Vacation Rentals in Fire Island, NY

1176 available vacation rental offers

7 nights
2
1
  • airbnb
  • booking
  • stayz
  • expedia
  • hotelscom
  • tripadvisor
  • tripcom
  • agoda
  • homestay
  • tuivillas
  • hostelworld
  • hotelopia
Fire Island, NY holiday rentals
Choose the perfect holiday accommodation
Price per night
Accommodation type
Rating

1176 Holiday rentals and Airbnb in Fire Island, NY

Plan Your Stay: Top Family Holiday Rentals in Fire Island, NY, United States

Give everyone space to stretch out, cook, and unwind together at family holiday rentals in Fire Island, NY, United States.

Charming Secluded Waterfront Retreat - Fire Island, NY
No reviews

Charming Secluded Waterfront Retreat

apartment, Great River
This Oakdale flat offers proximity to nature, being a mere 5-minute walk from Connetquot River and Bayard Cutting Arboretum State Park.
This family-friendly one-bedroom flat accommodates two guests and features air conditioning, Wi-Fi, a well-equipped kitchen with a microwave, and on-site parking, with local attractions such as Bay Shore Mini Golf and Fair Harbor Ferry Terminal nearby.
The Raabbit Hole - Fire Island, NY
9.4 29 reviews

The Raabbit Hole

apartment, Ocean Beach
This Ocean Beach holiday home is conveniently located near Great South Bay, Ocean Beach, and Atlantique Beach, all within a 1.6km walk, and approximately 4.8km from Sunken Forest and Sailors' Haven.
This four-bedroom, four-bathroom property sleeps eleven guests and boasts a fully equipped kitchen, patio, smart TV, barbecue grills, and is pet-friendly.
Private Apartment On River Ave. Close To Main St - Fire Island, NY
9.6 8 reviews

Private Apartment On River Ave. Close To Main St

apartment, Patchogue
This apartment is conveniently situated in Patchogue Village, just minutes from the ferry to Fire Island and an hour from both New York City and the Hamptons, offering easy access to both bustling city life and tranquil beach escapes. The peaceful atmosphere of Patchogue Village provides a welcome respite from the hustle and bustle, making this a perfect location for exploring the area.
This two-bedroom flat can comfortably accommodate up to five guests, making it ideal for families or groups of friends. It comes fully equipped with modern amenities including a kitchen with a fridge and microwave, air conditioning, a jacuzzi, and free parking, ensuring a comfortable and enjoyable stay.
Cozy Family-friendly Beach Retreat With Pool - Fire Island, NY
10 5 reviews

Cozy Family-friendly Beach Retreat With Pool

apartment, Bellport
This spacious apartment is located in Bellport, just a short drive from Patchogue Theatre for the Performing Arts and William Floyd Estate, making it a great base for exploring the area's cultural attractions. It has received excellent user ratings, indicating a high level of satisfaction from previous guests.
The apartment offers 232 square metres of living space with 5 bedrooms and 4 bathrooms, comfortably accommodating up to 10 guests. It includes a range of amenities, such as a private pool, a hot tub, a home gym, and two dedicated workspaces, ensuring a comfortable and enjoyable stay.

Browse Holiday Rentals with a Pool in Fire Island, NY, United States

Spend your days alternating between the sun loungers and the water at holiday rentals with a pool in Fire Island, NY, United States.

Beautiful Beach House With Large Swimming Pool In Ocean Beach - Fire Island, NY
9.9 51 reviews

Beautiful Beach House With Large Swimming Pool In Ocean Beach

apartment, Ocean Beach
This house is located in Ocean Beach, just 1 kilometre from the beautiful beaches of Great South Bay and Atlantique Beach, offering easy access to the oceanfront. The property has received excellent ratings for its location, cleanliness, and overall user experience.
This four-bedroom house spans 232 square metres and comfortably accommodates up to 10 guests. Enjoy a private pool, spa tub, barbecue grills, and a fully equipped kitchen, perfect for relaxing and entertaining.
Private Cherry Grove Home With Saltwater Pool - Fire Island, NY
10 2 reviews

