Search vacation rental in Fishers Island, NY from 100+ sites!

216 available vacation rental offers

7 nights
2
1
  • airbnb
  • booking
  • vrbo
  • expedia
  • sonder
  • priceline
  • tripadvisor
  • tripcom
  • homestay
  • hotelscom
  • orbitz
  • vacasa
Fishers Island, NY vacation rentals
Choose the perfect vacation accommodation
Price per night
Accommodation type
Rating

Best Vacation rentals and Airbnb offers in Fishers Island, NY

Best Fishers Island, NY vacation rentals with a balcony

Cozy Waterfront Cottage - Fishers Island, NY
10 3 reviews

Cozy Waterfront Cottage

apartment, Groton
This Groton waterfront cottage offers direct access to the water, a short walk from Esker Point Beach, and is a five-minute drive from Mystic's downtown area.
The 2,420-square-foot home features three bedrooms, two bathrooms, sleeps six, and includes a fully equipped kitchen, private patio with outdoor dining, access to kayaks, paddleboards, and bikes, plus shared fire pits and grills.
Magnificent Ferncrest - Towering Home On The Coast - Fishers Island, NY
10 88 reviews

Magnificent Ferncrest - Towering Home On The Coast

apartment, Groton
This 8-bedroom vacation home is situated by the sea in Groton, within a 15-minute walk of Eastern Point Beach and Shennecossett Golf Course, and within 1.2 miles of Bluff Point State Park and Avery Point Light. This spacious rental features a private fenced yard, a barbecue grill, and an arcade/game room, perfect for families or groups of friends seeking a relaxing getaway.
Historic 6-bed Pet-friendly Home, Walk To Seaport - Fishers Island, NY
10 24 reviews

Historic 6-bed Pet-friendly Home, Walk To Seaport

apartment, Stonington
This six-bedroom, four-bathroom house rental in Mystic, Connecticut, is located downtown, steps from the Mystic Drawbridge and within walking distance of numerous restaurants.
The 4,040-square-foot property features two kitchens, two family rooms, two dining rooms, a deck and two patios, accommodating up to 13 guests and offering high-speed Wi-Fi, smart TVs, and a Sonos sound system.
Vacation Starts Now! Pet Friendly, Beach Fun 5 Min Away! - Fishers Island, NY
9.4 10 reviews

Vacation Starts Now! Pet Friendly, Beach Fun 5 Min Away!

apartment, New London
This waterfront house in New London is a perfect destination for families and friends. It is a 15-minute walk from New London Harbor Light, Ocean Beach Park, Waterford Beach Park, and Pequot Chapel.
The house has 3 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms, and can accommodate up to 7 guests. It features a water park, garden, and barbecue grills, as well as a well-equipped kitchen, a cozy fireplace, and free WiFi.

Our Favorite Family-Friendly Vacation Rentals in Fishers Island, NY

Find the perfect family vacation rental or Airbnb in Fishers Island, NY with plenty of room to spread out near local beaches.

True Ocean Front Vacationing - Groton/mystic - Fishers Island, NY
9.9 228 reviews

True Ocean Front Vacationing - Groton/mystic

apartment, Groton
This contemporary beach house in Groton, Connecticut offers breathtaking views of Long Island Sound and is conveniently located near popular destinations like Mystic/Stonington, just 15 minutes away. The 3-bedroom, 2-bathroom home features a private roof deck, a sunroom with water views, and a 60-foot private waterfront with a seawall, perfect for fishing or relaxing by the water.
Historic Home, Walk To Seaport & Downtown - Fishers Island, NY
10 32 reviews

Historic Home, Walk To Seaport & Downtown

house, Stonington
The Avery Suite, a renovated historic townhouse in Mystic's downtown, is steps from the Mystic Drawbridge and a short walk from Mystic Seaport and Mystic Pizza.
This 2,020-square-foot house features three bedrooms, two bathrooms, and can comfortably accommodate six guests, offering a chef's kitchen, high-speed Wi-Fi, smart TVs, and ample on-site parking.
Charming Downtown Mystic Historic House - Fishers Island, NY
10 419 reviews

