Cottages in Cayuga Lake, NY

102 available cottage rental offers

7 nights
2
1
  • airbnb
  • booking
  • vrbo
  • expedia
  • sonder
  • priceline
  • tripadvisor
  • tripcom
  • homestay
  • hotelscom
  • orbitz
  • vacasa
Cayuga Lake, NY cottages
Choose the perfect vacation accommodation
Price per night
Accommodation type
Rating

102 Best cottages in Cayuga Lake, NY

Best family friendly Cayuga Lake, NY cottages

Among the 102 accommodations in Cayuga Lake, NY, here are the 4 best family friendly cottages

Cayuga Lake Cottage With Private Lake Access - Cayuga Lake, NY
No reviews

Cayuga Lake Cottage With Private Lake Access

cottage, Trumansburg
This lakeside cottage near Lansing, New York provides easy access to Cayuga Lake and attractions like Buttermilk Falls State Park and Ithaca Commons.
The two-bedroom, one-bathroom house sleeps six, features a private lake dock, picnic table, deck with grill, and includes a kitchen with a refrigerator and microwave; a washer/dryer is not available.
Discover Cayuga Lake Waterfront Cottage Charm - Cayuga Lake, NY
10 10 reviews

Discover Cayuga Lake Waterfront Cottage Charm

cottage, Romulus
This Romulus vacation home is conveniently located near Cayuga Lake, a 5-minute walk from Buttonwood Grove Winery and a short drive from Knapp Winery and Vineyard, also close to the Peter Whitmer Log Home and It's A Wonderful Life Museum.
This three-bedroom, two-bathroom house sleeps six and includes Wi-Fi, air conditioning, laundry facilities, and is close to Argyle Lake State Park for outdoor recreation.
Live Your Best Vacation Life! Lovely 4 Br Property On Cayuga Lake.  Dog Friendly - Cayuga Lake, NY
9.2 30 reviews

Live Your Best Vacation Life! Lovely 4 Br Property On Cayuga Lake. Dog Friendly

cottage, Aurora
This waterfront cottage is located just a short distance from Cayuga Lake and a few miles from Bright Leaf Vineyard, making it a perfect base for exploring Aurora and its surrounding attractions. The cottage has received excellent ratings from previous guests, indicating a high level of satisfaction.
The cottage offers four bedrooms and three bathrooms, providing ample space for up to eight guests. Enjoy the lake views from the terrace, grill up some food on the barbecue, or relax by the fireplace in the evenings.
Cayuga Lake Cottage Near Ithaca, Taughannock Falls State Park And Trumansburg, N - Cayuga Lake, NY
9.8 141 reviews

Cayuga Lake Cottage Near Ithaca, Taughannock Falls State Park And Trumansburg, N

cottage, Trumansburg
Canvasback Cottage is located on the west shore of Cayuga Lake, just a short drive from Taughannock State Park and the charming village of Trumansburg. The cottage has consistently received excellent ratings from previous guests, highlighting its comfortable and convenient accommodations.
The 1,000 square foot cottage comfortably sleeps six guests in two bedrooms and an enclosed porch with a futon. The cottage offers a range of amenities including a private dock, a spacious deck, a fully equipped kitchen, air conditioning, and a garden, making it an ideal choice for families and groups looking for a relaxing getaway.

Best Cayuga Lake, NY cottages with a garden

Unique Space-great View, East Side Sunsets A Plus -2 Nights Or More :) - Cayuga Lake, NY
9.8 202 reviews

Unique Space-great View, East Side Sunsets A Plus -2 Nights Or More :)

cottage, Moravia
This charming cottage is located just a short distance from Owasco Lake, offering easy access to water activities and scenic views, while also being close to nature trails, libraries, and parks. It's an excellent choice for travelers looking for a peaceful retreat in Moravia.
The cottage provides comfortable accommodations for two guests with one bedroom and one bathroom. It features a fully equipped kitchen, a fireplace, a balcony, and access to a swimming pool, a spa, and barbecue grills.
The Gate - Chapman House - Cayuga Lake, NY
10 3 reviews

