Compare vacation rentals in Fire Island, NY from 100+ sites!
741 available vacation rental offers
Choose the perfect vacation accommodation
Price per night
Accommodation type
Rating
Best Vacation rentals and Airbnb offers in Fire Island, NY
9.8 102 reviews
Fire Island, NY
06/21 – 06/22
$2790/nightfor 1 night
Ocean Bay Park - Now Booking 2026 Season! September 19 To 26 Date Available
1 1
apartment , Fire Island
This five-bedroom Fire Island beach house, steps from the ocean and close to restaurants, tennis courts, and the ferry, offers direct beach access. This 2,000-square-foot home features a spacious layout with a large open living/dining/kitchen area, wraparound deck, and sleeps up to 15 guests, boasting amenities like a full kitchen, washer/dryer, and beach chairs.
8.0 10 reviews
Fire Island, NY
06/21 – 06/22
$734/nightfor 1 night
Tranquil Stay
3 1
apartment , Mastic Beach
This single-family home is located in Shirley, a short drive from Mastic Beach with easy access to nearby attractions like Country Fair Entertainment Park, Swan Lake Golf Club, and William Floyd Estate. The home has received excellent reviews from previous guests. The 1600 square foot house comfortably sleeps six guests with three bedrooms and two bathrooms. The home offers a fully equipped kitchen, spacious living room, a private patio with a grill, and amenities like a Jacuzzi, air conditioning, and high-speed Wi-Fi.
9.4 106 reviews
Fire Island, NY
07/27 – 08/02
$156/nighttotal: $936 (6 )
Close-to-all 2nd Floor Sunny Sayville Studio
1 2
apartment , Sayville
This unique studio is located in Sayville, a charming town on Long Island. It's just a short distance from Ronkonkoma station, MacArthur Airport, Sayville Fire Island ferries, Sayville downtown, and Sunrise Highway, making it easy to explore the area. The studio has received excellent ratings for its location, cleanliness, and user experience. The studio is a cozy and private space with a queen bed and additional sturdy cot upon request. It features a modest shower, WiFi, and all items pictured. Guests will appreciate the contactless check-in with key lockbox and the convenient deli located directly below the studio.
Fire Island, NY
06/25 – 06/28
$2246/nighttotal: $6738 (3 )
4br Fire Island Coastal Cottage/ Sleeps Up To 10
1 8
apartment , Ocean Beach
This 4-bedroom, 2-bathroom house is located in Ocean Beach, Fire Island, a car-free community providing direct access to beaches and a dining scene. This rental accommodates up to 10 guests, features air conditioning and internet, and is ideal for enjoying beach activities, local shops, and cycling paths.
9.2 5 reviews
Fire Island, NY
07/31 – 08/03
$345/nighttotal: $1035 (3 )
Bay Shore Vacation Rental ~ 7 Mi To The Beach
1 1
apartment , North Bay Shore
This North Bay Shore apartment is located within walking distance of Islip Beach and a short drive from the Tanger Outlets Deer Park, offering easy access to both the beautiful Long Island shoreline and popular shopping destinations. Guests have consistently rated this rental as very good, highlighting its convenient location and comfortable amenities. The apartment features one bedroom and one bathroom, spanning 900 square feet and comfortably accommodating up to four guests. Enjoy a relaxing stay with amenities including a kitchen, washer and dryer, a shared yard with a fire pit, and modern features like a smart TV and keyless entry.
10 17 reviews
Fire Island, NY
07/31 – 08/03
$257/nighttotal: $771 (3 )
Sleepy Hollow
1 1
resort , Blue Point
This one-bedroom Blue Point apartment is located in a tranquil neighborhood, just a short distance from the village center and its waterfront. The apartment features a comfortable living space, a fully equipped kitchen, and a private bathroom, accommodating up to three guests.
10 3 reviews
Fire Island, NY
07/16 – 07/19
$319/nighttotal: $957 (3 )
Riad-famille-espace Sanitaire-vue Sur Le Bois-doub
1 2
riad , Fire Island
This Fire Island glamping site, located in the Fire Island National Seashore just beyond the primary dune, offers easy access to a lifeguarded ocean beach and the Otis High Dune Wilderness. The safari tents, sleeping up to six guests with additional cots, include picnic tables, charcoal grills, and an ice chest; on-site amenities also feature an outdoor restaurant and general store.
