Compare vacation rentals in New Plymouth, OH from 100+ sites!
Find the best offers in New Plymouth, OH
Choose the perfect vacation accommodation
Price per night
Accommodation type
Rating
Best Vacation rentals and Airbnb offers in New Plymouth, OH
10 31 reviews
New Plymouth, OH
10/18 – 10/20
$415/nighttotal: $830 (2 )
The Night Owl Nest Modern Retreat In Hocking Hills
1 4
apartment , Zaleski
This woodland escape is located in Hocking Hills, Ohio, just minutes from Old Man's Cave and Ash Cave. This 3-bedroom, 1-bathroom cabin sleeps 6 guests and features a private hot tub, a game room with a pool table and Infinity Gaming Table, and a modern kitchen with a coffee bar.
9.6 56 reviews
New Plymouth, OH
10/18 – 10/20
$388/nighttotal: $776 (2 )
Frog Hollow At Hocking Vacations
2 4
house , Logan
This recently renovated Logan, Ohio vacation home is located 9 miles from the Hocking Hills Golf Club and 50 miles from Rickenbacker International Airport, offering easy access to both golfing and the airport. This 900-square-foot house features two bedrooms, two bathrooms, a jacuzzi, and can comfortably accommodate six guests; amenities include free Wi-Fi, parking, a barbecue, and a private patio with an outdoor fireplace.
9.8 153 reviews
New Plymouth, OH
10/18 – 10/20
$224/nighttotal: $448 (2 )
Secluded Log Cabin With Premium Hot Tub Under Gazebo
1 4
cabin , Haydenville
The Beech Tree Burrow cabin is located just outside Logan, Ohio, on a secluded 45-acre property, offering peace and quiet away from the hustle and bustle. This highly-rated cabin receives excellent reviews from previous guests. The one-bedroom cabin comfortably sleeps up to 6 guests and features a family-friendly layout with a bunk room for children and a loft space. Enjoy the spacious hot tub under the gazebo, roast marshmallows around the fire pit, and take advantage of the fully equipped kitchen, including a Blackstone Griddle.
9.8 359 reviews
New Plymouth, OH
10/18 – 10/20
$268/nighttotal: $536 (2 )
Cabin On 100 Secluded Acres-hocking Hills, Oh
3 4
cabin , Zaleski
The Stargazer cabin is located in Zaleski State Forest, Ohio, near Ash Cave, Old Man's Cave, and Lake Hope State Park, offering easy access to hiking, biking trails, and other outdoor activities. This three-bedroom, one-bathroom lodge sleeps six, features a fully equipped kitchen, jacuzzi, and fire pit, and provides access to horseback riding, kayaking, and archery nearby.
9.9 166 reviews
New Plymouth, OH
10/18 – 10/20
$1367/nighttotal: $2734 (2 )
Majestic Lodge Epic Game Room, Hot Tub Soaks & Movie Nights In Hocking Hills
5 4
chalet , Zaleski
This 4,800 square foot lodge is located just minutes from the attractions of Hocking Hills State Park, a popular destination in Zaleski, Ohio. The property has received excellent ratings for location, cleanliness, and overall user experience. The cabin comfortably accommodates up to 14 guests in its five bedrooms and three bathrooms. Enjoy a private hot tub, a movie theater, a game room, a half basketball court, a fireplace, and a fully equipped kitchen with a dishwasher, microwave, and refrigerator.
9.5 65 reviews
New Plymouth, OH
10/18 – 10/20
$336/nighttotal: $672 (2 )
The Walden At Harble Ridge - Newly Renovated, 2 Bedroom, Hot Tub, Pond, Fire Pit
2 4
cabin , Logan
This family-friendly cabin is located in Logan, Ohio, just a short distance from The Perfect Touch Massage & Traveling Spa and Hocking Hills State Park, and within a 5km radius of Cedar Falls. It has received excellent ratings for user experience, location, and cleanliness. The 800-square-foot cabin has 2 bedrooms, 1 bathroom, and can accommodate up to 6 guests. Amenities include a fully equipped kitchen, a Jacuzzi, a garden, a fireplace, free WiFi, and a DVD player.