Private Cherry Grove Home With Saltwater Pool

apartment, Fire Island
This two-bedroom, one-bathroom holiday cottage offers prime access to Fire Island's amenities, situated just 100 metres from the ferry terminal, market, eateries, and nightlife, and a mere stone's throw from the beach.
This centrally located holiday home sleeps up to four guests and features a newly installed saltwater swimming pool, expansive wraparound sun decks, an outdoor shower, and a thoughtfully redesigned open-concept interior with high-end finishes and preserved original woodwork.
Fruit Of The Dune, Cherry Grove - Fire Island, NY
10 4 reviews

Fruit Of The Dune, Cherry Grove

apartment, Fire Island
This newly renovated, multi-level coastal luxury residence in Cherry Grove, Fire Island, offers direct oceanfront access to the Atlantic and views of the Great South Bay.
This four-bedroom, three-bathroom apartment accommodates eight guests and features air conditioning, internet, a kitchen with a fridge, freezer, microwave, and dishwasher, along with a heated swimming pool, cabana, garden, and an outdoor shower.
The Legendary Pyramid House - Fire Island, NY
9.7 92 reviews

The Legendary Pyramid House

apartment, Fire Island
This charming Fire Island apartment is located in the Pines district, just a short distance from the Fire Island National Seashore, offering stunning views of the dunes, ocean, and bay. The apartment has received excellent ratings for its cleanliness, location, and overall experience.
The property offers three bedrooms and two bathrooms, comfortably accommodating up to six guests. Amenities include a private heated saltwater pool, a hot tub, an outdoor kitchen, and multiple dining areas, ensuring a relaxing and enjoyable stay.

Frequently asked questions about holiday rentals in Fire Island, NY

  • What should a first-time visitor not miss in Fire Island, NY?

    First-timers should definitely check out the Fire Island Lighthouse, it's a must-see. The views from the top are incredible and you can learn about the history of the lighthouse. Another must-do is a walk along the beach, especially at sunset. The sunsets are stunning and the beach is beautiful.
  • What are the best Airbnb and holiday rentals in Fire Island, NY?

  • Which neighborhood in Fire Island, NY should you consider for a vacation rental?

    It really depends on what you're looking for. If you want to be in the heart of the action, Ocean Beach is a good choice. It's known for its lively nightlife and restaurants. If you prefer something quieter, consider a rental in Cherry Grove. It's known for its laid-back atmosphere and beautiful beaches.
  • What are the most popular Airbnbs in Fire Island, NY?

  • What are the top family-friendly attractions in Fire Island, NY?

    The Fire Island Lighthouse is a popular attraction for families, as is the Fire Island National Seashore. The National Seashore has plenty of space for kids to run around and explore, and there are also ranger-led programmes and activities during the summer months.
  • What are the best holiday rentals with a pool in Fire Island, NY?

  • When is the best time to book a vacation rental in Fire Island, NY?

    The best time to book a vacation rental in Fire Island is as early as possible, especially if you're travelling during the peak season from June to August. You can often find good deals if you book outside of these months, but availability might be limited.
  • What are the best rentals for families and kids in Fire Island, NY?

  • What are the best budget-friendly activities in Fire Island, NY?

    Walking or cycling along the beach is a great way to spend a day in Fire Island without spending a lot of money. You can also pack a picnic and enjoy a meal on the beach. The Fire Island National Seashore offers free ranger-led programmes and activities, which are a great way to learn about the local wildlife and history.
  • What are the best rentals or Airbnbs with a jacuzzi in Fire Island, NY?

  • What are the best restaurants with local dishes in Fire Island, NY?

    The Clamman is a popular spot for fresh seafood, and they've been serving up delicious dishes for years. The Lobster Roll is a classic Fire Island dish, and you can find it at many restaurants on the island. The Fire Island Pines has some great options for a more upscale dining experience.
  • What are the best walking or cycling routes in Fire Island, NY?

    The Fire Island National Seashore is a great place for a walk or cycle. There are miles of trails to explore, and you can see a variety of wildlife along the way. You can also walk or cycle along the beach, but be sure to check the tide times before you go.
  • Are there pet-friendly attractions in Fire Island, NY?

    Most of the beaches on Fire Island are not pet-friendly, but there are some exceptions. The westernmost part of the island, near the Robert Moses State Park, is generally more dog-friendly. You can also find pet-friendly restaurants and shops on the island.
  • What are the benefits of choosing a vacation rental in Fire Island, NY?

