Vacation rentals in Kelleys Island, OH

127 available vacation rental offers

7 nights
2
1
  • airbnb
  • booking
  • vrbo
  • expedia
  • sonder
  • priceline
  • tripadvisor
  • tripcom
  • homestay
  • hotelscom
  • orbitz
  • vacasa
Kelleys Island, OH vacation rentals
Choose the perfect vacation accommodation
Price per night
Accommodation type
Rating

Best Vacation rentals and Airbnb offers in Kelleys Island, OH

Best family friendly Kelleys Island, OH vacation rentals

Among the 127 accommodations in Kelleys Island, OH, here are the 4 best family friendly rentals

New Lakeside Cottage Sleeps 16 Includes Golf Cart Walk To Lake And Near Pool - Kelleys Island, OH
10 93 reviews

New Lakeside Cottage Sleeps 16 Includes Golf Cart Walk To Lake And Near Pool

apartment, Marblehead
This Lakeside cottage rental in Marblehead, Ohio, is a new build conveniently located near Cedar Point amusement park and Kalahari Waterpark.
The three-bedroom, four-bathroom home sleeps sixteen guests and boasts a fully equipped kitchen with dishwasher, laundry facilities, an ice maker, and a unique lobster pot, plus a yard and parking.
Spacious First-floor Cottage Nestled Between Lakeside And Marblehead! - Kelleys Island, OH
10 33 reviews

Spacious First-floor Cottage Nestled Between Lakeside And Marblehead!

apartment, Lakeside
This Lakeside vacation home is located just 0.7 miles from Lake Erie and within 3 miles of Marblehead Lighthouse State Park and Marblehead Lighthouse, offering easy access to scenic walks, historical sites, and outdoor activities. Guests consistently rate this property as excellent, praising its peaceful setting and convenient location.
This 1-bedroom, 1-bathroom property can accommodate up to 4 guests, and features a fully equipped kitchen, a washing machine, and free WiFi. Enjoy stunning lake views from the patio, relax in the garden, or take advantage of the barbecue grill for outdoor dining.
Cherry On Top! 2-bedroom House In South Lakeside! Great Porch And Outdoor Space! - Kelleys Island, OH
9.6 39 reviews

Cherry On Top! 2-bedroom House In South Lakeside! Great Porch And Outdoor Space!

apartment, Lakeside
This Marblehead vacation rental is conveniently located near South Lakeside, five minutes from the Kelley's Island Ferry, fifteen minutes from the Jet Express, and a short drive from Cedar Point.
The two-bedroom house features a queen bed and two full beds, accommodating four guests, and includes a full kitchen with a fridge, microwave, and dishwasher, a washer/dryer, air conditioning, a terrace, parking, and boat trailer parking.
Lake Erie Relaxing Getaway Clubhouse Sauna Pool - Kelleys Island, OH
10 1 review

Lake Erie Relaxing Getaway Clubhouse Sauna Pool

apartment, Marblehead
This Marblehead vacation home, part of the "Resort Living" offer, is conveniently located near Lakeside Daisy State Nature Preserve (a 7-minute walk) and Lake Erie (a 1-minute drive), offering easy access to Cedar Point and other attractions.
The three-bedroom, two-bathroom house sleeps eight guests and features a well-equipped kitchen, in-house laundry, a private terrace, swimming pool, and covered parking; nearby watersports include jet skiing and parasailing.

Best Kelleys Island, OH vacation rentals with a pool

Among the 127 accommodations in Kelleys Island, OH, here are the 4 best rentals with a pool

223 Walnut Ave. In Lakeside - Kelleys Island, OH
No reviews

223 Walnut Ave. In Lakeside

cottage, Lakeside
This Lakeside Chautauqua vacation home is located less than a block from the Hoover Building, offering easy access to Lakeside's shops and restaurants and proximity to Lake Erie.
This five-bedroom, three-bathroom house boasts 2,450 square feet of space, accommodating up to 18 guests with a fully equipped kitchen including a dishwasher, a swimming pool, and is close to attractions like Sports Force Parks and Cedar Point.
Lvi Suite 15 - Studio Apartment In The Heart Of Lakeside - Kelleys Island, OH
10 1 review

Lvi Suite 15 - Studio Apartment In The Heart Of Lakeside

studio, Lakeside
This studio suite, part of the Historic Lakeview Inn, is situated in Lakeside, just 500 feet from Lakeside Beach and within easy walking distance of downtown Lakeside and Lake Erie.
This 660 square foot accommodation accommodates up to three guests and features a full kitchen with a fridge, microwave, and dishwasher, air conditioning, shared porches with lake views, and parking.
344 Maple In Lakeside - Kelleys Island, OH
No reviews