10 31 reviews
New Plymouth, OH
10/18 – 10/20
$354/nighttotal: $708 (2 )
Meadows Edge -In The Heart Of The Hocking Hills!
3 4
apartment , Zaleski
This family-friendly apartment is located in New Plymouth, a short drive from R Adventure Park and Brass Ring Golf Club, with Hocking Valley Scenic Railway and Adventure Golf at Rempel's Grove also nearby. This retreat features 3 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms, and accommodates up to 8 guests with a kitchen including a fridge, microwave, and dishwasher, plus air conditioning, a jacuzzi, and parking.
9.5 2 reviews
New Plymouth, OH
10/18 – 10/20
$520/nighttotal: $1040 (2 )
Havenbrook-hocking Hills Luxury, 10 Acres, Hot Tub
4 4
house , Zaleski
This Zaleski house rental, near New Plymouth, Ohio, boasts a secluded 10-acre setting 16 miles from the Brass Ring Golf Club and 54 miles from Rickenbacker International Airport. The 1750-square-foot property features two bedrooms, two bathrooms, and accommodates up to 15 guests, offering a Jacuzzi, a fireplace, free Wi-Fi, and a fully equipped kitchen including a dishwasher.
This cabin on Cherry Ridge Road in Haydenville offers a secluded mountain setting with private hiking trails and a hot tub, located a short drive from popular parks and outdoor adventure destinations. This 3-bedroom, 2-bathroom lodge accommodates up to 6 guests and features a fully stocked kitchen, air conditioning, internet, a game room with a pool table, and a front porch swing.
10 21 reviews
New Plymouth, OH
10/18 – 10/20
$302/nighttotal: $604 (2 )
Located Behind A Tree Filled Garden Near Our Horse Barn And Farm Sanctuary.
1 4
cabin , Zaleski
This Zaleski cabin offers easy access to Wayne National Forest's Athens Unit, Hocking Hills State Park (9 miles away), and Lake Hope State Park. The one-bedroom, one-bathroom cottage sleeps six, features a fully equipped kitchen, Jacuzzi, and private garden with BBQ grills, perfect for exploring the area's natural beauty.
9.5 58 reviews
New Plymouth, OH
10/18 – 10/20
$210/nighttotal: $420 (2 )
Buckrun Cabin
1 4
cabin , Haydenville
This secluded Haydenville Hocking Hills retreat offers complete privacy near Hocking Hills State Park and its numerous waterfalls, providing a tranquil escape. This four-bedroom, one-bathroom lodge sleeps eight guests and features a full kitchen with dishwasher, a jacuzzi, a spacious deck with a hot tub and fire pit, two private lakes with a canoe, Starlink internet, and ample hiking trails on the property.
10 4 reviews
New Plymouth, OH
10/18 – 10/20
$263/nighttotal: $526 (2 )
Hocking Hills Cabin - Cluckingham - Pet Friendly!
1 4
cabin , Zaleski
This brand new Zaleski cabin is centrally located on State Route 93S in the Village of Mt. Pleasant, placing it within 5 miles of Hocking Hills attractions like Ash Cave and Old Man's Cave, and a 20-minute drive to Lake Hope and Zaleski State Forest. This pet-friendly lodge accommodates up to 6 guests with 2 bathrooms, a full kitchen including a fridge, freezer, and microwave, air conditioning, high-speed Wi-Fi, and a garden with a firepit and BBQ grill, offering Roku TVs and individually controlled heating and cooling for personalized comfort.
Our Favorite Family-Friendly Vacation Rentals in New Plymouth, OH
Booking a family-oriented vacation rental in New Plymouth, OH keeps you close to top city attractions for a stress-free getaway.
9.8 176 reviews
New Plymouth, OH
10/18 – 10/20
$456/nighttotal: $912 (2 )
Private, Cozy And Close To Everything!
