Find hotels in Sag Harbor, NY at the best prices

12 available hotel offers

2 nights
2
1
  • airbnb
  • booking
  • vrbo
  • expedia
  • priceline
  • tripadvisor
  • tripcom
  • sonder
  • homestay
  • hostelworld
  • hotelscom
  • agoda
Sag Harbor, NY hotels
Choose the perfect vacation accommodation
Price per night
Accommodation type
Rating

12 Cheap hotels in Sag Harbor, NY

Best Sag Harbor, NY luxury hotels (4 and 5 stars)

Among the 2 accommodations in Sag Harbor, NY, here are the 2 best luxury hotels

Silver Sands Motel & Beach Bungalows - Sag Harbor, NY
No reviews

Silver Sands Motel & Beach Bungalows

hotel, Greenport
The Silver Sands Motel & Beach Bungalows is situated in Southold, approximately 5km from Greenport town centre, offering convenient access to the Long Island Railroad Museum, East End Seaport Museum, and Greenport's antique carousel.
This 4-star lodging provides guest rooms with air conditioning, Wi-Fi, and parking, accommodating up to 2 guests, and features an on-site restaurant serving local cuisine, a terrace, and a garden.
Faraway Sag Harbor - Sag Harbor, NY
9.0 484 reviews

Faraway Sag Harbor

hotel, Sag Harbor
Baron's Cove is located in Sag Harbor, New York, just a short drive from Montauk and Mystic, offering a convenient base for exploring the charming Hamptons. This 4-star hotel has received very good user ratings for its location, cleanliness, and overall experience.
The accommodation has a range of rooms with either ocean or garden views. Guests can enjoy a saltwater swimming pool, on-site restaurant, bike hire, a shop, and a range of other amenities including a spa, fitness centre, and tennis court.

Best Sag Harbor, NY hotels with a pool

Among the 4 accommodations in Sag Harbor, NY, here are the 4 best hotels with a pool

Sound View Greenport - Sag Harbor, NY
8.4 955 reviews

Sound View Greenport

hotel, Southold
Sound View Greenport is a 3-star hotel situated on the North Fork in Greenport, just 98 miles from New York City and a short drive from popular destinations like Montauk and East Hampton. It has received very good user ratings, making it a popular choice for travellers seeking a relaxing getaway.
This hotel offers a range of amenities and activities to keep guests entertained, including a seasonal outdoor pool, a private beach area, bike hire, a tennis court, a shared lounge, a bar, and a restaurant. The rooms all have stunning waterfront views, allowing guests to enjoy the beauty of the Long Island Sound.
The Atlantic Hotel - Sag Harbor, NY
No reviews

The Atlantic Hotel

hotel, Tuckahoe
The Atlantic Hotel is situated in Tuckahoe, a quiet residential area 4 kilometres from the town centre and close to the renowned Shinnecock Hills Golf Course. This two-star hotel offers a range of amenities including a swimming pool, garden, and tennis court, perfect for a relaxing getaway.
Hamlet Inn - Passes To Coopers Beach - Sag Harbor, NY
8.6 801 reviews

Hamlet Inn - Passes To Coopers Beach

hotel, Shinnecock Hills
The Hamlet Inn is situated in Southampton, just a short walk from Shinnecock Bay and a couple of miles from Cooper's Beach, offering a peaceful retreat close to the area's attractions. This 3-star hotel consistently receives very good user ratings, highlighting its appeal to travellers seeking a comfortable and well-regarded stay.
The inn features a spacious layout with a garden and a terrace, perfect for relaxing. Guests can enjoy amenities such as a swimming pool, room service, and free parking, making their stay convenient and enjoyable.
Wainscott Woods Retreat - Sag Harbor, NY
8.0 8 reviews

Wainscott Woods Retreat

hotel, Wainscott
Wainscott Woods Retreat offers a peaceful Wainscott lodging option, 2.9 kilometres from Wainscott Beach and within 32 kilometres of Montauk Point Lighthouse and Montauk Downs State Park.
This one-bedroom, one-bathroom guesthouse features a seasonal outdoor swimming pool, free private parking, and an on-site garden, providing comfortable accommodation for families.

Frequently Asked Questions about hotels in Sag Harbor, NY

  • What are the most affordable attractions in and around Sag Harbor, NY?

    Take a stroll along the picturesque Sag Harbor waterfront, enjoy the free concerts at the Long Wharf, or visit the Long Island Aquarium and Exhibition Center in Riverhead for a discounted admission on certain days. You can also explore the charming shops and art galleries along Main Street, which are free to enter.
  • What are the best hotels with a swimming pool in Sag Harbor, NY?

    Sag Harbor Inn, Baron's Cove and Outdoor Living...ideal Location In East Hampton With Resort Inspired Backyard are among the best hotels with a swimming pool in Sag Harbor, NY.

  • How can travelers relax during a week in and arond Sag Harbor, NY?

    Sag Harbor is perfect for a relaxing getaway. Spend your mornings at the beach, enjoying the sun and the sound of the waves. In the afternoons, take a leisurely bike ride along the scenic Long Island Sound bike path, or head to the Sag Harbor Cinema for a movie under the stars. In the evenings, relax with a glass of wine at one of the many waterfront restaurants.
  • What are the most popular 2, 3 and 4-star hotels in Sag Harbor, NY?

    Among 2, 3 and 4-star hotels in Sag Harbor, NY, Sag Harbor Inn and Forever Bungalows are the most popular ones.

