Places to stay in New Buffalo, MI

277 available accommodation offers

7 nights
2
1
  • airbnb
  • booking
  • hotelscom
  • vrbo
  • tripadvisor
  • expedia
  • tripcom
  • agoda
  • homestay
  • tuivillas
  • hostelworld
  • hotelopia
New Buffalo, MI place to stay
Choose the perfect holiday accommodation
Price per night
Accommodation type
Rating

277 Best places to stay in New Buffalo, MI

Best New Buffalo, MI lodgings with a pool

Among the 277 accommodations in New Buffalo, MI, here are the 4 best ones with a pool

Hideaway - Pickleball Court, Private Pool, Hot Tub, Sleeps 25! - New Buffalo, MI
10 1 review
New Buffalo, MI
26/06 – 28/06
SG$5706/nighttotal: SG$11412 (2 )

Hideaway - Pickleball Court, Private Pool, Hot Tub, Sleeps 25!

7 16
apartment , Michigan City
This family-friendly flat is situated in a rural area of Michigan City, offering easy walking access to Friendship Botanic Gardens (720 metres) and Clare Lake (1.1 kilometres).
This spacious 372 square metre residence features 7 bedrooms, 5 bathrooms, a fully equipped kitchen, and on-site amenities including a swimming pool and hot tub, with covered parking provided.
Pvt Beach Htd Pool Open Now - New Buffalo, MI
10 17 reviews
New Buffalo, MI
20/08 – 24/08
SG$1731/nighttotal: SG$6924 (4 )

Pvt Beach Htd Pool Open Now

1 2
apartment , New Buffalo
This Union Pier holiday home in New Buffalo, Michigan is situated on a double lot, a 0.8km stroll from a private beach and close to Harbor Country's breweries and wineries.
The fully renovated property boasts three bedrooms, three bathrooms, sleeps eight guests, and includes a heated private pool, pool house with fireplace, children's playset, and firepit, offering ample space for family fun.
Poolside Retreat | Hot Tub & Fire Pit - New Buffalo, MI
10 3 reviews
New Buffalo, MI
20/06 – 27/06
SG$1406/nighttotal: SG$9842 (7 )

Poolside Retreat | Hot Tub & Fire Pit

1 2
apartment , Shorewood-Tower Hills-Harbert
Heron Woods, situated in the Shorewood-Tower Hills-Harbert area, offers easy access to the restaurants, wineries, and breweries of Harbor Country, though precise distances aren't specified.
This three-bedroom, two-bathroom house sleeps up to 11 guests and boasts a heated in-ground pool, hot tub, fire pit, screened porch, and fully equipped kitchen.
Michiana Beach And Pool House - New Buffalo, MI
10 1 review
New Buffalo, MI
20/06 – 27/06
SG$3672/nighttotal: SG$25704 (7 )

Michiana Beach And Pool House

1 2
house , Michiana
This six-bedroom, six-bathroom beachfront villa in New Buffalo, Michigan, offers direct lake access and is situated near various Michiana attractions, the precise distance to which is unspecified.
The 4,900 sq ft (approximately 455 sq m) property boasts a 1,000 sq ft (approximately 93 sq m) terrace, a private heated pool (seasonal, 24th May – 15th September), a fitness centre, and sleeps up to 16 guests.

Best family friendly New Buffalo, MI lodging

Among the 277 accommodations in New Buffalo, MI, here are the 4 best for families

The Beachside Harborfront Hideaway - New Buffalo, MI
New Buffalo, MI
01/07 – 06/07
SG$1284/nighttotal: SG$6420 (5 )

The Beachside Harborfront Hideaway

1 5
apartment , New Buffalo
This New Buffalo flat is located 500 meters from New Buffalo Beach, offering a prime position in the district.
This 149 square meter apartment comfortably accommodates up to 11 guests with 2 bathrooms, a fully equipped kitchen, and access to a swimming pool, fitness centre, and garden, alongside private parking.
Blue Fox Cottage - New Buffalo, MI
New Buffalo, MI
20/06 – 27/06
SG$419/nighttotal: SG$2933 (7 )