Charming Downtown Mystic Historic House

apartment, Stonington
This Stonington apartment is located in historic Mystic, just a 5-minute walk from the Mystic Seaport and a 5-minute drive from Mystic Market East. The apartment consistently receives excellent ratings for its location, cleanliness, and overall experience.
The 3-bedroom, 2-bathroom rental offers 1190 square feet of space and can comfortably accommodate up to 8 guests. Enjoy amenities like air conditioning, a private garden, parking, and a fully equipped kitchen, along with access to internet and a friendly host who can help plan your activities.
Luxurious-modern Feel W/ Custom Features - Ac, Short Walk To The Beach And Parks - Fishers Island, NY
10 13 reviews

Luxurious-modern Feel W/ Custom Features - Ac, Short Walk To The Beach And Parks

apartment, Waterford
This family-friendly vacation home is located in Waterford, just a short walk from two beautiful beaches and within two kilometers of Harkness Memorial State Park and the Eugene O'Neill Theater Center. The house consistently receives excellent user ratings, making it a popular choice for travelers seeking a relaxing and enjoyable stay.
The 1170 square foot house has two bedrooms and two bathrooms, comfortably accommodating up to six guests. Enjoy the amenities, including a swimming pool, a terrace, a garden, a fireplace, and a fully equipped kitchen.

Frequently Asked Questions about vacation rentals in Fishers Island, NY

  • What are some interesting places to visit in or near Fishers Island, NY?

    Fishers Island is a quiet, charming island, so the best places to visit are the natural ones. You can check out the historic Fishers Island Lighthouse, enjoy a picnic at the scenic Sunset Beach, or take a walk through the peaceful, 1,000-acre Fishers Island Conservancy. If you're looking for something a bit more lively, you can take the ferry over to the quaint town of New London, Connecticut, just across the water.
  • What are the best Airbnb and vacation rentals in Fishers Island, NY?

    Quiet Studio With Sleeping Loft And Deck, Quiet 2 Bedroom 1 Bath 3rd Floor Apartment Close To Everything and Amazing Beach House are the most popular Airbnb and vacation rentals in Fishers Island, NY among travelers.

  • Which walking or cycling routes are the best in Fishers Island, NY?

    The most popular walking and cycling route is the scenic 5-mile loop around the island. It takes you past beautiful beaches, historic landmarks, and quaint villages. You can also find some shorter, more challenging trails in the interior of the island, like the trail leading up to the Fishers Island Lighthouse.
  • What are the most popular Airbnbs in Fishers Island, NY?

  • What sports or outdoor activites can visitors enjoy in and around Fishers Island, NY?

    Fishers Island is a paradise for outdoor enthusiasts. You can enjoy swimming, sunbathing, and kayaking at the island's many beaches. You can also go fishing, birdwatching, hiking, and biking. For something a little more adventurous, you can try stand-up paddleboarding or windsurfing.
  • What are the best vacation rentals with a pool in Fishers Island, NY?

  • What other towns or cities can be easily accessed from Fishers Island, NY?

    The most easily accessible town from Fishers Island is New London, Connecticut. You can take the ferry from Fishers Island to New London, which is just a short ride across the water. From New London, you can easily access other towns and cities in Connecticut and Rhode Island.
  • What are the best rentals for families and kids in Fishers Island, NY?

  • What amenities are commonly available in vacation rentals in Fishers Island, NY?

    Vacation rentals on Fishers Island usually come equipped with basic amenities like a kitchen, bathroom, and bedrooms. Many also offer additional features like a fireplace, outdoor deck, and access to a private beach or dock. You'll find that most rentals are comfortable and well-maintained, offering a peaceful retreat from the hustle and bustle of everyday life.
  • What are the best rentals or Airbnbs with a jacuzzi in Fishers Island, NY?

  • What time of year is best to rent a vacation rental Fishers Island, NY?

