Vacation Rentals in Fire Island, NY

1176 available vacation rental offers

7 nights
2
1
  • airbnb
  • booking
  • stayz
  • expedia
  • hotelscom
  • tripadvisor
  • tripcom
  • agoda
  • homestay
  • tuivillas
  • hostelworld
  • hotelopia
Fire Island, NY holiday rentals
Choose the perfect holiday accommodation
Price per night
Accommodation type
Rating

1176 Holiday rentals and Airbnb in Fire Island, NY

Plan Your Stay: Top Family Holiday Rentals in Fire Island, NY, United States

Give everyone space to stretch out, cook, and unwind together at family holiday rentals in Fire Island, NY, United States.

Idéal Petite Maison Avec Piscine!!! - Fire Island, NY
10 68 reviews

Idéal Petite Maison Avec Piscine!!!

apartment, Bellport
This Bellport house, a 10-minute walk or 1.6 km drive from Bellport village and marina, offers easy access to local amenities and is situated approximately 1.5 hours or 145 km from New York City.
The two-bedroom, one-bathroom property sleeps four, features a private swimming pool, and includes a fully equipped kitchen with dishwasher, making it ideal for families or travelling nurses seeking short or long-term lets.
Fire Island (Obp) Waterfront Oasis W/private Beach - Fire Island, NY
9.8 25 reviews

Fire Island (Obp) Waterfront Oasis W/private Beach

apartment, Fire Island
This Fire Island bayfront beach house is located in Ocean Bay Park, directly on the Great South Bay with unobstructed sunset views and is just a short walk or bike ride from Ocean Beach. It has received excellent ratings for location, cleanliness and user experience.
The house offers two bedrooms and one bathroom, comfortably accommodating up to six guests. It comes fully equipped with everything you need for a relaxing stay, including air conditioning, internet access and a kitchen.
Beautiful Beach House With Large Swimming Pool In Ocean Beach - Fire Island, NY
9.9 51 reviews

Beautiful Beach House With Large Swimming Pool In Ocean Beach

apartment, Ocean Beach
This house is located in Ocean Beach, just 1 kilometre from the beautiful beaches of Great South Bay and Atlantique Beach, offering easy access to the oceanfront. The property has received excellent ratings for its location, cleanliness, and overall user experience.
This four-bedroom house spans 232 square metres and comfortably accommodates up to 10 guests. Enjoy a private pool, spa tub, barbecue grills, and a fully equipped kitchen, perfect for relaxing and entertaining.
Davis Park Fire Island Retreat - Fire Island, NY
No reviews

Davis Park Fire Island Retreat

house, Fire Island
This spacious air-conditioned holiday home is located in a quiet district of Fire Island, offering garden views from its terrace and easy access to the beach, just 100 meters away.
This 158 square meter property accommodates up to 19 guests with 2 bedrooms, 3 bathrooms, a fully equipped kitchen, complimentary WiFi, a private terrace, and a balcony.

Browse Holiday Rentals with a Pool in Fire Island, NY, United States

Spend your days alternating between the sun loungers and the water at holiday rentals with a pool in Fire Island, NY, United States.

Immaculate Luxury Fire Island Pines Home, Gourmet Kitchen, Pool, Hot Tub Private - Fire Island, NY
10 1 review

Immaculate Luxury Fire Island Pines Home, Gourmet Kitchen, Pool, Hot Tub Private

apartment, Fire Island
This Big Timber A-frame residence is situated in Sayville's town centre, a mere 200 metres from the beach and in proximity to the Cherry Grove Community House and Theatre.
This expansive, family-friendly dwelling offers 334 square metres of living space with 5 bedrooms, accommodating up to 8 guests, and features a heated swimming pool, hot tub, and a rooftop deck with panoramic ocean and harbour views.
2 Br Private Suite W/private Living Room & Kitchen - Fire Island, NY
10 37 reviews

2 Br Private Suite W/private Living Room & Kitchen

house, Fire Island
This Fire Island Pines suite, a three-minute walk from both the harbour and beach, offers a luxurious escape in a prime location.
The property comprises two bedrooms sleeping four guests, boasting a private poolside suite with living room, kitchen, and shared access to a heated pool, hot tub, roof deck, and small gym; modern amenities include air conditioning, a dishwasher, and a Jacuzzi.
Renovated Bellport Village Home - Fire Island, NY
No reviews

