Zey Hotel, a 3.5-star establishment in Greenport, is situated a short walk from the waterfront, the Greenport Farmers' Market, Greenport Harbor Brewing Company (both within 500 metres), and Greenport Station (800 metres away). This hotel offers complimentary WiFi in public areas, free self-parking, and bicycle hire, with concierge services available to assist guests, alongside a coffee shop/cafe and coffee/tea in a common area.
9.2 522 reviews
Shelter Island, NY
28/07 – 31/07
£490/nighttotal: £1470 (3 )
American Beech Hotel
1 2
hotel , Greenport
The American Beech Hotel is situated in Greenport, just 26 miles from Splish Splash water park and 48 miles from Long Island MacArthur Airport, making it a convenient base for exploring the charming town and surrounding area. This 4-star hotel has received very good user ratings, indicating a high level of satisfaction among guests. The hotel offers spacious rooms with air conditioning, seating areas, flat-screen TVs, safety deposit boxes, and private bathrooms with complimentary toiletries. Guests can enjoy a range of amenities, including a swimming pool, terrace, garden, spa, restaurant, bar, and free bikes to explore the local area.
8.3 942 reviews
Shelter Island, NY
28/07 – 31/07
£485/nighttotal: £1455 (3 )
Sound View Greenport
1 2
hotel , Southold
Sound View Greenport is a 3-star hotel situated on the North Fork in Greenport, just 98 miles from New York City and a short drive from popular destinations like Montauk and East Hampton. It has received very good user ratings, making it a popular choice for travellers seeking a relaxing getaway. This hotel offers a range of amenities and activities to keep guests entertained, including a seasonal outdoor pool, a private beach area, bike hire, a tennis court, a shared lounge, a bar, and a restaurant. The rooms all have stunning waterfront views, allowing guests to enjoy the beauty of the Long Island Sound.
9.7 195 reviews
Shelter Island, NY
28/07 – 31/07
£782/nighttotal: £2346 (3 )
Hotel Moraine
1 2
hotel , Greenport
Hotel Moraine is located in Greenport, 24 miles from Splish Splash and 46 miles from Long Island MacArthur Airport, making it a convenient base for exploring the area. The hotel consistently receives excellent ratings for its location, cleanliness and overall experience. The hotel offers a range of comfortable rooms, each accommodating up to two guests. Guests can enjoy a variety of amenities, including a seasonal outdoor swimming pool, a fitness centre, a bar and lounge, a sun terrace, free Wi-Fi, and complimentary bikes for exploring the charming streets and waterfront of Greenport.
9.0 484 reviews
Shelter Island, NY
28/07 – 31/07
£1533/nighttotal: £4599 (3 )
Faraway Sag Harbor
1 2
hotel , Sag Harbor
Baron's Cove is located in Sag Harbor, New York, just a short drive from Montauk and Mystic, offering a convenient base for exploring the charming Hamptons. This 4-star hotel has received very good user ratings for its location, cleanliness, and overall experience. The accommodation has a range of rooms with either ocean or garden views. Guests can enjoy a saltwater swimming pool, on-site restaurant, bike hire, a shop, and a range of other amenities including a spa, fitness centre, and tennis court.
9.0 37 reviews
Shelter Island, NY
28/07 – 31/07
£515/nighttotal: £1545 (3 )
The Chequit
1 2
hotel , Shelter Island Heights
The Chequit is a 3-star hotel located in The Heights district of Shelter Island Heights, offering convenient access to Shelter Island Country Club, Sunset Beach, and Crescent Beach, all within 1.6 kilometres, and Sylvester Manor and East End Seaport Maritime Museum within 3.2 kilometres. This establishment provides on-site dining with its own restaurant and cafe, complimentary self-parking, and free WiFi in public areas, and welcomes pets.
9.4 636 reviews
Shelter Island, NY
28/07 – 31/07
£300/nighttotal: £900 (3 )
The Shoals Suites & Slips
1 2
hotel , Southold
The Shoals Suites & Slips is located in Southold, a charming village on Long Island's North Fork, just a short drive from the beautiful beaches of Orient Point. It is a 4-star hotel with excellent user ratings. The hotel offers comfortable rooms with private bathrooms and free parking. Guests can enjoy a range of amenities, including a restaurant, bar, terrace, garden, and concierge service.
