Compare vacation rentals in Fire Island, NY from 100+ sites!

1176 available vacation rental offers

7 nights
2
1
  • airbnb
  • booking
  • vrbo
  • expedia
  • sonder
  • priceline
  • tripadvisor
  • tripcom
  • homestay
  • hotelscom
  • orbitz
  • vacasa
Fire Island, NY vacation rentals
Choose the perfect vacation accommodation
Price per night
Accommodation type
Rating

Best Vacation rentals and Airbnb offers in Fire Island, NY

Best Fire Island, NY vacation rentals with a balcony

Fire Island Pines Paradise - Fire Island, NY
No reviews

Fire Island Pines Paradise

apartment, Fire Island
This Sayville vacation home offers a prime location, just a 2-minute walk to the beach and a 5-minute walk to the Pines ferry dock, bars, restaurants, and a local market.
This 2-bedroom, 1-bathroom apartment accommodates up to 5 guests and features a private deck with ocean breezes, a Jacuzzi brand hot tub, an outdoor shower, new premium beds, 55” 4K smart TV, FIOS high-speed internet, and a fully stocked kitchen.
Davis Park Fire Island Retreat - Fire Island, NY
No reviews

Davis Park Fire Island Retreat

house, Fire Island
This air-conditioned, 1700 square foot house offers 2 bedrooms and accommodates up to 19 guests, featuring a fully equipped kitchen, complimentary WiFi, and a private host.
Enjoy garden views from the private terrace and balcony of this Fire Island vacation rental, located in a peaceful district with convenient access to island attractions.
Waterfront Home W/ Large Deck & Dock On Narrow Bay - Fire Island, NY
9.7 71 reviews

Waterfront Home W/ Large Deck & Dock On Narrow Bay

house, Mastic Beach
This waterfront home is located in Mastic Beach, just 20 miles from Splish Splash water park and 24 miles from the Long Island Railroad. This vacation rental has received excellent ratings for its location, cleanliness, and overall user experience.
The 1800 square foot house has 3 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms, and can comfortably accommodate up to 6 guests. Enjoy stunning water views from the large deck and private dock, relax with free WiFi and cable TV, and prepare meals in the fully equipped kitchen.
Fire Island White House - Ocean Bay Park  5 Bedroom Bayview Home - Sleeps 18! - Fire Island, NY
10 3 reviews

Fire Island White House - Ocean Bay Park 5 Bedroom Bayview Home - Sleeps 18!

apartment, Fire Island
This Bay Shore vacation home, two blocks from both the ocean and the ferry, offers easy access to Fire Island's attractions and the Cherry Grove Community House and Theatre.
This 3,500-square-foot house features five bedrooms, five bathrooms, sleeps up to 18 guests, and includes a heated pool, Jacuzzi, rooftop deck, and amenities like beach chairs and bikes.

Browse Family-Friendly Vacation Rentals in Fire Island, NY

Perfect for family trips, these spacious Fire Island, NY rentals and Airbnbs provide easy access to local beaches.

Fire Island 4br; Bay Views; Big Deck (No Cars!) - Fire Island, NY
9.7 76 reviews

Fire Island 4br; Bay Views; Big Deck (No Cars!)

apartment, Fire Island
This Fire Island rental is a four-bedroom, two-bathroom house located a five-minute walk from Ocean Beach's shops, restaurants, and lifeguarded beaches.
The 8-guest house features a spacious open-concept living and dining area, a large private deck, modern amenities including air conditioning and a smart TV, and stunning ocean bay views from three bedrooms.
Sandy Toes - Fire Island, NY
9.9 37 reviews

Sandy Toes

apartment, Ocean Beach
This Ocean Beach bungalow is just a 5-minute walk from the ferry dock, placing you close to shops and restaurants while offering a peaceful retreat. The property consistently receives excellent ratings for its cleanliness, location, and overall experience.
The 3-bedroom, 1-bathroom home comfortably sleeps 6 guests and features a spacious outdoor area with a deck and an outdoor shower. Enjoy modern comforts like air conditioning, plush beds, and a fully stocked kitchen, along with convenient amenities like bicycles, beach chairs, and Wi-Fi.
Relaxing Patchogue Retreat Near The Bay - Fire Island, NY
10 4 reviews