1 4
cabin , Zaleski
This Zaleski cabin rental is located in the Appalachian foothills, 4.1 miles from Hocking Hills State Park, providing easy access to Cedar Falls and Old Man's Cave. The two-bedroom, one-bathroom lodge sleeps six, boasting a fully equipped kitchen, private hot tub, fire pit, and fast Wi-Fi; enjoy grilling and outdoor dining amidst a five-acre wooded setting.
9.4 22 reviews
New Plymouth, OH
10/18 – 10/20
$348/nighttotal: $696 (2 )
New Listing-- Hocking Hills Modern Cabin
2 4
cabin , Logan
This modern 1,500-square-foot Hocking Hills lodge is located ten miles from the Brass Ring Golf Club in Logan, Ohio, and fifty miles from Rickenbacker International Airport, offering easy access to both golfing and regional attractions. The two-bedroom, three-bathroom retreat comfortably sleeps fifteen guests and features a fully equipped kitchen, a hot tub, a private balcony, free Wi-Fi, and free parking.
8.4 12 reviews
New Plymouth, OH
10/18 – 10/20
$352/nighttotal: $704 (2 )
Cozy Secluded Cabin For Family In The Heart Of Hocking Hills Hot Tub Retreat
3 4
cabin , Logan
This Logan, Ohio cabin rental is conveniently located 2.5 miles from the Ohio Operating Engineers Logan Training Center and within 6 miles of Hocking Hills State Park, offering easy access to attractions like Cedar Falls and The Perfect Touch Massage & Traveling Spa. This 1950-square-foot house sleeps eight guests and features three bedrooms, two bathrooms, a fully equipped kitchen with a dishwasher, laundry facilities, a fireplace, and a smart TV, perfect for families or groups visiting Hocking Hills.
9.9 139 reviews
New Plymouth, OH
10/18 – 10/20
$487/nighttotal: $974 (2 )
Lodge On 100 Secluded Acres In Hocking Hills
4 4
chalet , Zaleski
Escape to the tranquil Zaleski State Forest and enjoy a secluded getaway at this spacious 4-bedroom vacation home. Just 0.1 mi from the forest and within 6 mi of Hocking Hills State Park, this retreat offers an excellent location with top ratings for user experience, location, and cleanliness. The 3000-square-foot home boasts a fully equipped kitchen, cozy fireplace, spa tub, barbecue grills, and a private garden. With ample room for up to 14 guests, it's perfect for families or groups seeking a peaceful escape with plenty of amenities and activities.
Best New Plymouth, OH vacation rentals with parking
New Plymouth, OH
10/18 – 10/20
$522/nighttotal: $1044 (2 )
Belmont At Arcadia Hills Luxury Couples Cabin
1 4
cabin , Zaleski
This secluded cabin in New Plymouth is situated 15 miles from Brass Ring Golf Club and 57 miles from Rickenbacker International Airport. This 1000 square foot cabin accommodates up to 7 guests with 1 bedroom, 1 bathroom, air conditioning, and a full kitchen featuring a fridge, microwave, and dishwasher, plus complimentary Wi-Fi and parking.
9.8 118 reviews
New Plymouth, OH
10/18 – 10/20
$288/nighttotal: $576 (2 )
Spacious Log Cabin With Hot Tub, Fire Pit, Large Decks & Wood Fireplace
3 4
cabin , Haydenville
This three-story Haydenville lodge is situated in rural Logan County, Ohio, near Hocking Hills State Park (a 20-minute drive from Old Man's Cave). The 1970-square-foot retreat boasts three bedrooms, two bathrooms, sleeps ten, and includes a fully equipped kitchen, jacuzzi, expansive decks, a wood-burning fireplace, and outdoor amenities like a Blackstone griddle and fire ring.
9.8 13 reviews
New Plymouth, OH
10/18 – 10/20
$235/nighttotal: $470 (2 )
Cabin On 100 Secluded Acres In Hocking Hills
3 4
cabin , Zaleski
This Zaleski-area cabin, near Athens, Ohio, offers direct access to Wayne National Forest's Athens Unit and is within six miles of Zaleski State Forest, Stone Valley Ranch, and Lake Hope State Park. The three-bedroom, one-bathroom lodge sleeps six, features a full kitchen with refrigerator and microwave, a Jacuzzi, private patio, and is pet-friendly with Wi-Fi access.