8.7 1000 reviews
Shelter Island, NY
30/06 – 07/07
£557/nighttotal: £3899 (7 )
The Harbor Front Inn
1 2
hotel , Greenport
The Harbor Front Inn is conveniently located in the heart of Greenport, just a short walk from the North Ferry Terminal and a 3-minute drive from Kontokosta Winery. This 3-star hotel consistently receives very good user ratings, making it a popular choice for travellers visiting the area. The inn offers comfortable rooms with modern amenities, including a flat-screen TV, refrigerator, and private bathroom. Guests can enjoy a range of on-site facilities, such as a swimming pool, fitness centre, and free Wi-Fi.
9.3 215 reviews
Shelter Island, NY
28/07 – 31/07
£743/nighttotal: £2229 (3 )
The Pridwin Hotel
1 2
hotel , Shelter Island Heights
The Pridwin Hotel is situated on Shelter Island, a short ferry ride from the mainland and a short drive from the quaint village of Shelter Island Heights. It is a 4-star hotel with excellent user ratings for location, cleanliness, and overall experience. The hotel offers a variety of rooms and cottages, all with stunning water views. Guests can enjoy a range of amenities including a swimming pool, spa, restaurant, bar, fitness centre, tennis court, and a variety of seasonal activities.
8.5 82 reviews
Shelter Island, NY
28/07 – 31/07
£367/nighttotal: £1101 (3 )
Shelter Island House
1 2
hotel , Shelter Island Heights
The Shelter Island House is situated in Shelter Island Heights, a short distance from the village centre and the island's beautiful beaches. This 4-star hotel enjoys very good user ratings, making it a popular choice for travellers. The hotel has a range of facilities, including a swimming pool, garden, and terrace, perfect for relaxing and enjoying the sunshine. Guests can also enjoy the on-site restaurant, bar, and spa, as well as take advantage of the concierge service, room service, and free Wi-Fi.
9.6 273 reviews
Shelter Island, NY
30/06 – 07/07
£687/nighttotal: £4809 (7 )
The Menhaden Hotel
1 2
hotel , Greenport
The Menhaden Hotel is situated in Greenport, just 26 miles from Splish Splash water park and 47 miles from Long Island MacArthur Airport, making it an ideal base for exploring the charming waterfront town. This 4-star hotel boasts excellent user ratings for its location, cleanliness, and overall experience. The hotel offers comfortable rooms with private bathrooms and modern amenities, including air conditioning, free Wi-Fi, and flat-screen TVs. Guests can enjoy the on-site restaurant and bar, relax on the terrace, or explore the area on complimentary bikes.
Compare Luxury Hotels in Shelter Island, NY
Upscale hotels in Shelter Island, NY offer the kind of stay you will want to return to, featuring premium amenities and refined service throughout.
9.2 522 reviews
Shelter Island, NY
28/07 – 31/07
£490/nighttotal: £1470 (3 )
American Beech Hotel
1 2
hotel , Greenport
The American Beech Hotel is situated in Greenport, just 26 miles from Splish Splash water park and 48 miles from Long Island MacArthur Airport, making it a convenient base for exploring the charming town and surrounding area. This 4-star hotel has received very good user ratings, indicating a high level of satisfaction among guests. The hotel offers spacious rooms with air conditioning, seating areas, flat-screen TVs, safety deposit boxes, and private bathrooms with complimentary toiletries. Guests can enjoy a range of amenities, including a swimming pool, terrace, garden, spa, restaurant, bar, and free bikes to explore the local area.
9.0 484 reviews
Shelter Island, NY
28/07 – 31/07
£1533/nighttotal: £4599 (3 )
Faraway Sag Harbor
1 2
hotel , Sag Harbor
Baron's Cove is located in Sag Harbor, New York, just a short drive from Montauk and Mystic, offering a convenient base for exploring the charming Hamptons. This 4-star hotel has received very good user ratings for its location, cleanliness, and overall experience. The accommodation has a range of rooms with either ocean or garden views. Guests can enjoy a saltwater swimming pool, on-site restaurant, bike hire, a shop, and a range of other amenities including a spa, fitness centre, and tennis court.
9.4 636 reviews
Shelter Island, NY
28/07 – 31/07
£300/nighttotal: £900 (3 )
The Shoals Suites & Slips
1 2
hotel , Southold
The Shoals Suites & Slips is located in Southold, a charming village on Long Island's North Fork, just a short drive from the beautiful beaches of Orient Point. It is a 4-star hotel with excellent user ratings. The hotel offers comfortable rooms with private bathrooms and free parking. Guests can enjoy a range of amenities, including a restaurant, bar, terrace, garden, and concierge service.