Renovated Bellport Village Home

apartment, Bellport
This charming house is situated in Bellport, just under a mile from Great South Bay and about 3 miles from Carmans River, offering a peaceful retreat in a quiet neighbourhood. The house is less than a mile from the beautiful Great South Bay, ideal for swimming, fishing, kayaking, or simply enjoying the waterfront views.
The house has three bedrooms and two bathrooms, comfortably accommodating up to six guests. The property offers a private pool, a spacious garden, a terrace, and modern amenities like free WiFi, a washing machine, and a dishwasher.
Horace Gifford Design - Modernist Gem On Fire Island - Pines - Fire Island, NY
10 1 review

Horace Gifford Design - Modernist Gem On Fire Island - Pines

apartment, Fire Island
This Fire Island holiday home, located in Sayville, offers easy access to Fire Island National Seashore and is a short distance from Patchogue and its attractions, including the Patchogue Theatre for the Performing Arts.
The three-bedroom, three-bathroom property sleeps six guests and boasts a fully equipped kitchen, including a dishwasher, a large deck with a hot tub, and modern amenities such as Wi-Fi and satellite TV.

Frequently asked questions about holiday rentals in Fire Island, NY

  • What should a first-time visitor not miss in Fire Island, NY?

    First-timers should definitely check out the Fire Island Lighthouse, it's a must-see. The views from the top are incredible and you can learn about the history of the lighthouse. Another must-do is a walk along the beach, especially at sunset. The sunsets are stunning and the beach is beautiful.
  • What are the best Airbnb and holiday rentals in Fire Island, NY?

  • Which neighborhood in Fire Island, NY should you consider for a vacation rental?

    It really depends on what you're looking for. If you want to be in the heart of the action, Ocean Beach is a good choice. It's known for its lively nightlife and restaurants. If you prefer something quieter, consider a rental in Cherry Grove. It's known for its laid-back atmosphere and beautiful beaches.
  • What are the most popular Airbnbs in Fire Island, NY?

  • What are the top family-friendly attractions in Fire Island, NY?

    The Fire Island Lighthouse is a popular attraction for families, as is the Fire Island National Seashore. The National Seashore has plenty of space for kids to run around and explore, and there are also ranger-led programmes and activities during the summer months.
  • What are the best holiday rentals with a pool in Fire Island, NY?

  • When is the best time to book a vacation rental in Fire Island, NY?

    The best time to book a vacation rental in Fire Island is as early as possible, especially if you're travelling during the peak season from June to August. You can often find good deals if you book outside of these months, but availability might be limited.
  • What are the best rentals for families and kids in Fire Island, NY?

  • What are the best budget-friendly activities in Fire Island, NY?

    Walking or cycling along the beach is a great way to spend a day in Fire Island without spending a lot of money. You can also pack a picnic and enjoy a meal on the beach. The Fire Island National Seashore offers free ranger-led programmes and activities, which are a great way to learn about the local wildlife and history.
  • What are the best rentals or Airbnbs with a jacuzzi in Fire Island, NY?

  • What are the best restaurants with local dishes in Fire Island, NY?

    The Clamman is a popular spot for fresh seafood, and they've been serving up delicious dishes for years. The Lobster Roll is a classic Fire Island dish, and you can find it at many restaurants on the island. The Fire Island Pines has some great options for a more upscale dining experience.
  • What are the best walking or cycling routes in Fire Island, NY?

    The Fire Island National Seashore is a great place for a walk or cycle. There are miles of trails to explore, and you can see a variety of wildlife along the way. You can also walk or cycle along the beach, but be sure to check the tide times before you go.
  • Are there pet-friendly attractions in Fire Island, NY?

    Most of the beaches on Fire Island are not pet-friendly, but there are some exceptions. The westernmost part of the island, near the Robert Moses State Park, is generally more dog-friendly. You can also find pet-friendly restaurants and shops on the island.
  • What are the benefits of choosing a vacation rental in Fire Island, NY?

    Vacation rentals offer more space and privacy than a hotel room, and they're often a more affordable option for families or groups. You can find a wide variety of rentals on Fire Island, from cozy cottages to spacious houses. Many rentals also offer amenities that you won't find in a hotel, like a private deck or outdoor shower.

Popular destinations

Discover Holiday Rentals with a Balcony in Fire Island, NY, United States

Find holiday rentals with a balcony in Fire Island, NY, United States and wake up to ocean views.

