Search vacation rentals in New Buffalo, MI from 100+ sites!
258 available vacation rental offers
Choose the perfect vacation accommodation
Price per night
Accommodation type
Rating
Best Vacation rentals and Airbnb offers in New Buffalo, MI
9.7 117 reviews
New Buffalo, MI
09/29 – 10/01
$214/nighttotal: $428 (2 )
Updated Cottage Downtown, Walk To Beach
1 2
apartment , New Buffalo
This cozy coach house is located in downtown New Buffalo, just a 10-minute walk from the beautiful beach and steps away from shops, restaurants, and breweries. It has received excellent ratings for cleanliness, location, and overall experience. The one-bedroom apartment comfortably sleeps four guests and features a fully equipped kitchen, free parking, and a private garden. Enjoy the included beach gear, summer shuttle access, and additional amenities like a beach wagon and cooler.
9.9 179 reviews
New Buffalo, MI
08/20 – 08/24
$560/nighttotal: $2240 (4 )
New Hot Tub Heated Pool Union Pier
1 2
apartment , New Buffalo
This charming cottage is situated in Union Pier, a peaceful residential neighborhood close to Timothy's restaurant and Skip's Farmers Market, just a short drive from the beautiful shores of Lake Michigan. The cottage boasts excellent ratings for user experience, location, and cleanliness, ensuring a comfortable and enjoyable stay. This two-bedroom, one-bathroom vacation rental comfortably sleeps six guests. Enjoy the fully equipped kitchen, cozy living space with a fireplace, private hot tub, and screened-in porch. The community pool, clubhouse, and access to bicycles, beach chairs, and toys provide endless opportunities for fun and relaxation.
8.4 5 reviews
New Buffalo, MI
06/20 – 06/27
$414/nighttotal: $2898 (7 )
Cute Union Pier Cottage (3 Nt Min!)
2 2
apartment , New Buffalo
Barefeet Retreat, a two-bedroom cottage in Union Pier, New Buffalo, is located a short walk from Townline Beach and downtown Union Pier's restaurants and shops. This New Buffalo vacation rental sleeps four guests and features a fully equipped kitchen with dishwasher, central air conditioning, washer/dryer, a gas grill, outdoor shower, and firepit, plus parking for two cars and high-speed internet.
9.6 15 reviews
New Buffalo, MI
07/24 – 07/26
$893/nighttotal: $1786 (2 )
Pet-friendly Home - Hot Tub, Walk To Lake Mi Beach
2 4
apartment , Michigan City
This Michigan City vacation home is conveniently located near Lyon Oaks Golf Course (less than a mile away) and within two miles of Lake Michigan, Duneland Beach, and Michiana Beach. This 720-square-foot rental boasts two bedrooms, one bathroom, sleeps four guests, and features a fully equipped kitchen, Jacuzzi, patio, and access to a tennis court, concierge services, and on-site barbecue grills.
10 73 reviews
New Buffalo, MI
06/21 – 06/23
$412/nighttotal: $824 (2 )
Kid-friendly Michiana Cottage! Summer Dates Open - Including 4th Of July!
3 6
apartment , Michigan City
This family-friendly vacation home is located near the beach in Michigan City, within a 15-minute walk of Lyon Oaks Golf Course and Lake Michigan. The house is rated excellent by previous guests, making it a great choice for your Michigan City getaway. This 3-bedroom house offers 1400 square feet of space and can accommodate up to 6 guests. Enjoy amenities like free Wi-Fi, a fireplace, a fully equipped kitchen, a patio, and a garden with barbecue grills.
9.5 193 reviews
New Buffalo, MI
09/29 – 10/01
$272/nighttotal: $544 (2 )
Lake Condo In The Heart Of Downtown New Buffalo
1 2
apartment , New Buffalo
This apartment is ideally located in the heart of downtown New Buffalo, on Whittaker Street, just steps away from New Buffalo beach and breweries, restaurants, shops, and Amtrak. It has excellent user, location, and cleanliness ratings. This 2-bedroom, 1-bathroom apartment can accommodate up to 6 guests. It features a full kitchen, private patio with fire pit and grill, and washer/dryer. Guests can enjoy grilling and outdoor dining on the private patio, and take advantage of the Wi-Fi, air conditioning, and laundry facilities in the unit.
9.8 37 reviews
New Buffalo, MI
06/18 – 06/22
$497/nighttotal: $1988 (4 )
Union Pier Hidden Gem | 3 Blocks To Beach | Screened Porch & Fire Pit
3 2
cottage , New Buffalo
This Union Pier cottage, three blocks from Lake Michigan, offers easy access to the Whistle Stop Deli and Grocery Store, and various restaurants. This 1600-square-foot single-level home features three bedrooms, two bathrooms, sleeps six, and includes a fully equipped kitchen, screened porch, outdoor shower, beach essentials, and Starlink high-speed internet.