Blue Fox Cottage

1 2
apartment , Grand Beach
This 1916 cottage, located in Old Grand Beach, is a five-minute walk from beach access and close to local amenities.
Accommodating up to eight guests across two bedrooms and three bathrooms, this family-friendly property offers a loft-style bunk room with privacy curtains, a kitchen with a fridge and microwave, air conditioning, and a garden.
Archer's Retreat Sleeps 10 - New Buffalo, MI
10 1 review
New Buffalo, MI
07/08 – 10/08
SG$895/nighttotal: SG$2685 (3 )

Archer's Retreat Sleeps 10

4 4
house , Shorewood-Tower Hills-Harbert
Archer's Retreat Sleeps 10, a Sawyer, Michigan holiday home, is situated 2.6 km from Warren Dunes State Park Beach, offering stunning Lake Michigan views.
This 149 square metre property sleeps ten guests in four bedrooms and boasts two bathrooms, a fully equipped kitchen, free Wi-Fi, and private parking, plus nearby access to cycling and hiking trails.
Historic Farmhouse With Hot Tub, Treehouse Shower, & Chickens! - New Buffalo, MI
10 10 reviews
New Buffalo, MI
07/08 – 10/08
SG$2023/nighttotal: SG$6069 (3 )

Historic Farmhouse With Hot Tub, Treehouse Shower, & Chickens!

5 4
farm , Michigan City
GW's Farmhouse at Tryon Farm, situated in the Tryon Farm neighbourhood of Michigan City, Indiana, is a 10-minute drive (approx. 16km) from Lake Michigan and New Buffalo, offering easy access to both.
This 232-square-metre (2500 sq ft) five-bedroom, seven-bathroom farmhouse sleeps up to 13 guests and boasts amenities including a hot tub, EV chargers, and access to over 170 acres of hiking trails at the neighbouring Tryon Farm Institute.

Frequently asked questions about accommodations in New Buffalo, MI

Destinations nearby

Best New Buffalo, MI accommodations with a balcony

Updated, Hot Tub, Walk To Union Pier - New Buffalo, MI
9.4 15 reviews
New Buffalo, MI
25/09 – 27/09
SG$1155/nighttotal: SG$2310 (2 )

Updated, Hot Tub, Walk To Union Pier

3 5
apartment , New Buffalo
This New Buffalo lakefront property is less than 1.6km from the Wilkinson Village Heritage Museum and a short 24km drive from the Round Barn Union Pier Tasting Room and Edward and Elizabeth Leonard Wildlife Preserve.
This four-bedroom, two-bathroom house sleeps eight guests and boasts a fully equipped kitchen, Jacuzzi, patio, garden, parking, and in-unit laundry facilities, all within easy reach of local attractions.
Dog-friendly Cottage With Hot Tub & Firepit - New Buffalo, MI
10 13 reviews
New Buffalo, MI
06/07 – 09/07
SG$1292/nighttotal: SG$3876 (3 )

Dog-friendly Cottage With Hot Tub & Firepit

3 3
apartment , New Buffalo
This New Buffalo holiday home is situated 0.8km from the town centre, 1.6km from the beach, and close to the Four Winds Casino, offering easy access to restaurants, breweries, and local attractions.
The 186 square metre property boasts three bedrooms, three bathrooms, sleeps six guests, and includes a well-equipped kitchen with KitchenAid appliances, a screened-in porch, a six-person hot tub, and a fire pit.
Hot Tub + Fire Pit + Dog-friendly Retreat Beach - New Buffalo, MI
8.6 12 reviews
New Buffalo, MI
25/07 – 26/07
SG$3387/nightfor 1 night

