Compare vacation rentals in Sister Bay, WI from 100+ sites!

181 available vacation rental offers

7 nights
2
1
  • airbnb
  • booking
  • vrbo
  • expedia
  • sonder
  • priceline
  • tripadvisor
  • tripcom
  • homestay
  • hotelscom
  • orbitz
  • vacasa
Sister Bay, WI vacation rentals
Choose the perfect vacation accommodation
Price per night
Accommodation type
Rating

Best Vacation rentals and Airbnb offers in Sister Bay, WI

Find Vacation Rentals in Downtown of Sister Bay, WI

Choose a downtown Sister Bay, WI vacation rental for easy sightseeing. Compare the top centrally located properties and book your city stay with confidence.

The Cotter Cottage-sister Bay - Sister Bay, WI
9.7 104 reviews

The Cotter Cottage-sister Bay

apartment, Sister Bay
The Cotter Cottage is located in downtown Sister Bay, just a 5-minute walk from the beach, Al Johnson's Swedish Restaurant, and other popular spots. It consistently receives excellent ratings for location, cleanliness, and overall user experience. This charming vacation home offers ample space for families or groups, spanning 2,400 square feet with four bedrooms and three bathrooms. The cottage provides everything you need for a comfortable stay, including a fully equipped kitchen, air conditioning, a terrace, a garden, and parking, plus it's pet-friendly.
Mill Road Place #1 - Sister Bay, WI
9.9 57 reviews

Mill Road Place #1

apartment, Sister Bay
This Sister Bay apartment is located on Mill Road, just a half block from Bayshore Drive in downtown Sister Bay, putting you within walking distance of shops, restaurants, and the waterfront. It has excellent user, location, and cleanliness ratings.
The apartment has two bedrooms and three bathrooms, comfortably accommodating up to six guests. It offers a modern kitchen with stainless steel appliances, a fireplace, a private patio, a bike rack, and a propane grill for outdoor cooking.
Bay Blue In Downtown Sister Bay - Sister Bay, WI
8.7 6 reviews

Bay Blue In Downtown Sister Bay

apartment, Sister Bay
This Sister Bay apartment rental is ideally situated between Al Johnson's Restaurant and Husby's Food & Spirits, offering easy access to Sister Bay's beach and shops.
The one-bedroom, one-bathroom unit sleeps three, features a full kitchen with microwave, fridge, and freezer, in-unit air conditioning, off-street parking, and welcomes one small, well-behaved dog (fee applies).
Alpaca Grand Vacation Rental - Sister Bay, WI
9.8 28 reviews

Alpaca Grand Vacation Rental

apartment, Sister Bay
The Alpaca Grand Vacation apartment is located above Alpaca to Apparel in Sister Bay, Wisconsin, offering easy access to the town's shops and restaurants.
This three-bedroom, one-bathroom rental sleeps nine guests and features a full kitchen, two large TVs (75" and 65"), gas fireplaces (living room and outdoor patio), and a sunroom.

Best Sister Bay, WI vacation rentals with air conditioning

#1downtown Spot | Walk To Beach, Hot Tub & Pets Ok - Sister Bay, WI
No reviews

#1downtown Spot | Walk To Beach, Hot Tub & Pets Ok

house, Sister Bay
This Sister Bay house is located on North Bay Shore Drive, steps from the beach, Al Johnson's restaurant, and Sister Bay Marina, with Seaquist Orchards a 4-minute drive away.
This family-friendly vacation rental accommodates up to 10 guests in 4 bedrooms, featuring a private hot tub, full kitchen, high-speed internet with streaming services, and allows up to 2 dogs for a fee.
Cherry Hill- Charming Sister Bay Home, Backyard Oasis, Hottub - Sister Bay, WI
9.3 3 reviews

Cherry Hill- Charming Sister Bay Home, Backyard Oasis, Hottub

house, Sister Bay
This Sister Bay house rental, located 1.6 miles from Sister Bay Beach and 12 miles from Cana Island Lighthouse, offers easy access to downtown shops and restaurants.
The 2640-square-foot home features four bedrooms, three bathrooms, accommodates up to 23 guests, and includes a fully equipped kitchen, hot tub, and private garden with a terrace offering bay views.
Cozy Retreat | Hottub, Firepit, Arcade Fun & Dogs! - Sister Bay, WI
9.8 30 reviews

Cozy Retreat | Hottub, Firepit, Arcade Fun & Dogs!