Fire Island, NY
07/31 – 08/03
$1050/nighttotal: $3150 (3 )
The Surfcomber Unit 2
1 1
apartment , Fire Island
This one-bedroom rental is located in Ocean Bay Park, Fire Island, just 240 feet from the beach and the Atlantic Ocean, offering convenient access to watersports at Fire Island SUP Co. and a short walk to Seaview and dining options like Schooner's Inn. This pet-friendly apartment accommodates up to four guests and features a rooftop deck with outdoor dining, a well-equipped kitchen with a fridge and microwave, and air conditioning, making it ideal for a Fire Island getaway.
10 7 reviews
Fire Island, NY
06/22 – 06/29
$815/nighttotal: $5705 (7 )
Bellport Oasis
1 3
apartment , Bellport
This Bellport Village rental is steps from the Bellport Country Club and minutes from local restaurants, the marina, and beaches. The three-bedroom, two-bathroom apartment sleeps six and features a private in-ground pool, spacious deck, dishwasher, and electronic keypad entry.
9.5 74 reviews
Fire Island, NY
06/22 – 06/25
$933/nighttotal: $2799 (3 )
Entire Waterfront Home With Panoramic Views Of The Bay And Private Beach
4 4
apartment , Mastic Beach
This beachfront home in Mastic Beach is a short drive from the Hamptons and close to Osprey Park, offering access to a private beach and a nearby dock. The accommodation has excellent user, location, and cleanliness ratings, making it a great choice for travelers. The house has three bedrooms and three bathrooms, comfortably accommodating up to ten guests. The home offers a state-of-the-art kitchen, multiple decks with water views, and a private beach, perfect for enjoying the natural beauty of Long Island.
10 13 reviews
Fire Island, NY
07/31 – 08/03
$161/nighttotal: $483 (3 )
Charming Studio Close To Everything!
1 1
apartment , Bay Shore
This studio apartment in Bay Shore offers a prime location, placing you within 1,000 feet of the beach and a short distance from Fire Island ferries, local hospitals, and a variety of dining and shopping options. This smoke-free studio accommodates two guests and features a private entrance, free parking, and a kitchenette equipped with a microwave, small fridge, and coffeemaker, providing essential amenities for a comfortable stay near coastal activities.
10 4 reviews
Fire Island, NY
06/22 – 06/25
$1033/nighttotal: $3099 (3 )
Secluded Escaped In Ocean Bay Park
1 4
apartment , Fire Island
This three-bedroom, two-bathroom Fire Island beach house rental is ideally situated just five houses from the ocean, offering unparalleled beachfront proximity. The recently renovated unit sleeps eight guests comfortably, features an expansive deck with an outdoor shower, and includes four bikes, beach chairs, and an umbrella for guest use.
Best Fire Island, NY vacation rentals with a balcony
9.7 377 reviews
Fire Island, NY
07/27 – 08/02
$370/nighttotal: $2220 (6 )
Private 3br Apt: King-2queen -Petpally -Ltr-str
3 2
apartment , North Bay Shore
This North Bay Shore apartment is located near the sea, just 2 miles from Brentwood State Park and within 6 miles of Sky Zone and Tanger Outlets. It has excellent user, location, and cleanliness ratings. The apartment includes a fireplace, dining area, TV, refrigerator, microwave, and coffee/tea maker. You can enjoy the garden, barbecue grills, and limited housekeeping services during your stay.
10 91 reviews
Fire Island, NY
06/22 – 06/25
$1015/nighttotal: $3045 (3 )
Luxury Waterfront Retreat Private Hot Tub & Dock Near Sayville
4 4
apartment , Bayport
This Bayport vacation rental is a short 7-minute walk from a sandy beach and a 5-minute drive from two Fire Island Ferry terminals, making it easy to explore the area's attractions. It has received excellent user ratings. This 3-bedroom, 2-bathroom home comfortably sleeps 8 guests and features a spacious 2100 square feet layout. Enjoy a range of amenities including a swimming pool, jacuzzi, sauna, spa, and a private garden with a natural rock waterfall and koi pond.
9.8 20 reviews
Fire Island, NY
07/27 – 08/02
$1874/nighttotal: $11244 (6 )
Beautiful Fire Island Pines Beach Housepool, Hot Tub, Rooftop, Garden & More!
3 2
apartment , Fire Island
This apartment is located in Sayville, just a short distance from the harbor, ocean, and bay, offering easy access to water activities. The apartment has received excellent ratings for its location, cleanliness, and overall user experience. The accommodation features three bedrooms and two bathrooms, comfortably accommodating up to six guests. The apartment includes a swimming pool, hot tub, fire pit, multiple decks, a garden, a spa, and a fitness center, making it ideal for relaxation and entertainment.
