Search vacation rentals in Fire Island, NY from 100+ sites!
741 available vacation rental offers
Choose the perfect vacation accommodation
Price per night
Accommodation type
Rating
Best Vacation rentals and Airbnb offers in Fire Island, NY
Fire Island, NY
07/03 – 07/06
$3185/nighttotal: $9555 (3 )
Game Room, Hot Tub! Family Getaway In Bayshore
7 2
apartment , West Bay Shore
This 8,000 sq ft 'President's Mansion' vacation rental in West Bay Shore is located by the sea, offering proximity to Sagtikos Manor (0.7 miles), Gardiner County Park (0.8 miles), and the Bay Shore LIRR Station with NYC service (2 miles). This expansive home accommodates up to 28 guests with 7 bedrooms and 4 bathrooms, featuring a game room, home gym, hot tub, gas grill, and ample parking for 28 vehicles.
9.4 23 reviews
Fire Island, NY
08/01 – 08/03
$592/nighttotal: $1184 (2 )
Beachside Retreat
2 3
apartment , Shirley
This two-bedroom Shirley beach cottage offers easy walking access to Shirley Beach and a short drive to Smith Point Beach and Fire Island National Seashore. The 2-bedroom, 1-bathroom rental sleeps 5, features a kitchen, air conditioning, internet, parking, and a swimming pool, perfect for a relaxing Long Island getaway.
10 2 reviews
Fire Island, NY
06/25 – 06/28
$932/nighttotal: $2796 (3 )
Home In Davis Park Fire Island
4 6
apartment , Fire Island
This Fire Island rental is a short walk from the Atlantic Ocean and Great South Bay, near the ferry, a marina, a store, and a restaurant. The four-bedroom, two-bathroom house sleeps six and features a kitchen, air conditioning, outdoor shower, BBQ area, porch with sunset views, beach chairs, towels, and a foot-washing station.
9.7 86 reviews
Fire Island, NY
07/03 – 07/06
$4717/nighttotal: $14151 (3 )
The Legendary Pyramid House
3 2
apartment , Fire Island
This Fire Island apartment is located in the Pines district, bordering the National Seashore with stunning ocean and bay views. It has excellent user, location, and cleanliness ratings. The home features a unique pyramid design with a spacious master suite and multiple work spaces, accommodating up to six guests. Amenities include a private heated saltwater pool, hot tub, outdoor kitchen, and direct access to miles of pristine beaches.
10 1 review
Fire Island, NY
06/28 – 07/02
$286/nighttotal: $1144 (4 )
Cozy 1-bedroom Apartment In Charming Shirley With Private Entrance
1 2
apartment , Shirley
This private, first-level apartment is situated in Shirley, New York, offering convenient access to Smith Point Beach (7 minutes away), Carman's River, and major highways. This 1250 sq ft rental accommodates up to 4 guests with a queen-sized sofa bed, features a fully equipped kitchen, and provides access to a backyard patio, making it ideal for exploring nearby attractions like Splish Splash (23 miles) and Wertheim Wildlife Refuge (8 miles).
9.3 3 reviews
Fire Island, NY
06/27 – 07/04
$243/nighttotal: $1701 (7 )
Private Garden Suite In Bayshore
1 2
apartment , West Islip
This West Islip dwelling is located in a residential area, offering proximity to local shops and dining, and is a short walk to the Great South Bay. This 1-bedroom apartment accommodates up to 3 guests and includes free WiFi, private parking, and a kitchenette, with a check-out time between 8:00 AM and 11:00 AM.
10 5 reviews
Fire Island, NY
08/01 – 08/03
$1010/nighttotal: $2020 (2 )
Shirley Bayfront Getaway
1 3
apartment , Shirley
This Shirley bayfront home offers private water access with kayaks, ideal for swimming, crabbing, and fishing, and is a short distance from Smith Point Beach. This four-bedroom, two-bathroom rental sleeps ten guests and features a fully equipped kitchen (fridge, freezer, microwave, dishwasher), air conditioning, a garden, parking, and outdoor amenities including a firepit and enclosed porch.
10 3 reviews
Fire Island, NY
06/25 – 06/28
$1075/nighttotal: $3225 (3 )
Paradise On The Great South Bay
2 2
houseboat , Fire Island
This Sayville houseboat offers a unique Fire Island getaway, situated a short walk from Cherry Grove's community house and theater, and within one mile of Carrington House and Sailors' Haven, providing easy access to Fire Island ferries. The two-bedroom, two-bathroom vessel accommodates two guests and features air conditioning, internet access, and allows pets; enjoy swimming, boating, and fishing in the Great South Bay, with potential for stunning bay views.