New Plymouth, OH
10/18 – 10/20
$426/nighttotal: $852 (2 )
5-acre Hocking Hills Hideaway! Pet-friendly Home
3 4
apartment , Zaleski
This New Plymouth vacation home is located 8 miles from Hocking Hills State Park and within 15 to 18 miles of Lake Hope and Lake Logan, offering access to cliffs, caves, waterfalls, and lakes. This 1800 sq ft apartment accommodates up to 6 guests with 3 bedrooms and features a seasonal outdoor pool, hot tub, deck, fire pit, and is pet-friendly with a fee.
Frequently Asked Questions about vacation rentals in New Plymouth, OH
What sports or outdoor activites can visitors enjoy in and around New Plymouth, OH?
The Clear Fork River is great for kayaking and canoeing, and there are several fishing spots along its banks. If you're looking for something more active, the Mohican State Park, just a short drive from New Plymouth, offers hiking, camping, and horseback riding.
What are the best Airbnb and vacation rentals in New Plymouth, OH?
What other towns or cities can be easily accessed from New Plymouth, OH?
Mansfield is about 15 minutes away and is a larger city with more restaurants and shops. You can also easily drive to Ashland, which is about 30 minutes away and has a historic downtown area and a university.
What are the most popular Airbnbs in New Plymouth, OH?
What amenities are commonly available in vacation rentals in New Plymouth, OH?
Vacation rentals in New Plymouth typically offer basic amenities like a kitchen, bathroom, and bedrooms. Some rentals may also have a fireplace, a hot tub, or a patio. Most rentals are located in quiet, rural settings.
What are the best vacation rentals with a pool in New Plymouth, OH?
What time of year is best to rent a vacation rental New Plymouth, OH?
The best time to visit New Plymouth is in the fall, when the leaves change color and the weather is mild. Spring is also a nice time to visit, as the weather is warm and the flowers are in bloom. Summer can be hot and humid, but it's a great time to enjoy outdoor activities.
What are the best rentals for families and kids in New Plymouth, OH?
Find the Best Vacation Rentals with Balconies in New Plymouth, OH
Wake up to breathtaking views at these New Plymouth, OH vacation rentals with balconies, perfect for your morning coffee.
10 11 reviews
New Plymouth, OH
10/18 – 10/20
$1284/nighttotal: $2568 (2 )
Cherry Ridge Retreat Luxury Cabins
4 4
cabin , Haydenville
The Cherry Ridge Retreat Luxury Cabins are located in New Plymouth, Ohio, about 16.1 km from the Brass Ring Golf Club and offer a peaceful escape from the hustle and bustle of city life. These cabins have consistently received excellent ratings for location, cleanliness, and overall user experience. Each cabin features a private hot tub, a well-equipped kitchen, and a private patio with garden views. You can enjoy modern amenities like free WiFi and satellite TV, as well as outdoor activities like hiking and fishing in the surrounding area.
9.9 10 reviews
New Plymouth, OH
10/18 – 10/20
$1203/nighttotal: $2406 (2 )
The Quana - Hot Tub, Fire Pit, And Huge Entertainment Area
4 4
house , Haydenville
This brand-new Haydenville cabin, near Logan, Ohio, is 6.2 miles from the Hocking Hills Golf Club and 52 miles from Rickenbacker International Airport. This 2,550-square-foot lodge boasts four bedrooms, three bathrooms, and sleeps up to 27 guests, featuring a fully equipped kitchen, jacuzzi, terrace, free Wi-Fi, and parking, plus amenities like table tennis and barbecue facilities.