Fire Island, NY
07/03 – 07/06
$3082/nighttotal: $9246 (3 )
Game Room, Hot Tub! Family Getaway In Bayshore
7 2
house , West Bay Shore
Coastal Bayshore Presidents Mansion, a bayside estate in West Bay Shore, is located 1.8 miles from Benjamin's Memorial Beach and a short drive to Nassau Veterans Memorial Coliseum (18 miles) and Jones Beach (19 miles). This 8,000-square-foot vacation home accommodates up to 55 guests with 7 bedrooms, 4 bathrooms, a fully equipped kitchen, a fitness center, and a jacuzzi.
Browse Family-Friendly Vacation Rentals in Fire Island, NY
Perfect for family trips, these spacious Fire Island, NY rentals and Airbnbs provide easy access to local beaches.
Fire Island, NY
07/02 – 07/06
$3243/nighttotal: $12972 (4 )
Game Room, Hot Tub! Family Getaway In Bayshore
7 2
apartment , West Bay Shore
This 8,000 sq ft 'President's Mansion' vacation rental in West Bay Shore is located by the sea, offering proximity to Sagtikos Manor (0.7 miles), Gardiner County Park (0.8 miles), and the Bay Shore LIRR Station with NYC service (2 miles). This expansive home accommodates up to 28 guests with 7 bedrooms and 4 bathrooms, featuring a game room, home gym, hot tub, gas grill, and ample parking for 28 vehicles.
10 9 reviews
Fire Island, NY
07/16 – 07/19
$1068/nighttotal: $3204 (3 )
Bellport Inn, Charming Cottage In The Village!
1 2
cottage , Bellport
This Bellport cottage is located just a short walk from Great South Bay, providing easy access to the beach and a peaceful escape from the town center. The cottage has received excellent ratings for its cleanliness, location, and overall experience. The charming cottage has one bedroom and one bathroom, comfortably accommodating up to six guests. Enjoy a relaxing stay with amenities like a jacuzzi, a garden with barbecue grills, and a kitchen equipped with everything you need to prepare meals.
9.7 221 reviews
Fire Island, NY
06/22 – 06/25
$472/nighttotal: $1416 (3 )
Beautiful 3 Br Full House W/ King Bed & Pool Table On Dead End 5 Min From Town!
3 4
apartment , North Patchogue
This North Patchogue house is located just 1.2 miles from the Town of Brookhaven Wildlife and Ecology Center, offering easy access to various attractions and a peaceful neighborhood atmosphere. It has earned excellent ratings for location, cleanliness, and user experience, ensuring a comfortable and enjoyable stay. This 3-bedroom home can comfortably accommodate up to 7 guests, providing ample space for families or groups. Amenities include a fully equipped kitchen, a terrace or balcony, a garden, and free Wi-Fi, making it perfect for both relaxation and entertainment.
10 21 reviews
Fire Island, NY
07/31 – 08/03
$1084/nighttotal: $3252 (3 )
Ny Waterfront Home With Private Beach Access
1 1
apartment , East Patchogue
This waterfront rental is located in East Patchogue, just a short distance from the Fire Island Ferry, Patchogue train station, and the charming restaurants of Bellport and Patchogue Village. The property has received excellent ratings for location, cleanliness, and user experience. The apartment is spacious and can accommodate up to six guests. Enjoy amenities like a fully equipped kitchen, air conditioning, a private garden, and a bar, all while taking in breathtaking views of the Great South Bay and Fire Island from the expansive deck.
Frequently Asked Questions about vacation rentals in Fire Island, NY
What should a first-time visitor not miss in Fire Island, NY?
For a first-time visit, you absolutely have to check out the Fire Island Lighthouse, it's a classic! You can climb to the top for amazing views of the island and the Atlantic Ocean. You should also take a walk on the beach at Ocean Beach, it's one of the most popular spots on the island.
What are the best Airbnb and vacation rentals in Fire Island, NY?
Which neighborhood in Fire Island, NY should you consider for a vacation rental?
It really depends on what you're looking for! Ocean Beach is great for a lively atmosphere, while Fire Island Pines is known for its LGBTQ+ community. If you prefer a quieter vibe, you could try Cherry Grove or Kismet.
What are the most popular Airbnbs in Fire Island, NY?
What are the top family-friendly attractions in Fire Island, NY?
The Fire Island Lighthouse is a great family-friendly attraction. Kids love the climb to the top! The Fire Island National Seashore is also a great place for families to enjoy nature. You can go for walks, bike rides, or even have a picnic.
