Search vacation rental in Fishers Island, NY from 100+ sites!
154 available vacation rental offers
Choose the perfect vacation accommodation
Price per night
Accommodation type
Rating
Best Vacation rentals and Airbnb offers in Fishers Island, NY
Fishers Island, NY
06/23 – 07/04
$591/nighttotal: $6501 (11 )
Modern Home Minutes To Mystic, Casinos And Ocean
2 2
house , Groton
This modern duplex in Groton offers proximity to major employers like Pfizer and the Naval Sub Base, situated within a minute of the Mystic Marriott Hotel and five minutes from New London. This vacation rental accommodates up to four guests with two bedrooms, one bathroom, a full kitchen, air conditioning, and a workspace, featuring keyless entry, a shared outdoor yard, a Tesla Level 2 charger, and in-unit laundry.
9.9 20 reviews
Fishers Island, NY
06/23 – 07/04
$609/nighttotal: $6699 (11 )
Family Friendly Mystic Retreat - Close To Town
1 2
apartment , Groton
The Capstan, a three-bedroom house in Mystic, Connecticut, is located a mile from downtown Mystic and a ten-minute drive from Mystic Aquarium and Old Mystic Village, offering easy access to Groton attractions. This family-friendly home features a spacious layout sleeping eight, complete with a fully equipped kitchen, in-unit laundry, a fenced yard with cornhole, and a 75-inch HDTV, plus additional amenities for families and couples.
This luxurious waterfront home on Bakers Cove Lane in Groton, Connecticut, offers complete privacy and easy access to Long Island Sound, with New London Airport visible across the water. The four-bedroom, three-and-a-half-bathroom house accommodates eight guests and features a private dock, kayaks, and proximity to Mystic Aquarium, Mystic Seaport, various beaches, and hiking/biking trails (driving distances vary).
10 62 reviews
Fishers Island, NY
06/23 – 07/04
$813/nighttotal: $8943 (11 )
Dream Vacation Home Mystic, Ct
4 2
apartment , Groton
This vacation home in Groton provides a unique and cozy stay in the charming West Mystic district, close to Mystic Seaport and Mystic Seaport - The Museum of America and the Sea. With excellent user, location, and cleanliness ratings, this 4-bedroom, 2-bathroom house accommodates up to 6 guests and offers a range of amenities. Guests can relax in the on-site spa tub, enjoy the warmth of the cozy fireplace, and utilize the fully equipped kitchen. Additional conveniences include a washing machine, multiple bathrooms, and a smoke-free environment, ensuring a comfortable and memorable stay for all.
9.8 30 reviews
Fishers Island, NY
06/23 – 07/04
$405/nighttotal: $4455 (11 )
Eastern Point Beach And Golf Course
3 2
apartment , Groton
This Groton apartment is conveniently located within walking distance of UConn Avery Point and Eastern Point Beach, offering easy access to both academic and recreational activities. The apartment has excellent user, location, and cleanliness ratings, ensuring a comfortable and enjoyable stay. The apartment is spacious, with three bedrooms and one bathroom, comfortably accommodating up to five guests. It comes fully furnished, including linens, and offers free Wi-Fi, a kitchen with a fridge and microwave, parking, and access to a full basement.
10 1 review
Fishers Island, NY
06/23 – 07/04
$314/nighttotal: $3454 (11 )
The Rossie Studio · Near Mystic, Casinos + Uscga
1 2
studio , Groton
This Groton studio apartment is located in Mystic, Connecticut, near Mystic Seaport and Foxwoods Resort Casino, offering easy access to area attractions. The 430-square-foot unit features an open layout, sleeps two (with a pack-n-play available), includes a fully equipped kitchen with a fridge and microwave, and offers amenities such as air conditioning, a terrace, and free on-site parking.
9.3 8 reviews
Fishers Island, NY
06/23 – 07/04
$789/nighttotal: $8679 (11 )
Pool House Near Casinos!
1 2
apartment , Groton
This Groton house rental, perfect for families, offers a centrally located stay with easy access to local attractions, though specific distances aren't provided. The 4-bedroom, 2-bathroom home sleeps 12 guests and includes a private pool (May-October), full kitchen, air conditioning, parking, and excellent guest ratings.
Fishers Island, NY
06/23 – 07/04
$1918/nighttotal: $21098 (11 )
Historic Spite House, Captains Home, Sleeps 10, Walk To Downtown Mystic!!