Best New Buffalo, MI vacation rentals with a balcony
9.4 26 reviews
New Buffalo, MI
07/19 – 07/26
$5738/nighttotal: $40166 (7 )
Nothin Dune
5 2
house , New Buffalo
This New Buffalo vacation home is located a short distance from Lake Michigan and New Buffalo Public Beach, within a 3-mile radius of Galien River County Park. It has great user, location, and cleanliness ratings. The house has a spacious 5-bedroom layout with a sofa bed, a fully equipped kitchen, and a cozy fireplace. It has a floor area of 1880 square feet and can accommodate up to 10 guests. Guests can enjoy amenities such as a spa tub, barbecue grills, and a DVD player.
10 48 reviews
New Buffalo, MI
09/29 – 10/01
$422/nighttotal: $844 (2 )
Blue Haven Cottage - New Buffalo Beach, Near Wineries & Breweries
3 2
cottage , New Buffalo
This New Buffalo cottage, located less than a mile from Lake Michigan and the New Buffalo Railroad Museum, offers easy access to the New Buffalo Pere Marquette Depot and City Hall within a short drive. This 1190-square-foot vacation home sleeps six guests in three bedrooms and two bathrooms, boasting a fully equipped kitchen, free Wi-Fi, a terrace, a garden, parking, and air conditioning.
9.4 11 reviews
New Buffalo, MI
08/07 – 08/09
$2563/nighttotal: $5126 (2 )
12-20 Guests | Gamerm | Hot Tub-all Year | Dog Ok
5 8
apartment , Michigan City
This Michigan City lakefront home offers stunning views and direct access to water activities, situated near Washington Park (a 10-minute walk) and less than 3 miles from the Blue Chip Casino, Lake Michigan, and Indiana Dunes National Park. This 5-bedroom vacation rental boasts a fully equipped kitchen, Jacuzzi, terrace, and free WiFi, accommodating families or large groups and providing access to on-site amenities including a hot tub, arcade, and barbecue grills.
Search Family Vacation Rentals in New Buffalo, MI
Plan the perfect family beach trip to New Buffalo, MI with spacious rentals that offer plenty of room to spread out.
10 64 reviews
New Buffalo, MI
08/20 – 08/24
$1191/nighttotal: $4764 (4 )
Sun's Up-bar Down! Hot Tub, Putting Green, Fire Pit, 8 Min Walk To 2 Beaches!
5 2
apartment , New Buffalo
This New Buffalo vacation home is located just a mile from Union Pier Beach and within a 10-minute drive of Townline Beach and Gordon Beach, offering easy access to the area's beautiful shores. It has received excellent user ratings, making it a popular choice for travelers. This 5-bedroom, 3-bathroom retreat provides ample space for up to 11 guests and features a spacious 2,780 square feet of living space. Relax in the Jacuzzi, enjoy the lake views from the terrace, and take advantage of amenities like a fully equipped kitchen, a fireplace, and free Wi-Fi.
9.8 8 reviews
New Buffalo, MI
07/26 – 07/30
$1019/nighttotal: $4076 (4 )
Adventure Hub With Hot Tub
1 4
apartment , Michigan City
This Michigan City vacation rental is conveniently located near the Marquette Greenway bike path, a 17-minute walk from Lake Michigan, and a short drive from New Buffalo and Indiana Dunes National Park. This four-bedroom, two-bathroom apartment sleeps twelve guests and boasts a fenced backyard with a fire pit and hot tub, a deck, access to beach and bike supplies, and proximity to a pickleball court and Stop 50 Pizza.
9.6 23 reviews
New Buffalo, MI
08/20 – 08/24
$1149/nighttotal: $4596 (4 )
Enjoy A Scenic Getaway, A Relaxing Hot Tub, And Seasonal Comfort.
3 2
apartment , New Buffalo
This 2120 sq ft, 3-bedroom, 2-bathroom cottage is located in Downtown New Buffalo, two blocks from Whittaker Street and 0.6 miles from New Buffalo Beach, restaurants, shopping, and kayaking. This family-friendly rental accommodates up to 8 guests and features a private heated pool, year-round hot tub, outdoor gas fire pit, well-equipped kitchen with stainless-steel appliances, and a furnished patio with a grill.
Frequently Asked Questions about vacation rentals in New Buffalo, MI
What are some interesting places to visit in or near New Buffalo, MI?
