Search vacation rentals in Fire Island, NY from 100+ sites!

1176 available vacation rental offers

7 nights
2
1
  • airbnb
  • booking
  • vrbo
  • expedia
  • sonder
  • priceline
  • tripadvisor
  • tripcom
  • homestay
  • hotelscom
  • orbitz
  • vacasa
Fire Island, NY vacation rentals
Choose the perfect vacation accommodation
Price per night
Accommodation type
Rating

Best Vacation rentals and Airbnb offers in Fire Island, NY

Best Fire Island, NY vacation rentals with a balcony

Waterfront House Next To Bellport Golf Course - Fire Island, NY
10 17 reviews

Waterfront House Next To Bellport Golf Course

apartment, East Patchogue
This beachfront vacation rental in East Patchogue offers direct access to outdoor activities and is a 5-minute walk to Great South Bay and a 4-minute drive to Bellport Country Club.
This 3200 sq ft, 4-bedroom, 3-bathroom home accommodates up to 8 guests and features a full kitchen, air conditioning, a swimming pool, hot tub, and a terrace.
Air Conditioned 4 Bed/2 Bath Beach House - Fire Island, NY
10 25 reviews

Air Conditioned 4 Bed/2 Bath Beach House

apartment, Fire Island
This charming beach house is located on Davis Park in the Fire Island Community, a short 20-minute ferry ride from Patchogue and just steps away from the beach, the ferry, and the Casino restaurant. This Fire Island rental is rated excellent by previous guests.
This 4-bedroom, 3-bathroom home comfortably sleeps 8 guests in its 1190 square feet of space. Enjoy modern amenities, including air conditioning, a spacious kitchen, and a private outdoor shower, perfect for relaxing after a day at the beach.
Waterfront Home W/ Large Deck & Dock On Narrow Bay - Fire Island, NY
9.7 72 reviews

Waterfront Home W/ Large Deck & Dock On Narrow Bay

house, Mastic Beach
This waterfront home is located in Mastic Beach, just 20 miles from Splish Splash water park and 24 miles from the Long Island Railroad. This vacation rental has received excellent ratings for its location, cleanliness, and overall user experience.
The 1800 square foot house has 3 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms, and can comfortably accommodate up to 6 guests. Enjoy stunning water views from the large deck and private dock, relax with free WiFi and cable TV, and prepare meals in the fully equipped kitchen.
Fire Island White House - Ocean Bay Park  5 Bedroom Bayview Home - Sleeps 18! - Fire Island, NY
10 3 reviews

Fire Island White House - Ocean Bay Park 5 Bedroom Bayview Home - Sleeps 18!

apartment, Fire Island
This Bay Shore vacation home, two blocks from both the ocean and the ferry, offers easy access to Fire Island's attractions and the Cherry Grove Community House and Theatre.
This 3,500-square-foot house features five bedrooms, five bathrooms, sleeps up to 18 guests, and includes a heated pool, Jacuzzi, rooftop deck, and amenities like beach chairs and bikes.

Search Family Vacation Rentals in Fire Island, NY

Family beach vacations in Fire Island, NY are better in spacious rentals that offer plenty of room to spread out near the shore.

Newly Renovated Bellport Village Getaway With Pool - Fire Island, NY
10 5 reviews

Newly Renovated Bellport Village Getaway With Pool

apartment, Bellport
This Bellport apartment is ideally situated near both the charming village center and the local bay beach, offering easy access to the area's best attractions. It has consistently received excellent ratings for its cleanliness, location, and overall experience.
The apartment features four bedrooms and two bathrooms, comfortably accommodating up to seven guests. Enjoy the convenience of a fully equipped kitchen, in-house laundry, a private saltwater pool, and a spacious deck with a grill for outdoor dining.
Fall Into Coastal Luxury At Breakers  Ocean Beach, Fire Island - Fire Island, NY
10 1 review

Fall Into Coastal Luxury At Breakers Ocean Beach, Fire Island

apartment, Ocean Beach
This Ocean Beach vacation home, a four-bedroom, three-bathroom house, is ideally located near Great South Bay (a 4-minute walk) and Ocean Beach (a 6-minute walk), providing easy access to Cherry Grove Community House and Theatre and the Bay Shore Historical Society.
This family-friendly rental boasts a fully equipped kitchen, in-house laundry, air conditioning, Wi-Fi, a private patio with a fire pit, and comfortably accommodates up to ten guests.
Fi Pines Updated 3 Br/2 Ba With Heated Pool, Spa - Fire Island, NY
9.8 26 reviews

Fi Pines Updated 3 Br/2 Ba With Heated Pool, Spa

apartment, Fire Island
This Fire Island rental is a three-bedroom, two-bathroom house conveniently located a six-minute walk from the Fire Island ferry terminal.
The 6-guest home boasts a private pool, multiple decks, a Weber gas grill, a full kitchen with dishwasher, and a washer/dryer, offering flexible sleeping arrangements with twin XL beds convertible to king-size beds in two bedrooms.
The Coastal Cottage-entire Home 3 Beds/1 Bath - Fire Island, NY
9.7 70 reviews

The Coastal Cottage-entire Home 3 Beds/1 Bath

apartment, Bay Shore
This Bay Shore home is located in the historic Bay District, steps from Maria's Bay beach and a short walk from Main Street's shops and restaurants, with easy access to Fire Island ferries.
The three-bedroom, one-bathroom house sleeps four, features a fully equipped kitchen, large deck with BBQ grill and outdoor shower (May-October), and provides baby items upon request; nearby attractions include Robert Moses State Park, a 15-minute drive away.

