Compare Vacation Rentals & Airbnb in Sag Harbor, NY

This charming three-bedroom apartment is situated in the heart of Sag Harbor Village, just a short walk from the bustling downtown area and the picturesque Otter Pond. The apartment has received excellent ratings for location, cleanliness, and overall experience, making it an ideal choice for travellers seeking a comfortable and convenient stay.
The apartment offers a spacious and open layout, comfortably accommodating up to six guests. Guests can enjoy a fully equipped kitchen, a private garden, and a range of amenities including air conditioning, internet access, and parking.

This holiday flat is located in the Silver Beach district of Shelter Island, a 10-minute walk from Shell Beach and an 8-minute drive from Sunset Beach.
This accommodation sleeps 11 guests and offers a swimming pool, barbecue facilities, Wi-Fi, air conditioning, a fireplace, a well-equipped kitchen with a microwave and dishwasher, and in-unit laundry.

This Wainscott property is situated on a 4.2-hectare private estate, just 5km from Sag Harbor Village and 10km from East Hampton Village, offering a peaceful retreat close to the vibrant Hamptons scene. It has received excellent user, location and cleanliness ratings.
The spacious 372 square metre home features five bedrooms and six bathrooms, perfect for families or groups of friends. Guests can enjoy a heated swimming pool, a Jacuzzi, a tennis court, a fully equipped kitchen and a basement with entertainment options, ensuring a comfortable and enjoyable stay.

This East Hampton retro-modern house is situated near Northwest Harbour's bay beach (walking distance), with ocean beaches a 24km drive away and East Hampton, Sag Harbor, and Amagansett villages also within easy driving distance.
The three-bedroom property, sleeping six, boasts a heated pool, large deck with gas grill, fully equipped kitchen with stainless steel appliances, and modern amenities including Wi-Fi and TVs in every room; in-house washer/dryer, linens, towels and paper goods are provided.

This modern Sag Harbor house, steps from the water and a short drive from Long Beach, offers a convenient location in the heart of Sag Harbor village.
The three-bedroom, three-bathroom property sleeps six guests and boasts a fully equipped kitchen, high-speed Wi-Fi, air conditioning, and a private backyard; StayMarquis services are also included.

This apartment is located just 200 metres from Noyack village and is steps from Long Beach.
Accommodating up to 12 guests across 6 bedrooms, this residence offers air conditioning, a heated saltwater swimming pool, and a fully equipped kitchen, ideal for families and groups seeking a Hamptons experience.

This Hamptons retreat is situated on 4 acres of private woodland, a short drive from Northwest Harbor's attractions.
This four-bedroom residence accommodates up to eight guests and features a chef's kitchen with BOSCH appliances, a swimming pool, a wraparound deck with an outdoor kitchenette and BBQ, and a master bedroom with a fireplace and balcony.

This Bridgehampton residence, situated on over 0.4 hectares adjacent to the 404-hectare Long Pond Greenbelt, offers waterfront access and is conveniently located between Sag Harbor and Bridgehampton, mere minutes from ocean and bay beaches, as well as local shops and eateries.
This expansive 214 square meter dwelling, ideal for up to ten guests, features five bedrooms, three bathrooms, a newly renovated gourmet kitchen with Sub-Zero/Wolf/Cove appliances, a private heated swimming pool, and extensive outdoor amenities including a propane grill and basketball hoop, with proximity to activities like jet skiing, kayaking, and hiking.

This Water Mill house is conveniently located just a short drive from The Hamptons Beaches, Elizabeth A. Morton National Wildlife Refuge, and other popular attractions. It's also highly rated by previous guests, receiving excellent reviews for its comfort and amenities.
The four-bedroom property offers 650 square metres of space, comfortably accommodating up to eight guests. Enjoy a range of amenities, including a private pool, fitness centre, and fully equipped kitchen, perfect for relaxing and entertaining during your stay.

This waterfront property is located just 3 kilometres from Wades Beach, The Hamptons Beaches, and the Shelter Island Historical Society, offering easy access to both the island's attractions and its stunning coastline. It has been rated excellent by previous guests.
The three-bedroom house provides 149 square metres of space, comfortably accommodating up to 6 guests. Enjoy a fully equipped kitchen, a fireplace, a garden with BBQ facilities, a terrace, and free Wi-Fi, all within a relaxing and family-friendly environment.

This five-bedroom, five-bathroom East Hampton property, situated blocks from a bay beach and close to the Osborn-Jackson House Museum and Eastville Heritage House, offers a luxurious stay in Northwest Harbour.
The 1.47-acre estate boasts a private pool, multiple decks, a gourmet kitchen, multiple living areas accommodating eight guests, and ample outdoor amenities including bicycles and beach gear for exploring nearby attractions.

This waterfront property is situated on the Menantic Peninsula in Shelter Island Heights, offering a tranquil retreat just a short distance from the charming village centre. The house has received excellent ratings for user experience, location, and cleanliness.
This four-bedroom residence spans 372 square metres and offers a spacious interior with white oak floors, two large balconies with sea views, and a 1/4 kilometre driveway leading to park-like grounds. The property boasts a private sandy beach, a jacuzzi, a fitness centre, a tennis court, and a deep water dock, as well as concierge services and a gourmet kitchen.

This Sag Harbour apartment, situated less than 0.4 kilometres from Main Street and a short walk from Marine Park, offers a quiet residential setting close to shops, restaurants, and the Hampton Jitney bus service.
The recently renovated one-bedroom flat, sleeping four guests, boasts a modern beach bungalow aesthetic, a private entrance, garden access, and parking, complemented by a fully equipped kitchen and air conditioning.

This centrally located Water Mill basement flat offers easy access to autumnal attractions such as local farm stands and apple picking orchards, all within a short driving distance.
The newly renovated self-contained unit sleeps two, features a private entrance, in-unit laundry, a dishwasher, and radiant bathroom floor heating, plus off-street parking.

This Noyack holiday home is situated near Sag Harbor village, a five-minute walk from Long Beach and a short drive from East Hampton, Bridgehampton, and Southampton.
The four-bedroom, three-bathroom property sleeps eight guests and boasts a private heated saltwater pool, a fully equipped kitchen including a dishwasher, and convenient access to community tennis courts.

This Noyack residence offers a secluded retreat, situated just 5 minutes from Sag Harbor village and Long Beach, with Foster Memorial Long Beach a convenient 3-minute drive or 20-minute walk away.
This spacious four-bedroom house accommodates up to eight guests and features a heated saltwater swimming pool, jacuzzi, fire pit, and an expansive open-plan living area perfect for groups, all set within a tranquil, tree-lined garden.