    Vacation rentals offer more space and privacy than a hotel room, and they're often a more affordable option for families or groups. You can find a wide variety of rentals on Fire Island, from cozy cottages to spacious houses. Many rentals also offer amenities that you won't find in a hotel, like a private deck or outdoor shower.

Popular destinations

Discover Holiday Rentals with a Balcony in Fire Island, NY, United States

Find holiday rentals with a balcony in Fire Island, NY, United States and wake up to ocean views.

Bayfront Retreat  3 Ensuite Br + Hot Tub - Fire Island, NY
10 21 reviews

Bayfront Retreat 3 Ensuite Br + Hot Tub

apartment, Fire Island
This modern apartment is situated in Sayville, just 0.8 km east of the town centre, offering a peaceful retreat while still being close to shops and nightlife. It has received excellent user ratings, making it a popular choice for travellers.
The apartment spans 94 square metres and comfortably accommodates up to six guests across three bedrooms and three bathrooms. Enjoy a range of amenities including a fully equipped kitchen, air conditioning, a jacuzzi, a terrace, a garden, and direct access to the bay for swimming and water activities.
Westhampton Beach Oceanfront, 4 Bedrooms, Pool. Super Clean. Relax And Chill. - Fire Island, NY
9.8 79 reviews

Westhampton Beach Oceanfront, 4 Bedrooms, Pool. Super Clean. Relax And Chill.

apartment, West Hampton Dunes
This West Hampton Dunes beachfront property offers direct beach access and is a short 0.8km stroll from Moriches Bay and the Hamptons beaches, lying within 1.6km of Cupsogue County Park and Cupsogue Beach.
This 232 square metre house boasts four bedrooms, three bathrooms, sleeping eight guests, and includes a private pool, fully equipped kitchen, free Wi-Fi, and concierge service.
Waterfront House Next To Bellport Golf Course - Fire Island, NY
10 17 reviews

Waterfront House Next To Bellport Golf Course

apartment, East Patchogue
This beachfront holiday home in East Patchogue is located a 5-minute walk from Great South Bay and a 4-minute drive from Bellport Country Club.
This spacious 297 m² property accommodates up to 8 guests across 4 bedrooms and 3.5 bathrooms, featuring a swimming pool, hot tub, garden, and modern amenities including air conditioning and Wi-Fi.
Bright, Updated Ocean Beach Home Just Steps From The Beach And Village - Fire Island, NY
No reviews

Bright, Updated Ocean Beach Home Just Steps From The Beach And Village

apartment, Ocean Beach
This pet-friendly holiday flat is situated in Ocean Beach, a mere 3-minute walk from Great South Bay and 5 minutes from Ocean Beach, offering convenient access to the Fire Island Lighthouse and Carrington House, as well as Atlantic Beach.
This 111 square metre holiday home accommodates up to nine guests with four bedrooms and two bathrooms, featuring a fully equipped kitchen with a microwave, air conditioning, a terrace, a garden, and an in-unit washer and dryer.

Best Fire Island, NY holiday rentals with parking

Beachfront / Seaside Home  With Spectacular View - Fire Island, NY
9.1 102 reviews

Beachfront / Seaside Home With Spectacular View

apartment, East Patchogue
This East Patchogue beachfront house, situated directly on the Great South Bay, offers easy access to local shops and restaurants within a short driving distance (exact distance unspecified).
Sleeping up to 14 guests, this four-bedroom, three-bathroom property boasts a private raised bulkhead beach, large deck, modern kitchen with dishwasher, and ample indoor/outdoor space for relaxation and entertaining.
3 Story Beach Waterview, 3 King Bed, Golf Putting Green! - Fire Island, NY
9.9 224 reviews

3 Story Beach Waterview, 3 King Bed, Golf Putting Green!

apartment, Shirley
This beach house is located in Shirley, just 19 miles from Splish Splash water park and 26 miles from the Long Island Railroad, making it a great base for exploring the area. The property has consistently received excellent ratings for its cleanliness, location, and overall experience.
This spacious 4-bedroom house, spanning 186 square metres, comfortably accommodates up to 14 guests. Enjoy a range of amenities including a private swimming pool, a putting green, a balcony with stunning views, and a fully equipped kitchen.
Fire Island Pines Oasis W/4 King Bdrms, Heated Pool, Hot Tub, Ocean & Bay Views - Fire Island, NY
8.0 1 review