apartment, Sister Bay
This Sister Bay vacation home is conveniently located within one mile of Sister Bay Marina and Lake Michigan, and two miles from Waterfront Park and the Sister Bay Dog Park & Community Garden.
This 2,680-square-foot house features four bedrooms, three bathrooms, and sleeps eleven guests comfortably, boasting a jacuzzi, terrace, garden, and free Wi-Fi, plus a fully equipped kitchen and barbecue grills.
Fish Creek Beach House - Sister Bay, WI
9.8 33 reviews

Fish Creek Beach House

apartment
This Fish Creek apartment is located within walking distance of the town center, offering easy access to local shops, restaurants, and attractions. The apartment consistently receives excellent ratings for location, cleanliness, and overall experience.
The apartment features a unique floorplan with five bedrooms and a capacity for twelve guests. Guests can enjoy amenities like a fully equipped kitchen, a fire pit, a gas fireplace, a gas grill, and a private garden, making it an ideal choice for families or groups seeking a comfortable and convenient stay.

Frequently Asked Questions about vacation rentals in Sister Bay, WI

  • What are some interesting places to visit in or near Sister Bay, WI?

    You'll want to check out the Peninsula State Park, which is just a short drive from Sister Bay. There's a beautiful lighthouse there called Eagle Tower, and you can hike the trails and enjoy the stunning views of the bay. Also, the Sister Bay Historical Society Museum is a great place to learn about the history of the area.
  • What are the best Airbnb and vacation rentals in Sister Bay, WI?

    Harbor House - July Dates Just Became Available, Sister Bay Vintage Log Cabin and The Nordic Lodge are the most popular Airbnb and vacation rentals in Sister Bay, WI among travelers.

  • Which walking or cycling routes are the best in Sister Bay, WI?

    The most popular walking and biking route is the scenic Door County Coastal Bike Trail. It runs along the coast and offers beautiful views of the water. You can also check out the trails in Peninsula State Park, which offer a variety of options for all skill levels.
  • What are the most popular Airbnbs in Sister Bay, WI?

  • What sports or outdoor activites can visitors enjoy in and around Sister Bay, WI?

    Sister Bay is a great place for outdoor activities. You can go kayaking or paddleboarding on the bay, hiking in the nearby state parks, or fishing in the waters around the area. There's also a public beach in Sister Bay where you can relax and enjoy the sun.
  • What are the best vacation rentals with a pool in Sister Bay, WI?

  • What other towns or cities can be easily accessed from Sister Bay, WI?

    From Sister Bay, you can easily drive to nearby towns like Fish Creek, Ephraim, and Baileys Harbor. These towns offer a variety of shops, restaurants, and attractions. You can also take a ferry to Washington Island, which is known for its beautiful scenery and unique culture.
  • What are the best rentals for families and kids in Sister Bay, WI?

  • What amenities are commonly available in vacation rentals in Sister Bay, WI?

    Vacation rentals in Sister Bay usually come equipped with amenities like kitchens, bathrooms, bedrooms, and living areas. Many also offer additional features such as fireplaces, hot tubs, and decks. Some might even have private access to the beach or a dock.
  • What are the best rentals or Airbnbs with a jacuzzi in Sister Bay, WI?

    The best vacation rentals or Airbnb with a jacuzzi in Sister Bay, WI are The Nordic Lodge, Walk To Marina Hot Tub - Arcade & Pet-friendly and Spacious Family-friendly Cottage In Peaceful Woods.

  • What time of year is best to rent a vacation rental Sister Bay, WI?

    The best time to visit Sister Bay depends on your preferences. The summer months are popular for warm weather and outdoor activities, while the fall offers stunning foliage and a quieter atmosphere. Spring and early summer are great for fishing and enjoying the natural beauty of the area.
  • What are the local dishes in Sister Bay, WI region?

    You should try some fresh fish, like whitefish or perch, which are common in the area. Door County cherries are also a local favorite, and you can find them in pies, ice cream, and other desserts. And of course, you can't miss the famous Door County cherry pie!

Popular destinations

Top Vacation Rentals with Balconies in Sister Bay, WI

Wake up to breathtaking views at these Sister Bay, WI vacation rentals with balconies, perfect for your morning coffee.