10 3 reviews
Fire Island, NY
06/27 – 07/04
$3046/nighttotal: $21322 (7 )
Fire Island Pines H. Gifford's Famous Tree House
3 2
apartment , Fire Island
This Fire Island Pines apartment is located just a short walk from the Great South Bay and a stunning beach on the Atlantic Ocean, offering a peaceful retreat with easy access to the island's natural beauty. The apartment consistently receives excellent ratings for location, cleanliness, and overall user experience. The apartment has three bedrooms and three bathrooms, comfortably accommodating up to six guests. Enjoy modern amenities, a chef's kitchen, a private pool and hot tub, a roof deck with ocean and bay views, and multiple relaxing nooks.
10 12 reviews
Fire Island, NY
07/03 – 07/06
$2773/nighttotal: $8319 (3 )
The President Mansion\nluxurious Family Retreat - 1.5 Miles To Beach
7 2
apartment , West Bay Shore
This West Bay Shore vacation home is located less than a mile from the Sagtikos Manor and Great South Bay, and within two miles of the YMCA Boulton Center for the Performing Arts and Good Samaritan Hospital. This seven-bedroom, four-bathroom house sleeps 22 guests and boasts a Jacuzzi, sauna, terrace, and fully equipped kitchen including a refrigerator, microwave, and dishwasher, plus free Wi-Fi and parking.
10 20 reviews
Fire Island, NY
06/25 – 06/28
$1096/nighttotal: $3288 (3 )
Bellport Village Temperance Hall: Bellport Loft
2 2
apartment , Bellport
This Bellport apartment is conveniently located a short distance from the village center and a quick drive to the beautiful beaches. It boasts excellent user, location, and cleanliness ratings, ensuring a comfortable and enjoyable stay. The apartment features two bedrooms and two bathrooms, comfortably accommodating up to five guests. Amenities include a private upper deck with views, a heated pool, a full kitchen, laundry facilities, hardwood floors, plantation shutters, vaulted ceilings, and WiFi/cable access.
Fire Island, NY
06/27 – 07/04
$2023/nighttotal: $14161 (7 )
Fire Island Getaway | Renovated 5br | Sleeps 10
5 2
apartment , Fire Island
This Ocean Bay Park rental is located steps from the ferry and beach, offering convenient access to popular Fire Island establishments such as Flynn's and Schooner Inn. This 5-bedroom house accommodates up to 10 guests with 10 beds and features air conditioning in every room, a fully equipped kitchen, an on-site laundry shed, a deck, and an outdoor shower.
Best Fire Island, NY vacation rentals with a balcony
9.7 377 reviews
Fire Island, NY
06/28 – 07/02
$369/nighttotal: $1476 (4 )
Private 3br Apt: King-2queen -Petpally -Ltr-str
3 2
apartment , North Bay Shore
This North Bay Shore apartment is located near the sea, just 2 miles from Brentwood State Park and within 6 miles of Sky Zone and Tanger Outlets. It has excellent user, location, and cleanliness ratings. The apartment includes a fireplace, dining area, TV, refrigerator, microwave, and coffee/tea maker. You can enjoy the garden, barbecue grills, and limited housekeeping services during your stay.
9.5 2 reviews
Fire Island, NY
07/03 – 07/06
$2634/nighttotal: $7902 (3 )
The President Mansion Luxurious 7br Family Retreat
7 2
house , West Bay Shore
The President's Mansion is located in Bay Shore, just a short drive from West Bay Shore, with easy access to Nassau Veterans Memorial Coliseum and Jones Beach. This luxurious home is situated in a quiet, residential neighborhood, offering a peaceful retreat for families and groups. This spacious 7-bedroom villa comfortably accommodates up to 57 guests. The home features a fully equipped kitchen, a private spa, a terrace, and a garden, providing a relaxing and enjoyable stay.
10 91 reviews
Fire Island, NY
08/30 – 09/04
$862/nighttotal: $4310 (5 )
Luxury Waterfront Retreat Private Hot Tub & Dock Near Sayville
4 2
apartment , Bayport
This Bayport vacation rental is a short 7-minute walk from a sandy beach and a 5-minute drive from two Fire Island Ferry terminals, making it easy to explore the area's attractions. It has received excellent user ratings. This 3-bedroom, 2-bathroom home comfortably sleeps 8 guests and features a spacious 2100 square feet layout. Enjoy a range of amenities including a swimming pool, jacuzzi, sauna, spa, and a private garden with a natural rock waterfall and koi pond.