  • What amenities can travelers expect in hotel rooms in Sag Harbor, NY?

    Most hotels in Sag Harbor offer standard amenities like air conditioning, Wi-Fi, and flat-screen TVs. Some hotels also have swimming pools, fitness centres, and complimentary breakfast. If you're looking for something special, you might find hotels with private balconies or patios overlooking the water.
  • What are the best luxury hotels in Sag Harbor, NY?

    Baron's Cove is among the best luxury hotels in Sag Harbor, NY.

  • When is the best time to book a hotel in Sag Harbor, NY?

    The best time to book a hotel in Sag Harbor is in the spring or autumn, when the weather is pleasant and the crowds are smaller. If you're planning to visit during the summer, book your hotel well in advance, as prices can be higher and availability can be limited.
  • What are the best family friendly hotels in Sag Harbor, NY?

  • What are the best pet friendly hotels in Sag Harbor, NY?

Popular destinations

Best Sag Harbor, NY hotels with air conditioning

Wainscott Woods Retreat - Sag Harbor, NY
8.0 8 reviews

Wainscott Woods Retreat

hotel, Wainscott
Wainscott Woods Retreat offers a peaceful Wainscott lodging option, 2.9 kilometres from Wainscott Beach and within 32 kilometres of Montauk Point Lighthouse and Montauk Downs State Park.
This one-bedroom, one-bathroom guesthouse features a seasonal outdoor swimming pool, free private parking, and an on-site garden, providing comfortable accommodation for families.
Topping Rose House - Sag Harbor, NY
No reviews

Topping Rose House

hotel, Bridgehampton
The Topping Rose House is located in the centre of Bridgehampton, a short walk from shops, restaurants and the Children's Museum of The East End. This four-star hotel is perfect for those looking for a comfortable and convenient stay in this charming village.
The accommodation offers a range of rooms and suites, all featuring modern amenities and stylish décor. Guests can enjoy the outdoor pool, spa, restaurant, bar and a host of other facilities, including a library and concierge services.
Wainscott Woods Retreat - Sag Harbor, NY
No reviews

Wainscott Woods Retreat

hotel, Wainscott
The Wainscott Woods Retreat, a 2-star hotel, is centrally located in the Wainscott Woods district, offering city views and convenient access to local attractions.
This accommodation provides guests with complimentary Wi-Fi, air conditioning, a terrace or balcony, a garden, and on-site parking, alongside a seasonal outdoor swimming pool open from May to September and laundry facilities.
Journey East Hampton - Sag Harbor, NY
9.1 402 reviews

Journey East Hampton

hotel, East Hampton
Journey East Hampton is a 4-star hotel located a short walk from the beautiful beaches of East Hampton, offering a peaceful retreat from the bustling town. It has consistently received very good user ratings for its location, cleanliness and overall experience.
The hotel features modern rooms with a floor area of 33 square metres, each with a private bathroom and air conditioning. Guests can enjoy a range of amenities, including a swimming pool, a garden, a restaurant, a bar, and free parking, making it an ideal choice for a relaxing and enjoyable stay in East Hampton.

Best Sag Harbor, NY hotels with a balcony

The Menhaden Hotel - Sag Harbor, NY
9.6 274 reviews

The Menhaden Hotel

hotel, Greenport
The Menhaden Hotel is situated in Greenport, just 26 miles from Splish Splash water park and 47 miles from Long Island MacArthur Airport, making it an ideal base for exploring the charming waterfront town. This 4-star hotel boasts excellent user ratings for its location, cleanliness, and overall experience.
The hotel offers comfortable rooms with private bathrooms and modern amenities, including air conditioning, free Wi-Fi, and flat-screen TVs. Guests can enjoy the on-site restaurant and bar, relax on the terrace, or explore the area on complimentary bikes.
Wainscott Woods Retreat - Sag Harbor, NY
No reviews

Wainscott Woods Retreat

hotel, Wainscott
The Wainscott Woods Retreat, a 2-star hotel, is centrally located in the Wainscott Woods district, offering city views and convenient access to local attractions.
This accommodation provides guests with complimentary Wi-Fi, air conditioning, a terrace or balcony, a garden, and on-site parking, alongside a seasonal outdoor swimming pool open from May to September and laundry facilities.
Sound View Greenport - Sag Harbor, NY
No reviews

Sound View Greenport

hotel, Southold
The Sound View Greenport hotel is located in Greenport, just 3 kilometres from the town centre, offering easy access to local shops, restaurants, and attractions. This 4-star accommodation provides a comfortable and convenient base for exploring the area.
The hotel features a range of amenities, including an outdoor swimming pool, a fitness centre, and a tennis court. Guests can also enjoy a meal at the on-site restaurant and bar, or relax on the terrace or in the garden.
Hamlet Inn - Passes To Coopers Beach - Sag Harbor, NY
8.6 801 reviews

Hamlet Inn - Passes To Coopers Beach

hotel, Shinnecock Hills
The Hamlet Inn is situated in Southampton, just a short walk from Shinnecock Bay and a couple of miles from Cooper's Beach, offering a peaceful retreat close to the area's attractions. This 3-star hotel consistently receives very good user ratings, highlighting its appeal to travellers seeking a comfortable and well-regarded stay.
The inn features a spacious layout with a garden and a terrace, perfect for relaxing. Guests can enjoy amenities such as a swimming pool, room service, and free parking, making their stay convenient and enjoyable.
©2026 cozycozy.com