Fire Island White House - Ocean Bay Park  5 Bedroom Bayview Home - Sleeps 18! - Fire Island, NY
10 3 reviews

Fire Island White House - Ocean Bay Park 5 Bedroom Bayview Home - Sleeps 18!

apartment, Fire Island
This Bay Shore holiday home, situated just 0.32 kilometres from both the ocean and the ferry, offers easy access to Fire Island's beaches and transportation links.
This five-bedroom, five-bathroom property boasts a 325 square metre floor area, sleeping up to 18 guests and including a swimming pool, Jacuzzi, and rooftop deck; nearby attractions include the Cherry Grove Community House and Theatre, and the Bay Shore Historical Society.
Private 3br Apt: King-2queen -Petpally -Ltr-str - Fire Island, NY
9.7 407 reviews

Private 3br Apt: King-2queen -Petpally -Ltr-str

apartment, North Bay Shore
This apartment is conveniently located in North Bay Shore, just a short distance from Brentwood State Park and within easy reach of Sky Zone and Tanger Outlets. The property has consistently received excellent ratings for its location, cleanliness, and overall experience.
The apartment features a comfortable living space with a dining area and a TV for entertainment. You can enjoy the garden, barbecue grills, and a fireplace, as well as a fully equipped kitchenette, making it ideal for a relaxing and enjoyable stay.
Luxury Waterfront Retreat  Private Hot Tub & Dock Near Sayville - Fire Island, NY
10 97 reviews

Luxury Waterfront Retreat Private Hot Tub & Dock Near Sayville

apartment, Bayport
This Bayport holiday home is situated just 700 metres from a sandy beach and within a 3-kilometre drive of two Fire Island Ferry terminals. It enjoys an excellent user rating and is a great base for exploring the area.
The property offers 195 square metres of space, comfortably accommodating up to eight guests in its three bedrooms and two bathrooms. It boasts a range of amenities including a swimming pool, Jacuzzi, sauna, and a fully equipped kitchen, as well as a private garden and terrace, making it ideal for relaxing and enjoying the outdoors.
Windows On The Sea  Modern Pool & Beach Retreat  100 Ft To Beach  2 Masters - Fire Island, NY
10 78 reviews

Windows On The Sea  Modern Pool & Beach Retreat  100 Ft To Beach 2 Masters

apartment, Fire Island
This spacious five-bedroom apartment in Ocean Bay Park, Fire Island, is just 100 metres from the beach and a short walk from the ferry dock, offering a fantastic location for exploring the island. The property has received excellent ratings for location, cleanliness, and overall experience, ensuring a comfortable and enjoyable stay.
The apartment spans 167 square metres and comfortably accommodates 12 guests, making it ideal for families or groups. The home is fully equipped with modern amenities, including a private pool and hot tub, a spacious deck with ocean views, and a chef's kitchen, providing everything you need for a relaxing and memorable holiday.

Best Fire Island, NY holiday rentals with parking

Bay Shore Vacation Rental W/ Shared Yard! - Fire Island, NY
9.8 15 reviews

Bay Shore Vacation Rental W/ Shared Yard!

apartment, North Bay Shore
This North Bay Shore seaside flat is situated approximately 5 kilometres from Brentwood State Park, Sky Zone, and Tanger Outlets.
The 116 square metre property boasts three bedrooms, one bathroom, and sleeps six guests, offering a fully equipped kitchen, in-unit laundry, a private garden, and parking.
Luxurious, Pristine Apartment Near Country Club, Perfect For A Splendid Getaway! - Fire Island, NY
8.8 8 reviews

Luxurious, Pristine Apartment Near Country Club, Perfect For A Splendid Getaway!

apartment, Bohemia
This Bohemia apartment, in Suffolk County, Long Island, is situated 0.8km from Connetquot River State Park, 4.8km from the Bohemia Historical Society Museum, and 4km from Bayard Cutting Arboretum State Park, with Oakdale railway station a 20-minute walk away.
The self-catering flat offers one bedroom, one bathroom, sleeping two guests, and includes a microwave, stovetop, washing machine, Smart TV, air conditioning, and private garden parking; nearby activities include nature walks, historical exploration, and easy access to public transport.
Stylish Yet Cozy Experience At This Centrally-located Place In Patchogue. - Fire Island, NY
10 15 reviews