New Buffalo is on the shores of Lake Michigan and has a beautiful beach, so that's always a good place to start. There's also the historic New Buffalo Lighthouse, and if you're looking for something a little different, you can check out the Harbor Country Antique District, which has lots of unique shops and galleries.
What are the best Airbnb and vacation rentals in New Buffalo, MI?
Which walking or cycling routes are the best in New Buffalo, MI?
The Galien River Trail is a great option for a leisurely bike ride or walk. It runs along the Galien River and offers beautiful views of the surrounding area. The Warren Dunes State Park is another great choice for a walk or bike ride with trails leading up to the dunes and offering amazing views of Lake Michigan.
What are the most popular Airbnbs in New Buffalo, MI?
What sports or outdoor activites can visitors enjoy in and around New Buffalo, MI?
New Buffalo is a great place for water sports, like swimming, boating, and fishing. You can also go hiking, biking, and horseback riding in the nearby Warren Dunes State Park. If you're looking for something a little different, try sandboarding on the dunes. It's a fun and unique experience.
What are the best vacation rentals with a pool in New Buffalo, MI?
What other towns or cities can be easily accessed from New Buffalo, MI?
You can easily get to Chicago, Illinois, from New Buffalo, which is about a 90-minute drive. If you're looking for something closer, you can visit the charming town of Three Oaks, Michigan, which is just a short drive away. It's known for its art galleries, antique shops, and restaurants.
What are the best rentals for families and kids in New Buffalo, MI?
What amenities are commonly available in vacation rentals in New Buffalo, MI?
Most vacation rentals in New Buffalo have amenities like kitchens, bathrooms, bedrooms, and living areas. Many also have access to outdoor spaces like patios or decks, and some even have private pools or hot tubs. You can also find rentals with amenities like laundry facilities, fireplaces, and Wi-Fi.
What are the best rentals or Airbnbs with a jacuzzi in New Buffalo, MI?
What time of year is best to rent a vacation rental New Buffalo, MI?
The best time to visit New Buffalo is during the summer months, from June to August, when the weather is warm and sunny. You can enjoy the beach, go swimming, and participate in all sorts of outdoor activities. If you're looking for a quieter experience, you can visit during the shoulder seasons, in the spring or fall, when the crowds are smaller and the prices are lower.
Destinations nearby
Best New Buffalo, MI vacation rentals with parking
10 1 review
New Buffalo, MI
08/14 – 08/16
$543/nighttotal: $1086 (2 )
Cedar & Rye: Open Spaces And Cottage Charm
1 5
apartment , Three Oaks
This farmhouse rental is located just outside Three Oaks, offering peaceful farmland views and a short drive to Lake Michigan beaches, local wineries, distilleries, and downtown antique shops. This spacious accommodation accommodates up to eight guests with four bedrooms and two bathrooms, featuring a full kitchen, air conditioning, a garden, parking for six cars, a back porch with a grill, and a fire pit, plus a dedicated workspace with Wi-Fi and a laundry room.
8.6 8 reviews
New Buffalo, MI
07/03 – 07/05
$768/nighttotal: $1536 (2 )
Nd Games, Lakes, Casino, Shopping, Highways And Interstates. Central Location
5 13
apartment , Michigan City
This spacious Michigan City home, ideally located near Lighthouse Premium Outlets and a short drive from Indiana Dunes National Park, offers easy access to Lake Michigan beaches and the Blue Chip Casino. The 5-bedroom, 3-bathroom house comfortably sleeps 13 guests and features a fully equipped kitchen, washer/dryer, Wi-Fi, and outdoor spaces including a deck with a swing and fire pit, perfect for families or groups exploring Northwest Indiana's attractions.
New Buffalo, MI
07/25 – 07/26
$334/nightfor 1 night
Pine Lake Resort And Banquets
2 6
resort , La Porte
Pine Lake Resort and Banquets is located in La Porte, close to the city center and within easy reach of popular attractions. The resort offers a convenient location for exploring the city's shops, restaurants, and attractions. Pine Lake Resort and Banquets features a variety of amenities for a comfortable stay. Guests can enjoy a swimming pool, a fitness center, and free Wi-Fi access.
10 23 reviews
New Buffalo, MI
09/25 – 09/27
$672/nighttotal: $1344 (2 )
Cute New Buffalo Home, Fire Pit, Yard Games, Walkable
3 5
apartment , New Buffalo
This three-bedroom New Buffalo rental is located in the downtown area, a short walk from New Buffalo Public Beach, the marina, and local shops and restaurants. Offering a fully equipped kitchen with a French door refrigerator, an open floor plan with hardwood floors, a backyard with a gas grill and fire pit, and access to Third Coast Vacations perks including beach rental discounts, this home sleeps six guests and includes on and off-street parking for two vehicles.