344 Maple In Lakeside

cottage, Lakeside
This Lakeside Chautauqua cottage, located near Hoover Auditorium and a short walk from Lakeside's downtown, offers easy access to area attractions and events.
This 2290-square-foot home features seven bedrooms, two bathrooms, and can comfortably accommodate up to sixteen guests, boasting amenities such as a swimming pool, dishwasher, and charcoal grill, plus two cable TVs and a DVD player.
502 Walnut In Lakeside - Kelleys Island, OH
No reviews

502 Walnut In Lakeside

cottage, Lakeside
This Lakeside Chautauqua cottage on Walnut Street is conveniently located near downtown shops, Hoover Auditorium, and a short walk from the beach, dock, and new aquatic center.
This 860-square-foot lakeside house sleeps six, offering two bedrooms, one bathroom, a fully equipped kitchen with a gas grill, a fenced backyard, a swimming pool, three window air conditioning units, in-unit laundry, and a four-passenger golf cart for exploring.

Frequently Asked Questions about vacation rentals in Kelleys Island, OH

  • What are the must-see sights on Kelleys Island, Ohio?

    Kelleys Island boasts some incredible sights! The Glacial Grooves are a must-see, showcasing massive grooves carved into the bedrock by glaciers. You should also visit the Kelleys Island State Park, offering stunning Lake Erie views and hiking trails. Finally, the historic Kelleys Island Lighthouse provides a glimpse into the island's maritime past.
  • What are the best Airbnb and vacation rentals in Kelleys Island, OH?

  • Are there unique natural phenomena on Kelleys Island, Ohio?

    Absolutely! The Glacial Grooves are a unique geological feature, a testament to the power of the Ice Age glaciers. The island's diverse birdlife, particularly during migration seasons, is another noteworthy natural phenomenon. The varied plant life, reflecting the island's unique ecosystem, is also worth exploring.
  • What are the most popular Airbnbs in Kelleys Island, OH?

  • What essentials should you bring along for a trip to Kelleys Island, Ohio?

    Pack comfortable walking shoes for exploring the trails and exploring the island. Sunscreen and insect repellent are crucial, especially during the warmer months. Don't forget a hat and sunglasses for sun protection. Binoculars are great for birdwatching. Finally, a camera is a must to capture the stunning scenery.
  • What are the best vacation rentals with a pool in Kelleys Island, OH?

  • What is the average daily budget you should plan for (accommodation, food, transportation, activities) on Kelleys Island, Ohio?

    A daily budget of $150-$300 per person is a reasonable estimate. This includes accommodation (ranging from camping to more upscale options), meals at local restaurants, ferry transportation, and entry fees for attractions. Costs can be lower if you opt for camping or pack your own lunches.
  • What are the best rentals for families and kids in Kelleys Island, OH?

  • Where can you find the best restaurants serving local dishes on Kelleys Island, Ohio, and what are the must-try specialties?

    The island has a few restaurants offering delicious fare. The Kelleys Island Brewery is a popular choice, offering local brews and pub food. Other establishments offer fresh seafood dishes, reflecting the island's location on Lake Erie. There aren't specific, regionally unique 'must-try' dishes exclusive to Kelleys Island itself.
  • What are the best rentals or Airbnbs with a jacuzzi in Kelleys Island, OH?

  • What are some less-famous attractions on Kelleys Island, Ohio that are worth the visit?

    Explore the various hiking trails beyond the state park; some less-traveled paths offer beautiful views and a peaceful escape. Take a walk along the shoreline; you might discover hidden coves and interesting rock formations. Consider visiting the small local shops for unique souvenirs.
  • What are the best activities for engaging with locals and understanding their culture on Kelleys Island, Ohio?

    Striking up conversations with locals at the restaurants or shops is a great way to learn about the island's culture. Attend any community events that might be happening during your visit. Simply spending time exploring the island and engaging with the relaxed atmosphere will give you a sense of the island's unique community feel.
  • What unique natural landscapes and terrain features can travelers explore on Kelleys Island, Ohio?

    The dramatic limestone cliffs along the shoreline are a striking feature. The diverse vegetation, ranging from forests to coastal grasslands, provides varied landscapes to explore. The Glacial Grooves are a unique geological formation worth seeing. The relatively flat interior of the island offers easy walking and biking.
  • How many days are ideal for visiting Kelleys Island, Ohio, and what are some itinerary suggestions?

    Two days is a good amount of time to explore the island at a leisurely pace. Day one could focus on the Glacial Grooves, Kelleys Island State Park, and the lighthouse. Day two could involve exploring the less-traveled trails, relaxing on the beach, and enjoying the local restaurants. A single day is possible, but a longer stay allows for more in-depth exploration.
  • How is the weather on Kelleys Island, Ohio, in high season?

    Kelleys Island's high season (summer) typically sees warm temperatures, often in the 70s and 80s Fahrenheit, with plenty of sunshine. However, Lake Erie breezes can provide some relief from the heat. Be prepared for occasional showers, so packing layers is recommended.