    The best time to visit Fishers Island really depends on what you're looking for. If you want warm weather and beach days, summer is the ideal time. If you prefer cooler temperatures and fewer crowds, spring and fall are great options. Winter can be beautiful, but it's important to be prepared for colder temperatures and potential snow.

Popular destinations

Best Fishers Island, NY vacation rentals with parking

Pet Friendly | Downtown Mystic Family Retreat - Fishers Island, NY
9.6 54 reviews

Pet Friendly | Downtown Mystic Family Retreat

house, Stonington
This Stonington vacation home is situated by the sea in Mystic, within a 15-minute walk of Mystic River Bascule Bridge and Mystic Seaport, and has excellent ratings for location, cleanliness and user experience.
The house has 3 bedrooms, 1 bathroom, and can accommodate up to 6 guests. It features a kitchen with modern appliances, a washing machine, TV, and a smoke-free environment. Guests can enjoy barbecue grills in the garden, and nearby attractions include Mystic Seaport and the Mystic Arts Center.
Private Retreat, Minutes Walk To Downtown Mystic - Fishers Island, NY
10 178 reviews

Private Retreat, Minutes Walk To Downtown Mystic

apartment, Groton
This apartment is conveniently located in Mystic, just a short distance from popular attractions like the Mystic Arts Center and Mystic Seaport. It has consistently received excellent ratings for location, cleanliness, and overall experience.
The apartment is a one-bedroom, one-bathroom unit with a spacious 600 square feet, comfortably accommodating up to four guests. It comes equipped with a full kitchen, a balcony, a garden, and other amenities such as internet access, air conditioning, and parking.
Harbor View Landing, The Mystic - 3rd Floor Suite - Fishers Island, NY
10 110 reviews

Harbor View Landing, The Mystic - 3rd Floor Suite

apartment, Groton
This vacation home is located in West Mystic, just a short drive from Mystic Downtown Marina and Mystic Seaport, offering easy access to the area's top attractions. It has received excellent ratings for location, cleanliness, and overall experience.
The house has 3 bedrooms and 2 bathrooms, comfortably accommodating up to 8 guests. Amenities include a fully equipped kitchen, a balcony, a garden, parking, and barbecue grills, making it perfect for a relaxing getaway.
Coastal Victorian Home, Walk To Downtown - Fishers Island, NY
10 369 reviews

Coastal Victorian Home, Walk To Downtown

apartment, Groton
This family-friendly vacation home is located in Mystic, just a short walk from Mystic Arts Center and Mystic Seaport, and within a 5-minute drive of Mystic River Bascule Bridge and Mystic Downtown Marina. This rental has received excellent ratings for location, cleanliness, and overall experience.
This 4-bedroom, 3-bathroom house is perfect for families or groups of up to 9 guests, offering 2600 square feet of living space. The house features a fully equipped kitchen, a private yard, air conditioning, a patio, and parking, ensuring a comfortable and enjoyable stay.

Browse Vacation Rentals with a Pool in Fishers Island, NY

Complement your beach days with a dip in the pool at these premier vacation rentals in Fishers Island, NY.

Tee N Sea | Luxury Getaway - Golf & Coastal Views - Fishers Island, NY
9.8 8 reviews

Tee N Sea | Luxury Getaway - Golf & Coastal Views

apartment, Groton
If you are looking for a special place to stay in Groton, consider the Shennecossett Golf Course Apartment. This 3,000 sq. ft. home is situated between the Shennecossett Golf Course and the coast, offering stunning views of both. Just minutes away from Eastern Point Beach, Bluff Point State Park, and Mystic Seaport, this apartment is the perfect home base for exploring the area.
The apartment has four bedrooms and three bathrooms, and can accommodate up to 12 guests. The open-concept main level boasts a fully equipped kitchen, dining area, and living room. The master suite includes a sitting area, work desk, en suite bathroom, and a private porch overlooking the backyard and coast. The apartment also features a brand-new pool, top-notch spa, and multiple outdoor seating areas.
Tee N Sea | Luxury Getaway - Golf & Coastal Views - Fishers Island, NY
9.9 39 reviews

