Hotels in Fire Island, NY

55 available hotel offers

2 nights
2
1
  • airbnb
  • booking
  • stayz
  • expedia
  • hotelscom
  • tripadvisor
  • tripcom
  • agoda
  • homestay
  • tuivillas
  • hostelworld
  • hotelopia
Fire Island, NY hotels
Choose the perfect holiday accommodation
Price per night
Accommodation type
Rating

Fire Island, NY Hotels: no available offers. Here are other great options for your stay!

The Stella ~ A 1920s Beach Bungalow - Fire Island, NY
9.8 156 reviews

The Stella ~ A 1920s Beach Bungalow

apartment, Bellport
The Stella, a 1920s house in Bellport Village, offers easy access to several beaches, including Fire Island's Ho Hum Beach (reachable by ferry), Mother's Beach, Shirley Beach, and Smith Point Beach, with some within walking distance.
This 111.5 square metre property boasts three bedrooms, sleeping up to five guests, and features a fully equipped kitchen, a living room with a fireplace, a garden, and parking; it also includes modern amenities such as fast Wi-Fi and smart home technology.
Private 3br Apt: King-2queen -Petpally -Ltr-str - Fire Island, NY
9.7 409 reviews

Private 3br Apt: King-2queen -Petpally -Ltr-str

apartment, North Bay Shore
This apartment is conveniently located in North Bay Shore, just a short distance from Brentwood State Park and within easy reach of Sky Zone and Tanger Outlets. The property has consistently received excellent ratings for its location, cleanliness, and overall experience.
The apartment features a comfortable living space with a dining area and a TV for entertainment. You can enjoy the garden, barbecue grills, and a fireplace, as well as a fully equipped kitchenette, making it ideal for a relaxing and enjoyable stay.
Spacious One Bedroom Apartment W/private Entrance - Fire Island, NY
10 32 reviews

Spacious One Bedroom Apartment W/private Entrance

apartment, East Islip
This East Islip flat is situated in a peaceful neighbourhood, offering excellent transport links with the Long Island Rail Road (LIRR) just a short walk away, McArthur Airport 8 kilometres distant, and the Fire Island Ferry 16 kilometres away, alongside convenient access to local shops and restaurants. This one-bedroom flat accommodates up to four guests and includes a kitchen with a fridge, freezer, and microwave, air conditioning, and parking.
Bayfront Retreat  3 Ensuite Br + Hot Tub - Fire Island, NY
9.9 106 reviews

Bayfront Retreat 3 Ensuite Br + Hot Tub

apartment, Fire Island
This newly appointed modernist home is located directly on the bay, just three blocks east of Fire Island’s town centre and a five-minute walk from shops and nightlife. The apartment has been highly rated by previous guests for its cleanliness, location and overall experience.
The three-bedroom, three-bathroom property sleeps up to six guests, offering plenty of space and privacy for all. It comes with a range of amenities including a private hot tub, outdoor showers, a spacious cedar deck, and access to kayaks, fishing poles and other water sports equipment.

Frequently asked questions about hotels in Fire Island, NY

  • What are the most affordable attractions in Fire Island, NY?

    You can't beat the free attractions on Fire Island! The beautiful beaches are a great way to spend the day, and you can also enjoy the scenic walks along the boardwalk or through the dunes. You can also visit the Fire Island Lighthouse Museum for a small fee.
  • What are the best hotels with a swimming pool in Fire Island, NY?

  • How can travelers relax during a week in Fire Island, NY?

    Fire Island is a perfect spot for a relaxing getaway. You can spend your days swimming, sunbathing, and enjoying the natural beauty of the island. In the evenings, you can stroll along the beach, have a delicious meal at a local restaurant, or simply unwind with a good book.
  • What are the most popular 2, 3 and 4-star hotels in Fire Island, NY?

    Among 2, 3 and 4-star hotels in Fire Island, NY, Holiday Inn - Long Island - Islip Arpt East By Ihg, Hampton Inn Long Island/commack and Residence Inn Long Island Holtsville are the most popular ones.

  • Where can you find the best traditional local cuisine in Fire Island, NY?

    While Fire Island doesn't have specific traditional cuisine, you'll find many great restaurants serving fresh seafood, like the famous Fire Island Lobster Roll at the Clamman. You can also find delicious pizza and burgers at local eateries.
  • What are the best luxury hotels in Fire Island, NY?

    Hyatt Regency Long Island is among the best luxury hotels in Fire Island, NY.

  • What hotel chains can you find in Fire Island, NY?

    You won't find any major hotel chains on Fire Island. The island is mostly made up of private homes and smaller, independent hotels and guesthouses.
  • What are the best family friendly hotels in Fire Island, NY?

  • What type of hotels can you find in Fire Island, NY?

    Fire Island offers a variety of accommodations, from charming bed and breakfasts to cozy guesthouses and more modern hotels. You can find options to suit different budgets and preferences.
  • What are the best pet friendly hotels in Fire Island, NY?

  • When is the best time to book a hotel in Fire Island, NY?

    The best time to book a hotel in Fire Island is during the shoulder seasons, from April to May and September to October. You'll find better deals and fewer crowds during these months.
  • What are the best hotels with jacuzzi in Fire Island, NY?

  • What amenities do hotel rooms typically offer in Fire Island, NY?

    Hotel rooms in Fire Island usually offer basic amenities like air conditioning, heating, and private bathrooms. Some may have additional features like balconies, kitchenettes, or fireplaces.
  • What pet-friendly activities are available in Fire Island, NY?

    Fire Island is a very dog-friendly destination. You can bring your furry friend to the beach, enjoy walks along the boardwalk, or relax on the ferry with them. Some restaurants also have outdoor seating areas where you can dine with your dog.

Popular destinations

©2026 cozycozy.com