9.6 273 reviews
Shelter Island, NY
30/06 – 07/07
£687/nighttotal: £4809 (7 )
The Menhaden Hotel
1 2
hotel , Greenport
The Menhaden Hotel is situated in Greenport, just 26 miles from Splish Splash water park and 47 miles from Long Island MacArthur Airport, making it an ideal base for exploring the charming waterfront town. This 4-star hotel boasts excellent user ratings for its location, cleanliness, and overall experience. The hotel offers comfortable rooms with private bathrooms and modern amenities, including air conditioning, free Wi-Fi, and flat-screen TVs. Guests can enjoy the on-site restaurant and bar, relax on the terrace, or explore the area on complimentary bikes.
Choose the Right Hotel with a Swimming Pool in Shelter Island, NY
Dip in whenever you like, as every hotel near the water in Shelter Island, NY comes with a swimming pool on-site.
8.3 942 reviews
Shelter Island, NY
28/07 – 31/07
£485/nighttotal: £1455 (3 )
Sound View Greenport
1 2
hotel , Southold
Sound View Greenport is a 3-star hotel situated on the North Fork in Greenport, just 98 miles from New York City and a short drive from popular destinations like Montauk and East Hampton. It has received very good user ratings, making it a popular choice for travellers seeking a relaxing getaway. This hotel offers a range of amenities and activities to keep guests entertained, including a seasonal outdoor pool, a private beach area, bike hire, a tennis court, a shared lounge, a bar, and a restaurant. The rooms all have stunning waterfront views, allowing guests to enjoy the beauty of the Long Island Sound.
9.7 195 reviews
Shelter Island, NY
28/07 – 31/07
£782/nighttotal: £2346 (3 )
Hotel Moraine
1 2
hotel , Greenport
Hotel Moraine is located in Greenport, 24 miles from Splish Splash and 46 miles from Long Island MacArthur Airport, making it a convenient base for exploring the area. The hotel consistently receives excellent ratings for its location, cleanliness and overall experience. The hotel offers a range of comfortable rooms, each accommodating up to two guests. Guests can enjoy a variety of amenities, including a seasonal outdoor swimming pool, a fitness centre, a bar and lounge, a sun terrace, free Wi-Fi, and complimentary bikes for exploring the charming streets and waterfront of Greenport.
8.7 1000 reviews
Shelter Island, NY
30/06 – 07/07
£557/nighttotal: £3899 (7 )
The Harbor Front Inn
1 2
hotel , Greenport
The Harbor Front Inn is conveniently located in the heart of Greenport, just a short walk from the North Ferry Terminal and a 3-minute drive from Kontokosta Winery. This 3-star hotel consistently receives very good user ratings, making it a popular choice for travellers visiting the area. The inn offers comfortable rooms with modern amenities, including a flat-screen TV, refrigerator, and private bathroom. Guests can enjoy a range of on-site facilities, such as a swimming pool, fitness centre, and free Wi-Fi.
9.3 215 reviews
Shelter Island, NY
28/07 – 31/07
£743/nighttotal: £2229 (3 )
The Pridwin Hotel
1 2
hotel , Shelter Island Heights
The Pridwin Hotel is situated on Shelter Island, a short ferry ride from the mainland and a short drive from the quaint village of Shelter Island Heights. It is a 4-star hotel with excellent user ratings for location, cleanliness, and overall experience. The hotel offers a variety of rooms and cottages, all with stunning water views. Guests can enjoy a range of amenities including a swimming pool, spa, restaurant, bar, fitness centre, tennis court, and a variety of seasonal activities.
Frequently asked questions about hotels in Shelter Island, NY
What are the top landmarks to see in and around Shelter Island, NY?
Shelter Island is known for its natural beauty, so you'll want to check out Mashomack Preserve, a 1,000-acre nature reserve with hiking trails and stunning views. The Shelter Island Historical Society Museum is also worth a visit, offering a glimpse into the island's past. If you're looking for something a bit more modern, head to the Shelter Island Country Club, which has a beautiful golf course and a charming clubhouse.
What are the best hotels with a swimming pool in Shelter Island, NY?
What are the most affordable attractions in and around Shelter Island, NY?