Scandia- Secluded Home, Walk To Marina, Game Room & Hot Tub - Sister Bay, WI
10 2 reviews

Scandia- Secluded Home, Walk To Marina, Game Room & Hot Tub

house, Sister Bay
This Sister Bay home is just a short walk from the beach and a scenic drive from Cana Island Lighthouse, offering easy access to the area's natural beauty. The house itself is spacious and can comfortably accommodate up to 19 guests.
The home features a fully equipped kitchen, a private hot tub, and a fire pit for cozy evenings. You can also enjoy the private garden, balcony, and free Wi-Fi.
Waterfront Lake Michigan Tranquility Bay Getaway - Sister Bay, WI
8.6 15 reviews

Waterfront Lake Michigan Tranquility Bay Getaway

apartment, Sister Bay
This Sister Bay waterfront home, less than 0.1 miles from Lake Michigan and six miles from Sister Bay Beach and Pirate's Cove Adventure Golf, offers stunning lake views.
This 1000-square-foot vacation rental boasts three bedrooms, two bathrooms, sleeps six, and includes a spa, tennis court, and on-site arcade.
Centrally Located-home In Ephraim- Sleeps 8 - Sister Bay, WI
9.3 66 reviews

Centrally Located-home In Ephraim- Sleeps 8

cabin, Ephraim
This smoke-free cabin is located in a peaceful rural setting near Ephraim, just a mile from Eagle Harbor and Lake Michigan. It has earned excellent ratings for its location, cleanliness, and overall experience.
This two-bedroom, two-bathroom cabin comfortably accommodates up to eight guests. Enjoy a fully equipped kitchen, a terrace or balcony, free Wi-Fi, a DVD player, barbecue grills, and limited housekeeping services.
Peaceful,nature Retreat! Country Stroll To Pebble Beach! Close To Town. Charming - Sister Bay, WI
10 28 reviews

Peaceful,nature Retreat! Country Stroll To Pebble Beach! Close To Town. Charming

apartment, Sister Bay
This 850 sq ft, 2-bedroom condo is located in a private, wooded setting in Sister Bay, Wisconsin, just 2 miles from downtown attractions and a short walk to Pebble Beach, offering proximity to Cana Island Lighthouse and The Skyway Drive-In Theatre.
This family-friendly unit features air conditioning, a full kitchen, internet, a swimming pool, a spa, and parking, accommodating up to 4 guests with a check-out time of 11:00 AM.

Neighborhoods and points of interest in Sister Bay, WI

Discover Family-Friendly Vacation Rentals in Sister Bay, WI

These kid-friendly vacation rentals in Sister Bay, WI keep you close to top city attractions for a stress-free family vacation.

The Deckhouse | Water Views, Walk Downtown, Sauna - Sister Bay, WI
10 23 reviews

The Deckhouse | Water Views, Walk Downtown, Sauna

house, Ephraim
The Deckhouse, a five-bedroom, four-bathroom house, is located in downtown Fish Creek on Main Street, offering easy walking access to shops, restaurants, the beach, and Peninsula State Park.
This spacious vacation rental sleeps ten guests and boasts a modern kitchen with granite countertops, stainless steel appliances, and a custom coffee bar, along with an infrared sauna, BBQ grill, and multiple decks offering stunning Fish Creek Harbor and Peninsula State Park water views.
New! Walk To Water, Shops | Hot Tub, Sauna & Pool - Sister Bay, WI
8.0 1 review

New! Walk To Water, Shops | Hot Tub, Sauna & Pool

apartment, Ellison Bay
This 4-bedroom, 4-bathroom condo in Ellison Bay offers a prime village location, just a 5-minute walk to shops and dining, and a 10-minute walk to the beach and marina, with popular natural attractions like Mink River Estuary Preserve 3 minutes away by car.
This 3,040 sq ft residence accommodates up to 8 guests with a dedicated media and game room, an outdoor spa oasis with a hot tub and sauna, a fireplace, smart appliances, and dog-friendly accommodations with a 3-car garage.
Carraig Beag Cottage - Sister Bay, WI
8.0 1 review

Carraig Beag Cottage

house, Baileys Harbor
Carraig Beag Cottage, a three-bedroom Baileys Harbor house rental, is conveniently located 6.5 miles from Cana Island Lighthouse and 11 miles from Cave Point County Park.
This 1300-square-foot vacation home sleeps up to 19 guests and boasts a fully equipped kitchen, air conditioning, a garden, free parking, and on-site bike rentals for exploring nearby cycling paths.
Exceptional Home In Tranquil Door County Setting. - Sister Bay, WI
9.8 38 reviews

Exceptional Home In Tranquil Door County Setting.

cottage, Baileys Harbor
This family-friendly cabin is located just three miles from Kangaroo Lake and Lake Michigan, offering easy access to swimming, fishing, and kayaking. It's also close to Door County Brewing Company, a popular spot for craft beer enthusiasts. The cabin has consistently received excellent ratings from previous guests.
The 1,190 square foot cabin can comfortably accommodate up to eight guests in its three bedrooms and two bathrooms. It features a fully equipped kitchen, a garden, a barbecue grill, free WiFi, and air conditioning, ensuring a comfortable and enjoyable stay for the whole family.