Relaxing Patchogue Retreat Near The Bay

apartment, Patchogue
This four-bedroom, two-bathroom apartment in Patchogue accommodates up to eight guests and features a full kitchen with a fridge, freezer, microwave, and dishwasher, plus air conditioning and Wi-Fi for a comfortable stay. Enjoy on-site parking and access to a garden, making this residence a convenient base for exploring Patchogue, located just 0.5 miles from the historic Patchogue Theatre and 1 mile from Shorefront Park.
Waterfront Round House View - Fire Island, NY
9.8 176 reviews

Waterfront Round House View

apartment, Oakdale
This Oakdale house is located just a short walk from the Great South Bay, Connetquot River, and Bayard Cutting Arboretum State Park, making it ideal for nature lovers and those looking for a peaceful getaway. It has consistently received excellent ratings for its location, cleanliness, and overall experience.
This 3-bedroom, 1-bathroom vacation rental can comfortably accommodate up to 7 guests. Enjoy amenities like internet, air conditioning, a Jacuzzi, and a fully equipped kitchen, as well as a garden and parking.

Frequently Asked Questions about vacation rentals in Fire Island, NY

  • What should a first-time visitor not miss in Fire Island, NY?

    For a first-time visit, you absolutely have to check out the Fire Island Lighthouse, it's a classic! You can climb to the top for amazing views of the island and the Atlantic Ocean. You should also take a walk on the beach at Ocean Beach, it's one of the most popular spots on the island.
  • What are the best Airbnb and vacation rentals in Fire Island, NY?

    In-law Apt A Block Away From Patchogue Bay, Private Queen Bedrm Pet Pally - Work - Events - Ltr - Mtr - Str and Just A Cozy Stay are the most popular Airbnb and vacation rentals in Fire Island, NY among travelers.

  • Which neighborhood in Fire Island, NY should you consider for a vacation rental?

    It really depends on what you're looking for! Ocean Beach is great for a lively atmosphere, while Fire Island Pines is known for its LGBTQ+ community. If you prefer a quieter vibe, you could try Cherry Grove or Kismet.
  • What are the most popular Airbnbs in Fire Island, NY?

  • What are the top family-friendly attractions in Fire Island, NY?

    The Fire Island Lighthouse is a great family-friendly attraction. Kids love the climb to the top! The Fire Island National Seashore is also a great place for families to enjoy nature. You can go for walks, bike rides, or even have a picnic.
  • What are the best vacation rentals with a pool in Fire Island, NY?

  • When is the best time to book a vacation rental in Fire Island, NY?

    To avoid the crowds and get the best deals, book your vacation rental in the shoulder seasons, April-May or September-October. If you want to be in the heart of the action, book your rental in the summer months, June-August.
  • What are the best rentals for families and kids in Fire Island, NY?

  • What are the best budget-friendly activities in Fire Island, NY?

    Fire Island is all about the beach, so you can easily spend the day soaking up the sun for free. You can also take a walk or bike ride along the Fire Island National Seashore, which is free to enter. And if you're looking for a cheap bite to eat, there are plenty of affordable food trucks and stands around the island.
  • What are the best rentals or Airbnbs with a jacuzzi in Fire Island, NY?

  • What are the best restaurants with local dishes in Fire Island, NY?

    The Sunken Forest Restaurant in Ocean Beach has great seafood dishes. The Fire Island Pines Inn has a more upscale dining experience. For a casual, fun atmosphere, check out The Clamman in Cherry Grove.
  • What are the best walking or cycling routes in Fire Island, NY?

    The Fire Island National Seashore is a great place to walk or bike. You can take the Ocean Beach to Fire Island Pines trail, which is about 7 miles long. If you want a shorter walk, there are plenty of trails within Ocean Beach itself.
  • Are there pet-friendly attractions in Fire Island, NY?