Tee N Sea | Luxury Getaway - Golf & Coastal Views

apartment, Groton
This Groton vacation home, located a block from the Shennecossett Golf Course clubhouse and one mile from the beach, boasts stunning coastal views from the Thames River to the Atlantic Ocean.
The 3,000-square-foot house features four bedrooms with 65-inch TVs, two bathrooms, a chef's kitchen with high-end appliances, a private 16x32-foot pool, a hot tub, and accommodates up to twelve guests.
Sunset Oasis 1 @ Ocean Beach: $1mil View 6 Queen - Fishers Island, NY
9.7 270 reviews

Sunset Oasis 1 @ Ocean Beach: $1mil View 6 Queen

apartment, New London
This Cape Cod-style beach house is located directly across from Ocean Beach Park, just steps away from the water. With excellent user, location, and cleanliness ratings, this accommodation is a great choice for travelers visiting New London.
The house has four bedrooms and two bathrooms, a floor area of 2200 square feet, and can accommodate up to 12 guests. It features a large balcony deck with seating, offering stunning views of the Atlantic Ocean. The house also includes free high-speed internet, five HD TVs, a keyless passcode entry, and a fully fenced backyard. Pets are allowed for an additional fee.
Luxury 8br Winter Wonderland  Sleeps 22  Indoor Fireplaces & Ocean Views - Fishers Island, NY
9.8 48 reviews

Luxury 8br Winter Wonderland Sleeps 22 Indoor Fireplaces & Ocean Views

house, New London
This New London villa, a spacious 8-bedroom home, is conveniently located within a 10-minute walk of Pequot Chapel, Mitchell College, and the New London Harbor Light, with Monte Cristo Cottage and Green Harbor Beach less than a mile away.
This 14-bedroom, 4-bathroom property sleeps up to 22 guests and boasts a fitness center, swimming pool, and a fully equipped kitchen with modern appliances, plus free Wi-Fi, a terrace, and a garden.

Search Coastal Vacation Rentals near Fishers Island, NY

Discover relaxing coastal properties with these seaside vacation rentals in Fishers Island, NY, located near the shore for an ideal beach-town escape.

Waterfront - Harbor View Landing - The Mystic - Second Floor Only - Fishers Island, NY
10 83 reviews

Waterfront - Harbor View Landing - The Mystic - Second Floor Only

apartment, Groton
Noank Tranquil Waterfront - Fishers Island, NY
10 15 reviews

Noank Tranquil Waterfront

apartment, Groton
Waterfront Cottage - Harbor View Landing - Mystic, Ct - Fishers Island, NY
10 250 reviews

Waterfront Cottage - Harbor View Landing - Mystic, Ct

apartment, Groton
New Cozy Coastal Retreat! - Fishers Island, NY
8.7 27 reviews

New Cozy Coastal Retreat!

house, Groton

Top-Rated 5-Star Vacation Rentals in Fishers Island, NY

Discover the best of the coast with a luxury vacation rental in Fishers Island, NY, offering sophisticated rooms and prime locations.

Cozy Bungalow Just Minutes From Mystic, Westerly Beaches, Boating And Casinos! Bungalow - Fishers Island, NY
9.4 71 reviews

Cozy Bungalow Just Minutes From Mystic, Westerly Beaches, Boating And Casinos! Bungalow

house, Groton

Best Vacation Rentals with a Steam Room in Fishers Island, NY

Recover properly with on-site sauna access, a standard feature at these premier Fishers Island, NY vacation rentals.

Elevate Your New England  Beach Retreat Experience - Fishers Island, NY
9.9 146 reviews

Elevate Your New England Beach Retreat Experience

apartment, Groton
New! Updated Mystic Home W/ Sauna, Hot Tub & Deck - Fishers Island, NY
10 44 reviews

New! Updated Mystic Home W/ Sauna, Hot Tub & Deck

apartment, Groton
©2026 cozycozy.com