Frequently Asked Questions about vacation rentals in Fire Island, NY

  • Which neighborhood in Fire Island, NY should you consider for a vacation rental?

    It really depends on what you're looking for. If you want to be in the heart of the action, Ocean Beach is the place to be. It's got the most restaurants, bars, and shops. If you're looking for something quieter, try a place like Cherry Grove or Fire Island Pines. They're both known for their laid-back atmosphere and beautiful beaches.
  • What are the best Airbnb and vacation rentals in Fire Island, NY?

    In-law Apt A Block Away From Patchogue Bay, Private Queen Bedrm Pet Pally - Work - Events - Ltr - Mtr - Str and Just A Cozy Stay are the most popular Airbnb and vacation rentals in Fire Island, NY among travelers.

  • When is the best time to book a vacation rental in Fire Island, NY?

    You'll want to book early, especially if you're looking for a place during the peak season, which is from Memorial Day to Labor Day. If you're flexible with your dates, you can often find good deals on rentals during the shoulder seasons, which are the spring and fall.
  • What are the most popular Airbnbs in Fire Island, NY?

  • What are the best budget-friendly activities in Fire Island, NY?

    The beaches are free, so you can spend the day swimming, sunbathing, and playing in the sand. You can also take a walk or bike ride along the beach. And don't forget about the free concerts and events that are held in the parks throughout the summer.
  • What are the best vacation rentals with a pool in Fire Island, NY?

  • What are the best restaurants with local dishes in Fire Island, NY?

    The Clamman is a popular spot for fresh seafood. They have a great menu of local dishes, like the clam chowder and the lobster roll. The Fire Island Restaurant is another great option. They have a more upscale menu, but they also have some classic Fire Island dishes, like the fried clams and the fish and chips.
  • What are the best rentals for families and kids in Fire Island, NY?

  • What are the best walking or cycling routes in Fire Island, NY?

    The Fire Island National Seashore is a great place to go for a walk or bike ride. It's a 32-mile long stretch of beach and dunes, and you can enjoy beautiful views of the ocean and the bay. You can also take a walk or bike ride along the paved path that runs through the center of the island.
  • What are the best rentals or Airbnbs with a jacuzzi in Fire Island, NY?

  • Are there pet-friendly attractions in Fire Island, NY?

    Many of the beaches on Fire Island are dog-friendly, especially during the off-season. You can also take your dog for a walk along the Fire Island National Seashore. There are also a few pet-friendly restaurants and shops on the island.
  • What are the benefits of choosing a vacation rental in Fire Island, NY?

    Vacation rentals offer a lot of flexibility and privacy. You can choose a rental that's the right size for your group and that has the amenities you need. You can also often find rentals in great locations, close to the beach or other attractions.
  • What are the top sports attractions and facilities in Fire Island, NY?

    Fire Island is known for its beautiful beaches and its laid-back atmosphere. There's not a lot of organized sports activities, but there are plenty of opportunities for swimming, sunbathing, surfing, and kayaking. You can also find tennis courts and basketball courts in some of the neighborhoods.

Popular destinations

Best Fire Island, NY vacation rentals with parking

Bay Shore Vacation Rental ~ 7 Mi To The Beach - Fire Island, NY
10 1 review

Bay Shore Vacation Rental ~ 7 Mi To The Beach

cottage, North Bay Shore
This North Bay Shore cottage is close to local attractions like Brentwood State Park and Tanger Outlets, and it has received an excellent user rating. With a fully equipped kitchen and air conditioning, this smoke-free cottage provides a comfortable stay for guests.
It has a convenient location for boating and water activities, and it offers free self-parking and free WiFi in public areas. The cottage has a TV, a shower, and an iron/ironing board, and it's within a 3-mile radius of Sky Zone and Hauppauge Industrial Park.
Sun, Sand & Serenity: Your 4bedroom Fire Island Pines Escape - Fire Island, NY
No reviews

Sun, Sand & Serenity: Your 4bedroom Fire Island Pines Escape

apartment, Fire Island
This 4-bedroom, 2-bathroom Fire Island rental home is a 5-minute walk from Great South Bay and offers convenient access to Ocean Beach, Heckscher State Park, Bowlero Sayville, and Bellport Country Club.
This pet-friendly vacation home accommodates up to 8 guests, featuring air conditioning, Wi-Fi, a smart TV, a private terrace, and laundry facilities, with popular evening spots like Flynn's Fire Island and People's Pub within walking distance.
La Quinta Inn & Suites By Wyndham Islip - Macarthur Airport - Fire Island, NY
No reviews

La Quinta Inn & Suites By Wyndham Islip - Macarthur Airport

farm, Bohemia
This farm stay in Bohemia requires a government ID for check-in, offering a secure and regulated rural experience without specific district or landmark distances provided. Travelers can anticipate an authentic Bohemian farm experience, potentially engaging with local procedures in this implied getaway setting.
California Modern With A Fire Island Soul - Fire Island, NY
No reviews

California Modern With A Fire Island Soul

apartment, Bellport
This recently renovated three-bedroom, three-bathroom apartment in Bellport offers bay views from a quiet dead-end street, just a short walk to village shops and restaurants.
This spacious apartment accommodates six guests and features a heated saltwater pool, a secluded backyard with a lawn, a large kitchen, and a covered porch, with air conditioning and parking included.