5 2
apartment , Stonington
This 5-bedroom, 5-bathroom vacation rental is conveniently located in Mystic, just a short walk from the Mystic River Bascule Bridge and Mystic Arts Center, and a 4-minute drive from Olde Mistick Village. The charming town of Stonington is a short drive away, offering a peaceful escape from the bustling Mystic waterfront. The spacious home comfortably accommodates up to 10 guests, making it perfect for families or groups of friends. Modern amenities like Wi-Fi, air conditioning, and a dryer ensure a comfortable stay, and the close proximity to Mystic Seaport, Mystic Aquarium, and Ocean Beach Park provides plenty of opportunities for fun and exploration.
10 10 reviews
Fishers Island, NY
06/23 – 07/04
$598/nighttotal: $6578 (11 )
Downtown Mystic Loft!
1 2
apartment , Stonington
This top-floor condo in Mystic offers Mystic River views and is a 5-minute walk to downtown Mystic's dining, the Mystic Seaport Museum, and Sift Bake Shop. This 2-bedroom, 1-bathroom unit sleeps 4 guests and features A/C, Wifi, a fully equipped kitchen with a coffee machine, a Peloton, and Youtube TV.
9.9 72 reviews
Fishers Island, NY
06/23 – 07/04
$1579/nighttotal: $17369 (11 )
Spacious Oceanview Villa • Sleeps 22 • 8br
1 2
house , New London
This eight-bedroom, four-bathroom house is located in New London, Connecticut, just a four-minute drive from Ocean Beach Park, a renowned beach named one of the best by National Geographic. The house features breathtaking ocean views, a spacious outdoor area with a balcony, dining space, couches, a gas fire pit, and a grill, as well as a well-equipped kitchen, multiple living spaces, and access to three carload beach passes for Ocean Beach Park.
10 1 review
Fishers Island, NY
06/23 – 07/04
$349/nighttotal: $3839 (11 )
The Cutler 1-bedroom · Near Mystic, Casinos + Uscga
1 2
apartment , Groton
This cozy Mystic, Connecticut rental is conveniently located near Mystic Seaport and Foxwoods Resort Casino, offering easy access to popular attractions in southeastern Connecticut. The 430-square-foot, one-bedroom apartment features an open layout, sleeps two (plus a child in a pack-n-play), and includes a fully equipped kitchen, free parking, and a terrace.
8.9 7 reviews
Fishers Island, NY
06/23 – 07/04
$353/nighttotal: $3883 (11 )
Charming Open Layout 2 Bedroom Cape-lord's Point
1 2
apartment , Stonington
This Stonington cottage is located near Lord's Point Beaches, providing easy access to tennis and basketball courts. The two-bedroom, one-bathroom house sleeps four, features a fully equipped kitchen with dishwasher, air conditioning, a private yard with grill, and pet-friendly accommodations for small, non-shedding dogs.
Best Fishers Island, NY vacation rentals with a balcony
This New London villa, a spacious 8-bedroom home, is conveniently located within a 10-minute walk of Pequot Chapel, Mitchell College, and the New London Harbor Light, with Monte Cristo Cottage and Green Harbor Beach less than a mile away. This 14-bedroom, 4-bathroom property sleeps up to 22 guests and boasts a fitness center, swimming pool, and a fully equipped kitchen with modern appliances, plus free Wi-Fi, a terrace, and a garden.
Fishers Island, NY
06/23 – 07/04
$314/nighttotal: $3454 (11 )
The Morgan Studio · Near Mystic, Casinos + Uscga
1 2
studio , Groton
This studio apartment is located in a peaceful, rural area of Mystic, just a short drive from attractions like Olde Mistick Village and Mohegan Sun Arena. The surrounding area offers a tranquil escape from the hustle and bustle of city life. The cozy studio is perfect for a couple, with a comfortable layout and a total floor area of 430 square feet. The studio includes a well-equipped kitchen, a private balcony, and a garden, making it ideal for enjoying meals and relaxing outdoors.
10 1 review
Fishers Island, NY
06/23 – 07/04
$314/nighttotal: $3454 (11 )
The Kelly Studio · Near Mystic, Casinos + Uscga
1 2
studio , Groton
This Groton studio apartment is located in a rural area of southern Connecticut, near Mystic Seaport and Foxwoods Resort Casino. The 430-square-foot unit features an open layout, sleeps two (with a pack-n-play available), and includes a fully equipped kitchen, air conditioning, a terrace, and free parking; nearby attractions include Ocean Beach Park and the Mystic Aquarium.