Neighborhoods and points of interest in New Buffalo, MI
Check Out Vacation Rentals with a Pool in New Buffalo, MI
A vacation rental with a pool in New Buffalo, MI is the ideal way to complement your daily coastal adventures.
9.0 2 reviews
New Buffalo, MI
06/20 – 06/27
$624/nighttotal: $4368 (7 )
Union Pier Condo Close To Everything!
3 2
apartment , New Buffalo
This two-bedroom, two-bathroom condo in Union Pier's Pier 9 community is a five-minute walk from Lake Michigan beach and near New Buffalo's shops and restaurants. The 2-story unit sleeps six guests comfortably, offering a fully equipped kitchen, a screened porch, access to a shared heated pool, and family-friendly extras like blackout curtains and children's toys.
New Buffalo, MI
06/20 – 06/27
$1504/nighttotal: $10528 (7 )
The Oasis At Forest Beach | Updated House In New Buffalo With Shared Amenities
5 2
apartment , Grand Beach
This spacious 3500 sq ft apartment in a private lakeside neighborhood in New Buffalo is steps from the community beach, pool, tennis, basketball, playground, and fitness center, and a short drive to New Buffalo Recreational Facilities, Galien River County Park, Hesston Steam Museum, and Downtown Chicago. This family-friendly accommodation offers 5 bedrooms, 4 bathrooms, and sleeps 14, featuring a chef's kitchen, an enormous family room with games, central air conditioning, an outdoor firepit, and a Jacuzzi, with parking available.
9.2 98 reviews
New Buffalo, MI
06/26 – 06/28
$2300/nighttotal: $4600 (2 )
7 Bed 6 Bad Sovepladser 20 + 4 I Pensionatet + Golf Cart + Resort Faciliteter
7 16
resort , Michigan City
This Michigan City vacation rental is located in Beachwalk, a resort community with direct access to Lake Michigan's beach and a short walk from the Indiana Dunes National Park. This property has earned an excellent user rating, making it a popular choice for travelers. The house has 7 bedrooms and 6 bathrooms, comfortably accommodating up to 24 guests. This spacious home offers a range of amenities, including a swimming pool, tennis court, and a private guest house, perfect for families and groups looking for a memorable vacation.
New Buffalo, MI
07/26 – 07/30
$915/nighttotal: $3660 (4 )
The Neighborhood Hotel Grand Beach Suite 2 - Two Bedroom
2 4
apartment , Grand Beach
This three-bedroom, two-bathroom New Buffalo condo is located near Lake Michigan, less than a mile from Michiana Beach and under two miles from Duneland Beach and Lyon Oaks Golf Course. The 3-bedroom rental boasts a fully equipped kitchen, fireplace, in-unit laundry, free WiFi, and access to a swimming pool, hot tub, tennis court, and game room, comfortably sleeping six guests.
Search Coastal Vacation Rentals near New Buffalo, MI
Enjoy a relaxing beach getaway with these coastal and seaside vacation rentals in New Buffalo, MI. Book your next shoreside stay today.
9.6 20 reviews
New Buffalo, MI
09/05 – 09/07
$734/nighttotal: $1468 (2 )
Blocks To Beach Golf Tennis Park & Lake Mi Sunsets
3 7
apartment , Grand Beach
Compare Luxury Vacation Rentals in New Buffalo, MI
Experience 5-star comfort in a luxury New Buffalo, MI vacation rental designed with premium amenities throughout.
New Buffalo, MI
07/19 – 07/26
$898/nighttotal: $6286 (7 )
Cozy Oasis By Lake Mi & Dunes With Hot Tub!
3 2
apartment , Shorewood-Tower Hills-Harbert
Discover Vacation Rentals with Saunas in New Buffalo, MI
Elevate your wellness routine with a vacation rental featuring a sauna in New Buffalo, MI , ideal for a restorative end to your day.
New Buffalo, MI
07/01 – 07/06
$719/nighttotal: $3595 (5 )
Witch Hazel - Upscale 2 Bedroom Villa At Petite Acres
1 4
house , New Buffalo
New Buffalo, MI
09/29 – 10/01
$500/nighttotal: $1000 (2 )
Wild Indigo - Upscale 2 Bedroom Villa At Petite Acres
1 2
house , New Buffalo
New Buffalo, MI
09/29 – 10/01
$516/nighttotal: $1032 (2 )
Woodsage - Upscale 2 Bedroom Villa At Petite Acres