For budget-friendly fun, you can't beat the beaches! Shelter Island has some beautiful public beaches, like Crescent Beach and Wades Beach, where you can enjoy swimming, sunbathing, and picnicking. You can also take a walk along the scenic waterfront or explore the many hiking trails in the area.
What are the most popular 2, 3 and 4-star hotels in Shelter Island, NY?
How can travelers relax during a week in and arond Shelter Island, NY?
Shelter Island is all about slowing down and enjoying the simple things. You can relax by the beach, rent a bike and explore the island, or take a boat trip to one of the nearby islands. If you're looking for something more active, there are plenty of opportunities for kayaking, paddleboarding, and fishing.
What are the best luxury hotels in Shelter Island, NY?
What amenities can travelers expect in hotel rooms in Shelter Island, NY?
Most hotels on Shelter Island offer standard amenities like comfortable beds, air conditioning, and private bathrooms. Some hotels also have swimming pools, fitness centres, and restaurants. You can also find some charming bed and breakfasts with unique amenities.
What are the best family friendly hotels in Shelter Island, NY?
When is the best time to book a hotel in Shelter Island, NY?
The best time to book a hotel in Shelter Island is during the shoulder seasons, from April to May and September to October, when the weather is still pleasant but the crowds are smaller. Booking in advance is always a good idea, especially during peak season, which runs from June to August.
What are the best pet friendly hotels in Shelter Island, NY?
What are some pet-friendly activities in and around Shelter Island, NY?
Shelter Island is a very dog-friendly place. You can bring your furry friend to many of the beaches, restaurants, and shops. You can also enjoy a walk along the scenic waterfront or explore the many hiking trails in the area. There are also several dog parks on the island, where your dog can run and play off-leash.
What are the best hotels with jacuzzi in Shelter Island, NY?
Which towns or cities worth a visit near Shelter Island, NY?
If you're looking to explore beyond Shelter Island, you can take a short ferry ride to Greenport, a charming village on the North Fork of Long Island. Greenport has a lively waterfront, a variety of restaurants and shops, and a historic downtown area. You can also visit the nearby town of Sag Harbor, which is known for its beautiful beaches, its historic whaling district, and its vibrant arts scene.
Destinations nearby
Discover Hotels by the Shore in Shelter Island, NY
Base your holiday at scenic seaside hotels in Shelter Island, NY, positioned just a short journey away from popular local beaches.
9.2 305 reviews
Shelter Island, NY
28/07 – 31/07
£207/nighttotal: £621 (3 )
Zey Hotel
1 2
hotel , Greenport
Zey Hotel, a 3.5-star establishment in Greenport, is situated a short walk from the waterfront, the Greenport Farmers' Market, Greenport Harbor Brewing Company (both within 500 metres), and Greenport Station (800 metres away). This hotel offers complimentary WiFi in public areas, free self-parking, and bicycle hire, with concierge services available to assist guests, alongside a coffee shop/cafe and coffee/tea in a common area.
Best Shelter Island, NY hotels with air conditioning
8.7 1000 reviews
Shelter Island, NY
30/06 – 07/07
£557/nighttotal: £3899 (7 )
The Harbor Front Inn
1 2
hotel , Greenport
The Harbor Front Inn is conveniently located in the heart of Greenport, just a short walk from the North Ferry Terminal and a 3-minute drive from Kontokosta Winery. This 3-star hotel consistently receives very good user ratings, making it a popular choice for travellers visiting the area. The inn offers comfortable rooms with modern amenities, including a flat-screen TV, refrigerator, and private bathroom. Guests can enjoy a range of on-site facilities, such as a swimming pool, fitness centre, and free Wi-Fi.
8.5 82 reviews
Shelter Island, NY
28/07 – 31/07
£367/nighttotal: £1101 (3 )
Shelter Island House
1 2
hotel , Shelter Island Heights
The Shelter Island House is situated in Shelter Island Heights, a short distance from the village centre and the island's beautiful beaches. This 4-star hotel enjoys very good user ratings, making it a popular choice for travellers. The hotel has a range of facilities, including a swimming pool, garden, and terrace, perfect for relaxing and enjoying the sunshine. Guests can also enjoy the on-site restaurant, bar, and spa, as well as take advantage of the concierge service, room service, and free Wi-Fi.
