Search vacation rental in Fishers Island, NY from 100+ sites!

216 available vacation rental offers

7 nights
2
1
  • airbnb
  • booking
  • vrbo
  • expedia
  • sonder
  • priceline
  • tripadvisor
  • tripcom
  • homestay
  • hotelscom
  • orbitz
  • vacasa
Fishers Island, NY vacation rentals
Choose the perfect vacation accommodation
Price per night
Accommodation type
Rating

Fishers Island, NY Vacation rentals: no available offers. Here are other great options for your stay!

Heart Of Mystic Flat - Fishers Island, NY
10 32 reviews

Heart Of Mystic Flat

apartment, Groton
This newly renovated one-bedroom apartment in Mystic, Groton, is located on the Groton side of the Mystic River drawbridge, within walking distance of the Mystic Seaport Museum and numerous restaurants.
The 1-bathroom unit sleeps two guests and features a fully equipped kitchen with a Nespresso machine, in-unit laundry, a 50" smart TV with streaming services, and off-street parking.
Historic Mystic, Ct - Harbor View Landing - Block Island Waterfront Cottage - Fishers Island, NY
10 109 reviews

Historic Mystic, Ct - Harbor View Landing - Block Island Waterfront Cottage

apartment, Groton
This charming cottage in West Mystic is conveniently located near Mystic Downtown Marina and Mystic Seaport, both within a 2-mile radius. The cottage has received excellent ratings for its location, cleanliness, and overall experience.
The cottage offers 450 square feet of space, perfect for accommodating up to 4 guests in its one bedroom and one bathroom. Enjoy modern comforts, outdoor space, and entertainment options like a patio, sofa bed, TV, and games.
Charming Carriage House-ocean View-beach-fireplace - Fishers Island, NY
10 336 reviews

Charming Carriage House-ocean View-beach-fireplace

house, New London
This guesthouse in New London's beach community offers private beach access and expansive views of Long Island Sound, with Ocean Beach Park and the New London Harbor Lighthouse located 1.5 miles away.
This 900 square foot apartment accommodates up to four guests with one bedroom and one bathroom, featuring a fully renovated kitchen, a queen-size sleeper sofa, air conditioning, a swimming pool, a jacuzzi, a fitness center, a tennis court, and Wi-Fi.
Eastern Point 4 Season Ranch - Fishers Island, NY
9.8 107 reviews

Eastern Point 4 Season Ranch

apartment, Groton
This fully renovated three-bedroom ranch house is located in Groton's desirable Eastern Point neighborhood, offering convenient access to local attractions; exact distances to specific landmarks require further inquiry.
The pet-friendly home features a full kitchen, a large backyard with a fire pit, a private deck, an attached garage, and accommodates up to five guests; discounted rates are available for military, EB, or healthcare contractors seeking extended stays.

Frequently Asked Questions about vacation rentals in Fishers Island, NY

  • What are some interesting places to visit in or near Fishers Island, NY?

    Fishers Island is a quiet, charming island, so the best places to visit are the natural ones. You can check out the historic Fishers Island Lighthouse, enjoy a picnic at the scenic Sunset Beach, or take a walk through the peaceful, 1,000-acre Fishers Island Conservancy. If you're looking for something a bit more lively, you can take the ferry over to the quaint town of New London, Connecticut, just across the water.
  • What are the best Airbnb and vacation rentals in Fishers Island, NY?

    Quiet Studio With Sleeping Loft And Deck, Quiet 2 Bedroom 1 Bath 3rd Floor Apartment Close To Everything and Amazing Beach House are the most popular Airbnb and vacation rentals in Fishers Island, NY among travelers.

  • Which walking or cycling routes are the best in Fishers Island, NY?

    The most popular walking and cycling route is the scenic 5-mile loop around the island. It takes you past beautiful beaches, historic landmarks, and quaint villages. You can also find some shorter, more challenging trails in the interior of the island, like the trail leading up to the Fishers Island Lighthouse.
  • What are the most popular Airbnbs in Fishers Island, NY?

  • What sports or outdoor activites can visitors enjoy in and around Fishers Island, NY?

    Fishers Island is a paradise for outdoor enthusiasts. You can enjoy swimming, sunbathing, and kayaking at the island's many beaches. You can also go fishing, birdwatching, hiking, and biking. For something a little more adventurous, you can try stand-up paddleboarding or windsurfing.
  • What are the best vacation rentals with a pool in Fishers Island, NY?

  • What other towns or cities can be easily accessed from Fishers Island, NY?

    The most easily accessible town from Fishers Island is New London, Connecticut. You can take the ferry from Fishers Island to New London, which is just a short ride across the water. From New London, you can easily access other towns and cities in Connecticut and Rhode Island.
  • What are the best rentals for families and kids in Fishers Island, NY?

  • What amenities are commonly available in vacation rentals in Fishers Island, NY?

    Vacation rentals on Fishers Island usually come equipped with basic amenities like a kitchen, bathroom, and bedrooms. Many also offer additional features like a fireplace, outdoor deck, and access to a private beach or dock. You'll find that most rentals are comfortable and well-maintained, offering a peaceful retreat from the hustle and bustle of everyday life.
  • What are the best rentals or Airbnbs with a jacuzzi in Fishers Island, NY?

  • What time of year is best to rent a vacation rental Fishers Island, NY?

    The best time to visit Fishers Island really depends on what you're looking for. If you want warm weather and beach days, summer is the ideal time. If you prefer cooler temperatures and fewer crowds, spring and fall are great options. Winter can be beautiful, but it's important to be prepared for colder temperatures and potential snow.

Popular destinations

©2026 cozycozy.com