Nearby regions

Best Kelleys Island, OH vacation rentals with a balcony

Historic Lakeside Cottage Close To Downtown. - Kelleys Island, OH
9.6 26 reviews

Historic Lakeside Cottage Close To Downtown.

cottage, Lakeside
This Lakeside cottage is located just 0.2 miles from Lake Erie, close to the Marblehead Lighthouse and State Park, offering easy access to the beautiful shoreline and scenic views. The cottage has received excellent user ratings.
The lakeside retreat has two bedrooms and can accommodate up to six guests. It offers a range of amenities, including a fitness center, tennis court, swimming pool, and a terrace, perfect for enjoying the peaceful surroundings.
Lake Escape Ultimate Getaway Clubhouse Sauna Pool - Kelleys Island, OH
10 1 review

Lake Escape Ultimate Getaway Clubhouse Sauna Pool

apartment, Marblehead
This Marblehead condo offers direct Lake Erie access, placing guests within walking distance of the lake and a short drive to Cedar Point and Kalahari Waterpark Resort.
This 15,070 sq ft residence accommodates 10 guests with 3 bedrooms and 2 bathrooms, featuring a private seasonal pool, clubhouse with gym and sauna, fully stocked kitchen, and a tiki bar.
Didi's House-miley Drive - Kelleys Island, OH
9.9 176 reviews

Didi's House-miley Drive

apartment, Lakeside
This family-friendly vacation home is located in Marblehead, Ohio, just a short distance from Lake Erie, The Keeper’s House, and Sandusky Bay. The house consistently receives excellent ratings for its location, cleanliness, and overall experience.
This 4-bedroom, 2-bathroom home offers 1880 square feet of space and can comfortably accommodate up to 10 guests. Enjoy a relaxing stay with amenities like a swimming pool, spa, and a fully equipped kitchen, and take advantage of the nearby attractions like the Watering Hole Safari and Waterpark.
Spacious Lakeside Cottage - 2 Miles To Marblehead! - Kelleys Island, OH
9.2 73 reviews

Spacious Lakeside Cottage - 2 Miles To Marblehead!

house, Lakeside
This Lakeside house is conveniently located just 2 miles from Marblehead, 22 miles from Cedar Point, and 6.6 miles from African Safari Wildlife Park, offering easy access to popular attractions. The property enjoys excellent ratings for location, cleanliness, and overall user experience.
The house has 4 bedrooms and 2 bathrooms, spanning 1500 square feet, comfortably accommodating up to 12 guests. Enjoy a range of amenities, including a swimming pool, spa, fitness center, tennis court, and a fully equipped kitchen, ensuring a relaxing and enjoyable stay.

Neighborhoods and points of interest in Kelleys Island, OH

Best Kelleys Island, OH vacation rentals with parking

Spacious Cottage In Lakeside - Kelleys Island, OH
No reviews

Spacious Cottage In Lakeside

apartment, Lakeside
This newly upgraded cottage is located within the exclusive Lakeside Chautauqua gated community in Northeast Ohio, offering proximity to the 3,000-seat Hoover Auditorium and the community's daily programming and nightly entertainment.
This 2-bedroom, 1-bathroom rental accommodates up to 6 guests and features a fully equipped kitchen, smart TV, an all-season front porch with a daybed, and a large screened-in back porch, with ample off-street parking available from two avenues.
Cozy Anchor Cottage - Kelleys Island, OH
9.9 30 reviews

Cozy Anchor Cottage

apartment, Lakeside
Cozy Anchor Cottage sits just outside Lakeside, Ohio's gates, steps from Marblehead Village and minutes from Lake Erie.
This three-bedroom, one-bathroom lakeside house sleeps six, features a fully equipped kitchen with dishwasher, in-unit laundry, air conditioning, ample outdoor space including a deck, patios, fire pit, and grill, plus private parking for multiple vehicles.
The Island Retreat On Kelleys Is - Kelleys Island, OH
10 43 reviews

The Island Retreat On Kelleys Is

house, Kelleys Island
This newly built retreat on Kelleys Island is located on a quiet dead-end street, just a short walk from the Kelleys Island Winery and a quick drive to the downtown area and ferry dock. The peaceful setting offers privacy and tranquility while still being conveniently close to island attractions.
The spacious vacation home can comfortably accommodate up to 10 guests, with a dedicated kids' room featuring a foosball table. Enjoy modern amenities, a large deck with a bar and TV, a private garden, and ample parking for multiple vehicles.
Memory Manor - Kelleys Island, OH
9.6 177 reviews

Memory Manor

apartment, Kelleys Island
Memory Manor is a charming cottage located in a peaceful neighborhood just a mile from Kelleys Island town and two blocks from the lake. The cottage has consistently received excellent ratings for location, cleanliness, and overall user experience.
This three-bedroom, two-bathroom vacation rental comfortably sleeps up to seven guests. Enjoy modern amenities like central air conditioning, a full kitchen, and satellite TV, along with a spacious deck, gas grill, and fire ring for outdoor dining and relaxation.
©2026 cozycozy.com