9.8 43 reviews
New Plymouth, OH
10/18 – 10/20
$663/nighttotal: $1326 (2 )
Modern Farmhouse: 30 Private Acres + King Bed + Hot Tub
4 4
farm , Zaleski
This gîte is located in a peaceful rural setting, just outside of Zaleski. It is surrounded by scenic countryside and is just 6 miles from Hocking Hills State Park. The gîte has received excellent ratings for its location, cleanliness, and user experience. The gîte has four bedrooms, three bathrooms, and a floor area of 2500 square feet. It can accommodate up to 11 guests. The gîte has a fully equipped kitchen, air conditioning, a Jacuzzi, a terrace, a balcony, a garden, and parking. Guests can enjoy a variety of activities and amenities, including hiking, biking, fishing, and swimming.
10 46 reviews
New Plymouth, OH
10/18 – 10/20
$600/nighttotal: $1200 (2 )
Authentic Log Cabin - Sleeps 10 - Hot Tub - Fire Pit - Hocking Hills
3 4
cabin , Haydenville
This Haydenville cabin rental, near Logan, Ohio, is less than 15 miles from Hocking Hills State Park attractions like Old Man's Cave and Ash Cave. This 1990-square-foot lodge boasts three bedrooms, two bathrooms, sleeps ten, and features a full kitchen, game room, hot tub, fire pits, and two decks on five private acres.
Top Dog-Friendly Vacation Rentals in New Plymouth, OH
Stay in a pet-friendly vacation rental in New Plymouth, OH situated near dog parks and city walks, ensuring a comfortable stay for both you and your pet.
9.8 122 reviews
New Plymouth, OH
10/18 – 10/20
$556/nighttotal: $1112 (2 )
Hobbit Inspired Fairytale Hocking Hills State Park 3 Mi Away Pet Friendly
1 4
apartment , Zaleski
This vacation home is located in Creola and offers a peaceful retreat in the heart of nature, with Wayne National Forest Athens Unit right at your doorstep and Hocking Hills State Park within a short drive. It has excellent user, location, and cleanliness ratings. The vacation home features a cozy fireplace, a fully equipped kitchenette, a Smart TV, and a floor area of 380 square feet. It has one bedroom, one bathroom, and a guest capacity of four. Guests can unwind in the sauna or fire up the barbecue grills for a memorable outdoor experience.
10 12 reviews
New Plymouth, OH
10/18 – 10/20
$489/nighttotal: $978 (2 )
Hill Yea! Deck Fireplace + Hot Tub + Dog Run + Ev
2 4
cabin , Zaleski
This lodge is located in Hocking Hills, 5 miles from Ash Cave and 12 miles from Old Man's Cave. This pet-friendly cabin accommodates up to 6 guests with 2 bedrooms and 1 bathroom, featuring a hot tub, a game room with a Pac-Man arcade game, and an EV charger.
9.6 19 reviews
New Plymouth, OH
10/18 – 10/20
$429/nighttotal: $858 (2 )
Frog Hollow At Hocking Vacations
2 4
apartment , Logan
This Logan vacation home, situated 2.3 miles from the Ohio Operating Engineers Logan Training Center and within 9 miles of Hocking Hills State Park, offers a peaceful rural setting near popular attractions. This 900-square-foot house features two bedrooms, two bathrooms, accommodates four guests, and includes amenities such as a Jacuzzi, a terrace, a fully equipped kitchen, free Wi-Fi, and outdoor grills.
10 15 reviews
New Plymouth, OH
10/18 – 10/20
$465/nighttotal: $930 (2 )
Aladdin Inspired Fairytale Cabin Hot Tub 3 Miles From Hocking Hills State Park
1 4
apartment , Zaleski
This troglodyte is located in Creola, just 3 miles from Hocking Hills State Park, offering easy access to the natural beauty of the area. The troglodyte has received excellent user ratings, indicating a positive experience for previous guests. The unique adobe accommodation features a kitchenette, a queen bed, and a cedar wood hot tub with stunning views. The troglodyte also boasts a sauna pod, a smart TV, Wi-Fi, a fire pit, and proximity to local attractions, making it a perfect choice for a relaxing and adventurous getaway.