Fire Island, NY
06/27 – 07/04
$1347/nighttotal: $9429 (7 )
The Pelican's Nest
1 2
house , Fire Island
The Pelican's Nest is a beachfront house located in Ocean Bay Park, Fire Island, directly adjacent to Ocean Beach. This 1030 square foot residence accommodates up to 15 guests with 3 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms, a living room, TV, and includes a kitchen with a fridge, microwave, and dishwasher, plus a terrace, balcony with sea views, garden, outdoor dining area, picnic area, and an on-site restaurant.
Search Family Vacation Rentals in Fire Island, NY
Family beach vacations in Fire Island, NY are better in spacious rentals that offer plenty of room to spread out near the shore.
9.9 266 reviews
Fire Island, NY
07/31 – 08/03
$753/nighttotal: $2259 (3 )
By Nyc & Hamptons - Hot Tub, Pool Table, Speakeasy
1 1
apartment , Shirley
This Shirley, Long Island vacation home boasts three bedrooms and two bathrooms, comfortably sleeping eight guests, and is conveniently located near Smith Point Beach, a short drive from Brookhaven National Laboratory and the Hamptons. The house features a hidden speakeasy, a master suite with a Jacuzzi tub and private balcony, a fully equipped kitchen, and numerous amenities including a pool table, ping pong, foosball, hot tub, and outdoor grill, perfect for family gatherings or celebrations.
9.9 16 reviews
Fire Island, NY
06/28 – 07/02
$1184/nighttotal: $4736 (4 )
Stunning 4 Bedroom Bellport Village House W/pool
1 2
apartment , Bellport
This luxurious Bellport home, a short distance from Bellport's private beach and the village's restaurants and shops, offers a prime location for exploring the area. The four-bedroom, three-bathroom house boasts a mid-century modern design with a double-height cathedral ceiling, a private pool, and accommodates up to eight guests, complete with amenities such as a fitness center and a washer/dryer.
10 21 reviews
Fire Island, NY
08/01 – 08/03
$1142/nighttotal: $2284 (2 )
Ny Waterfront Home With Private Beach Access
1 3
apartment , East Patchogue
This waterfront rental is located in East Patchogue, just a short distance from the Fire Island Ferry, Patchogue train station, and the charming restaurants of Bellport and Patchogue Village. The property has received excellent ratings for location, cleanliness, and user experience. The apartment is spacious and can accommodate up to six guests. Enjoy amenities like a fully equipped kitchen, air conditioning, a private garden, and a bar, all while taking in breathtaking views of the Great South Bay and Fire Island from the expansive deck.
9.9 123 reviews
Fire Island, NY
08/30 – 09/04
$341/nighttotal: $1705 (5 )
Stay Downtown & Walk To Fire Island Ferries
1 2
apartment , Bay Shore
This ground-floor apartment rental in Bay Shore's historic Bay District is steps from restaurants, a spray park, the beach, the Bay Shore Ferry, and a 10-minute walk from the Long Island Rail Road. The one-bedroom, one-bathroom unit sleeps two, features a kitchen with a refrigerator, freezer, and microwave, private parking, and backyard access, plus it's located in a 150-year-old Mansard Victorian.
Frequently Asked Questions about vacation rentals in Fire Island, NY
Which neighborhood in Fire Island, NY should you consider for a vacation rental?
It really depends on what you're looking for. If you want to be in the heart of the action, Ocean Beach is the place to be. It's got the most restaurants, bars, and shops. If you're looking for something quieter, try a place like Cherry Grove or Fire Island Pines. They're both known for their laid-back atmosphere and beautiful beaches.
What are the best Airbnb and vacation rentals in Fire Island, NY?
When is the best time to book a vacation rental in Fire Island, NY?
You'll want to book early, especially if you're looking for a place during the peak season, which is from Memorial Day to Labor Day. If you're flexible with your dates, you can often find good deals on rentals during the shoulder seasons, which are the spring and fall.
What are the most popular Airbnbs in Fire Island, NY?
What are the best budget-friendly activities in Fire Island, NY?