The Gate - Chapman House

cottage, Skaneateles
This Skaneateles Lake cottage, located within two kilometers of the John D. Barrow Art Gallery, Skaneateles Historical Society, and White Birch Vineyards Tasting Room, offers easy access to area attractions.
This 800-square-foot house features two bedrooms, one bathroom, sleeps six, and includes a fully equipped kitchen, Wi-Fi, air conditioning, and a private balcony; pets are welcome.
Cottage Retreat In The Heart Of The Finger Lakes - Cayuga Lake, NY
9.4 9 reviews

Cottage Retreat In The Heart Of The Finger Lakes

cottage, Ovid
This Ovid, New York cottage sits on one acre, seven miles from the Cayuga Lake Wine Trail and near the Seneca Lake Wine & Food Trail, offering a peaceful rural setting amidst the Finger Lakes region's wineries.
This 1370-square-foot vacation home features two bedrooms (one queen, one full bed), a living room futon, one bathroom, and sleeps five; amenities include air conditioning, Wi-Fi, a washer/dryer, massage chairs, and an outdoor space with a grill and fire pit.
Sunset Bungalow On The Water - Cayuga Lake, NY
9.6 13 reviews

Sunset Bungalow On The Water

cottage, Moravia
This charming cottage is located in Indian Cove, Moravia, a short drive from the Ward W. O'Hara Agricultural Museum and Merry-Go-Round Playhouse, offering a peaceful lakeside retreat. It has earned an excellent rating from previous guests, making it a popular choice for travelers.
The cottage features a custom-built loft space upstairs that comfortably accommodates up to 7 guests. Enjoy modern amenities like air conditioning, a fully equipped kitchen, fast Wi-Fi, and a smart TV, along with outdoor activities like swimming, kayaking, and relaxing by the fire pit.

Frequently Asked Questions about cottages in Cayuga Lake, NY

  • What are the top must-see attractions in and around Cayuga Lake, NY?

    For stunning lake views, head to Taughannock Falls State Park, boasting a breathtaking 215-foot waterfall. The Cayuga Lake State Park offers beautiful beaches and hiking trails. In Ithaca, Cornell University's campus is worth exploring, and you can visit the impressive Johnson Museum of Art. For a charming small-town experience, explore the village of Watkins Glen and its historic downtown. Don't miss Watkins Glen State Park with its gorge trails.
  • What are the best cottages in Cayuga Lake, NY?

    Among the cottages in Cayuga Lake, NY, Experience Minka Life: Simple Is Good, Winery Cabin - Relax On The Ridge and Magnolia Lakeside Cottage are the most popular ones.

  • How to spend a 5-day holiday at Cayuga Lake, NY?

    Day 1: Explore Ithaca, visiting Cornell University and the Johnson Museum of Art. Day 2: Hike to Taughannock Falls and enjoy the park's trails. Day 3: Relax at Cayuga Lake State Park, swimming or sunbathing. Day 4: Drive the scenic route along the lake, stopping at charming towns like Watkins Glen. Day 5: Hike the gorge trails in Watkins Glen State Park and explore the village's historic downtown.
  • What are the best cottages with a pool in Cayuga Lake, NY?

  • Is Cayuga Lake, NY a good destination to rent a cottage?

    Absolutely! Many charming cottages and vacation rentals are available around Cayuga Lake, offering a relaxing and picturesque getaway. You'll find options in towns like Watkins Glen, Ithaca, and smaller communities along the lake's shores, providing various sizes and amenities to suit different needs and budgets.
  • What are the best cottages with a jacuzzi in Cayuga Lake, NY?

  • What weather, wildlife, or natural hazards might affect travelers in the Cayuga Lake, NY area?

    Summers are warm and humid, while winters can be cold and snowy. Be prepared for varying weather conditions. Wildlife includes deer, birds, and various smaller animals. Be aware of your surroundings and practice responsible wildlife viewing. Steep slopes and gorges in some areas can pose a risk, so exercise caution when hiking. Check weather forecasts before heading out, especially during the colder months.
  • What are the best cottages for families and kids in Cayuga Lake, NY?