9.2 522 reviews
Shelter Island, NY
28/07 – 31/07
£490/nighttotal: £1470 (3 )
American Beech Hotel
1 2
hotel , Greenport
The American Beech Hotel is situated in Greenport, just 26 miles from Splish Splash water park and 48 miles from Long Island MacArthur Airport, making it a convenient base for exploring the charming town and surrounding area. This 4-star hotel has received very good user ratings, indicating a high level of satisfaction among guests. The hotel offers spacious rooms with air conditioning, seating areas, flat-screen TVs, safety deposit boxes, and private bathrooms with complimentary toiletries. Guests can enjoy a range of amenities, including a swimming pool, terrace, garden, spa, restaurant, bar, and free bikes to explore the local area.
9.3 215 reviews
Shelter Island, NY
28/07 – 31/07
£743/nighttotal: £2229 (3 )
The Pridwin Hotel
1 2
hotel , Shelter Island Heights
The Pridwin Hotel is situated on Shelter Island, a short ferry ride from the mainland and a short drive from the quaint village of Shelter Island Heights. It is a 4-star hotel with excellent user ratings for location, cleanliness, and overall experience. The hotel offers a variety of rooms and cottages, all with stunning water views. Guests can enjoy a range of amenities including a swimming pool, spa, restaurant, bar, fitness centre, tennis court, and a variety of seasonal activities.
Search Hotels with a Balcony in Shelter Island, NY
Morning coffee with views of the water and coastal scenery is one of the simple pleasures of staying in a hotel near the water in Shelter Island, NY.
9.2 305 reviews
Shelter Island, NY
28/07 – 31/07
£207/nighttotal: £621 (3 )
Zey Hotel
1 2
hotel , Greenport
9.2 522 reviews
Shelter Island, NY
28/07 – 31/07
£490/nighttotal: £1470 (3 )
American Beech Hotel
1 2
hotel , Greenport
9.0 484 reviews
Shelter Island, NY
28/07 – 31/07
£1533/nighttotal: £4599 (3 )
Faraway Sag Harbor
1 2
hotel , Sag Harbor
9.6 273 reviews
Shelter Island, NY
30/06 – 07/07
£687/nighttotal: £4809 (7 )
The Menhaden Hotel
1 2
hotel , Greenport
Guest-Favourite Family-Friendly Hotels in Shelter Island, NY
Travelling to Shelter Island, NY with children? A quality family hotel makes everything easier, with lifeguarded beaches and plenty of room to spread out at every option.
9.2 522 reviews
Shelter Island, NY
28/07 – 31/07
£490/nighttotal: £1470 (3 )
American Beech Hotel
1 2
hotel , Greenport
8.5 82 reviews
Shelter Island, NY
28/07 – 31/07
£367/nighttotal: £1101 (3 )
Shelter Island House
1 2
hotel , Shelter Island Heights
9.3 215 reviews
Shelter Island, NY
28/07 – 31/07
£743/nighttotal: £2229 (3 )
The Pridwin Hotel
1 2
hotel , Shelter Island Heights
9.0 484 reviews
Shelter Island, NY
28/07 – 31/07
£1533/nighttotal: £4599 (3 )
Faraway Sag Harbor
1 2
hotel , Sag Harbor
Handpicked Pet-Friendly Hotels in Shelter Island, NY
Book a dog-friendly hotel in Shelter Island, NY, perfectly placed for coastal strolls and sandy paw adventures.
9.0 37 reviews
Shelter Island, NY
28/07 – 31/07
£515/nighttotal: £1545 (3 )
The Chequit
1 2
hotel , Shelter Island Heights
Best Hotels with Free Parking in Shelter Island, NY
Park up and enjoy the coast and local beaches since every hotel in Shelter Island, NY comes with a free on-site car park.
8.7 1000 reviews
Shelter Island, NY
30/06 – 07/07
£557/nighttotal: £3899 (7 )
The Harbor Front Inn
1 2
hotel , Greenport
9.2 522 reviews
Shelter Island, NY
28/07 – 31/07
£490/nighttotal: £1470 (3 )
American Beech Hotel
1 2
hotel , Greenport
9.3 215 reviews
Shelter Island, NY
28/07 – 31/07
£743/nighttotal: £2229 (3 )
The Pridwin Hotel
1 2
hotel , Shelter Island Heights
9.2 305 reviews
Shelter Island, NY
28/07 – 31/07
£207/nighttotal: £621 (3 )
Zey Hotel
1 2
hotel , Greenport
Our Favourite Hotels with Spa Facilities in Shelter Island, NY
Wellness travel to Shelter Island, NY starts with a hotel that has a proper spa. Every option in our collection has one.