Fire Island Pines Oasis W/4 King Bdrms, Heated Pool, Hot Tub, Ocean & Bay Views

apartment, Fire Island
This Fire Island holiday home, situated in Sayville, offers easy access to attractions such as Carrington House and the Patchogue Theatre, though precise distances aren't provided.
The four-bedroom property boasts a spacious open-plan layout, sleeping up to nine guests and featuring a full kitchen, heated pool, hot tub, wrap-around decks, and direct beach access.
Cozy 1-bedroom Cottage In Delightful Mastic Beach With Ac - Fire Island, NY
10 2 reviews

Cozy 1-bedroom Cottage In Delightful Mastic Beach With Ac

apartment, Mastic Beach
This one-bedroom holiday let in Mastic Beach is situated a short distance from the William Floyd Estate and the TWA Flight 800 International Memorial.
This 58 square meter property accommodates up to three guests and includes a king-sized bed, air conditioning, and internet access, with nearby attractions such as Bellport Country Club and Waterdrinker Family Farm & Garden.

Escape to the Coast: Luxury Holiday Rentals in Fire Island, NY, United States

Bask in absolute tropical privacy with upscale coastal design at luxury holiday rentals in Fire Island, NY, United States.

Huron Hideaway - Fire Island, NY
9.5 4 reviews

Huron Hideaway

house, Fire Island

Browse Downtown Holiday Rentals in Fire Island, NY, United States

Stay just steps away from local boutiques, seafood spots, and the sand at holiday rentals in the heart of Fire Island, NY, United States.

Beach House In Ocean Beach, Fire Island - Fire Island, NY
9.9 32 reviews

Beach House In Ocean Beach, Fire Island

apartment, Ocean Beach
Windows On The Sea  Modern Pool & Beach Retreat  100 Ft To Beach  2 Masters - Fire Island, NY
10 78 reviews

Windows On The Sea  Modern Pool & Beach Retreat  100 Ft To Beach 2 Masters

apartment, Fire Island
Family Beach House - Fire Island, NY
9.7 6 reviews

Family Beach House

apartment, Fire Island
Tranquility By The Sea - In Seaview Fire Island - Fire Island, NY
10 3 reviews

Tranquility By The Sea - In Seaview Fire Island

apartment, Fire Island

Browse Coastal Holiday Rentals in Fire Island, NY, United States

Walk directly out of your living room straight onto the soft sand at seashore holiday rentals in Fire Island, NY, United States.

Cayuga Street Sunshine Retreat - Fire Island, NY
9.5 2 reviews

Cayuga Street Sunshine Retreat

house, Fire Island
Cedar & Glass Home In The Pines L Heated Pool - Fire Island, NY
10 9 reviews

Cedar & Glass Home In The Pines L Heated Pool

apartment, Fire Island
Waterfront Home W/ Large Deck & Dock On Narrow Bay - Fire Island, NY
9.7 72 reviews

Waterfront Home W/ Large Deck & Dock On Narrow Bay

house, Mastic Beach
Come Relax At The Reef - Fire Island, NY
No reviews

Come Relax At The Reef

apartment, Fire Island

Browse Holiday Rentals with a Hot Tub in Fire Island, NY, United States

Watch the sun set over the horizon while soaking in a steaming outdoor hot tub at island holiday rentals in Fire Island, NY, United States.

Sun, Sand & Serenity: Your 4bedroom Fire Island Pines Escape - Fire Island, NY
No reviews

Sun, Sand & Serenity: Your 4bedroom Fire Island Pines Escape

apartment, Fire Island
The Peaceful Beach House - Fire Island, NY
9.8 13 reviews

The Peaceful Beach House

apartment, Fire Island
Tranquil Stay - Fire Island, NY
8.2 12 reviews

Tranquil Stay

apartment, Shirley
Bellport Tranquility - Fire Island, NY
10 6 reviews

Bellport Tranquility

apartment, Bellport
©2026 cozycozy.com