  • Is the Cayuga Lake, NY area pedestrian and cyclist-friendly?

    Parts of the area are quite pedestrian and cyclist-friendly, especially within Ithaca and Watkins Glen. Ithaca has a decent network of bike paths, and the lake's perimeter offers scenic cycling opportunities, though some roads may have limited shoulders. However, always exercise caution when sharing roads with vehicles.
  • What are the best pet friendly cottages in Cayuga Lake, NY?

  • Are there any unusual or hidden places to explore in and around Cayuga Lake, NY?

    The gorges and trails less traveled in Watkins Glen State Park offer a sense of seclusion. Exploring the backroads and smaller towns along the lake can uncover charming hidden gems and local spots. Some of the smaller wineries and breweries offer a more intimate experience than larger establishments.
  • What are the best cottages with parking in Cayuga Lake, NY?

  • What are some of the best cultural experiences that allow you to meet locals near Cayuga Lake, NY?

    Visiting local farmers' markets in Ithaca and Watkins Glen provides opportunities to interact with local producers and artisans. Attending community events in smaller towns along the lake offers a chance to mingle with residents. Many local restaurants and pubs provide a relaxed atmosphere where you can chat with locals and experience regional hospitality.
  • What are the best authentic dishes to taste in the Cayuga Lake, NY region?

    The region is known for its fresh, locally sourced ingredients. Look for dishes featuring lake trout, other locally caught fish, and seasonal produce. Many restaurants offer creative takes on classic American cuisine, incorporating regional flavors. Ithaca and Watkins Glen both have a diverse culinary scene to explore.
  • Are there any recommended items to pack for a stay near Cayuga Lake, NY?

    Comfortable walking shoes are essential for exploring the many trails and towns. Layers of clothing are recommended, as weather can change quickly. Swimsuits, sunscreen, and insect repellent are advisable during warmer months. If you plan on hiking, bring appropriate gear, including sturdy footwear and rain gear.

Nearby regions

Best Cayuga Lake, NY cottages with jacuzzi

Among the 102 accommodations in Cayuga Lake, NY, here are the 1 best cottages with a jacuzzi

La Bella Vita: Spectacular Cayuga Lake Sunsets! - Cayuga Lake, NY
9.2 19 reviews

La Bella Vita: Spectacular Cayuga Lake Sunsets!

cottage, Union Springs
This Union Springs waterfront home offers direct Cayuga Lake access, proximity to Izzo's White Barn Winery (2.1 miles) and Montezuma National Wildlife Refuge (9 miles).
This 4,700-square-foot vacation rental boasts five bedrooms, four bathrooms, sleeps twelve, and includes a full kitchen, Jacuzzi, private yard, and free Wi-Fi.

Best pet friendly Cayuga Lake, NY cottages

Among the 102 accommodations in Cayuga Lake, NY, here are the 2 best pet friendly cottages

Idle Hour: "Stunning Panoramic Views Of Cayuga Lake!" - Cayuga Lake, NY
No reviews

Idle Hour: "Stunning Panoramic Views Of Cayuga Lake!"

cottage, Aurora
This pet-friendly cottage in Ovid, New York, offers easy access to Cayuga Lake (a 5-minute walk) and Sheldrake Point Winery (a 6-minute drive).
This 1,500-square-foot lakeside house features three bedrooms, three bathrooms, sleeps eight guests, and includes amenities such as a fully equipped kitchen, Wi-Fi, air conditioning, a terrace, and on-site kayaks.
Lakeview Crooked Cascade Cottage On Owasco - Cayuga Lake, NY
9.4 18 reviews

Lakeview Crooked Cascade Cottage On Owasco

cottage, Moravia
This Moravia, NY waterfront cottage boasts stunning Owasco Lake views, located just 0.1 miles from the lake and within 6 miles of Fillmore Glen State Park and Powers Public Library.
This 1000-square-foot vacation home features three bedrooms, one bathroom, sleeps six, and includes a fully equipped kitchen, air conditioning, Wi-Fi, a fireplace, and a patio; enjoy swimming, boating, fishing, and hiking nearby.
©2026 cozycozy.com