Best Sister Bay, WI vacation rentals with parking

Ellison Bay Retreat - Little House In The Woods - Sister Bay, WI
10 218 reviews

Ellison Bay Retreat - Little House In The Woods

apartment, Ellison Bay
New Construction  Private Lot: Near Sister Bay - Sister Bay, WI
9.0 4 reviews

New Construction Private Lot: Near Sister Bay

apartment, Sister Bay
Luxury Remodeled 4br | Downtown Sister Bay - Sister Bay, WI
9.9 58 reviews

Luxury Remodeled 4br | Downtown Sister Bay

house, Sister Bay
Secluded Home | Walk To Marina + Gameroom & Hottub - Sister Bay, WI
9.7 227 reviews

Secluded Home | Walk To Marina + Gameroom & Hottub

apartment, Sister Bay

Best 5-Star Vacation Rentals in Sister Bay, WI

Stay in a luxury city-center vacation rental in Sister Bay, WI for a sophisticated urban escape with premium 5-star amenities.

Dog Friendly Ephraim Home-wooded Lot With Fire Pit - Sister Bay, WI
No reviews

Dog Friendly Ephraim Home-wooded Lot With Fire Pit

apartment, Ephraim

Find the Best Dog-Friendly Vacation Rentals in Sister Bay, WI

Stay in a pet-friendly vacation rental in Sister Bay, WI situated near dog parks and city walks, ensuring a comfortable stay for both you and your pet.

Charming Sister Bay Vacation Home With Hot Tub, Steps From Beach & Downtown, Wisconsin - Sister Bay, WI
No reviews

Charming Sister Bay Vacation Home With Hot Tub, Steps From Beach & Downtown, Wisconsin

house, Sister Bay
Carraig Dale Cottage - Sister Bay, WI
10 2 reviews

Carraig Dale Cottage

house, Baileys Harbor
Walk To Sister Bay | Fireplace, Ping Pong & Spacious Retreat - Sister Bay, WI
10 5 reviews

Walk To Sister Bay | Fireplace, Ping Pong & Spacious Retreat

apartment, Sister Bay
The Goat And Cherry- Cozy Retreat, Hot Tub, Fire Pit, Arcade Fun & Dogs! - Sister Bay, WI
9.0 2 reviews

The Goat And Cherry- Cozy Retreat, Hot Tub, Fire Pit, Arcade Fun & Dogs!

house, Sister Bay

Search Vacation Rentals with Swimming Pool in Sister Bay, WI

Dive into a refreshing stay with these Sister Bay, WI rentals and Airbnbs that offer on-site swimming pool access in the heart of the city.

Ellison Bay Spahouse- New, Walk To Water, Shops, Hot Tub, Sauna & Games - Sister Bay, WI
No reviews

Ellison Bay Spahouse- New, Walk To Water, Shops, Hot Tub, Sauna & Games

house, Ellison Bay
High Point Inn - Sister Bay, WI
9.4 328 reviews

High Point Inn

resort, Ephraim
Peaceful Nature Retreat! Short Walk 2 Pebble Beach - Sister Bay, WI
10 23 reviews

Peaceful Nature Retreat! Short Walk 2 Pebble Beach

apartment, Sister Bay
Spacious 3br@ Little Sweden Club Wyndham Resort - Sister Bay, WI
No reviews

Spacious 3br@ Little Sweden Club Wyndham Resort

apartment, Egg Harbor

Top-Rated Vacation Rentals with a Hot Tub in Sister Bay, WI

Coming home to a private hot tub after a day of urban exploration completely transforms your Sister Bay, WI experience.

Design Cabin With Jacuzzi And Porch In Sister Bay, Wisconsin - Sister Bay, WI
No reviews

Design Cabin With Jacuzzi And Porch In Sister Bay, Wisconsin

cabin, Sister Bay
Cozy Retreat | Hottub, Firepit, Arcade Fun & Dogs! - Sister Bay, WI
9.8 115 reviews

Cozy Retreat | Hottub, Firepit, Arcade Fun & Dogs!

house, Sister Bay
Serene Cabin With Beautiful Outdoor Space In Sister Bay, Wisconsin - Sister Bay, WI
No reviews

Serene Cabin With Beautiful Outdoor Space In Sister Bay, Wisconsin

cabin, Sister Bay
Luxurious Retreat With Expansive Yard In Sister Bay, Wisconsin - Sister Bay, WI
No reviews

Luxurious Retreat With Expansive Yard In Sister Bay, Wisconsin

house, Sister Bay
©2026 cozycozy.com