    Most of the beaches on Fire Island are not pet-friendly during the summer months. However, Robert Moses State Park, which is located on the mainland, has a dog beach. You can also take your dog for a walk along the Fire Island National Seashore.
  • What are the benefits of choosing a vacation rental in Fire Island, NY?

    Vacation rentals offer more space and privacy than a hotel. They often have kitchens, so you can save money by preparing some of your own meals. And many rentals are located in quieter areas of the island, which can be a nice change of pace from the hustle and bustle of the main towns.
  • What are the top sports attractions and facilities in Fire Island, NY?

    Fire Island is known for its beaches, so swimming, sunbathing, and surfing are popular activities. There are also a few tennis courts on the island. If you're looking for more organized sports, you'll need to head to the mainland.

Popular destinations

Best Fire Island, NY vacation rentals with parking

Cute Fipines Home W/pool, Hot Tub, Rooftop & More - Fire Island, NY
9.9 21 reviews

Cute Fipines Home W/pool, Hot Tub, Rooftop & More

apartment, Fire Island
This apartment is located in Sayville, just a short distance from the harbor, ocean, and bay, offering easy access to water activities. The apartment has received excellent ratings for its location, cleanliness, and overall user experience.
The accommodation features three bedrooms and two bathrooms, comfortably accommodating up to six guests. The apartment includes a swimming pool, hot tub, fire pit, multiple decks, a garden, a spa, and a fitness center, making it ideal for relaxation and entertainment.
Amildean Family Oasis: 10 Minutes From Connequot Park, The Golf Course And The Beach! - Fire Island, NY
No reviews

Amildean Family Oasis: 10 Minutes From Connequot Park, The Golf Course And The Beach!

apartment, Central Islip
This Central Islip dwelling offers a 2-bedroom, 1-bathroom rental ideal for up to 2 guests, featuring a family-friendly atmosphere with a relaxing backyard and proximity to Connetquot River State Park and Bayard Cutting Arboretum State Park, all within easy driving distance of Long Island beaches. This accommodation includes a modern convection oven, a fully equipped kitchen, and blackout curtains in the bedrooms for a comfortable stay, with internet and air conditioning provided.
Elevated House With Stunning Views Of Narrow Bay - Fire Island, NY
9.9 214 reviews

Elevated House With Stunning Views Of Narrow Bay

apartment, Mastic Beach
This Mastic Beach apartment is just minutes from Smith Point Beach, one of Long Island's most popular beaches, offering a peaceful escape from the city. The apartment has excellent user, location, and cleanliness ratings.
The apartment has an open floor plan, ideal for couples, with a capacity for four guests. It features a fully equipped kitchen, air conditioning, a private garden, parking, and stunning bay views from the outdoor deck, perfect for relaxing or hosting small gatherings.
Bay Shore Boat House - Fire Island, NY
10 79 reviews

Bay Shore Boat House

apartment, Bay Shore
This Bay Shore waterfront vessel offers a prime location, a short walk from downtown, near Fire Island Ferries and Captain Bill's.
The three-bedroom, one-bathroom houseboat sleeps six, features a designer kitchen with a dishwasher, a private dock, a bluestone patio with a fire pit and cabana bar, and includes access to a fitness center.

Choose the Right Vacation Rentals with a Pool in Fire Island, NY

Enhance your coastal getaway with a Fire Island, NY vacation rental featuring a pool.

