Find hotels in Shelter Island, NY at the best prices

Baron's Cove is located in Sag Harbor, New York, just a short drive from Montauk and Mystic, offering a convenient base for exploring the charming Hamptons. This 4-star hotel has received very good user ratings for its location, cleanliness, and overall experience.
The accommodation has a range of rooms with either ocean or garden views. Guests can enjoy a saltwater swimming pool, on-site restaurant, bike hire, a shop, and a range of other amenities including a spa, fitness centre, and tennis court.

Zey Hotel, an adults-only boutique accommodation in Greenport, is conveniently situated a short walk from the beach, 300 metres from Greenport Farmers' Market, and 400 metres from Camera Obscura.
This establishment offers Pan-Asian dining at the onsite Kon-Tiki restaurant, a bar/lounge, complimentary wireless internet, and a terrace and garden, with free self-parking available.

The American Beech Hotel is situated in Greenport, just 26 miles from Splish Splash water park and 48 miles from Long Island MacArthur Airport, making it a convenient base for exploring the charming town and surrounding area. This 4-star hotel has received very good user ratings, indicating a high level of satisfaction among guests.
The hotel offers spacious rooms with air conditioning, seating areas, flat-screen TVs, safety deposit boxes, and private bathrooms with complimentary toiletries. Guests can enjoy a range of amenities, including a swimming pool, terrace, garden, spa, restaurant, bar, and free bikes to explore the local area.

The Harbor Front Inn is conveniently located in the heart of Greenport, just a short walk from the North Ferry Terminal and a 3-minute drive from Kontokosta Winery. This 3-star hotel consistently receives very good user ratings, making it a popular choice for travellers visiting the area.
The inn offers comfortable rooms with modern amenities, including a flat-screen TV, refrigerator, and private bathroom. Guests can enjoy a range of on-site facilities, such as a swimming pool, fitness centre, and free Wi-Fi.

The Chequit is a 3-star hotel located in The Heights district of Shelter Island Heights, offering convenient access to Shelter Island Country Club, Sunset Beach, and Crescent Beach, all within 1.6 kilometres, and Sylvester Manor and East End Seaport Maritime Museum within 3.2 kilometres.
This establishment provides on-site dining with its own restaurant and cafe, complimentary self-parking, and free WiFi in public areas, and welcomes pets.

Sound View Greenport is a 3-star hotel situated on the North Fork in Greenport, just 98 miles from New York City and a short drive from popular destinations like Montauk and East Hampton. It has received very good user ratings, making it a popular choice for travellers seeking a relaxing getaway.
This hotel offers a range of amenities and activities to keep guests entertained, including a seasonal outdoor pool, a private beach area, bike hire, a tennis court, a shared lounge, a bar, and a restaurant. The rooms all have stunning waterfront views, allowing guests to enjoy the beauty of the Long Island Sound.

Sound View Greenport, a four-star hotel in Greenport, NY, offers a prime location on the coastline with excellent access to local attractions.
This family-friendly establishment provides complimentary breakfast, free Wi-Fi, on-site parking, concierge and ticket services, room service, a swimming pool with a poolside bar, and tennis courts, alongside a restaurant and bar.

The Harbor Front Inn is located in Southold, a 7km drive from the centre of Greenport. This 3-star hotel offers a peaceful retreat after a day exploring the bustling town.
The hotel has a range of facilities including a swimming pool, a fitness centre, a terrace, and a concierge service. Guests can also enjoy free Wi-Fi and parking, as well as comfortable rooms with amenities like a TV, bathrobes, and slippers.

The Pridwin Hotel is situated on Shelter Island, a short ferry ride from the mainland and a short drive from the quaint village of Shelter Island Heights. It is a 4-star hotel with excellent user ratings for location, cleanliness, and overall experience.
The hotel offers a variety of rooms and cottages, all with stunning water views. Guests can enjoy a range of amenities including a swimming pool, spa, restaurant, bar, fitness centre, tennis court, and a variety of seasonal activities.

The Shoals Suites & Slips is located in Southold, a charming village on Long Island's North Fork, just a short drive from the beautiful beaches of Orient Point. It is a 4-star hotel with excellent user ratings.
The hotel offers comfortable rooms with private bathrooms and free parking. Guests can enjoy a range of amenities, including a restaurant, bar, terrace, garden, and concierge service.

Hotel Moraine is located in Greenport, 24 miles from Splish Splash and 46 miles from Long Island MacArthur Airport, making it a convenient base for exploring the area. The hotel consistently receives excellent ratings for its location, cleanliness and overall experience.
The hotel offers a range of comfortable rooms, each accommodating up to two guests. Guests can enjoy a variety of amenities, including a seasonal outdoor swimming pool, a fitness centre, a bar and lounge, a sun terrace, free Wi-Fi, and complimentary bikes for exploring the charming streets and waterfront of Greenport.

Zey Hotel, a 3.5-star establishment in Greenport, is situated a short walk from the waterfront, the Greenport Farmers' Market, Greenport Harbor Brewing Company (both within 500 metres), and Greenport Station (800 metres away).
This hotel offers complimentary WiFi in public areas, free self-parking, and bicycle hire, with concierge services available to assist guests, alongside a coffee shop/cafe and coffee/tea in a common area.