10 1 review
Fishers Island, NY
06/23 – 07/04
$314/nighttotal: $3454 (11 )
The Andrews Studio · Near Mystic, Casinos + Uscga
1 2
studio , Groton
This Groton apartment rental is conveniently located within 6 miles of Mystic Aquarium, Olde Mistick Village, and Mystic Downtown Marina, offering easy access to popular attractions. The 430-square-foot unit features one bedroom, one bathroom, a fully equipped kitchen, a private balcony, and accommodates two guests; on-site amenities include a swimming pool and a garden.
Our Favorite Family-Friendly Vacation Rentals in Fishers Island, NY
Find the perfect family vacation rental or Airbnb in Fishers Island, NY with plenty of room to spread out near local beaches.
9.9 15 reviews
Fishers Island, NY
06/23 – 07/04
$408/nighttotal: $4488 (11 )
Beach Haven W/ Beach Passes
1 2
apartment , New London
This New London house rental is located two blocks from a beach (beach passes provided) and one block from a cove, offering easy access to the train station, ferry, shopping, and major highways. The 8-guest home features two bedrooms with queen beds, one with a full bed, a living room with a sofa bed, a dedicated TV room with games, a full kitchen with a gas range and dishwasher, a washer/dryer, and a private deck.
10 18 reviews
Fishers Island, NY
06/23 – 07/04
$1902/nighttotal: $20922 (11 )
The Wallasey: Mystic Harborside Home , Sleeps 14
1 2
apartment , Groton
This seven-bedroom, four-bathroom house in Groton, Connecticut, is centrally located in downtown Mystic, offering easy access to Mystic's attractions. This fully restored home boasts ample off-street parking for eight cars, a modern open floor plan, a fully equipped kitchen with dishwasher, and can comfortably accommodate fourteen guests; nearby amenities include Mystic's dining and nightlife.
Frequently Asked Questions about vacation rentals in Fishers Island, NY
What are some interesting places to visit in or near Fishers Island, NY?
Fishers Island is a quiet, charming island, so the best places to visit are the natural ones. You can check out the historic Fishers Island Lighthouse, enjoy a picnic at the scenic Sunset Beach, or take a walk through the peaceful, 1,000-acre Fishers Island Conservancy. If you're looking for something a bit more lively, you can take the ferry over to the quaint town of New London, Connecticut, just across the water.
What are the best Airbnb and vacation rentals in Fishers Island, NY?
Which walking or cycling routes are the best in Fishers Island, NY?
The most popular walking and cycling route is the scenic 5-mile loop around the island. It takes you past beautiful beaches, historic landmarks, and quaint villages. You can also find some shorter, more challenging trails in the interior of the island, like the trail leading up to the Fishers Island Lighthouse.
What are the most popular Airbnbs in Fishers Island, NY?
What sports or outdoor activites can visitors enjoy in and around Fishers Island, NY?
Fishers Island is a paradise for outdoor enthusiasts. You can enjoy swimming, sunbathing, and kayaking at the island's many beaches. You can also go fishing, birdwatching, hiking, and biking. For something a little more adventurous, you can try stand-up paddleboarding or windsurfing.
What are the best vacation rentals with a pool in Fishers Island, NY?
What other towns or cities can be easily accessed from Fishers Island, NY?
The most easily accessible town from Fishers Island is New London, Connecticut. You can take the ferry from Fishers Island to New London, which is just a short ride across the water. From New London, you can easily access other towns and cities in Connecticut and Rhode Island.
What are the best rentals for families and kids in Fishers Island, NY?
What amenities are commonly available in vacation rentals in Fishers Island, NY?
Vacation rentals on Fishers Island usually come equipped with basic amenities like a kitchen, bathroom, and bedrooms. Many also offer additional features like a fireplace, outdoor deck, and access to a private beach or dock. You'll find that most rentals are comfortable and well-maintained, offering a peaceful retreat from the hustle and bustle of everyday life.
What are the best rentals or Airbnbs with a jacuzzi in Fishers Island, NY?
What time of year is best to rent a vacation rental Fishers Island, NY?
The best time to visit Fishers Island really depends on what you're looking for. If you want warm weather and beach days, summer is the ideal time. If you prefer cooler temperatures and fewer crowds, spring and fall are great options. Winter can be beautiful, but it's important to be prepared for colder temperatures and potential snow.