The beaches are free, so you can spend the day swimming, sunbathing, and playing in the sand. You can also take a walk or bike ride along the beach. And don't forget about the free concerts and events that are held in the parks throughout the summer.
What are the best vacation rentals with a pool in Fire Island, NY?
What are the best restaurants with local dishes in Fire Island, NY?
The Clamman is a popular spot for fresh seafood. They have a great menu of local dishes, like the clam chowder and the lobster roll. The Fire Island Restaurant is another great option. They have a more upscale menu, but they also have some classic Fire Island dishes, like the fried clams and the fish and chips.
What are the best rentals for families and kids in Fire Island, NY?
What are the best walking or cycling routes in Fire Island, NY?
The Fire Island National Seashore is a great place to go for a walk or bike ride. It's a 32-mile long stretch of beach and dunes, and you can enjoy beautiful views of the ocean and the bay. You can also take a walk or bike ride along the paved path that runs through the center of the island.
What are the best rentals or Airbnbs with a jacuzzi in Fire Island, NY?
Are there pet-friendly attractions in Fire Island, NY?
Many of the beaches on Fire Island are dog-friendly, especially during the off-season. You can also take your dog for a walk along the Fire Island National Seashore. There are also a few pet-friendly restaurants and shops on the island.
What are the benefits of choosing a vacation rental in Fire Island, NY?
Vacation rentals offer a lot of flexibility and privacy. You can choose a rental that's the right size for your group and that has the amenities you need. You can also often find rentals in great locations, close to the beach or other attractions.
What are the top sports attractions and facilities in Fire Island, NY?
Fire Island is known for its beautiful beaches and its laid-back atmosphere. There's not a lot of organized sports activities, but there are plenty of opportunities for swimming, sunbathing, surfing, and kayaking. You can also find tennis courts and basketball courts in some of the neighborhoods.
Destinations nearby
Best Fire Island, NY vacation rentals with parking
8.8 3 reviews
Fire Island, NY
07/03 – 07/06
$820/nighttotal: $2460 (3 )
Private Apartment On River Ave. Close To Main St
2 2
apartment , Patchogue
This apartment is located in Patchogue Village, a short walk from the ferry to Fire Island and an hour from both New York City and the Hamptons, making it an ideal base for exploring Long Island's diverse attractions. The apartment is perfect for families or groups of up to five guests, offering a comfortable and convenient stay. The apartment includes two bedrooms, a bathroom, a fully equipped kitchen, and a jacuzzi, providing all the comforts of home. Enjoy free parking, free coffee, and amenities like towels, linens, soap, shampoo, and conditioner, making your stay even more relaxing.
Fire Island, NY
07/18 – 07/20
$248/nighttotal: $496 (2 )
Sundown Escape Near Southshore University Hospital
1 2
house , Islip
This Bay Shore house is conveniently located 8.7 miles from Long Island MacArthur Airport and is a short drive from SouthShore University Hospital. This 500 square foot accommodation offers a kitchenette, air conditioning, a private garden, and can host up to three guests, with free WiFi and full-day security provided.
10 10 reviews
Fire Island, NY
07/31 – 08/03
$2986/nighttotal: $8958 (3 )
Dream Beach Home W/ Heated Saltwater Pool: 4bd/2bt
1 1
apartment , Brookhaven
This Brookhaven Hamlet Airbnb rental is minutes from Brookhaven Beach and a short walk to local shops and restaurants in the town center. The newly renovated three-bedroom, one-bathroom house sleeps seven guests and boasts a heated pool, a large backyard deck, a modern kitchen, and a home office overlooking the garden.
9.6 28 reviews
Fire Island, NY
08/30 – 09/04
$474/nighttotal: $2370 (5 )
Fully Modern 3 Bedroom 65"smart Tvs Cable Bluetooth Speakers Etc
3 2
apartment , Islip
This Islip vacation home is conveniently located near the Cohalan Court Complex, Alfonse M. D'Amato United States Courthouse, and Bethpage Ballpark, all within roughly two miles. This 1630-square-foot property features four bedrooms, one bathroom, sleeps six guests, and includes a private garden, swimming pool, and free Wi-Fi; enjoy nearby recreational activities at the on-site water park.
Check Out Vacation Rentals with a Pool in Fire Island, NY
A vacation rental with a pool in Fire Island, NY is the perfect amenity to complement your time spent by the water.