What are the best vacation rentals with a pool in Fire Island, NY?
When is the best time to book a vacation rental in Fire Island, NY?
To avoid the crowds and get the best deals, book your vacation rental in the shoulder seasons, April-May or September-October. If you want to be in the heart of the action, book your rental in the summer months, June-August.
What are the best rentals for families and kids in Fire Island, NY?
What are the best budget-friendly activities in Fire Island, NY?
Fire Island is all about the beach, so you can easily spend the day soaking up the sun for free. You can also take a walk or bike ride along the Fire Island National Seashore, which is free to enter. And if you're looking for a cheap bite to eat, there are plenty of affordable food trucks and stands around the island.
What are the best rentals or Airbnbs with a jacuzzi in Fire Island, NY?
What are the best restaurants with local dishes in Fire Island, NY?
The Sunken Forest Restaurant in Ocean Beach has great seafood dishes. The Fire Island Pines Inn has a more upscale dining experience. For a casual, fun atmosphere, check out The Clamman in Cherry Grove.
What are the best walking or cycling routes in Fire Island, NY?
The Fire Island National Seashore is a great place to walk or bike. You can take the Ocean Beach to Fire Island Pines trail, which is about 7 miles long. If you want a shorter walk, there are plenty of trails within Ocean Beach itself.
Are there pet-friendly attractions in Fire Island, NY?
Most of the beaches on Fire Island are not pet-friendly during the summer months. However, Robert Moses State Park, which is located on the mainland, has a dog beach. You can also take your dog for a walk along the Fire Island National Seashore.
What are the benefits of choosing a vacation rental in Fire Island, NY?
Vacation rentals offer more space and privacy than a hotel. They often have kitchens, so you can save money by preparing some of your own meals. And many rentals are located in quieter areas of the island, which can be a nice change of pace from the hustle and bustle of the main towns.
What are the top sports attractions and facilities in Fire Island, NY?
Fire Island is known for its beaches, so swimming, sunbathing, and surfing are popular activities. There are also a few tennis courts on the island. If you're looking for more organized sports, you'll need to head to the mainland.
Destinations nearby
Best Fire Island, NY vacation rentals with parking
10 12 reviews
Fire Island, NY
07/03 – 07/06
$2773/nighttotal: $8319 (3 )
The President Mansion\nluxurious Family Retreat - 1.5 Miles To Beach
7 2
apartment , West Bay Shore
This West Bay Shore vacation home is located less than a mile from the Sagtikos Manor and Great South Bay, and within two miles of the YMCA Boulton Center for the Performing Arts and Good Samaritan Hospital. This seven-bedroom, four-bathroom house sleeps 22 guests and boasts a Jacuzzi, sauna, terrace, and fully equipped kitchen including a refrigerator, microwave, and dishwasher, plus free Wi-Fi and parking.
Fire Island, NY
06/22 – 06/25
$2054/nighttotal: $6162 (3 )
Gatsbys Sky Level. Ocean Bay Park. \Nsleeps 12. Hot Tub + Ocean Views
4 4
apartment , Fire Island
This Fire Island rental, situated in Ocean Bay Park, is a 2-3 minute walk from the ferry and beach, and a 10-minute bike ride or 20-minute walk from Ocean Beach village. This 4-bedroom, 3-bathroom apartment accommodates up to 12 guests and features a prime sky-level unit with a third-level deck, a private hot tub with ocean views, multiple outdoor living spaces, and an outdoor shower, with 12 beach chairs, 12 beach towels, and a cooler with wheels provided.
Fire Island, NY
06/22 – 06/25
$591/nighttotal: $1773 (3 )
1 Block To Bellport Bay! Scenic Hamptons Hideaway
3 4
apartment , Shirley
This Mastic Beach apartment is located one block from Bellport Bay and 17 miles from Long Island MacArthur Airport, with Splish Splash 19 miles away and the Long Island Railroad 26 miles away. This 1500 square foot residence accommodates up to 11 guests with three bedrooms, two bathrooms, a fully equipped kitchen including a dishwasher and oven, complimentary WiFi, air conditioning, and an outdoor dining area.
Fire Island, NY
06/22 – 06/29
$723/nighttotal: $5061 (7 )
Fire Island Pines Getaway
3 3
apartment , Fire Island
This Fire Island rental home is located a 2-minute walk from the beach and a 5-minute walk from the Pines ferry dock, bars, restaurants, and a market. This 3-bedroom, 1-bathroom house accommodates up to 7 guests and features a private deck, a Jacuzzi hot tub, an outdoor shower, and a 55” 4K smart TV with high-speed FIOS internet.