Destinations nearby
Best Fishers Island, NY vacation rentals with parking
Fishers Island, NY
06/23 – 07/04
$316/nighttotal: $3476 (11 )
The Denison Studio · Near Casinos Smoke/vape Smell
1 2
studio , Groton
This pet-friendly studio is located in a peaceful rural area of Mystic, just a short 6-minute drive from both Olde Mistick Village and Mystic Aquarium. The studio is ideal for travelers seeking a quiet retreat while still being close to attractions. The studio comfortably sleeps two guests and includes a fully equipped kitchen with a refrigerator, oven, stovetop, microwave, coffee maker, and ice maker. Enjoy the convenience of free Wi-Fi, a television, a hairdryer, towels, and a private balcony or garden.
10 1 review
Fishers Island, NY
06/23 – 07/04
$314/nighttotal: $3454 (11 )
The Bradley Studio · Near Mystic, Casinos + Uscga
1 2
studio , Groton
This Groton apartment rental is conveniently located near the beach and within six miles of attractions like Olde Mistick Village, Mystic Aquarium, and Mystic Downtown Marina. This smoke-free, 430-square-foot unit features one bedroom, one bathroom, accommodates two guests, and includes amenities such as a fully equipped kitchen, a balcony, free WiFi, a swimming pool, and on-site water park and garden.
Fishers Island, NY
06/23 – 07/04
$949/nighttotal: $10439 (11 )
Brand-new Designer Home In Mystic | 3br, 2ba
1 2
apartment , Stonington
This brand-new luxury duplex offers exclusive upper-level access in Mystic, just a short distance from downtown, the Mystic Seaport Museum, and the Mystic Aquarium, with waterfront dining and beaches also nearby. This spacious apartment accommodates up to 8 guests with three bedrooms and an upstairs lounge, featuring a chef's kitchen, two spa-like bathrooms, air conditioning, a private deck, garden, and parking.
9.6 11 reviews
Fishers Island, NY
06/23 – 07/04
$3542/nighttotal: $38962 (11 )
Queenann Vintagevillagevictorian Old Port
1 2
resort , Groton
This first-floor apartment in Mystic's Vintage Village offers easy access to Downtown Mystic and the Mystic River, a short walk from both. The one-bedroom, one-bathroom unit features a full kitchen, queen-sized bed, and a relaxing backyard space, comfortably accommodating two guests and providing easy access to Mystic's attractions.
Browse Vacation Rentals with a Pool in Fishers Island, NY
Complement your beach days with a dip in the pool at these premier vacation rentals in Fishers Island, NY.
9.3 8 reviews
Fishers Island, NY
06/23 – 07/04
$789/nighttotal: $8679 (11 )
Pool House Near Casinos!
1 2
apartment , Groton
This Groton house rental, perfect for families, offers a centrally located stay with easy access to local attractions, though specific distances aren't provided. The 4-bedroom, 2-bathroom home sleeps 12 guests and includes a private pool (May-October), full kitchen, air conditioning, parking, and excellent guest ratings.
This New London villa, a spacious 8-bedroom home, is conveniently located within a 10-minute walk of Pequot Chapel, Mitchell College, and the New London Harbor Light, with Monte Cristo Cottage and Green Harbor Beach less than a mile away. This 14-bedroom, 4-bathroom property sleeps up to 22 guests and boasts a fitness center, swimming pool, and a fully equipped kitchen with modern appliances, plus free Wi-Fi, a terrace, and a garden.
Search Coastal Vacation Rentals near Fishers Island, NY
Discover relaxing coastal properties with these seaside vacation rentals in Fishers Island, NY, located near the shore for an ideal beach-town escape.
9.0 4 reviews
Fishers Island, NY
06/23 – 07/04
$1011/nighttotal: $11121 (11 )
2-bedroom Getaway Steps From Downtown Mystic
1 2
apartment , Groton
Fishers Island, NY
06/23 – 07/04
$553/nighttotal: $6083 (11 )
Residential Home.
1 2
apartment , Groton
Top-Rated 5-Star Vacation Rentals in Fishers Island, NY
Discover the best of the coast with a luxury vacation rental in Fishers Island, NY, offering sophisticated rooms and prime locations.
9.6 91 reviews
Fishers Island, NY
06/23 – 07/04
$342/nighttotal: $3762 (11 )
The Golden Cape Of Historic Mystic
2 2
apartment , Stonington
Best Vacation Rentals with a Steam Room in Fishers Island, NY
Recover properly with on-site sauna access, a standard feature at these premier Fishers Island, NY vacation rentals.