Hot Tub + Fire Pit + Dog-friendly Retreat Beach

4 6
apartment , Michigan City
This six-bedroom lakefront property in Michigan City boasts direct access to Lake Michigan, a ten-minute walk from Washington Park, and is 4km from Indiana Dunes National Park.
This 193 square metre holiday home sleeps fourteen guests and offers a fully equipped kitchen, swimming pool, jacuzzi, spa, and terrace, alongside free Wi-Fi.
Remodeled Home Close To Lake Michigan - Walk To The Beach, One Dog Ok - New Buffalo, MI
New Buffalo, MI
20/08 – 24/08
SG$1112/nighttotal: SG$4448 (4 )

Remodeled Home Close To Lake Michigan - Walk To The Beach, One Dog Ok

4 2
apartment , New Buffalo
This New Buffalo holiday home is situated just one house from Lake Michigan and 1.6 kilometres from New Buffalo Public Beach, within walking distance of downtown shops, restaurants, and the Marina Grand Hotel.
This four-bedroom, two-bathroom holiday home accommodates up to eight guests and features a newly remodelled interior with a modern kitchen, a private fenced garden with a grill, and high-speed WiFi.

Best New Buffalo, MI accommodations with a kitchen

The Hickory House - Walk To Downtown Three Oaks - Week Stay Discount - New Buffalo, MI
9.9 201 reviews
New Buffalo, MI
19/06 – 21/06
SG$1100/nighttotal: SG$2200 (2 )

The Hickory House - Walk To Downtown Three Oaks - Week Stay Discount

1 10
apartment , Three Oaks
The Hickory House, a spacious property in Three Oaks, Michigan, is situated less than 1.6km from local shops and restaurants, and a 16km drive from New Buffalo's beaches.
This 223 square metre house sleeps twelve guests in six bedrooms, boasts two and a half bathrooms, a fully equipped kitchen including a dishwasher, and features two screened-in porches, a garden with a fire pit, and parking; note proximity to Amtrak train tracks.
In-town Lovely Home! Steps To Starbucks & Beach! - New Buffalo, MI
9.9 201 reviews
New Buffalo, MI
29/09 – 01/10
SG$477/nighttotal: SG$954 (2 )

In-town Lovely Home! Steps To Starbucks & Beach!

1 2
apartment , New Buffalo
This three-bedroom apartment is located in downtown New Buffalo, just a short walk from the beach, Starbucks, Stray Dog restaurant, and a grocery store.
The property boasts a fully fenced yard with a shed, sandbox, and outdoor games, perfect for families with children, and also features a fire pit for evening entertainment.
Cozy 3 Bedroom 2 Bathroom House - New Buffalo, MI
10 1 review
New Buffalo, MI
20/06 – 21/06
SG$514/nightfor 1 night

Cozy 3 Bedroom 2 Bathroom House

1 2
apartment , Michigan City
This 3-bedroom, 2-bathroom flat in Michigan City offers a prime location, situated 644 metres from the Blue Chip Casino, 1.9 kilometres from Lighthouse Place Premium Outlets, and 2.6 kilometres from Washington Park Beach on Lake Michigan.
This accommodation allows pets and sleeps up to six guests, featuring a kitchen with a fridge and microwave, air conditioning, and is ideal for families or groups seeking a comfortable retreat with convenient access to local attractions.
Downtown Bungalow Near Beach - New Buffalo, MI
9.9 230 reviews
New Buffalo, MI
26/07 – 30/07
SG$1117/nighttotal: SG$4468 (4 )

Downtown Bungalow Near Beach

1 4
apartment , New Buffalo
This renovated brick bungalow is located just 200 metres from the bars, restaurants, and shops on Whittaker Avenue, and less than 8 kilometres from New Buffalo Beach. It has received excellent ratings for location, cleanliness, and user experience.
The property offers five bedrooms, including one in the basement without a door, and a large recreation room in the basement with two single beds, accommodating up to 14 guests. Amenities include a fully equipped kitchen, a terrace, a garden, a spa, parking, high-speed internet, a 50-inch TV, and a fire pit for relaxing evenings.
©2026 cozycozy.com