Choose the Right Vacation Rentals with a Pool in Fire Island, NY
Enhance your coastal getaway with a Fire Island, NY vacation rental featuring a pool.
Fire Island, NY
07/27 – 08/02
$2121/nighttotal: $12726 (6 )
Fruit Of The Dune, Cherry Grove
4 2
apartment , Fire Island
This oceanfront residence in Cherry Grove, Fire Island, NY, offers direct Atlantic Ocean access and Great South Bay views. This four-bedroom, three-bathroom house accommodates up to eight guests and features a newly renovated interior, a heated swimming pool, a cabana, and multiple decks.
10 13 reviews
Fire Island, NY
06/22 – 06/25
$1048/nighttotal: $3144 (3 )
Stylish, Sun-filled Bellport Home With Pool
3 4
apartment , Bellport
This Bellport apartment is located on a quiet street, just a short walk from the village, marina, Mother's Beach, and other local attractions. The apartment has consistently received excellent ratings for its cleanliness, location, and overall experience. This home offers three bedrooms and two bathrooms, comfortably accommodating up to six guests. Enjoy a private garden oasis, a heated saltwater pool, bay views, luxury amenities, a fully equipped kitchen, and easy access to the charming Bellport village and transportation.
10 5 reviews
Fire Island, NY
06/22 – 06/29
$848/nighttotal: $5936 (7 )
Fire Island Pines Waterfront Oasis - Pool & Hottub
1 3
apartment , Fire Island
This charming cottage is located in the Pines district of Fire Island, directly on the waterfront of the Fire Island National Seashore, offering breathtaking ocean views. The property boasts excellent user, location, and cleanliness ratings, ensuring a comfortable and enjoyable stay. The cottage features two bedrooms and two bathrooms, accommodating up to four guests. Amenities include a private pool, hot tub, a fully equipped kitchen, a 72" TV, high-speed internet, and a unique "gay-zebo" for relaxing and entertaining.
10 38 reviews
Fire Island, NY
08/01 – 08/03
$605/nighttotal: $1210 (2 )
Guest House Retreat
With Amazing Pool !!!
1 3
house , North Bellport
This house in North Bellport is located in the picturesque Bellport Village, known for its colonial architecture, small-town ambiance, and performing arts center. It's only 90 minutes from New York City and offers proximity to the Great South Bay. With excellent user, location, and cleanliness ratings, this 1-bedroom, 1-bathroom house can accommodate up to 4 guests. It features a well-equipped kitchen, comfortable furnishings, air conditioning, a swimming pool, a garden, and internet access.
Browse Waterfront Vacation Rentals in Fire Island, NY
Discover beautiful beach towns with these seaside vacation rentals in Fire Island, NY, perfect for relaxing near the coast and exploring the shore.
9.0 101 reviews
Fire Island, NY
06/22 – 06/25
$780/nighttotal: $2340 (3 )
5 Bedroom Home Steps From Beach
1 4
apartment , Fire Island
Fire Island, NY
07/27 – 08/02
$1293/nighttotal: $7758 (6 )
Bayfront Beach House!
1 2
apartment , Fire Island
Fire Island, NY
06/22 – 06/29
$856/nighttotal: $5992 (7 )
Horseshoe Den - Fair Harbor, Fire Island
1 3
apartment , Fire Island
9.7 86 reviews
Fire Island, NY
07/31 – 08/03
$5554/nighttotal: $16662 (3 )
The Legendary Pyramid House
3 1
apartment , Fire Island
Traveler-Approved Luxury Vacation Rentals in Fire Island, NY
Refined interiors and prime locations make these luxury waterfront vacation rentals in Fire Island, NY the ideal choice for your stay.
9.6 10 reviews
Fire Island, NY
06/21 – 06/22
$324/nightfor 1 night
Lakefront Getaway & Romantic Nights + Beaches Near
1 1
apartment , West Islip
Explore Vacation Rentals with Saunas in Fire Island, NY
Maximize your wellness with vacation rentals in Fire Island, NY featuring on-site saunas and steam rooms.
Fire Island, NY
08/14 – 08/20
$4266/nighttotal: $25596 (6 )
Fabulous Fip Whole House Bayfront Retreat
1 10
house , Fire Island
9.6 5 reviews
Fire Island, NY
07/16 – 07/19
$431/nighttotal: $1293 (3 )
Exceptional & Central, Garden Suite, Top Amenities & Care!