Industrial Designer Beach House. - Fire Island, NY
10 12 reviews

Industrial Designer Beach House.

apartment, Fire Island
This Fire Island Pines home is a 3-minute walk from the town and a 1-minute walk from the beach, offering stunning east, south, and west ocean views.
The four-bedroom, two-bathroom house sleeps eight guests and boasts a heated saltwater pool, chef's kitchen with a large center island, SONOS sound system, and high-speed WiFi.
Ocean Beach, Beautiful & New, Covered Deck, Great Bay Views, Pool, Outdoor Grill - Fire Island, NY
10 1 review

Ocean Beach, Beautiful & New, Covered Deck, Great Bay Views, Pool, Outdoor Grill

apartment, Fire Island
This Ocean Beach house is located in the Ocean Beach district of Fire Island, near the Fair Harbor Ferry Terminal and Bay Shore Mini Golf, and is steps from Atlantique Beach and Ocean Beach.
This 2000 square foot residence offers 4 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms, and a capacity for 8 guests, featuring a kitchen with a fridge, microwave, and dishwasher, air conditioning, a swimming pool, garden, outdoor shower, grill with a separate fridge, and two bikes for island exploration.
Promise Land, Fire Island Pines - Fire Island, NY
10 6 reviews

Promise Land, Fire Island Pines

apartment, Fire Island
This Fire Island beach house, a 1,500-square-foot single-story home on a 9,000-square-foot lot, offers expansive privacy and is a short ferry ride from Long Island's mainland.
The three-bedroom, two-bathroom rental sleeps six, boasting a heated pool, hot tub, outdoor BBQ, and a spacious living area with a fireplace; pet-friendly and with internet access.
Resort-style Estate | Pool, Sauna, Spa & Game Room - Fire Island, NY
9.8 31 reviews

Resort-style Estate | Pool, Sauna, Spa & Game Room

apartment, Bellport
This charming 1920s plantation-style estate is located on a sprawling 1.26-acre lot in Bellport, just a short walk from the village and a ferry ride away from Ho-Hum beach on Fire Island. The home's peaceful setting provides a tranquil escape while still being close to all that Bellport has to offer.
The spacious house offers 5 bedrooms and 5.5 bathrooms, comfortably accommodating up to 15 guests. Enjoy modern amenities, a fully equipped kitchen, a refreshing pool, and a dedicated children's play set for a memorable stay.

Browse Waterfront Vacation Rentals in Fire Island, NY

Discover beautiful beach towns with these seaside vacation rentals in Fire Island, NY, perfect for relaxing near the coast and exploring the shore.

The Legendary Pyramid House - Fire Island, NY
9.7 89 reviews

The Legendary Pyramid House

apartment, Fire Island
2 Br Private Suite W/private Living Room & Kitchen - Fire Island, NY
10 34 reviews

2 Br Private Suite W/private Living Room & Kitchen

house, Fire Island
Fire Island White House - Fire Island, NY
10 12 reviews

Fire Island White House

apartment, Fire Island
Luxury Waterfront Retreat  Private Hot Tub & Dock Near Sayville - Fire Island, NY
10 94 reviews

Luxury Waterfront Retreat Private Hot Tub & Dock Near Sayville

apartment, Bayport

Traveler-Approved Luxury Vacation Rentals in Fire Island, NY

Refined interiors and prime locations make these luxury waterfront vacation rentals in Fire Island, NY the ideal choice for your stay.

Luxury 4br Home: Bay Views, Heated Pool & Spa, Ac - Fire Island, NY
9.9 16 reviews

Luxury 4br Home: Bay Views, Heated Pool & Spa, Ac

apartment, Fire Island

Explore Vacation Rentals with Saunas in Fire Island, NY

Maximize your wellness with vacation rentals in Fire Island, NY featuring on-site saunas and steam rooms.

The President Mansion Luxurious Family Retreat - 1.5 Miles To Beach - Fire Island, NY
10 15 reviews

The President Mansion Luxurious Family Retreat - 1.5 Miles To Beach

apartment, West Bay Shore
Exceptional & Central, Garden Suite, Top Amenities & Care! - Fire Island, NY
9.6 6 reviews

Exceptional & Central, Garden Suite, Top Amenities & Care!

apartment, Central Islip
Renovated House With An Entertainment Backyard - Fire Island, NY
10 13 reviews

Renovated House With An Entertainment Backyard

apartment, North Great River
©2026 cozycozy.com