Stylish Yet Cozy Experience At This Centrally-located Place In Patchogue.

apartment, Patchogue
This Patchogue flat is conveniently located less than 0.8 km from Patchogue train station, providing easy access to New York City and offering proximity to the Bowl Long Island and Patchogue Theatre, both under 1.6 km away.
The two-bedroom, one-bathroom apartment sleeps six guests and includes in-unit laundry facilities, a microwave, stovetop, and Smart TV, plus on-site parking; nearby attractions include the 89 North Music Venue and Fire Island National Seashore, both within a 2.4km radius.
Sundown Escape Near Southshore University Hospital - Fire Island, NY
No reviews

Sundown Escape Near Southshore University Hospital

apartment, Islip
This private studio suite in Bay Shore, Long Island's South Shore, offers convenient access to LIRR Central Islip (7 minutes) and MacArthur Airport (11 minutes), with Robert Moses State Park 27 kilometres and Jones Beach State Park 39 kilometres away.
This 46 square metre studio accommodates two guests and features a private entrance, a fully equipped kitchen with a fridge and microwave, air conditioning, parking, a workspace with high-speed Wi-Fi, and a queen-size bed, situated 14.5 kilometres from Fire Island Ferries.

Escape to the Coast: Luxury Holiday Rentals in Fire Island, NY, United States

Bask in absolute tropical privacy with upscale coastal design at luxury holiday rentals in Fire Island, NY, United States.

Cedar And Glass Guest Cabana - Fire Island, NY
10 9 reviews

Cedar And Glass Guest Cabana

house, Fire Island

Browse Downtown Holiday Rentals in Fire Island, NY, United States

Stay just steps away from local boutiques, seafood spots, and the sand at holiday rentals in the heart of Fire Island, NY, United States.

Updated Beach Cottage - Fire Island, NY
9.8 10 reviews

Updated Beach Cottage

apartment, Fire Island
Bay Front Upper Level Cottage 47e - Fire Island, NY
9.7 53 reviews

Bay Front Upper Level Cottage 47e

house, Fire Island
Bay Front Beach House 49e - Fire Island, NY
9.5 46 reviews

Bay Front Beach House 49e

apartment, Fire Island
Michigan Ave - Fire Island, NY
9.8 12 reviews

Michigan Ave

apartment, Fire Island

Browse Coastal Holiday Rentals in Fire Island, NY, United States

Walk directly out of your living room straight onto the soft sand at seashore holiday rentals in Fire Island, NY, United States.

Seaside Escape On Huron - Fire Island, NY
No reviews

Seaside Escape On Huron

house, Fire Island
Fi Pines - 3 Bedroom / 2 Bath Beach House - Fire Island, NY
10 7 reviews

Fi Pines - 3 Bedroom / 2 Bath Beach House

apartment, Fire Island
Cherry Pop - Fire Island, NY
10 1 review

Cherry Pop

apartment, Fire Island
Waterfront Home W/ Large Deck & Dock On Narrow Bay - Fire Island, NY
9.7 72 reviews

Waterfront Home W/ Large Deck & Dock On Narrow Bay

house, Mastic Beach

Browse Holiday Rentals with a Hot Tub in Fire Island, NY, United States

Watch the sun set over the horizon while soaking in a steaming outdoor hot tub at island holiday rentals in Fire Island, NY, United States.

Luxury Pines 5br Gourmt Kit Pool Jacuzzi Fireplace - Fire Island, NY
10 14 reviews

Luxury Pines 5br Gourmt Kit Pool Jacuzzi Fireplace

apartment, Fire Island
Sun, Sand & Serenity: Your 4bedroom Fire Island Pines Escape - Fire Island, NY
No reviews

Sun, Sand & Serenity: Your 4bedroom Fire Island Pines Escape

apartment, Fire Island
Fire Island Pines Oasis W/4 King Bdrms, Heated Pool, Hot Tub, Ocean & Bay Views - Fire Island, NY
8.0 1 review

Fire Island Pines Oasis W/4 King Bdrms, Heated Pool, Hot Tub, Ocean & Bay Views

apartment, Fire Island
Fire Island Pines ...On The Great South Bay! - Fire Island, NY
10 2 reviews

Fire Island Pines ...On The Great South Bay!

apartment, Fire Island
©2026 cozycozy.com