Compare best cottages in New Buffalo, MI from 100+ sites!

This modern cottage is located in a desirable New Buffalo neighborhood, offering easy walking access to downtown restaurants, shops, and the Lake Michigan beach.
This 2000 square foot rental accommodates up to 8 guests with 3 bedrooms and 2 bathrooms, featuring a private 6-person hot tub, a swimming pool, and high-speed internet, with proximity to a playground, tennis courts, and Indiana Dunes National Park.

Tallgrass Cottage, a serene retreat in the Walden enclave, offers a peaceful escape a short walk from downtown New Buffalo and less than a mile from the beach, located 70 miles from Chicago.
This 2000 square foot cottage accommodates up to six guests with three bedrooms, three bathrooms, and an activity loft, featuring a full kitchen with a fridge, microwave, and dishwasher, central air conditioning, high-speed internet, and a garden with a spa.

This pet-friendly vacation rental in New Buffalo is conveniently located within walking distance of the New Buffalo Township Public Library and 8 minutes on foot from the New Buffalo train station.
This 3-bedroom, 2-bathroom cottage accommodates up to 7 guests, offering amenities like a full kitchen, complimentary Wi-Fi, on-site water sports equipment, and a fire pit, with Lake Michigan and Indiana Dunes National Lakeshore nearby.

This Union Pier cottage offers three bedrooms and two bathrooms, sleeping six, and is located steps from Lake Michigan and a six-minute walk from Union Pier Beach.
The rental includes a full kitchen with dishwasher, laundry facilities, air conditioning, Wi-Fi, and parking, plus proximity to winter activities like ice skating and skiing/snowboarding.

This charming cottage is situated just three miles from Lake Michigan, Cherry Beach, and Warren Woods State Park, offering easy access to beautiful natural landscapes and a peaceful setting. Guests consistently rate this property as excellent, making it a popular choice for travelers seeking a relaxing getaway.
The cottage provides ample space for families or groups of friends with its two bedrooms, one bathroom, and a comfortable sofa bed, accommodating up to six guests. Enjoy the convenience of a fully equipped kitchen, a cozy fireplace, and a relaxing spa tub, along with outdoor amenities like a private garden and barbecue grill.

This charming cottage is located on a lake, just a mile from Lyon Oaks Golf Course and Lake Michigan, with Michiana Beach and Duneland Beach also within a mile. The cottage consistently receives excellent ratings from guests, making it a popular choice for families and groups.
This five-bedroom cottage comfortably sleeps up to eight guests. The cottage provides a fully equipped kitchen, a fireplace, a garden, and a terrace, as well as free Wi-Fi and air conditioning.

This cottage in New Buffalo is located a few houses from a Lake Michigan overlook and community beach access points, with a park and golf course nearby.
This family-friendly rental accommodates up to 8 guests with 3 bedrooms and 2 bathrooms, offering air conditioning, internet, a full kitchen, and a screened porch, with proximity to Lake Michigan and Indiana Dunes National Park.

This cottage is located in Union Pier, just a short walk from downtown and three beach accesses, making it a perfect spot for exploring the area. The cottage has received excellent user ratings, highlighting its quality and appeal.
The cottage is spacious, offering 1000 square feet of living space and accommodating up to 12 guests. This charming vacation rental features a fully equipped kitchen, a Jacuzzi, a garden, a spa, and air conditioning, providing a comfortable and enjoyable stay.

This New Buffalo cottage, located less than a mile from Lake Michigan and the New Buffalo Railroad Museum, offers easy access to the New Buffalo Pere Marquette Depot and City Hall within a short drive.
This 1190-square-foot vacation home sleeps six guests in three bedrooms and two bathrooms, boasting a fully equipped kitchen, free Wi-Fi, a terrace, a garden, parking, and air conditioning.

This New Buffalo vacation home in Union Pier, Michigan, is a short walk from Lake Michigan and conveniently located near the Vickers Theatre and Hesston Steam Museum.
The three-bedroom, two-bathroom house sleeps six guests comfortably and features a fully equipped kitchen, in-unit laundry, jacuzzi, outdoor shower, fire pit, and grill; plus beach chairs, cooler, and towels are provided.

This Michigan City cottage sits a half-block from the South Shore Train Station, one mile from Washington Park Beach, and within walking distance of downtown restaurants, shops, and Lighthouse Place Premium Outlets.
This two-bedroom, one-bathroom rental sleeps five guests and boasts a fully stocked kitchen with appliances like a crockpot, waffle iron, and Ninja blender, a 55" 4K smart TV, and comfortable Serta memory foam mattresses.

This charming cottage is located within walking distance of New Buffalo's downtown area, restaurants, and the beach. Guests have consistently rated this property excellent, highlighting its convenient location and comfortable amenities. This 3-bedroom, 2-bathroom home offers 1440 square feet of space, comfortably accommodating up to 8 guests. Amenities include a fully equipped kitchen, a hot tub, a fire pit, and a private garden, providing everything you need for a relaxing and enjoyable stay.