Check Out Vacation Rentals with a Pool in Fire Island, NY

A vacation rental with a pool in Fire Island, NY is the perfect amenity to complement your time spent by the water.

Colorful + Modern Home In Cherry Grove W/ Pool - Fire Island, NY
10 11 reviews

Colorful + Modern Home In Cherry Grove W/ Pool

apartment, Fire Island
This 2-bedroom, 1-bathroom rental is located in Cherry Grove, a historic queer community on Fire Island, steps from the ocean beach and a short walk to the ferry.
This residence accommodates up to 4 guests and features a brand new swimming pool, a roof deck, an outdoor kitchen, and an outdoor shower.
Modern All-suite Home  Rooftop  Bay Views  Pool - Fire Island, NY
10 9 reviews

Modern All-suite Home Rooftop Bay Views Pool

apartment, Fire Island
This brand-new Fire Island Pines beach house, four houses from the ocean, offers prime access to the beach and the area's attractions.
The three-bedroom, three-bathroom home features an open-concept design, a private pool, three levels of decking including a rooftop deck, and accommodates up to eight guests with amenities including a chef's kitchen, fast Wi-Fi, and a bonus den.
Ocean View Home With Heated Pool - Fire Island, NY
9.7 18 reviews

Ocean View Home With Heated Pool

apartment, Fire Island
This Fire Island Pines house, a seven-minute walk from the harbor and near the beach, offers expansive ocean views.
The three-bedroom, two-bathroom home sleeps six and features a private pool, updated kitchen with dishwasher, and multiple outdoor spaces including a pool cabana with twin beds and an outdoor shower.
Fruit Of The Dune, Cherry Grove - Fire Island, NY
10 4 reviews

Fruit Of The Dune, Cherry Grove

apartment, Fire Island
This oceanfront residence in Cherry Grove, Fire Island, NY, offers direct Atlantic Ocean access and Great South Bay views.
This four-bedroom, three-bathroom house accommodates up to eight guests and features a newly renovated interior, a heated swimming pool, a cabana, and multiple decks.

Browse Waterfront Vacation Rentals in Fire Island, NY

Enjoy a relaxing beach getaway with these coastal and seaside vacation rentals in Fire Island, NY. Book your next shoreside stay today.

Charming Quintessential Beach House - Fire Island, NY
10 9 reviews

Charming Quintessential Beach House

apartment, Fire Island
Fi Pines - 3 Bedroom / 2 Bath Beach House - Fire Island, NY
10 7 reviews

Fi Pines - 3 Bedroom / 2 Bath Beach House

apartment, Fire Island
Ocean Beach, Fire Island,ny 4 Bed,2 Bath, Sleeps 9, Full Kitchen, Deck, Bicycles - Fire Island, NY
8.0 1 review

Ocean Beach, Fire Island,ny 4 Bed,2 Bath, Sleeps 9, Full Kitchen, Deck, Bicycles

apartment, Fire Island
Summer In Beautiful, Private Fire Island Cottage! - Fire Island, NY
9.6 22 reviews

Summer In Beautiful, Private Fire Island Cottage!

apartment, Fire Island

Compare Luxury Vacation Rentals in Fire Island, NY

Experience 5-star comfort in a luxury Fire Island, NY vacation rental designed with premium amenities throughout.

Huron Hideaway - Fire Island, NY
9.5 4 reviews

Huron Hideaway

house, Fire Island

Discover Vacation Rentals with Saunas in Fire Island, NY

Maximize your recovery with an on-site sauna, a standard feature at these premier Fire Island, NY vacation rentals.

The President Mansion Luxurious Family Retreat - 1.5 Miles To Beach - Fire Island, NY
10 15 reviews

The President Mansion Luxurious Family Retreat - 1.5 Miles To Beach

apartment, West Bay Shore
Luxury Waterfront Retreat  Private Hot Tub & Dock Near Sayville - Fire Island, NY
10 97 reviews

Luxury Waterfront Retreat Private Hot Tub & Dock Near Sayville

apartment, Bayport
Exceptional & Central, Garden Suite, Top Amenities & Care! - Fire Island, NY
9.6 6 reviews

Exceptional & Central, Garden Suite, Top Amenities & Care!

apartment, Central Islip
The Legendary Pyramid House - Fire Island, NY
9.7 92 reviews

The Legendary Pyramid House

apartment, Fire Island
©2026 cozycozy.com