within the Grove Hotel, the largest hotel in Fire Island, placing it right in the heart of the island's activity. It has consistently received excellent ratings for its cleanliness, location, and overall experience.
Each room in this guesthouse offers two queen-size beds, comfortably accommodating up to four guests. The B&B provides a range of amenities, including internet access and air conditioning, and its central location allows for easy access to the island's beaches, shops, and restaurants.
The Ocean Bay House - Fire Island, NY
9.9 127 reviews

The Ocean Bay House

B&B, Bay Shore
The Ocean Bay House is a charming bed and breakfast in Bay Shore, New York, just a short drive from Benjamin's Memorial Beach and within easy reach of Nassau Veterans Memorial Coliseum and Jones Beach. It has consistently received excellent ratings for location, cleanliness, and overall experience.
The property offers a range of modern amenities, including a swimming pool, garden, and spa facilities, ideal for relaxation and rejuvenation. Guests can enjoy a continental breakfast, room service, and a private terrace with stunning views, making it a perfect choice for a comfortable and enjoyable stay.
Come As You Are Inn Llc - Fire Island, NY
9.5 36 reviews

Come As You Are Inn Llc

B&B, Sayville
Come As You Are Inn LLC is a recently renovated, adults-only guesthouse located in Sayville, 6.9 kilometres from Long Island MacArthur Airport, with Splish Splash 43.5 kilometres away and Nassau Veterans Memorial Coliseum 49.9 kilometres distant.
This establishment offers guest rooms with air conditioning, private bathrooms, and mini-bars, alongside a saltwater pool, hot tub, and garden, accommodating up to two guests with a floor area of 14 square metres.

Find the Best Seaside Bed and Breakfasts in Fire Island, NY

Take in the relaxing maritime atmosphere at shoreside bed and breakfasts a short distance from the coast in Fire Island, NY.

Come As You Are Inn - Fire Island, NY
No reviews

Come As You Are Inn

B&B, Sayville

Discover Luxury Bed and Breakfasts in Fire Island, NY

For those seeking excellence, a high-end B&B near the water in Fire Island, NY offers a refined retreat with exceptional attention to detail.

Moonrise Motel Kismet Unit 104 - Fire Island, NY
10 4 reviews

Moonrise Motel Kismet Unit 104

B&B, Fire Island

Guest-Favourite Guesthouses with Parking in Fire Island, NY

Free on-site parking comes with these B&Bs in Fire Island, NY, letting you focus entirely on the local beaches from the start.

Come As You Are Inn - Fire Island, NY
9.8 154 reviews

Come As You Are Inn

B&B, Sayville
Come As You Are Inn Llc - Fire Island, NY
9.5 36 reviews

Come As You Are Inn Llc

B&B, Sayville
Bask In This Bay-shore Beauty!! (Listing #3) - Fire Island, NY
No reviews

Bask In This Bay-shore Beauty!! (Listing #3)

B&B, Bay Shore
Private Room With Private Bathroom. King Size Bed - Fire Island, NY
10 2 reviews

Private Room With Private Bathroom. King Size Bed

B&B, Bayport

Explore Bed and Breakfasts with a Hot Tub in Fire Island, NY

Whether you prefer a jacuzzi or a hot tub, these B&Bs in Fire Island, NY feature private facilities.

Come As You Are Inn Llc - Fire Island, NY
9.5 36 reviews

Come As You Are Inn Llc

B&B, Sayville

Top-Rated Guesthouses with a Spa in Fire Island, NY

Choose a spa-equipped B&B in Fire Island, NY for the ultimate waterside wellness experience integrated seamlessly into your relaxing stay.

Double Queen Room - Fire Island, NY
9.8 82 reviews

Double Queen Room

B&B, Fire Island
©2026 cozycozy.com