9.9 49 reviews
Fire Island, NY
06/27 – 07/04
$2183/nighttotal: $15281 (7 )
Beautiful Beach House With Large Swimming Pool In Ocean Beach
4 2
apartment , Ocean Beach
This Ocean Beach vacation home is a short walk from the beaches of Great South Bay and Atlantique Beach, offering easy access to the area's natural beauty. The property has consistently received excellent ratings for location, cleanliness, and overall guest experience. This 4-bedroom rental sleeps up to 10 guests and features a spacious 2500 square foot layout. Enjoy amenities like a private pool, spa tub, barbecue grills, and a fully equipped kitchen, perfect for relaxing and entertaining during your stay.
Fire Island, NY
06/25 – 06/28
$5322/nighttotal: $15966 (3 )
Brand New Fire Island Home With Bay & Ocean Views
5 8
apartment , Fire Island
This newly constructed apartment in Ocean Bay Park offers direct access to the Fire Island beach. This 4-bedroom, 3-bathroom residence accommodates up to 10 guests and features a private heated freshwater pool, hot tub, a well-equipped gym with a sauna, and four adult and four children's bicycles for island exploration.
10 2 reviews
Fire Island, NY
06/27 – 07/04
$5062/nighttotal: $35434 (7 )
Destination Ocean
1 2
apartment , West Hampton Dunes
This oceanfront home on Dune Road in Westhampton Beach is a short walk from Cupsogue County Park and Tiki Joes, offering a prime location for exploring the area. The house is just a few steps from the beach and offers stunning views of the Atlantic Ocean and the bay. This six-bedroom, five-bathroom vacation rental comfortably accommodates 14 guests. The home features a spacious living room, a second living area on the third floor, a fully equipped kitchen with high-end appliances, a heated pool on the oceanfront deck, and a gas grill on the deck.
Fire Island, NY
06/25 – 06/28
$5374/nighttotal: $16122 (3 )
Modern Fire Island House Steps From The Beach
5 8
apartment , Fire Island
This newly constructed 5-bedroom, 6-bathroom rental home is located one house back from the beach in Fire Island, near the Point O' Woods border, offering direct beach access and proximity to Ocean Bay Park Beach. This ocean-view residence features nearly 3,600 square feet of interior space, a private heated saltwater pool, a roof deck with a wet bar, a dedicated gym, and accommodates up to 10 guests, with all bedrooms offering en-suite bathrooms and outdoor access.
Browse Waterfront Vacation Rentals in Fire Island, NY
Enjoy a relaxing beach getaway with these coastal and seaside vacation rentals in Fire Island, NY. Book your next shoreside stay today.
Fire Island, NY
06/28 – 07/02
$789/nighttotal: $3156 (4 )
The Surfcomber Unit 1
1 2
apartment , Fire Island
10 69 reviews
Fire Island, NY
07/03 – 07/06
$384/nighttotal: $1152 (3 )
Turtle Dove Cozy Gem On The Bay
1 2
apartment , Bay Shore
10 3 reviews
Fire Island, NY
06/25 – 06/28
$1082/nighttotal: $3246 (3 )
Family Beach House
3 2
apartment , Fire Island
9.8 72 reviews
Fire Island, NY
06/27 – 07/04
$2486/nighttotal: $17402 (7 )
Westhampton Beach Oceanfront, 4 Bedrooms, Pool. Super Clean. Relax And Chill.
4 2
apartment , West Hampton Dunes
Compare Luxury Vacation Rentals in Fire Island, NY
Experience 5-star comfort in a luxury Fire Island, NY vacation rental designed with premium amenities throughout.
Fire Island, NY
06/28 – 07/02
$222/nighttotal: $888 (4 )
Sundown Escape Near Southshore University Hospital
1 2
apartment , Islip
Discover Vacation Rentals with Saunas in Fire Island, NY
Maximize your recovery with an on-site sauna, a standard feature at these premier Fire Island, NY vacation rentals.
10 12 reviews
Fire Island, NY
06/25 – 06/28
$1178/nighttotal: $3534 (3 )
Renovated House With An Entertainment Backyard
1 6
apartment , North Great River
Fire Island, NY
08/14 – 08/20
$4266/nighttotal: $25596 (6 )
Fabulous Fip Whole House Bayfront Retreat
1 10
house , Fire Island
9.6 5 reviews
Fire Island, NY
08/01 – 08/03
$482/nighttotal: $964 (2 )
Exceptional & Central, Garden Suite, Top Amenities & Care!
